Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., August 13, 2007 Av 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:09 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 12:22 06/08/2007
If Hamas isn't in the game
By Danny Rubinstein

The Olmert government in Israel and the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank, headed by Mahmoud Abbas, are in the midst of renewed political activity, encouraged by intensive American efforts. There have been frequent meetings, discussions of an agreement of principles and plans for a regional conference. Although there still are many problems in the field, like the amnesty agreement for wanted men that the two sides haven't managed to finalize, there certainly has been progress. The liaison committees between Israel and the Palestinian Authority have begun operating again, the government headed by Prime Minister Salam Fayad is receiving substantial financial support, and the security services in the West Bank are beginning to be restored.

The Palestinian media has been reporting that a new city is being planned in the West Bank, between Nablus and Ramallah. One newspaper said it would be a top-priority national project: the first new Arab city since Arab conquerors founded Ramle 1,500 years ago. The Americans and the Saudis will fund the construction, which will provide work for tens of thousands of unemployed Palestinians.

This backdrop makes an apparently marginal disagreement interesting. The dispute in question began after Israel announced that it would allow a few dozen Palestinian refugees who fled Iraq to return to the West Bank. The refugees are members of families that lived in villages in the southeast Carmel region. The Iraqi army, which reached northern Samaria in the 1948 War of Independence, was assisted by some of the residents of those villages. After the Arab defeat, they were allowed to go to Iraq, and lived there until they were compelled to flee, due to the war there. Some had been living in temporary camps on the Jordanian and Syrian borders, and now Israel is allowing a few dozen of them to move to the West Bank and become PA citizens.

Advertisement
The problem, as explained by Palestinian newspapers, is that in accepting the right to be naturalized in the West Bank, they must give up their United Nations refugee certificates. From a Palestinian nationalist perspective, this is practically treason, since it means giving up the right of return. In the past 60 years, almost all Palestinian political statements have completely rejected the idea of resettling the refugees anywhere other than where they used to live in Palestine.

Hamas representatives expressed fierce opposition to the Iraq refugees giving up their UN certificates. Many members of Fatah and the other Palestinian factions joined Hamas in condemning the move.

The matter is primarily a symbolic one, but Hamas spokesmen - led by political adviser Ahmed Yousef - have said in the past few days that they would torpedo any Palestinian development that runs contrary to their position. This applies to Palestinian elections, along with other political and practical issues going beyond the refugees. Abbas has announced that he wants to move ahead the general elections for the PA parliament and chairmanship. Hamas is opposed, and it clearly won't allow elections to take place in the Gaza Strip. If Hamas calls for a boycott of the elections, it will be impossible to hold them in the West Bank, too. Hamas has a lot of destructive power regarding a variety of other issues as well.

There is an almost unanimous consensus in Palestinian politics regarding the conditions for any agreement with Israel: A Palestinian state must be established on the basis of the 1967 borders, with East Jerusalem as its capital, and there must be some solution to the refugee problem. Even Hamas is prepared to agree to such a deal, in exchange for a long-term cease-fire and cooperation with Israel, though without peace or official recognition of Israel. The Hamas government in Gaza is currently making every effort to show that it is capable of maintaining good governance, law and order. Last week it invited foreign journalists to see what was happening there, and most left with a positive impression.

However, there is no doubt that Hamas is more capable of sabotaging Abbas' policy than it is of ruling. As long as the Hamas leadership has a hope of holding on in Gaza and of influence in the West Bank, there will be relative quiet. But when Hamas loses hope and it becomes clear that Abbas is far from achieving the minimum that the Palestinians are demanding, then the terrorism and violence almost certainly will be renewed. In other words, all the current political activity is liable to turn out to be nothing but bunk. Ultimately, the opinion of many Palestinians will turn out to be right: If Hamas isn't in the game, there is no game.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Shark tank
An economist says Israel's top reforms are made by headfirst, anti-government blitzes.
The builder crumbles
When a contractor collapses, the buyers may suffer heavy costs they can't cover.
  1.   HAMAS IS READY TO PEACE 09:48  |  indrajaya 06/08/07
  2.   danny confuses arab demands with reality 09:49  |  victor hardman 06/08/07
  3.   Peace is the last thing on their mind 10:02  |  Natallie Durson 06/08/07
  4.   This is obviously, plainly, transparently true 10:02  |  Clickfool 06/08/07
  5.   Natallie and Clickfool 10:30  |  Ehud 06/08/07
  6.   Any realistic approach to overcoming the Arab 10:33  |  Asaf Noyman 06/08/07
  7.   Abbas 10:43  |  Hannah 06/08/07
  8.   Fooling ourselves 10:44  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 06/08/07
  9.   Danny Rubinstein 10:49  |  iletzter 06/08/07
  10.   It`s a matter of money 10:52  |  Hannah 06/08/07
  11.   If Hamas isn`t in the game 11:02  |  Steve the Pals. 06/08/07
  12.   Spot on Danny Rubinstein 11:04  |  Nick Ferriman 06/08/07
  13.   Clearly speaking the truth 11:29  |  Johnboy 06/08/07
  14.   2 questions for Natallie. 11:33  |  Hubal 06/08/07
  15.   Hamas ready for peace, Abbas ready for surrender 11:43  |  American living here 06/08/07
  16.   truce 12:22  |  gedalia 06/08/07
  17.   Hamas and the New City 13:16  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/08/07
  18.   peace has to inclusive... 13:18  |  ravi 06/08/07
  19.   gedalia @15 13:22  |  Avi Yerushalmi 06/08/07
  20.   Hamas is a sinking ship 13:30  |  ScotGuy 06/08/07
  21.   Nothing is going to happen without Hamas in the game;abbas knows 14:04  |  lakshmi 06/08/07
  22.   What a deal how could anyone refuse? 14:57  |  Joel Weltman 06/08/07
  23.   17Ronnie Wolman,nice dream,but won`t happen.First off,there was a 15:35  |  lakshmi 06/08/07
  24.   Rubinstein on arab cities 15:38  |  peter 06/08/07
  25.   Play with who? 15:55  |  Walter 06/08/07
  26.   Ravi How wise would you be if you have 22 guns at YOUR head? 16:06  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/08/07
  27.   "Unanimous consensus" described does not include peace 16:24  |  McQueen 06/08/07
  28.   How can Israel concede everything and not even get peace?! 16:26  |  McQueen 06/08/07
  29.   FATAH FARCE 17:17  |  Arik Silverman 06/08/07
  30.   American Living Here is Khalid 17:24  |  Gina 06/08/07
  31.   Please, Seperate the leaders of Hamas from the ordinary people 17:39  |  Truth Magnified 06/08/07
  32.   hamas is on it`s way out, They Lost 17:44  |  Shepherd 06/08/07
  33.   If Hanmas is not in the Game 18:07  |  Ibrahim elLiddawi 06/08/07
  34.   I Hope Nothing Happens - It Will All Be Bad For Israel 18:20  |  Tod Zuckerman 06/08/07
  35.   RATIFICATION 18:27  |  Mark of Lewiston 06/08/07
  36.   "Most [journalists] left with a good impression..." 18:47  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 06/08/07
  37.   Hamas has a lot of destructive power 18:59  |  akiva P 06/08/07
  38.   If Hamas isn`t in the game, there is no game? 19:03  |  akiva P 06/08/07
  39.   The way to handle Hamas 19:44  |  Tosefta 06/08/07
  40.   The result of keeping Hamas out 19:47  |  Tosefta 06/08/07
  41.   NICE WISHFUL THINKING, IN THE MEANTIME LET`S GET BACK TO REALITY 20:00  |  G. Marcus 06/08/07
  42.   Mark Of Lewiston& American Living here,true neither Olmert nor 20:01  |  lakshmi 06/08/07
  43.   Then I guess we shouldnt play 20:02  |  Herbert Kaine 06/08/07
  44.   Who really can reach peace? 20:05  |  john 06/08/07
  45.   Palestinians are Tosefta`s dogs. 20:18  |  woof woof 06/08/07
  46.   Doubting Durson 20:39  |  akiva P 06/08/07
  47.   If Hamas is a player--No palestinian state, No peace in our time 20:47  |  Voice of Reason 06/08/07
  48.   4 Lakshmi - Hamas Input 21:11  |  Mark of lewiston 06/08/07
  49.   Hamas should be brought into the game 21:26  |  Terminator 06/08/07
  50.   Ibrahim eLidawi - I asked same question about refugees 21:33  |  Sam 06/08/07
  51.   We cannot do without hamas (?) 21:42  |  KUTW 06/08/07
  52.   Of course they`re in the game 22:08  |  Elias Khoury 06/08/07
  53.   The amnesty for wanted men 22:11  |  KUTW 06/08/07
  54.   FALSE HANNAH ALERT! #7, 10 22:21  |  Hannah 06/08/07
  55.   Is there no danger to Israel? 22:23  |  KUTW 06/08/07
  56.   Giving up the UN refugees certificates is treason 22:35  |  KUTW 06/08/07
  57.   Hamas is so clever 22:40  |  KUTW 06/08/07
  58.   Journalists? good impression 22:44  |  KUTW 06/08/07
  59.   What I see 23:10  |  Hadyn 06/08/07
  60.   woof woof: sit down!! you need to be muzzled, ugly dog 23:21  |  nobodysacred 06/08/07
  61.   Failures who reinforce failure - Tosefta 23:36  |  Mark Lincoln 06/08/07
  62.   I`m in total agreement with your assessment. MR D.Rubinstein. 23:39  |  Arik 06/08/07
  63.   NOW is the time to get ALL the Palestinians from Iraq 23:50  |  Hamza 06/08/07
  64.   Stupidest article of the MONTH!! 00:16  |  polybios 07/08/07
  65.   There is no "game". This is our land. 00:23  |  Chaim 07/08/07
  66.   citizen/refugee status 00:28  |  Jim 07/08/07
  67.   #1 indrajaya 00:34  |  Jim 07/08/07
  68.   Failed Ideologues (Mark Lincoln #59) 00:39  |  Tosefta 07/08/07
  69.   You can`t negotiate with people who want to destroy you. 00:53  |  Josh N 07/08/07
  70.   This is all they want. 01:04  |  ScotGuy 07/08/07
  71.   #66 Citizen Jim or is that the Lord`s Jim? 02:30  |  Joel Weltman 07/08/07
  72.   KUTW 03:14  |  Lynn 07/08/07
  73.   what is there to negotiate? 03:27  |  shahid 07/08/07
  74.   Olmert and Haniyah should arm wrestle 03:29  |  tony J 07/08/07
  75.   Failed Ideologues (Mark Lincoln #59) 04:02  |  Tosefta 07/08/07
  76.   The Abominable Slowman 04:27  |  Danny Rubinstein 07/08/07
  77.   Hamas 04:39  |  C .Shallom 07/08/07
  78.   So let me get this straight... 04:55  |  Paul 07/08/07
  79.   re: citizen/refugee status 05:02  |  Paul 07/08/07
  80.   IF THERE ARE DECENT PEOPLE TO TALK WITH WHY TALK TO THUGS!!! 05:04  |  Marco 07/08/07
  81.   # 1-INDRAJAYA WHICH WORLD ARE YOU LIVING IN? Allien? 05:17  |  Marco 07/08/07
  82.   #65Chaim, it`s as much our land as it is yours and some! 06:53  |  Elias Khoury 07/08/07
  83.   Get that Chaim # 65 07:13  |  Steve the Pals. 07/08/07
  84.   Bravo! Bravo! Danny Rubinstein you are right on point! 08:34  |  Dutch 07/08/07
  85.   A "walk over" for Fatah.. 09:20  |  Willy 07/08/07
  86.   KUTW 09:24  |  Willy 07/08/07
  87.   #76DORIS AND THE POPE AGREE THEY HAVE NO EFFECT AT ALL 09:57  |  paul harris 07/08/07
  88.   39# Tosefta. Unfinished picture ! 10:11  |  Akram Zekaria 07/08/07
  89.   Marco, Your self -righteous attitude is short sighted 10:26  |  Dutch 07/08/07
  90.   Hamas Cannot be a partner for peace 10:26  |  Paul 07/08/07
  91.   76# Willy .The one who is not playing is Olmert. 10:30  |  Akram Zekaria 07/08/07
  92.   # 82 Support for Khoury 10:38  |  Andrew Watson 07/08/07
  93.   Akiva P #37 Hamas has a lot of destructive power 01:38  |  American in NY 14/08/07
  94.   KUTW #51 01:46  |  American in NY 14/08/07
 Today Online
U.K. panel tells Brown boycott of Hamas is counterproductive
Responses: 275
Israeli Arab group claims responsibility for Jerusalem attack
Responses: 143
Kurds build an island of calm within Iraq's inferno
Responses: 90
Shlomo Avineri: Israel cannot appear to be driving force in Iraq
Responses: 69
American billionaire Adelson pledges $60 million to birthright
Responses: 68


More Headlines
22:50 IDF identifies bodies of 5 soldiers killed in 1948 war
22:28 Prominent law professors sign petition slamming justice min.
23:41 Young Jewish woman, 23, attacked in Paris by hooded men
00:18 Hamas says it's ready for any dialogue with the West
22:29 MKs criticize Itzik for ignoring Holocaust survivors' plight
02:02 Anti-Zionist rabbi to arrive, lay J'lem housing project foundation
01:46 U.S. adds Islamic group in Lebanon to terrorism blacklist
22:31 IDF backtracks on criminalization of illegal W. Bank construction
23:15 IDF troops capture four armed Palestinian infiltrators near the Gaza border
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Hertz Special deals
don't miss Hertz fantastic deals for the "Tishrei" holidays
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved