Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., August 10, 2007 Av 26, 5767 | | Israel Time: 04:41 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
Defense Minister Ehud Barak (BauBau Archives)
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 12:31 08/08/2007
Barak: Missile defense is precondition for W. Bank pullout
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent

Defense Minister Ehud Barak attributes great importance to speeding up the development of technological defenses against rocket fire on the home front, as he considers this a precondition for any significant withdrawal from the West Bank.

Such a withdrawal would put Israel's main population centers in Qassam rocket range of the Palestinian Authority. Therefore, Barak believes, Israel must first develop and deploy an effective anti-missile system - a process that is expected to take three to five years.

Though Barak has declined to say so explicitly or to point an accusing finger at anyone, he has been unpleasantly surprised by what he has discovered about the Israel Defense Forces' preparedness in the weeks since his return to the Defense Ministry. At a meeting Tuesday with reservists from an armored brigade, one tank gunner told him that his current reserve duty is the first time he has seen an actual shell in five years. "No one will wait five years before the next exercise," promised Barak, who believes that live-fire exercises are critical, as they are the closest thing to real combat.

Advertisement
Last week, Barak met with a group of brigade commanders and was surprised to hear some of them say that during last summer's Lebanon war, they had faced difficult dilemmas when they weighed the "value of their missions" against the danger to soldiers' lives. Barak, like other former generals, has been critical of some units' failure to stick to their missions during that war, and he told the brigade commanders that this is not an issue they should even consider during wartime. A single brigade commander, he explained, lacks a clear picture of the entire front, and must therefore act on the assumption that his superiors have good reason for their orders.

Each commander, he added, must behave as if the outcome of the war depends on his actions alone.

Barak has also met recently with several of the retired officers who led the army's in-house probes into the Second Lebanon War. Based on these meetings and his studies of the material, he has concluded that the biggest problem was the enormous difference between a real war and counterterrorism activity in the territories, coupled with the lack of an "institutional memory": Israel's last real war occurred 24 years ago, and the IDF no longer has any officers who remember what that was like.

Operations to arrest wanted terrorists, for instance, are often halted in the middle if a soldier is wounded, as evacuating him is considered to take priority. In war, however, such conduct would be beyond the pale: An assault must continue even if the unit suffers casualties.

On the more practical level, Barak's main conclusion from the war is the need to improve the home front's defenses against rockets. He envisions a multilayered system capable of intercepting anything from Iran's long-range Shihab-3 missile to the short-range, relatively primitive Palestinian Qassams. Such a system would include an improved version of the Arrow anti-missile system, which is designed to intercept long-range missiles; the "Iron Dome" system designed by Rafael - the Armaments Development Authority, which is aimed at short-range missiles; and perhaps a laser-based system as well.

In the offensive realm, Barak considers it critical to improve the IDF's maneuverability. He has already proposed to the cabinet that two new reserve divisions be created. These would include armored brigades, but would not require the purchase of many new tanks, as several units have been disbanded in recent years, and their tanks are still in IDF warehouses.

In addition, all tanks must be protected against the advanced antitank missiles now owned by Hezbollah and Syria. Spending $150,000 to armor a tank that costs $3 million is a good investment, Barak says.

Some of Barak's proposals would require massive expenditures, so he is banking on the promised increase in American military aid


Ehud Barak, Qassam, pullout, missile
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Sebastia U.
People should know degrees from Ariel's 'Civilian University College' will not be legal.
Soul in a bowl
Muscat wine gives the sorbet a sweet flavor, and the alcohol helps maintain a soft texture.
  1.   And the Palestinians are not going to wait another 5 03:06  |  lakshmi 08/08/07
  2.   Very good observations by Barak 03:16  |  GPS 08/08/07
  3.   No Precondions - Just Pull Out 03:20  |  Mr. Knowitall 08/08/07
  4.   blackmail to get more money from the U.S. 03:21  |  Wendy 08/08/07
  5.   Swimming piglets 03:24  |  Hannah 08/08/07
  6.   withdraw and get missles 03:26  |  Bobus 08/08/07
  7.   Says it all 03:27  |  steve 08/08/07
  8.   withdraw and get missles for thanks 03:29  |  BobUSA 08/08/07
  9.   Lakshmi 03:30  |  ChanahS 08/08/07
  10.   Barak is crazy! 03:39  |  eddie 08/08/07
  11.   Best defense is offense 03:55  |  Joseph E . 08/08/07
  12.   look into my crystal ball 04:07  |  Future1 08/08/07
  13.   Barak arrogance once again shows, thinking he has it figured out. 04:10  |  Dr. L. Brnd 08/08/07
  14.   Barak 04:16  |  Shmuelshachor 08/08/07
  15.   Torpedoes Loss! 04:18  |  Mark Lincoln 08/08/07
  16.   120,000.00$ against around 25$ well.... 04:23  |  Michael 08/08/07
  17.   so he wants to WITHDRAW KNOWING IT WILL BRING KASSAMIM ?!?!?! 04:25  |  amir 08/08/07
  18.   Missile defense 04:30  |  Bart COlingwood 08/08/07
  19.   Barak 04:32  |  Dave 08/08/07
  20.   Hit the missles before they are built! 04:33  |  HonestAbe 08/08/07
  21.   On the SAME day Israel withdrew from Gaza.There was aQassem salvo 04:36  |  PETER SM 08/08/07
  22.   Israel Follies 04:36  |  tbartman 08/08/07
  23.   Joseph E. # 11 04:39  |  Hunter 08/08/07
  24.   Anyone who was deluded enough 04:44  |  Mark Lincoln 08/08/07
  25.   10Eddie,good phrase,land for war ! 04:44  |  lakshmi 08/08/07
  26.   Wrong Eddie 04:48  |  Mark Lincoln 08/08/07
  27.   Knowitall & laksahmi & Michael 04:49  |  Brad 08/08/07
  28.   LAKSHMI`s Lies and Cluster bomb myth 05:08  |  CK Tan 08/08/07
  29.   #5 hannah - barak is fat. So you are a 34-26-34 model? 05:12  |  CK Tan 08/08/07
  30.   ITS the best option while Hamas& their ilk exist. 05:12  |  PETER SM 08/08/07
  31.   The PA precondition shall be... 05:13  |  Dutch Dirk 08/08/07
  32.   B ARAK IS BARKING MAD 05:19  |  paul harris 08/08/07
  33.   To #1"Palestinians are not going to wait 5 years"! ...... 05:23  |  Massoud Levy 08/08/07
  34.   LAKSASHIMI 05:25  |  Barry 08/08/07
  35.   #26, "the one clearly favored by the current government" 05:28  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/08/07
  36.   #13, Dr. L. Brand 05:34  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/08/07
  37.   barak on target except 05:34  |  Twogunz 08/08/07
  38.   21Peter SM you still don`t get it. 05:42  |  lakshmi 08/08/07
  39.   Pal state idea failed , it stinks now , stop stirring that stench 05:43  |  Joseph E . 08/08/07
  40.   Barak is clear, mature and sober. 05:49  |  Mireya Siqueiros 08/08/07
  41.   A missile defense system is aggression 05:53  |  Hojatoleslam Ahvazi 08/08/07
  42.   An Admission of an insane policy 05:58  |  Chick 08/08/07
  43.   The Arab League Should Pay For the Missile Defense In Exchange 06:02  |  Tal 08/08/07
  44.   Lakshmi - can`t wait 5 years ( will use terror) 06:04  |  Ed 08/08/07
  45.   #3 Frostbie - Conditions are mandatory 06:16  |  * BEN JABO 08/08/07
  46.   #6 Bobus - You have it backwards 06:17  |  * BEN JABO 08/08/07
  47.   Shmuelshachor 06:21  |  * BEN JABO 08/08/07
  48.   Lakshmi 06:26  |  * BEN JABO 08/08/07
  49.   Why do an INDIAN or INDONESIAN make a career of hating Israel 06:28  |  Aaron 08/08/07
  50.   # 23 Hunter 06:32  |  Joseph E . 08/08/07
  51.   Haaretz makes up stories? 06:55  |  Dina 08/08/07
  52.   NO LAKSHMI you do not get it.No Hudna tricks,agree to peace talks 07:04  |  PETER SM 08/08/07
  53.   Hojatoleslam Ahvazi.A DEFENCE system is agression& missiles are? 07:12  |  PETER SM 08/08/07
  54.   Hojatoleslam Ahvazi.A DEFENCE system is agression& missiles are? 07:12  |  PETER SM 08/08/07
  55.   #40, Ahvazi 07:13  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/08/07
  56.   This the presupposes that we will be ATTACKED!!!! 07:42  |  Ben Uziel 08/08/07
  57.   No luck for Lakshmi 08:16  |  Dan 08/08/07
  58.   The Palestinians will win the cold war 08:23  |  Henry 08/08/07
  59.   CALCULATE! 08:24  |  Vladimir 08/08/07
  60.   If we`re expecting missiles from "peace partners" why are we ... 08:35  |  Tova M. 08/08/07
  61.   Mr.Barak, the children of Abraham need peace not missile 08:47  |  Dr. Julian Darwish 08/08/07
  62.   CIPORA J.K.@55 08:47  |  PETER SM 08/08/07
  63.   Lakshmi - all numbers 08:49  |  S 08/08/07
  64.   Barak should also have said to reenforce roofs , knowing that 09:07  |  Joseph E . 08/08/07
  65.   Allon Plan worth considering again 09:18  |  MC 08/08/07
  66.   Aaron 49, it is their jihad 09:30  |  Uri 08/08/07
  67.   #3, Mr. Knowitall... 09:37  |  David 08/08/07
  68.   Israel will never pull out of the west bank 09:59  |  Natallie Durson 08/08/07
  69.   The solution 10:01  |  Paul 08/08/07
  70.   Dr Julian Darwish 10:15  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 08/08/07
  71.   # 61 Dr Julian Darwish. 10:26  |  David Nigel Braham 08/08/07
  72.   Barak`s declarations, oye vey for peace..... 10:27  |  Esther 08/08/07
  73.   Mr Knowitall come back down to earth 10:29  |  george 08/08/07
  74.   Dr L Brnd 10:33  |  george 08/08/07
  75.   Indrajaya 10:36  |  Indrajaya 08/08/07
  76.   Indrajaya 10:44  |  george 08/08/07
  77.   Jews must go..Palestinians may stay ?! 11:02  |  Akram Zekaria 08/08/07
  78.   Esther know it all #72 11:09  |  S 08/08/07
  79.   Tova #60 Bravo Tova! 11:14  |  S 08/08/07
  80.   False Hannah Alert #5 11:18