Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., August 08, 2007 Av 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:01 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The cold truth about 'Hot House'
By Frimet Roth

Reading reviews of the Israeli documentary "Hot House" has been a traumatic experience for me. Is this normal? I doubt if even psychologists could say.

No compassionate state would subject a mother to such torture. No sane government would help a cold-blooded mass murderer ascend a cinematic soapbox, spew her venom and get her smiling, glamorous promotional picture in the international papers.

But Israel, in the throes of an existential war on terror, saw no reason to deny Ahlam Tamimi - the person who planned the Jerusalem terror massacre that killed my daughter - that privilege. She and dozens of other Palestinian terrorists were allowed to star in a documentary film that has sold out theaters.

Advertisement

Shimon Dotan, the Romanian-born former Israeli who made "Hot House," says the Prisons Service freely admitted him to half a dozen prisons across Israel over the course of a year. The authorities deserve a "certificate of honor," he says, for their permissiveness, adding: "It is difficult for me to say that, and I don't want to brag about it."

His film exposes astonishing aspects of life behind bars in Israel where convicted Palestinian terrorists enjoy country-club-like conditions. They all have access to Israeli and Palestinian radio, television and newspapers. Cells, shared with terror-group cronies, are equipped with their choice of colorful rugs and wall hangings. Cooking facilities allow them to indulge their personal culinary tastes. They enjoy bi-weekly family visits. They are free to hone their political skills, conduct internal elections and nurture their political careers. Prison garb is waived; women sport Islamic attire, down to the colorful silk scarves my daughter's murderer favors. Prayer halls are available for the free practice of the very faith that inspired their crimes. And as the film points out, many of them earn, at the Israeli citizen's expense, university degrees. In Israel, the death penalty is never applied to terrorists.

No one in the Prisons Service challenges this absurd state of affairs.

"Hot House" could have been used to counter the rampant disinformation about Israel's treatment of Palestinian prisoners. Yet nothing was farther from the producers' minds.

Dotan, who has resided in the U.S. and Canada for several years, missed one of Israel's most harrowing periods. Yet he says his motive is to "make Israelis understand the issue of Palestinian prisoners [and] think we are doing exactly the same things [to the Palestinians] in their civilian life. We owe them empathy." Dotan is not alone in his conviction that to defend yourself against murderers is no different than murder. Many Israelis espouse and express this perverted morality.

In Israel, as in any authentic democracy, everyone may freely voice his views. Yet "Hot House" goes beyond free speech. It was primarily underwritten by Israeli government sources - not Dotan's personal funds. In other words, by us taxpayers. The New Foundation for Film and Television was established in 1993 to essentially support the production of documentary films. With 60 percent of its budget, millions of shekels annually, coming from the Education, Culture and Sports Ministry, this foundation was a primary source of the film's budget.

Compared to the release of 256 Palestinian prisoners and amnesty granted to 180 wanted terrorists, both of which Israel recently did, funding a pro-terrorist film may seem like child's play. But films are skillful victors over naive hearts and minds.

Israel's leaders have been notoriously lax in their attitude toward public relations. "Hot House" reveals that they have actually been pro-actively blackening their country's image.

Consider one of the human beings they have chosen to profile: my daughter's murderer. Dotan says he sat with her for two hours, having a "gripping" conversation. He asked whether she knew how many children had perished in the bombing of Sbarro. Smiling, as she generally does, she guessed "three." "It was eight," Dotan corrected her. She seemed delighted and smiled again, asking, "really?"

Dotan and his fellow producers are marketing this film aggressively throughout the world. If it hasn't yet, "Hot House" will undoubtedly reach a theater near you soon. Before entering the building, please consider this:

You will be bringing this evil creature, Tamimi, untold pleasure. Dotan says she was keen to publicize her views.

You will pad the bank accounts of individuals who revile Israel.

And you may emerge convinced that this film conveys a balanced picture of the entire Israeli-Palestinian conflict. A film without a single appearance by a victim of the terrorists. Not one photograph. Not even one name.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Racing against time
Avichai Kremer has mobilized his remaining strength to find a cure for his ALS.
The song isn't over
Chair of Zimriya World Assembly of Choirs decries the decline of Israeli choral music.
  1.   Jewish prisoners don`t get the luxuries that terrorists do! 12:55  |  Nannette 07/08/07
  2.   Death Penalty 13:02  |  Nik Miller 07/08/07
  3.   Disgusting 13:08  |  ron 07/08/07
  4.   GOD STRIKE US DOWN UNLESS WE MAKE SOME CHANGES TO THIS STATE! 13:37  |  don 07/08/07
  5.   Nannette #1 13:45  |  jjvanka 07/08/07
  6.   Bad PR 13:47  |  Carlos - NY 07/08/07
  7.   5. Israelis didn`t cause terrorism Arabs massacred Jews before 48 14:19  |  Nannette 07/08/07
  8.   The Secret is out!! 14:36  |  Natallie Durson 07/08/07
  9.   Few Omissions? 14:47  |  ACRI 07/08/07
  10.   to ACRI 14:59  |  linda 07/08/07
  11.   I never thought I`d say - Kol HaKavod to Haaretz 15:05  |  Mike 07/08/07
  12.   a film with disastrous consequences 15:07  |  Jonas 07/08/07
  13.   Liberal-socialism is evil 15:37  |  Gene 07/08/07
  14.   Nannette #7 15:44  |  jjvanka 07/08/07
  15.   To linda 15:45  |  ACRI 07/08/07
  16.   Was it financed by Haaretzniks? 15:45  |  Steve from Raleigh 07/08/07
  17.   Acri!what a profound intellectual masturbation 16:03  |  Za`atar 07/08/07
  18.   The Israeli 5 star prisons entice more than 72 virgins 16:21  |  Alicia 07/08/07
  19.   CORRECTION: Israel is not democratic, it`s a Jewish(racial) state 16:36  |  anti-racist 07/08/07
  20.   14 Wrong again. The Crusades came AFTER Muslim invasion of Europe 16:36  |  Nannette 07/08/07
  21.   Pal terrorism is direct result of Israeli racist occupation 16:37  |  anti-racist 07/08/07
  22.   9. Acri, prisoners in Arab jails are treated disgustingly! 16:42  |  Nannette 07/08/07
  23.   To Za`atar 16:52  |  EhadHaAm 07/08/07
  24.   The evil of liberal socialism 16:53  |  Alicia 07/08/07
  25.   To Nannette 17:00  |  ACRI 07/08/07
  26.   So the film is bad and Haaretz is good? Inter.Leftist relativism? 17:06  |  Ignacio 07/08/07
  27.   ..and Israeli racist occupation is direct result of pal terrorism 17:14  |  Anti-anti 07/08/07
  28.   jjvanka #14 - what a load of crap 17:16  |  William 07/08/07
  29.   Anti-racist#21 - what was it before 1948? 17:22  |  William 07/08/07
  30.   hey nast natalie 17:34  |  joseph 07/08/07
  31.   Bravo #19 anti-racist 17:39  |  dave 07/08/07
  32.   Hot house 17:42  |  TheAZCowBoy 07/08/07
  33.   21. Read about the Arab attacks on Jews BEFORE 1948... 18:01  |  Nannette 07/08/07
  34.   AZcowardboy 18:13  |  gay fool 07/08/07
  35.   Nannette #20 18:17  |  jjvanka 07/08/07
  36.   The Cold Truth about Hot House 18:39  |  Morton Narrowe 07/08/07
  37.   ...and israeli occupation is the result of pal terrorism... 19:05  |  Anti-anti 07/08/07
  38.   Ante Anti-anti! 19:33  |  gay fool 07/08/07
  39.   jjvanka: your outrage is pitifully misdirected 19:34  |  Aaron 07/08/07
  40.   AZCowBoy From The Univ Of Arizona Mosque 19:41  |  Yosemite 07/08/07
  41.   This is extraordinarily badly written 19:49  |  Rowan Berkeley 07/08/07
  42.   Rowan Berkeley 20:22  |  gay fool 07/08/07
  43.   gnat Dursleys` posts 20:30  |  Hassan Nassrallah 07/08/07
  44.   i have to agree 20:56  |  felistenya 07/08/07
  45.   Correction: and you say this in Israeli democracy 21:17  |  Anti-anti 07/08/07
  46.   Nothing matches freedom 21:29  |  Ahmed 07/08/07
  47.   And Ofcourse The Malaysian Caning Video... 21:46  |  Yosemite 07/08/07
  48.   everyone elses fault 23:44  |  ricki bobbi 07/08/07
  49.   Canadian Television Showed Film 00:09  |  Jacob 08/08/07
  50.   Canadian Television Showed Film 00:11  |  Jacob 08/08/07
  51.   Aaron #29 00:24  |  jjvanka 08/08/07
  52.   To # 48 (ricki bobbi) 06:18  |  Joe 08/08/07
  53.   Refuah Shleimah 08:25  |  ill 08/08/07
  54.   The Education, Culture and Sports Minister was... 09:38  |  Efox 08/08/07
  55.   re: ACRI 09:46  |  Efox 08/08/07
  56.   re: TheAZCowBoy 09:50  |  Efox 08/08/07
  57.   hot house again 10:49  |  Morton 08/08/07
 Today Online
Editorial: Don't miss this opportunity to solve the conflict
Send response
Amira Hass: Harassment and sabotage routine for Palestinians
Responses: 6
Barak: Missile defense is precondition for West Bank pullout
Responses: 76
PA presses for arms shipments said needed to stave off Hamas
Responses: 11


More Headlines
09:19 Barak: Missile defense is precondition for pullout
10:55 Security cabinet meets on prospect of conflict with Syria
08:20 IDF soldiers kill two Palestinian militants in the Gaza Strip
04:34 Israel asks U.K. for more details on journalist killed in Gaza
10:48 Company vows to make Dan buses environmentally friendly
05:37 Peres expecting U.S., European support for peace proposal
08:56 PA presses for arms shipments said needed to stave off Hamas
05:32 Kadima aims to gain support of Russian-speaking constituency
08:19 Despite allegations of fraud, no criminal probe into Heftsiba
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved