Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., July 31, 2007 Av 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:40 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The Saudi fantasy
By Zvi Bar'el

The town square is full of joy. A divine voice has been heard heralding the news that soon his lordship from Riyadh will be arriving for a visit; maybe not a real visit, but there most certainly will be a meeting. Alright, maybe not a private meeting with the head of the shtetl, but certainly he will pass by and wave hello from his carriage. Maybe he won't wave hello, but he'll certainly agree to be photographed, something to put on the bookcase in a nice cardboard frame - to make the neighbors jealous.

Saudi Arabia has become the fantasy of Israeli policymakers. After Jordan and Egypt are "in our pocket," their foreign ministers, who visited Israel on Wednesday, can forget about new conciliatory gestures. Israel, please note, is in the midst of a new courtship season: It's either Saudi Arabia or nothing. If you bring Saudi Arabia, you'll get territories, illegal outposts, prisoner releases, withdrawal to the '67 lines, an arrangement for the refugees, and a villa and a car as well. Anyone who wants Israel to accept the Saudi peace initiative will be so kind as to first bring Saudi Arabia.

It is difficult to understand why Saudi Arabia has become such a desirable objective. Certainly not because it is controlled by a corrupt family of princes, or because part of radical Islam grew in its bosom. Nor is the model of human and civic rights in the country exactly the heart's desire of every peace-loving liberal. Maybe the reason is that Saudi Arabia disproves the claim that only democracies don't fight one another - but Egypt already disproved this through nearly 30 years of peace with Israel, and the same is true of Jordan.

Advertisement

Apparently the real reason is related to the outmoded idea that if Saudi King Abdullah will agree to meet with the president or prime minister of Israel, then all the Arab leaders will march en masse in the direction of Jerusalem, and Israel will then really become an inseparable part of the Middle East.

But Saudi Arabia is not exactly at the forefront of the Arab world. It did not succeed in preventing the occupation of Kuwait by Iraq in 1990, or the first and second Iraqi wars. It is not succeeding in bringing about a political compromise in Lebanon, and friendship is not exactly the term to describe its relations with Syria. It is in a conflict with Qatar; is making out, not in secret, with Iran; is unable to influence events in Iraq, and even its worthwhile efforts to make peace among the Palestinians have been a resounding failure. The Mecca summit left more holes than solutions.

And yet Saudi Arabia chalked up a particularly important achievement, when without consulting any Arab leader it presented its peace initiative and turned it into the Arab initiative. By doing so, it brought about a new consensus in the Middle East. Not simply a dialectical change, this is a new basis of understandings for ending the Israeli-Arab conflict. While there are understandings and an Arab agreement, we would do well to remember that Saudi Arabia is not responsible for the individual behavior of every Arab country toward Israel.

And now, with near genius, Israel is succeeding in convincing everyone that the Saudi initiative, which is full of demands of Israel, must be implemented by Saudi Arabia rather than by Israel. As though Saudi Arabia has to withdraw from the territories and deal with the right of return or peace with the Palestinians. As though Saudi Arabia has to make peace with Syria or remove the settlements.

Those who are disseminating the Saudi dream should pinch themselves: Saudi Arabia is neither the prize nor the threat. When U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice and Secretary of Defense Robert Gates arrive in Israel this week, we should once again ask them why they are searching in the wrong place for Israel's sake. Why aren't they promoting negotiations with Syria; how will they turn President George W. Bush's international summit into a show with content and not only fireworks, and are they convinced that the "agreement of principles" being proposed by Prime Minister Ehud Olmert to Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas is not just another piece of paper that fell out of the loose-leaf binder of Oslo Accord drafts? These are the real issues the Olmert government has to address. It would be nice if an important Saudi Arabian visited Israel and had his picture taken here - but no Qassam rocket will pause in mid-air for that reason.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Galilean shelters
Until now, Galilee cliff dwellings and refuge caves have not been studied in depth.
Confidence booster
From pillaging the fridge to competing on the race track: 3 stories of personal change.
  1.   How stupid do they think we are? 09:52  |  Mike Blackman 29/07/07
  2.   Possession is nine tenths of the law. 10:39  |  Uzi 29/07/07
  3.   #1, Mike Blackman 11:31  |  Silvienne 29/07/07
  4.   Another angle 11:50  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/07/07
  5.   Accepting the Saudi plan would save Israels dignity 11:52  |  Natallie Durson 29/07/07
  6.   #3 if you get the law right silvienne you have a point 11:53  |  victor hardman 29/07/07
  7.   SAUDI IS THE NEXT TARGET 13:06  |  indrajaya 29/07/07
  8.   The Israeli Initiative 13:26  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/07/07
  9.   The Saudis would be most useful if they assisted Jordan and Egypt 13:58  |  Avihu 29/07/07
  10.   indrajaya is right on target 14:13  |  Joel Weltman 29/07/07
  11.   So exactly what do you think Condi Rice is shoving down our throa 15:21  |  Simcha 29/07/07
  12.   What`s the Saudi Plan for Iran?Iraq?Jordan?? 15:25  |  Simcha 29/07/07
  13.   Even without right of return 16:11  |  AnonUSA 29/07/07
  14.   For # 5 Natalie Durson - A Disagreement 19:05  |  chet 29/07/07
  15.   Is any other Arab nation amicable ? 19:32  |  Lou B 29/07/07
  16.   Lou B and amicability 19:58  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 29/07/07
  17.   Zvi Barel is right about his main point 20:13  |  David Hoffman 29/07/07
  18.   And the (poliitical) games go on 20:22  |  TonyL 29/07/07
  19.   Saudi royal family doesn`t want to die either. 20:36  |  Jack Garbuz 29/07/07
  20.   Much more than a Saudi fantasy ... 23:16  |  Dutch 29/07/07
  21.   14.Chet,you may want to check this out,`Why does Bush talk about 23:43  |  lakshmi 29/07/07
  22.   Its no FANTASY that 15 saudis did 9/11,US 2 give them arms? 09:45  |  sam 30/07/07
  23.   #6 Victor doesn`t seem to know his law 10:49  |  Johnbou 30/07/07
 Today Online
10,000 academics sign petition against U.K. boycott bid
Responses: 263
Moshe Arens: JNF's Jews-only land sale violates democracy
Responses: 66
Rosner's Guest: Anti-Israel sentiment in the Democratic Party
Responses: 55
Olmert, Abbas said holding secret talks on final status agreement
Responses: 59
Yoel Marcus: Bush is admitting his Mideast policies have failed
Responses: 18


More Headlines
20:59 PM expects calm summer, fall, despite warnings of impending war
21:36 Suspects in killing of 10-year-old Palestinian girl not to be tried
20:40 Hamas provides limited proof for sweeping allegation against PA gov't
15:55 Israel restores contacts with official PA representatives abroad
21:00 Russia announces intentions to downgrade ties with Hamas
19:59 Palestinian security prisoners' matriculation exams halted
17:38 Second child in week dies while trapped inside parents' car
21:09 Histadrut: Negev firm instigated forged letter saying labor dispute over
15:29 PM granted Holocaust survivors' stipend to CIS immigrants
18:59 4 mothers of murder victims to protest public apathy outside Knesset
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved