Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., August 19, 2007 Elul 5, 5767 | | Israel Time: 14:31 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Arts & Leisure Real Estate Jewish World National Advertising
Magazine Week's End Business Opinion Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel Sports
British photojournalist James Miller, seen here at left holding camera, filming youths in Gaza on the day he was killed in May, 2003. (Archives)
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 08:03 06/08/2007
U.K. may seek extradition over British cameraman's Gaza death
By Akiva Eldar

Britain may seek the extradition of Israel Defense Forces troops in the shooting death of a British television cameraman in May 2003 in the southern Gaza Strip unless Attorney General Menachem Mazuz reverses his position and carries out a criminal investigation against those suspected of involvement.

In a letter to the family of James Miller, a 34-year-old photojournalist shot and killed in Rafah, Lord Peter Goldsmith, Britain's attorney general, says he wrote Mazuz on June 26 and gave him six weeks to respond. The deadline is on Tuesday.

According to Goldsmith, after an inquest by a coroner, Dr. Andrew Scott Reid, Miller had been unlawfully killed by troops of the Israel Defense Forces.

Advertisement
"Dr. Scott Reid wrote to me and invited me to consider instituting criminal proceedings in the United Kingdom against... members of the Israeli Defence Forces... for an offence of willful killing contrary to section I of the Geneva Conventions Act 1957."

While Goldsmith's letter does not explicitly discuss a possible request for an extradition, British law requires that any suspects be in British custody for charges to be brought up against them. Israel and Britain have an extradition treaty, and a refusal to extradite military personnel may result in a crisis between the two countries.

Justice Ministry sources confirmed that Goldsmith's letter had been received, but could not say how they would respond in the matter.

According to attorneys for the Miller family, Avigdor Feldman and Michael Sfard, as of last night there had still not been an official Israeli response to the letter from the British attorney general.

Miller was killed while filming a documentary in the southern Gaza town of Rafah, on the border with Egypt. According to Alrahman Abdallah, a freelance journalist who accompanied Miller as his translator, the photographer was shot as he tried to exit a Rafah house while holding a white flag.

A British inquiry, in part based on evidence from the video recording of the incident, showed that Miller was shot in the neck by an IDF patrol.

At the time the IDF expressed its sorrow for Miller's death and said that "the entry of photographers into war zones during exchanges of fire endangers both sides."

However, according to eyewitnesses, there had been calm in the area at the time of the shooting.

Initially, the IDF suggested that Miller had been killed by Palestinians. Ballistic tests carried out on behalf of Miller's family showed that IDF troops killed Miller, and the Military Advocate General ordered an investigation into the killing.

Following a lengthy investigation, it was decided in March 2005 not to press criminal charges against those involved because of insufficient evidence. The commander of the Israeli force that shot and killed Miller faced disciplinary proceedings for illegal use of firearms, but was exonerated.

Miller's family filed a suit against the State of Israel for murder, and in 2006 a British jury ruled the killing a murder.

In his letter to the Miller family, Lord Goldsmith points to the conclusions of an expert analysis of the video of the shooting, which he says was sent to Mazuz. According to the British attorney general, the conclusions of the expert "disproved the [Israeli] suggestion that the shots came from two areas... [and] identified the direction of the shot that killed James as coming from the armoured vehicle."

In Goldsmith's letter, received by Haaretz, the British attorney general writes that the ballistic tests carried out in Israel "could only show that the bullet that killed James did not come from the rifle barrels of the weapons that were examined." In essence, the senior British official is charging Israeli authorities with tampering with evidence, there having "been a significant opportunity for the rifle barrels to have been changed."

Requests to try those responsible and compensate the family - Miller is survived by his wife Sophy and two children - were raised at high-level talks between the two countries, including meetings between Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and his then counterpart, Tony Blair.

According to Feldman, the Israeli government did not treat these requests with the required seriousness and has not considered it necessary to compensate the families.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Who needs a director?
In the past, the playwright would see to it that his play was performed.
Hug by SMS
I found myself looking at the perfect condolence letter, but hesitating to press 'Send.'
  1.   U.K. and U.S. are allies 03:29  |  Wendy 05/08/07
  2.   deaths 04:20  |  DOV KORET 05/08/07
  3.   Where was Brown this week? 04:28  |  Mark Lincoln 05/08/07
  4.   U.K. and U.S are not allies 04:31  |  Truthteller 05/08/07
  5.   Working in a war zone 04:46  |  Joel Weltman 05/08/07
  6.   Extradite the alleged killer! 04:52  |  Dutch Dirk 05/08/07
  7.   UK Arrogance 04:54  |  Philippe 05/08/07
  8.   Millers Death is Unfortunate but Cameramen Take Risks 04:57  |  Dan Gerrious 05/08/07
  9.   To U.K. 04:58  |  Yosemite 05/08/07
  10.   Allies is all about personal interests and there US gives orders 05:17  |  The real Truthteller 05/08/07
  11.   Those must be same brits that 05:18  |  Mikle White 05/08/07
  12.   Israelis will be executed in British court system... 05:36  |  Tom 05/08/07
  13.   `Tried to Enter the Gaza Strip` 06:18  |  Tom 05/08/07
  14.   Poor Israel 06:29  |  Fred 05/08/07
  15.   Killing Journalists 06:48  |  Neil 05/08/07
  16.   Died in line of duty 06:59  |  Sam 05/08/07
  17.   UK extradiction 07:11  |  Vogel 05/08/07
  18.   Brazil to Demand Extradition 07:14  |  Bill 05/08/07
  19.   A Reply to talkback responses 07:19  |  MB 05/08/07
  20.   @6, dutch dirk, first let UK to prosecute 07:19  |  vladimir 05/08/07
  21.   UK Guilty of War Crimes They should be extradited 07:24  |  ralphsrant1 05/08/07
  22.   Fred, Fred. Poor you 07:41  |  Ruben Misrahi 05/08/07
  23.   ISN`T THAT AMAZING CASE 07:43  |  indrajaya 05/08/07
  24.   USAF accidently shot Brit soldiers in Iraq , we saw no extraditio 07:51  |  Joseph E . 05/08/07
  25.   brits in n. ireland 07:52  |  Tom hanks 05/08/07
  26.   Eldar`s an old far left shmatta 08:01  |  Maya 05/08/07
  27.   Miller was shot by a pal sniper , 08:13  |  Joseph E . 05/08/07
  28.   cameraman`s death 08:13  |  evan jones 05/08/07
  29.   ENGLAND DIGGING ITS OWN GRAVE 08:13  |  HAL TRIPP 05/08/07
  30.   #13 Tom seems to have missed something 08:25  |  Johnboy 05/08/07
  31.   investigations are still on....! 08:37  |  ravi 05/08/07
  32.   A LEGAL TRAVESTY! A BRITISH JURY FOUND? WHAT 08:38  |  paul harris 05/08/07
  33.   Fred # 14 08:52  |  ChanahS 05/08/07
  34.   The day of his death depicts Miller and his colleagues 08:52  |  Joseph E . 05/08/07
  35.   #19 MB 09:06  |  Joseph E . 05/08/07
  36.   No 17 09:08  |  Palestinian Brit 05/08/07
  37.   Poor Fred 09:10  |  Dan 05/08/07
  38.   Lord Goldsmith 09:15  |  Palestinian Brit 05/08/07
  39.   Fred baa baa 09:19  |  Hannah 05/08/07
  40.   Death In Gaza -- Watch The Film 09:20  |  Slibovitz 05/08/07
  41.   To All 09:22  |  Dan 05/08/07
  42.   Vogel even more 09:25  |  Hannah 05/08/07
  43.   Would the shooter get a fair trial? 09:29  |  Slibovitz 05/08/07
  44.   More Israeli holiday plans cancelled 09:31  |  Clickfool 05/08/07
  45.   It is high time the UK should ask itself why their press 09:36  |  Dalia Hareven 05/08/07
  46.   Cameraman looks like a gunman in the photo 09:39  |  Dani 05/08/07
  47.   We had Hass report for the weekend , we now have Akiva siftah 09:39  |  Joseph E . 05/08/07
  48.   A deliberate muredr by Lieutenant Haib 09:40  |  Clickfool 05/08/07
  49.   Letters 09:53  |  Ethan 05/08/07
  50.   Why is it that we only hear about British journalists getting 10:03  |  Israeli 05/08/07
  51.   The latent anti semitism lurking in the British claims 10:09  |  Aaron 05/08/07
  52.   Joseph E reaches for the IDF lie # 25 10:18  |  Clickfool 05/08/07
  53.   Question for Hal Tripp # 27 10:23  |  Clickfool 05/08/07
  54.   Aaron reaches for the anti-semitism label # 40 10:26  |  Clickfool 05/08/07
  55.   Aaron - reading through your smokescreen 10:30  |  Palestinian Brit 05/08/07
  56.   Brits OK murder of Brazilians 10:34  |  Semsem 05/08/07
  57.   Terrorism, Floods and Mad Cow Disease in Britain 10:37  |  Laila 05/08/07
  58.   It is difficult to separate between this case and 10:43  |  Buber 05/08/07
  59.   Don`t Just Extradite The Trigger Man 10:51  |  Rowan Berkeley 05/08/07
  60.   No 29 Warning shots 10:51  |  Palestinian Brits 05/08/07
  61.   British ballistic tests 11:00  |  Gil 05/08/07
  62.   compensation 11:02  |  samir khoury 05/08/07
  63.   # 40 Clickfool @ Sussex / England 11:31  |  Joseph E . 05/08/07
  64.   Ban all journalisys from Gaza, Judea etc 11:32  |  rich 05/08/07
  65.   Gil ballistic tests: the answer 11:32  |  Hannah 05/08/07
  66.   brits OK murder of civilians- 54 11:34  |  hannah fogel 05/08/07
  67.   Clickfool 11:37  |  watcher 05/08/07
  68.   aaron reading through your smoke screen 11:38  |  hannah fogel 05/08/07
  69.   F..the Brits,they cringed for Hamas&Iran,trying to compensate on 11:42  |  Absolute Sweden 05/08/07
  70.   Israel has to stop media from getting in!!! 11:51  |  Gil 05/08/07
  71.   Sami Khoury your are stepping in murkey waters 11:52  |  Judith, Haifa 05/08/07
  72.   #44 CLIKKY JOINS THE LYNCHING PARTY 11:53  |  paul harris 05/08/07
  73.   You are all forgetting one thing 11:55  |  Adrian de Klerk 05/08/07
  74.   As Aaron says, What had Israel to gain from the shooting 11:57  |  Hannah 05/08/07
  75.   Plagues in England etc # 57 11:58  |  Clickfool 05/08/07
  76.   What do Britons seek in the Gaza Strip but 12:00  |  Robert 05/08/07
  77.   samir khoury 12:06  |  hannah 05/08/07
  78.   clickfool-FROM RUSSIA WITH LOVE 12:08  |  Sam 05/08/07
  79.   PROWLING AROUND GAZA STRIP IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT VERY SAFE! 12:11  |  don 05/08/07
  80.