Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., August 13, 2007 Av 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:58 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Last update - 10:47 01/08/2007
Back to a corrupt occupation
By Amira Hass

In one of the alarming news items of the past week, it was reported that Israel has green-lighted the transfer of 1,000 rifles from Jordan to the security forces loyal to Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas.

This is not the first time Israel has permitted the transfer of weapons and security equipment to Abbas' forces. The alarming thing about this report is that Abbas and his circles continue to cling to the illusion that the failure in the Gaza Strip was purely military. Equally alarming is Fatah's determination to do what Israel and the United States expect (and which it failed to do in Gaza): Fight Hamas.

And there have been several other disturbing news items in recent days: Once again Israeli representatives are permitted to talk with official Palestinian representatives abroad; Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Abbas will meet again in the near future, this time in Jericho; civil coordination between Israel and the PA has been renewed; and at the Muqata in Ramallah a new American-Palestinian business project has been launched after President George W. Bush approved a loan of $228 million for small and medium-sized Palestinian businesses to improve the Palestinians' living standard. "The United States is committed to strengthening the Palestinian economy ... as an important step toward a peaceful and independent Palestinian state," declared the official July 27 State Department announcement.

Advertisement
Why are these news items worrying? Because they show that things have gone back to the way they were - that is, to the style of "managing the occupation" that reigned between 1994 and 2001, into which the Fatah movement integrated well. Now, as then, there is a Palestinian government (the legality of which is temporary and shaky) acceptable to Israel and the West; talks are supposedly taking place; the occupation continues; and the Palestinians are quarreling. Didn't this all lead to the second uprising?

It is not a Fatah man who heads the Palestinian government in Ramallah, but the spirit of Fatah as a ruling movement that continues to prevail - and with it, what made large portions of the public fed up with the movement. For example, Yasser Arafat unnecessarily inflated his security forces with people from poor families and from refugee families, with the aim of creating a large group of loyalists under his aegis in return for a meager but vital wage. Arafat hoped this would perpetuate their political support for his movement with no connection to his political impotence vis-a-vis the Israeli colonization and the policy of closure and separation.

The failure of this tactic became clear in the 2006 elections. The American and Israeli reliance on "bolstering Abbas' security mechanisms" shows that Arafat's logic is continuing to guide the three leaders who see the Palestinian people as the object of all kinds of "gestures" - even in the form of salaries for superfluous security people.

It is as though life under the Israeli occupation is not the main reason for the Palestinians' distress but rather "poverty" that appears to have materialized out of the blue.

Under the auspices of what is called "the peace process" between 1994 and 2001, and under the mantra of "strengthening the Palestinian economy will advance peace," many of the senior Fatah people and their circles hastened to make their personal fortunes. This might have been legitimate, of course, had the economic situation of a considerable part of the inhabitants of the occupied territories not become worse because of the Israeli restrictions on movement and had it not been a matter of money found for them in the coffers of Arafat and the Palestine Liberation Organization, or in shadier ways.

All too often there was a direct correlation between the newly rich Palestinian's ties to members of a Palestinian security force and the latter's ties to the Israeli Shin Bet security service or senior people in Israel. Closeness of this kind (to senior Fatah members and the Shin Bet) provided movement permits, ensured "family reunification," and so on. These and other kinds of occupation-dependent protectionism led the Palestinians to make a connection between "the peace process" and corruption.

The failures of 2006 and 2007 have not produced any proof, yet, that Fatah has learned the lesson. It has not distanced itself from protectionism and the system by which those close to the right people have convenient opportunities to get richer - in a sea of impoverishment.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Green giant
Yaniv Green's 16 points, 8 rebounds helped Israel beat Ukraine Saturday night.
Raw catch
Fresh fish need minimal treatment to become a delicacy worthy of any dinner table.
  1.   Danger Danger peace moves in the air,Amira is terrified 10:58  |  PETER SM 01/08/07
  2.   IT IS THE LAND, NOT ECONOMY 11:19  |  indrajaya 01/08/07
  3.   Amira, at least give it a chance...... 11:41  |  Esther 01/08/07
  4.   Ms. Hass, is there anything that Israel ever does and it is 11:50  |  Avihu 01/08/07
  5.   Fatah and Abbas do not believe in Democracy 11:51  |  Nina 01/08/07
  6.   Unfortunately not only a Palestinian problem here..... 12:06  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/08/07
  7.   Little completion to my # 6 12:21  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/08/07
  8.   # 6, SWISS (DINO) 12:23  |  indrajaya 01/08/07
  9.   Amira on Fatah 12:34  |  Nuradin 01/08/07
  10.   Yesterday was a key day for Fatah 12:45  |  Clickfool 01/08/07
  11.   Amir and Amira 13:13  |  Ronnie Wolman 01/08/07
  12.   # 8 Indrajaya 13:14  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/08/07
  13.   Amira is right,this policy is rotten to the core and will not 13:16  |  lakshmi 01/08/07
  14.   Amir and Amira 13:28  |  Ronnie Wolman 01/08/07
  15.   what´s so bad ??? 13:37  |  Jacob 01/08/07
  16.   For Clickfool and his "thieves and gangsters" 13:40  |  Esther 01/08/07
  17.   Israel should let Hamas to depose Abbas and smash Fatah in Judea 13:54  |  Uzi 01/08/07
  18.   14Ronnie Wolman,I don`t know whether you are aware that 13:59  |  lakshmi 01/08/07
  19.   amira`s hanging in the wind 14:03  |  peter 01/08/07
  20.   # 11 Ronnie Wolman Visions and ME = (natural) enemies ???? 14:09  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/08/07
  21.   There is much truth in what Amira says. 14:11  |  S 01/08/07
  22.   Amira ,an anti peace activist??? 14:12  |  Willy 01/08/07
  23.   reproducing the Oslo Euphoria 14:16  |  Khalid 01/08/07
  24.   Clickfool 14:21  |  Benny 01/08/07
  25.   Nina 14:31  |  Infidel Too 01/08/07
  26.   Treating the symptoms 14:32  |  bobby 01/08/07
  27.   #6, swiss dino, i totally agree 14:47  |  VIPER 01/08/07
  28.   #20 Suisse (Dino) on brain power 14:48  |  SG 01/08/07
  29.   Harakat al-Muqawima al-Islamiyya :Read and weep 14:50  |  Joel Weltman 01/08/07
  30.   This Is A Major Consequence of Occupation 14:57  |  Yaakov Sullivan 01/08/07
  31.   For Benny # 24 15:14  |  Clickfool 01/08/07
  32.   #30 YAAKOV WAVES THE TRICOLOUR 15:25  |  paul harris 01/08/07
  33.   # 27 VIPER 15:27  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/08/07
  34.   # 28 SG 15:36  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/08/07
  35.   Amend your Charter Ismail 15:37  |  Joel Weltman 01/08/07
  36.   THAT AMIRA SUPPORTS HAMAS IS ANYTHING BUT A SURPRISE. 15:45  |  martyrmaker 01/08/07
  37.   Paying the bills 15:53  |  Dr D 01/08/07
  38.   Swiss #6 and #7 16:25  |  Lynn 01/08/07
  39.   Corruption 16:56  |  Tony 01/08/07
  40.   pragmatism or high moral horse 16:57  |  Adam 01/08/07
  41.   # 38 Lynn 17:04  |  Swiss (Dino) 01/08/07
  42.   # 12, SWISS (DINO) 17:06  |  indrajaya 01/08/07
  43.   Israel needs a sea change in attitude 17:10  |  Ibrahim 01/08/07
  44.   Amira Hass 17:11  |  Ralph 01/08/07
  45.   23Khalid,are you opposed to the Arab Initiative? Hamas endorses 17:47  |  lakshmi 01/08/07
  46.   Stop all the crap! Here are the facts! 18:00  |  Robert Blum 01/08/07
  47.   corruption Tony`s logic is 18:02  |  bobby 01/08/07
  48.   Khalid#23 - Are Pals spoils of war, or spoiled brats? 18:04  |  William 01/08/07
  49.   Please deport Amira Mass to Gaza, let it live there 18:16  |  John Ryan 01/08/07
  50.   Dino Swiss (פעם שלישית ) 18:32  |  Judge Judy 01/08/07
  51.   SG 18:34  |  Hannah 01/08/07
  52.   bigotry, Swiss, and Indrajaya 18:37  |  bobby 01/08/07
  53.   The Occupation is a business, a partnership 18:40  |  El-birawi 01/08/07
  54.   Ibrahim, greedy and difficult? 18:43  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 01/08/07
  55.   Swiss 18:55  |  Gina 01/08/07
  56.   Swiss -- 2 18:59  |  Gina 01/08/07
  57.   Re: Feinstein/Lugar Resolution 19:16  |  Mimi 01/08/07
  58.   Margie on self-indulgence... 19:43  |  Ibrahim 01/08/07
  59.   El Birawie 19:46  |  Ibrahim 01/08/07
  60.   Bobbys Past 20:07  |  Tony 01/08/07
  61.   End the occupation... by kicking out the enemy to Jordan 20:07  |  JailAmiraHass 01/08/07
  62.   Amira Hass 20:08  |  Bill 01/08/07
  63.   Ibrahim 20:13  |  Brett 01/08/07
  64.   ...to Mr Clickfool...the smart...We`ll see how this will play amo 20:27  |  UGY the she camel 01/08/07
  65.   Self Indulgence 20:27  |  Tony 01/08/07
  66.   Amira is a woman of substance, vision, wisdom 20:36  |  Sam (UK) 01/08/07
  67.   Brett...grow up 20:42  |  Ibrahim 01/08/07
  68.   For "JailAmiraHass" # 61 21:00  |  Clickfool 01/08/07
  69.   The way to handle Hamas 21:03  |  Tosefta 01/08/07
  70.   What Hamas can do 21:07  |  Tosefta 01/08/07
  71.   Thanks Amira !! 21:08  |  David James Vickery 01/08/07
  72.   She really does support Hamas = TREASON 21:18  |  KJJ 01/08/07
  73.   David James Vickery 21:22  |  KJJ 01/08/07
  74.   Ibrahim - I`m all grown up 21:32  |  Brett 01/08/07
  75.   59Ibrahim & El Birawi,as both of you are Palestinians,one in the 21:43  |  lakshmi 01/08/07
  76.   Tony`s continued tortured logic 21:49  |  bobby 01/08/07
  77.   Tony`s self indulgence 21:54  |  bobby 01/08/07
  78.   Tony`s self indulgence 21:54  |  bobby 01/08/07
  79.   Ibrahim twist of logic 21:54  |  peter 01/08/07
  80.   El -Birawi -- there`s not much choice 21:55  |  Gina 01/08/07
  81.   Ibrahim -- Incorrect 22:00  |  Gina 01/08/07
  82.