Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., August 11, 2007 Av 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:36 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:11 05/08/2007
The never-ending evacuation
By Haaretz Editorial

The evacuees of Gush Katif, who are having a hard time putting their lives back together, cannot be envied. Their situation is similar to that of middle-aged new immigrants, although they are not confronted by a language barrier and each has received some $500,000 in compensation. The main difficulty in absorbing them stems from the fact that they left behind an economic paradise, which was subsidized by the state, and most lack the professional skills needed for a free-market economy. In this, they are different from the Russian immigrants who were successfully absorbed in Israel.

Why are the evacuees unable to rebuild the businesses they left behind in Gush Katif, where they acquired their professional knowledge and experience? The first reason is that their businesses were not profitable even in Gush Katif. The second reason is they no longer enjoy cheap Palestinian labor, nearly free water, free land, subsidized electricity and tremendous tax benefits. The Gush Katif evacuees' lobby in the Knesset is trying to acquire even more compensation, each time for something else. It is very likely that this lobby will succeed, considering settlers' lobby victories of the past.

A new campaign related to the Gush Katif evacuees has recently begun: In addition to the demand for full pension benefits starting at age 46, they want more compensation for every child born in Gush Katif. In early July, a plan was presented to establish a new community called Mirsham in the Lachish region, for some of the Kfar Darom evacuees. Another new community, Givat Hazan, is intended to settle some of the residents of Neveh Dekalim. This is because of the evacuees' insistence that they not be absorbed into other communities in the area where permits have already been issued for the construction of thousands of new homes. Unfortunately, the evacuees do not wish to be assimilated, not even in communities with other evacuees. Each group selects several dozen families for its own dream community - built at the state's expense.

Advertisement
The position of the finance minister and environmental organizations is that new communities should not be constructed; rather, existing towns should be expanded. This is not merely in order to avoid damaging nature, but because of the enormous cost of building infrastructures for several dozen families. The response to the claim that the evacuees have been stuck in prefabricated homes since 2005 and that the state is behind in building permanent housing, is that it is very difficult to satisfy the wishes of the evacuees. For example, Avi Farhan is leading a group of 28 families who insist on living in Givat Olga.

The Lachish region is covered in fields and hills that attract residents of the crowded Dan region in the winter. These are the same people who pay high mortgages for small apartments, who have never received grants or benefits, who never have lived in villas that ranged from 250 to 450 square meters, and who were also not compensated for being evacuated. They, too, deserve nature and vistas.

The suffering of the Gush Katif evacuees is similar to that of the British evacuated from India, who had to leave behind mansions with servants to begin their life anew in a small apartment in Manchester. This is the price a state pays for exceeding both its borders and its logic. The never-ending problems of the absorption and inflated cost of the evacuation may deter against further evacuations, and perhaps this is the reason for this endless saga.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Food for thought
The Torah shows J'lem's role in taxes that were meant to stabilize Israelite society.
Shades of gray
'The Palestinian reality is perfect for mystery fiction,' says author Beynon Rees.
  1.   Enough Already 10:37  |  Eco 05/08/07
  2.   Welcome into the real world, no paradise ! 11:26  |  Sara 05/08/07
  3.   evacuees are racist kookians,racist Chabadists 11:31  |  KMS 05/08/07
  4.   Eco #1 11:31  |  Eco #1 05/08/07
  5.   Wicked Editorial 11:32  |  Nathan 05/08/07
  6.   Gaza evacuees are pawns of Israeli policy 11:51  |  Natallie Durson 05/08/07
  7.   How assimilitated are Gideon Levy,A.Hass,D.Rubinstein,Z.Barel ? 11:56  |  Absolute Sweden 05/08/07
  8.   Nattering Know It Alls 12:10  |  Meir 05/08/07
  9.   give the money to the holocaust survivors they went through worse 12:17  |  don 05/08/07
  10.   No sympathy 12:19  |  Amnon Goethe 05/08/07
  11.   Nyet to ha`aretz for vilifying the best of Jews 12:30  |  BenTemalion 05/08/07
  12.   You said it, eco 12:37  |  newageblue 05/08/07
  13.   #2, Absolute Sweden is setting new standards for assimilation 12:42  |  zmogus 05/08/07
  14.   Where in the world does the figure $500,000 come from? 12:52  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 05/08/07
  15.   this article is unfounded and full of lies 13:08  |  Ronit 05/08/07
  16.   At last it`s stated succinctly and honestly 13:23  |  Esther 05/08/07
  17.   Hippies, Lawyers, and beach side property 13:34  |  FOX 05/08/07
  18.   Grains of Sand 13:39  |  Choni Davidowitz 05/08/07
  19.   Total distortion 14:20  |  Yehudit 05/08/07
  20.   Evaciees 14:48  |  Hilda 05/08/07
  21.   Disgusting Cheap Shot Editorial 15:03  |  Ben Israel 05/08/07
  22.   19: Yes, Yehudit, your post is a complete distortion 15:30  |  David Teich 05/08/07
  23.   Longing for the days of yore...... 15:36  |  Esther 05/08/07
  24.   Honest Reporting 16:03  |  Double Click 05/08/07
  25.   +Esther 16:24  |  Jo Jo 05/08/07
  26.   Welfare Queens 16:24  |  Mark Lincoln 05/08/07
  27.   not like they had a choice!!!! 16:29  |  Ben 05/08/07
  28.   The cost is too high 17:00  |  Tosefta 05/08/07
  29.   Ben Temalion#11 about "best of Jews" 17:03  |  S 05/08/07
  30.   Mark Lincoln 26 17:18  |  Jo Jo 05/08/07
  31.   I paid for the settlements with my tax money 17:22  |  Yonatan 05/08/07
  32.   Not true Zionists 17:27  |  Yonatan 05/08/07
  33.   #22 Davud Teichm you said it much better than I could 17:42  |  Yonatan 05/08/07
  34.   What an work of fiction! 17:47  |  Menachem 05/08/07
  35.   Obligations 18:16  |  Hannah 05/08/07
  36.   Evil article 18:33  |  Ben 05/08/07
  37.   Thank You 18:43  |  Ari 05/08/07
  38.   yonatan 31 18:58  |  realism 05/08/07
  39.   Rubbish! This is the price paid for political corruption 19:25  |  bernard ross 05/08/07
  40.   Israelis won`t tolerate more evacuations. 19:28  |  Chaim 05/08/07
  41.   Government subsidies- worldwide not just Israel 19:28  |  Avrum 05/08/07
  42.   abject stupidity 19:40  |  chaim 05/08/07
  43.   The state ?excess?? 19:42  |  KUTW 05/08/07
  44.   What a bunch of whiners 19:42  |  Other Voices 05/08/07
  45.   3. KMS: what does this have to do with racism? 19:45  |  KUTW 05/08/07
  46.   16. Esther 19:53  |  KUTW 05/08/07
  47.   24.Double Click 20:01  |  KUTW 05/08/07
  48.   The never-ending evacuation 21:06  |  Bruce 05/08/07
  49.   40: Correct, Chaim, that doesn`t obviate that ... 21:34  |  David Teich 05/08/07
  50.   missing points 21:36  |  Michael N 05/08/07
  51.   Tosefta - of course, and isn`t that the objective? 22:04  |  Mark Lincoln 05/08/07
  52.   The priorities of Israelis - Yonatan 22:08  |  Mark Lincoln 05/08/07
  53.   Yes, Jo Jo 22:15  |  Mark Lincoln 05/08/07
  54.   # 5 Nathan. Wicked Editorial....... 22:55  |  Fed-Up 05/08/07
  55.   Not Enough Class 22:55  |  Double Click 05/08/07
  56.   The priorities of Israelis - Mark Lincoln 23:20  |  Bruce 05/08/07
  57.   Evacuation Makes Gazan Farms Wasteland and Farmers Pensioners 23:31  |  Efox 05/08/07
  58.   re: KMS 23:32  |  Efox 05/08/07
  59.   No 500,000 Dollars Has Been Paid to Most 23:36  |  Efox 05/08/07
  60.   Who is this Haaretz Editorial Person? 23:37  |  Efox 05/08/07
  61.   re: Tosefta 23:40  |  Efox 05/08/07
  62.   re: Mark Lincoln 23:45  |  Efox 05/08/07
  63.   Haaretz,|Why are You Not Putting Out My Response to# 5 Nathan?? 23:55  |  KATH` 05/08/07
  64.   When Feiglin is PM, we will rebuild Jewish Aza and... 23:55  |  Dudu 05/08/07
  65.   # 6 Durson.HOW CYNICAL OF YOU........ 23:57  |  KATH` 05/08/07
  66.   #49 David. On what basis was Disengagement "right"? 23:59  |  Chaim 05/08/07
  67.   re:Double Click 23:59  |  Efox 05/08/07
  68.   Response for Fed-up #54 00:00  |  Esther 06/08/07
  69.   # 50 Michel N.MISSING POINTS?NO! LIKE DURSON,YOU TOO ARE CINYCAL, 00:01  |  KATH` 06/08/07
  70.   55 Double Click 00:01  |  KUTW 06/08/07
  71.   Yonatan kfar-saba used to an arab village 00:08  |  Jabadini 06/08/07
  72.   re: Esther 00:09  |  Efox 06/08/07
  73.   Hannah - Gov told them if you dont agree to leave no compensation 00:11  |  Jabadini 06/08/07
  74.   Gaza Evacuees 00:15  |  Simcha 06/08/07
  75.   When Feiglin is PM... (Dudu #64) 00:15  |  Moshiach 06/08/07
  76.   For Ari #37 00:16  |  Esther 06/08/07
  77.   Well done #37 ari you helped start the destruction of your own 00:17  |  Jabadini 06/08/07
  78.   Michael N #50 the country doesnt care about them 00:20  |  Jabadini 06/08/07
  79.   # 68 Esther.Response for (ME) Thank You.. 00:23  |  Fed-Up (I am too) 06/08/07
  80.   FALSE HANNAH ALERT! #35 00:38  |  Hannah 06/08/07
  81.   # 58 and # 59 Efox. You are Just Wasting Your Breath.. 00:38  |  Fed-Up(yes it is me) 06/08/07
  82.   # 77 Jabadini re:#37 AND MY ADDENDUM TO YOURS 00:53  |  kATH` 06/08/07
  83.   Some thoughts 00:57  |  Gary 06/08/07
  84.   # 41 Avrum.IF HAARETZ PLEASES.WELL SAID I COMMEND YOUR POST.. 01:04  |  KATH` 06/08/07
  85.   KUTW TO ALL YOUR POSTS IN TRUTH AND RIGHT YOU ARE.. 01:09  |  KATH` 06/08/07
  86.   # 31 Yonatan and your Taxes.OH POOR YOU! READ ON .. 01:17  |  KATH` 06/08/07
  87.   HAARETZ.WHY ARE YOU BEING STINGY WITH THE POSTS?IS IT TOO MUCH 01:20  |  KATH` 06/08/07
  88.   All Hannahs are fake anyway 01:45  |  Shi`it happens 06/08/07
  89.   Poor Aristocrates 02:18  |  Danite 06/08/07
  90.   Mark Lincoln #52 02:20  |  Danite 06/08/07
  91.   mark Lincoln #51 02:20  |  Danite 06/08/07
  92.   # 73 Jabadini.I sent you a response but no sign of it yet!! 02:29  |  KATH` 06/08/07
  93.   # 83 Gary. Some,Thoughts. 03:26  |  KATH` 06/08/07
  94.   Gush Katif 03:37  |  YIDN 06/08/07
  95.   Compensation or Pay-Back time 04:03  |  Fair 06/08/07
  96.   Everyone should read that last paragraph over and over 04:09  |  Johnboy 06/08/07
  97.   Is Fair #93 really fair 04:28  |  Jabadini 06/08/07
  98.   Johnboy #96 04:59  |  Bruce 06/08/07
  99.   MOSHE FEIGLIN - MELECH YISRAEL! 05:23  |  Yosef 06/08/07
  100.   #97 Is Fair #95 really fair 05:28  |  Jabadini 06/08/07
  101.   Danite - #52 wrong and not paranoid 06:12  |  Mark Lincoln 06/08/07
  102.   Danite - welfare queens and reality 06:16  |  Mark Lincoln 06/08/07
  103.   mark Lincoln 07:36  |  danite 06/08/07
  104.   mark Lincoln 07:39  |  Danite 06/08/07
  105.   # 11 to ben temalion 07:47  |  eric 06/08/07
  106.   #69 KATH 08:01  |  Michael N 06/08/07
  107.   # 59 how do you know, efox? 08:07  |  eric 06/08/07
  108.   AMNON GOETHE NO 10. WE DONT NEED YOUR DAMN SYMPATHY. 08:57  |  Miriam Ashkelon 06/08/07
  109.   NO 11 BEN TEMALION - G-D BLESS YOU 08:59  |  Miriam - Ashkelon 06/08/07
  110.   Half truths and outright lies 09:36  |  Moshe 06/08/07
  111.   Haaretz: Why are you stll alive? 10:02  |  Vladimir 06/08/07
  112.   #96 Bruce seems not to know his history 10:25  |  Johnboy 06/08/07
  113.   85. KATH 11:25  |  KUTW 06/08/07
  114.   Settler apologists not making sense 23:12  |  Dov 06/08/07
  115.   112: JB can`t can`t get it right w/territories (2nd try) 10:48  |  David Teich 11/08/07
 Today Online
Ten wounded in shooting attack in Old City of Jerusalem
Responses: 288
Beilin: We must reach deal with Hamas prior to Mideast summit
Responses: 235
Jews, Catholics bid farewell to Jewish-born French cardinal
Responses: 171
Yoel Marcus: Mideast summit is Bush's last chance to defeat terror
Responses: 96
Benny Ziffer: Hebron evacuation was not a battle of good vs. evil
Responses: 69
Rosner: Orthodox Union should object to Jews' insubordination
Responses: 19


More Headlines
07:12 20 wounded in Gaza clashes after top Fatah officials arrested
10:56 Israeli Web site causes dirty bomb scare in New York
07:19 Ten wounded in shooting attack in Old City of Jerusalem
03:12 Egypt warns it won't take back refugees who cross into Israel
06:58 Security Council unanimously okays expansion of UN role in Iraq
22:33 Jews, Catholics bid farewell to Jewish-born French cardinal
05:18 Arabic-themed NYC school principal quits over criticism of 'intifada' T-shirts
19:02 Qassam rocket hits Sderot, sparks brushfire; no casualties
20:28 Tel Aviv court extends remand of developer Heftsiba`s CFO
22:03 Two people killed in two separate traffic accidents in North
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved