Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., July 31, 2007 Av 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:09 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Everyone knows the solution
By Haaretz Editorial

Anyone with eyes in his head knows the land will be divided between the Israelis and the Palestinians, along borders similar to the pre-1967 lines, and that the refugee problem will be resolved through a reparations arrangement. Every few years, there is an attempt to move toward such a diplomatic division, and the moderates suffer a resounding failure as radicals on both sides undermine compromises by claiming "it's all mine."

The settlers think - correctly, by and large - that every failed round of talks further strengthens them, and that time is on their side. But what is good for the settlers is bad for the country. Last week, Moshe Levinger and Daniella Weiss were once again clashing with Israel Defense Forces soldiers on hilltops. Another Sebastia at Homesh, another house commandeered by squatters, another expansion of an existing settlement, another infiltration of an Arab neighborhood. If Israel's strategic goal is to live in peace with its neighbors, it must work harder to block the settlers. Anyone who does not want a historic compromise is bolstered by the violence and suffering the sides cause each other.

Has another opportunity for change become available, now that the West Bank is controlled by PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas and Prime Minister Salam Fayad, and the State of Israel is being led by people prepared to divide the land? Will Tony Blair, even if his job is limited to establishing Palestinian government institutions, generate a sweeping new dynamic? Has Condoleezza Rice committed herself to advancing an Israeli-Palestinian agreement as part of the global effort to bolster the moderates? Will the peace-seeking Israeli president contribute?

Advertisement

The Israeli side cannot wait for the results of the tussle between Hamas and Fatah. It was therefore important to hear the prime minister, his vice-premier Haim Ramon and Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni saying that "there is a partner for talks," and that these talks should take place urgently. The ball is largely in our court, as we are the party in possession of the territories supposed to serve the independent Palestinian state. The disengagement from Gaza, which is considered a failure, was not carried out by agreement with the Palestinians. But despite the Qassam fire, nobody can imagine another solution to the conflict other than each side assembling in its own independent country.

Ehud Olmert's government is powerful in the Knesset and weak among the public, but the diplomatic positions it is putting forward vis-a-vis the Palestinians are held by the majority. The public does not support the evacuees who want to return to Homesh. Abbas and Fayad claim this is also the case on the Palestinian side, and that if a fair agreement is placed on the table and put to a referendum, a majority of Palestinians will support it. We currently have the opportunity to draft such an agreement, even if its implementation is postponed or partially executed according to Ramon's plan, which calls for a withdrawal by agreement, and the deployment of an international force in the area. Since the solution is really not in dispute, and both sides have learned and suffered much from the second intifada, we may be able to come to the international conference being planned for this fall with more than an agreement of principles, and have the moderate Arab states help promote it.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Sewage Valley
A stench hangs over Majdal Krum, as the greenery is flourishing in a bed of sewage.
Now what?
Despite the latest rally of the stock market, after its sharp fall, the future is still cloudy.
  1.   the error is in denying the land of israel haaretz 09:39  |  victor hardman 29/07/07
  2.   Everyone knows the solution 09:52  |  iletzter 29/07/07
  3.   Settlers know better 10:03  |  Wandering Jew 29/07/07
  4.   Learn from experience 10:03  |  Former meretz voter 29/07/07
  5.   Everyone Knows The ONLY Solution Is To Expel Our Enemies 10:08  |  Yishai Kohen 29/07/07
  6.   time is on our side 10:17  |  Uri 29/07/07
  7.   #1 legal or not 10:19  |  A.M. 29/07/07
  8.   Expelling the Palestinians 10:25  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  9.   Real solution must allow everybody to stay where they are and 10:25  |  Uzi 29/07/07
  10.   No 1 - legal in whose eyes? 10:27  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  11.   Timely editorial 10:30  |  Esther 29/07/07
  12.   Want to divide land or not? 10:34  |  Tzfonit 29/07/07
  13.   Hem Shelanu? 10:37  |  ussishkin 29/07/07
  14.   Israeli cocoons 10:39  |  Clickfool 29/07/07
  15.   #5 Everyone knows the only solution 10:39  |  Jens 29/07/07
  16.   For Victor Hardman # 1 10:45  |  Clickfool 29/07/07
  17.   Solution 10:52  |  YIDN 29/07/07
  18.   Fatah - No 11 10:59  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  19.   Am I dreaming? No 16 11:00  |  ussishkin 29/07/07
  20.   In Switzerland we also have our "settlers" 11:03  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/07/07
  21.   Response for Ussishkin #13 11:03  |  Esther 29/07/07
  22.   Settlers 11:09  |  Gabe 29/07/07
  23.   Little, but important correction to my # 20 11:11  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/07/07
  24.   Settlers to No.20 the Swiss Patriot 11:11  |  Gabe 29/07/07
  25.   everyone knows simply means brainwashed 11:14  |  joe 29/07/07
  26.   Mountain Huts on Mount Hermon? 11:14  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  27.   To Islamists, ALL Israelis are settlers ! 11:15  |  Paul Henzen 29/07/07
  28.   Let the Settlers of Tel Aviv Leave First 11:24  |  Yaakov Ish Tam 29/07/07
  29.   Settlers part of Israel? 11:28  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  30.   For Gabe #22 11:35  |  Esther 29/07/07
  31.   # 24 (The Israeli) Gabe 11:38  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/07/07
  32.   What you won`t see 11:38  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/07/07
  33.   Palestine supporter 11:42  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/07/07
  34.   # 26 Palestinian Brit What about a settler mountain village ?? 11:44  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/07/07
  35.   As Palestinians console themselves Israel will soon be destroyed 11:46  |  Sam 29/07/07
  36.   #16 how it is viewed clikky is not the legal situation 11:51  |  victor hardman 29/07/07
  37.   No violence amongst Israeli`s? 11:51  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  38.   Settlers of Tel Aviv etc 12:00  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  39.   Strategic Goal 12:03  |  Johnny Weintraub 29/07/07
  40.   Palestinian Brit 12:05  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/07/07
  41.   For Victor Hardman, doing Zionist somersaults # 36 12:12  |  Clickfool 29/07/07
  42.   PB 12:13  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/07/07
  43.   Israeli violence - Margie 12:17  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  44.   # 32 Margie in Tel Aviv 12:19  |  Swiss (Dino) 29/07/07
  45.   Margie - because they were Jews? 12:21  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  46.   "Sooner or later there will have to be a settlement" 12:22  |  Sam 29/07/07
  47.   It`s always been land for peace, but where`s the peace? 12:22  |  Nannette 29/07/07
  48.   And where is the land....? 12:30  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  49.   Palestinian Brit 12:32  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/07/07
  50.   Water shortage in the gulf 12:50  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  51.   Peace Huts on the Golan 12:54  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  52.   No Jews in the Muddle East? 13:02  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  53.   So Obvious 13:05  |  ERSB 29/07/07
  54.   IF "HAARETZ" CONTINUES TO CENSOR OPINIONS 13:05  |  index_on_censorship 29/07/07
  55.   341 that is the chuckle clikko how to make asilk purse out of a 13:18  |  victor hardman 29/07/07
  56.   UNTIL ONE SIDE BE TOTALLY DESTROYED 13:20  |  indrajaya 29/07/07
  57.   The existence of the "settlements" is legal 13:23  |  Montefiore 29/07/07
  58.   Settlements maybe legal - in Palestine 13:38  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  59.   Anybody with eyes in their head 13:43  |  A man with eyes 29/07/07
  60.   Anyone with a brain in his head... 13:44  |  Choni Davidowitz 29/07/07
  61.   Gave back Gaza 13:48  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/07/07
  62.   Palestinian Brit 13:51  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/07/07
  63.   Gaza abandoned 13:59  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  64.   Everyone knows the solution, indeed, the transfer of most of the 14:04  |  Avihu 29/07/07
  65.   The solutions is closing down Haaretx newspaper 14:07  |  Shmuel 29/07/07
  66.   # 8 Palestinian Brit 14:12  |  Gil 29/07/07
  67.   Jordan yes. Egypt...? 14:19  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  68.   How is it good for us to pay "reparations" to deserting Arabs? 14:28  |  Reuven 29/07/07
  69.   Kuwait. 14:39  |  Palestinian Brit 29/07/07
  70.   Extremism: An Extreme Solution 15:03  |  Idan 29/07/07
  71.   You first, Victor # 55 15:03  |  Clickfool 29/07/07
  72.   # 67 Palestinian Brit`s taqqiyah 15:31  |  martyrmaker 29/07/07
  73.   Marvelous Article by Haaretz 15:33  |  Sharif Hafez 29/07/07
  74.   Palestinian Brit, Jerusalem is NOW open to people of all faiths, 15:36  |  Avihu 29/07/07
  75.   Occupation is a crime 15:39  |  Euroliberal 29/07/07
  76.   The settler enterprise is America`s curse 15:40  |  Ivar 29/07/07
  77.   #71 so clikky posts tripe but cannot back it up with fact 15:41  |  victor hardman 29/07/07
  78.   Yes, Time Is On Israel`s Side 15:43  |  Ben Israel 29/07/07
  79.   DECEPTION For Islam:Muslims already HAVE Arab Palestinian State 15:51  |  Linda Rivera 29/07/07
  80.   U$ $$ fund an army of OCCUPATION, creating WAR 15:52  |  Ivar 29/07/07
  81.   If Everyone REALLY KNEW 15:53  |  Kate 29/07/07
  82.   The Wicked PROPAGANDA Lie of Occupation 15:56  |  Linda Rivera 29/07/07
  83.   One Million JEWISH Refugees&Their Descendants Must be COMPENSATED 16:04  |  Linda Rivera 29/07/07
  84.   #79 ivar and his childs intelligence ! 16:07  |  victor hardman 29/07/07
  85.   To the editors - a clarification, please 16:09  |  Yonatan 29/07/07
  86.   Re: iletzter 16:15  |  PIN 29/07/07