Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., August 12, 2007 Av 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:07 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 23:05 12/08/2007
Fuchs isn't the only 'bastard'

Being cut off from the regular news flow during my miluim reserve service last week, I wasn't aware of all the details of the eviction of the two Jewish families from the Hebron marketplace. Of course I heard about the clash between settlers and security forces and the decision of a number of religious soldiers to disobey orders rather than carrying out a minor role in the operation, but only upon reading the weekend papers did I realize that what seemed to me as relatively small detail of the saga had gathered momentum and turned into the main event.

I mean of course the way Bar Ilan University Professor Hillel Weiss cursed the local brigade commander Col. Yehuda Fuchs. Why has that particular scene captured both the media and public imagination in such a way? After all there was a lot of cussing and swearing going on between settlers and soldiers at that moment, so why zero in on that particular verbal attack.

The answer should be clear, Weiss is no cursory curser, his age and academic position set him aside from the rest of the young hot-headed and loose-tongued youths fulminating around him. Also the precise wording of the curse - "your mother should be bereaved, your wife a widow, your children orphans and you should be decimated in the next war and no memory of you remain" - was not a mere slur thrown out instinctively on the spot, it was well crafted and designed for maximum insult. The Professor's curse is something else. I know, I have also been cursed by him.

Advertisement
A couple of years ago, I was working on a project in which Prof. Weiss had some kind of ill-defined advisory capacity. As a result we used to see each other once a week when he came in for meetings. He enjoyed walking through the offices and I found him an interesting and amusing man to talk to. It was clear, at least to me but I think also to him, that our political positions were wide apart, but our conversations were friendly.

We usually spoke about Israeli literature, especially S Y Agnon on whom Weiss is recognized as one of the greatest living experts. In addition to his academic and political pursuits, Weiss is also one of the leading lights of the "Sanhedrin," a group of ultra-right wing rabbis who style themselves as the real spiritual leadership of the Jewish people, unaccountable to the non-Jewish restrictions of democracy or to any mainstream rabbinical authority.

Once, in one of our conversations, I referred jokingly to the "Sanhedrin," but this was a topic on which he was not prepared to allow any jokes. He stopped in mid-speech, fixed me with a stern look and said slowly, enunciating every word, "You are a bastard." He then turned away. I was too shocked to reply and I don't think we've spoken to each other since.

Now, I've been called a bastard before, last week in miluim probably at least once an hour, and I must admit I've used the word myself on occasion at others. But it's always been either part of friendly, if unruly, banter, or angry recriminations of the kind thrown out on the spur of the moment but hastily retracted and forgotten soon after.

With Weiss it was something different. His curse was deliberate, calculated, he meant to put me in my place and instill a feeling of worthlessness. As a lifelong student of literature, he knows full well the power of words and uses them to the utmost.

All this doesn't mean that I think Weiss should be prosecuted by the police or disciplined by the Bar Ilan Senate for what he said to Col. Fuchs. Weiss may be a self-admitted enemy of democracy but that doesn't mean he should not enjoy the right to freedom of speech as the rest of us. Clumsy efforts to muzzle him will not take the sting out of his curses, challenging him in words would be much more effective.

Previous entries:
August 10, 2007: Too tired to blog, but...
August 8, 2007: 'You bet I'm going on this march'
August 7, 2007: Training for the war that won't be
August 6, 2007: 'The real change is that we're training at all'
August 5, 2007: Olmert's own heritage is no excuse
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A slippery slide
The roads to pure pleasure are many and varied at the Holon water park.
A daring insight
The philosophy of Rabbi Shagar has found a place in the hearts of many.
 Today Online
Arafat's doctor: There was HIV in his blood, but poison killed him
Responses: 199
Jerusalem source: Syria worried by Iran's bear hug
Responses: 60
Gideon Levy: Failure to uproot Hebron settlers is the real crime
Responses: 105
Hamas announces formation of new naval coast guard unit
Responses: 69
Carlo Strenger: Peres must address the pain of the religious right
Responses: 49
Rosner's Domain
* Blog and Poll: Is the US leaving Iraq? Not so fast...
* The Orthodox Union should raise its voice against Orthodox disobedience
* WTR: Opposing the Saudi deal from right and left
* Guest: What Jewish American voters want


More Headlines
22:05 Lantos: Early removal of roadblocks may resusciate terror attacks
22:18 Cabinet votes 21-5 in favor of proposed 2008 State Budget
22:02 Police release security video of Jerusalem shooting attack
22:39 Report: Hezbollah buying up lands in southern Lebanon
22:40 Company commander who left soldier behind in Gaza receives note in record
19:51 Jordan mulling cheaper alternative to Red Sea-Dead Sea canal
17:04 Israel probing kickback claims against ambassador to Hungary
14:19 Foreign Minister, Palestinian PM to meet in W. Bank Wednesday
10:06 Sderot residents: Restraint policy on Qassams promoting war of attrition
13:04 Jerusalem source: Syria is worried by Iran's 'bear hug'
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved