Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., December 23, 2007 Tevet 14, 5768 | | Israel Time: 13:26 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File Hanukkah
del.icio.us
Digg It!  new
Their success is the problem
By Abraham H. Foxman

Yair Sheleg in "The Dilemma of American Jews" (Haaretz, July 18) speaks to critical issues facing the American Jewish community but gets them wrong.

As has been said many times, the great challenge facing Jews in America is maintaining Jewish identity. Sheleg agrees with this but the context in which he presents the subject is out of whack and reflects an outdated model.Sheleg posits the dilemma facing Jews as one of integration and acceptance by the surroundings versus preservation of Jewish identity. He talks as if Jews are still unsure about their acceptance in America and that as a result they run from their Jewish identity so as not to jeopardize that acceptance. To back up this thesis, he cites numerous examples, such as the fact that campaigns against mixed marriages are dismissed and that far greater donations from the community go to general causes than Jewish ones. Sheleg also notes that Jews oppose government subsidies for Jewish education, which he attributes to the greater importance for Jewish self-image to be part of the liberal camp than to reinforce Jewish identity. Furthermore, he claims that the fact that the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) did not sing "Hatikva" at its national conference is an indicator that Jews are terrified of "dual loyalty" charges and thus it affects their behavior.

In a way I'm tempted to say that the challenges facing American Jews are greater than Sheleg describes because the issue of Jewish continuity stems not from insecurity, as he alleges, but rather from a level of comfort and apathy in society. I am not suggesting that there are no insecurities in American Jewish life. There surely still are. However, the dominant reason why Jews are not maintaining their Jewish identity is not that they are escaping their Jewishness but rather their indifference to it in an open and welcoming country.
Advertisement
American Jews give the bulk of their donations to hospitals, cultural institutions and universities because they are fully part of American society. It's a natural development both in terms of having impact on the general culture and for receiving plaudits for the effort. Philanthropy to Jewish institutions, of which there is also a lot, does not offer the level of prestige and fame that comes with giving to the other institutions. That's a price of acceptance, not rejection.

Questions may have been raised over "Hatikvah" not being sung at AIPAC. Yet it hardly signifies wider Jewish fears about dual loyalty. American Jewish support for Israel in every sense - financially, politically, emotionally, publicly - is as strong as ever. This is the case even as people like John Mearsheimer, Stephen Walt and Jimmy Carter seek to intimidate Jews by accusing them of controlling American policy against the interests of their own country. Again, Sheleg is overstating the insecurity factor.

As to Jewish opposition to government funding for religious education: There is a lively debate on this subject within the community. However, it is a misunderstanding to suggest, as Sheleg does, that opposition reflects a distorted self- image or that being part of the liberal world is more important than reinforcing Jewish identity. It is, rather, a product of an understanding that Jewish life in America is unique, as British historian Paul Johnson noted, exactly because of church-state separation. Moreover, those who oppose funding fear that the freedom and comfort level of American Jews will be eroded if the wall of separation is eviscerated.

The challenge of maintaining Jewish identity in America does not come from Jews worrying about their place in America. That was true in years past. Today, it comes from a sense that in a free country, being Jewish may not be significant to them. This apathy or indifference is what leads to intermarriage and distancing from the community.

In sum, Sheleg is right to worry about Jewish continuity. It is a problem we all worry about, even in Israel. It is the draw of America, not the fear of it, that makes the challenge very different from the one Sheleg articulates. In many ways, it is even a more difficult challenge. As tough as it is to rouse the community in the face of fears, it is even more so in the face of indifference. Identifying the problem correctly is the first step to solving it.

Abraham H. Foxman is national director of the Anti-Defamation League and author of "The Deadliest Lies: The Israel Lobby and the Myth of Jewish Control," to be published by Palgrave Macmillan.
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Bye bye Borat
Sacha Baron Cohen will reportedly retire his much-loved alter-egos Borat and Ali G.
Divided reformists
Reform head Eric Yoffie slams a vote on Jerusalem by the Conference of Presidents.
  1.   America 10:48  |  Hannah 27/07/07
  2.   Carter intimidating Jews? 11:14  |  Wiktor 27/07/07
  3.   Religious Indifference 11:15  |  Bandar Michaels 27/07/07
  4.   Condoleeza says get out of the West Bank 13:11  |  Chris Linthwaite 27/07/07
  5.   No. 3 14:11  |  W 27/07/07
  6.   assimilation and secular lifestyle 15:00  |  kyle 27/07/07
  7.   Perhaps it has something to do with... 15:01  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/07/07
  8.   Perhaps it has something to do with...Part II 15:11  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/07/07
  9.   Yaakov Sullivan #6 and #7 15:36  |  Chaval 27/07/07
  10.   Wiktor, of course you`re right 15:42  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/07/07
  11.   Yaakov Sullivan 15:51  |  Oh Please 27/07/07
  12.   Yaakov Sullivan #10 15:56  |  Facts and Figures 27/07/07
  13.   Their cheating is the problem 16:05  |  Dav 27/07/07
  14.   Oh Please is all we get??? #11 16:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/07/07
  15.   Ah, yes, the Christian zionists in US #12 16:21  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/07/07
  16.   Answer is Make Jewish Schools More Accessible 16:35  |  ME 27/07/07
  17.   All the Paradigms are Inaccurate 16:42  |  ARTH 27/07/07
  18.   We ARE Different - Admit It! 16:47  |  Tony Anthony 27/07/07
  19.   Live and Let Live 16:49  |  Happy 27/07/07
  20.   Yaakov Sullivan 16:49  |  Facts and Figures 27/07/07
  21.   Jewish Charity goes to 16:52  |  Jews around world 27/07/07
  22.   Is this why Foxman sees anti-Semitism behind every potted plant? 16:55  |  George W 27/07/07
  23.   Adaptation and evolution. 17:00  |  Seth Halpern 27/07/07
  24.   Adaptation and evolution. 17:01  |  Seth Halpern 27/07/07
  25.   Schooling 17:01  |  Eli 27/07/07
  26.   Jewish survival depends on 17:05  |  Israel 27/07/07
  27.   Most in America encourage the Jews to not only maintain their 17:19  |  Virginia 27/07/07
  28.   Will you kiss the Torah today?Thanks be to God & Am. Jews, I will 17:24  |  Virginia 27/07/07
  29.   A melting pot in which... 17:26  |  Veritas 27/07/07
  30.   What problem? From my view, I can not see one. Anyone want to 17:29  |  Virginia 27/07/07
  31.   Abe the mouth Foxman 17:40  |  Mira 27/07/07
  32.   Yaakov #`s 6&7, Great posts.Love God who Commands we be our best 17:45  |  Virginia 27/07/07
  33.   a melting pot and multicultural 18:29  |  America is both 27/07/07
  34.   Do as I say, not as I do 18:39  |  Tosefta 27/07/07
  35.   future of the Jews in America 18:43  |  20-50 years ahead 27/07/07
  36.   When God builds the bridge, who can demolish it? 18:45  |  Virginia 27/07/07
  37.   17 Virginia - American Evangelical Duality 18:48  |  Mark of Lewiston 27/07/07
  38.   America`s success has been accompanied by a fear of the pampered 18:56  |  David Hoffman 27/07/07
  39.   17 Virginia - American Evangelical Duality 2 19:00  |  Mark of Lewiston 27/07/07
  40.   Loving Jews to death 19:15  |  Mark Marshall 27/07/07
  41.   Yaakov Sullivan 19:45  |  Gina 27/07/07
  42.   IDENITY AND EINSTIEN AND IMPORTANCE 19:56  |  JACK EL BEANSTALK 27/07/07
  43.   IDENITY EINSTIEN IMPORTANCE? TWO 20:03  |  JACK EL BEANSTALK 27/07/07
  44.   #2 & 4 20:22  |  Czarkazem13 27/07/07
  45.   20-50 years ahead - You are right 20:23  |  American 27/07/07
  46.   Mira - AMEN! 20:24  |  American 27/07/07
  47.   20-50 years ahead Abe Foxman No Job 20:36  |  Yosemite 27/07/07
  48.   Their success is the problem - But.... 20:36  |  Joel 27/07/07
  49.   Success! 20:53  |  P. J. Casey 27/07/07
  50.   The biggest danger to Judaism 21:19  |  michael N 27/07/07
  51.   Gina #40 and look at what happens to those... 21:22  |  Yaakov Sullivan 27/07/07
  52.   Mark of Lewiston 21:40  |  Gina 27/07/07
  53.   American 21:41  |  Gina 27/07/07
  54.   Mark # 36 & 38, A sad letter. Many Evangelicals are still unaware 21:42  |  Virginia 27/07/07
  55.   Mira 21:48  |  Gina 27/07/07
  56.   Yosemite, Do you know the Hebrew word for "The Way" 21:54  |  Virginia 27/07/07
  57.   Rmember Hyman Appelman.... 21:56  |  Webster 27/07/07
  58.   Better to assimilate to US civism then to 22:21  |  Joseph E . 27/07/07
  59.   Yaakov Sullivan 22:46  |  Gina 27/07/07
  60.   49 Gina - Thanks for the InfoGina 22:49  |  Mark of Lewiston 27/07/07
  61.   Jackass 23:17  |  Paul 27/07/07
  62.   Fear and Acceptance 23:22  |  Efox 27/07/07
  63.   To Webster 55 23:24  |  Jewish AND American 27/07/07
  64.   Webster 23:25  |  Simone 27/07/07
  65.   American Jewish Success 23:32  |  Sidney Fink 27/07/07
  66.   `60" Sidney Fink 00:02  |  Labhras 28/07/07
  67.   Message to Foxman 00:03  |  Tod Zuckerman 28/07/07
  68.   The wierd vision 01:56  |  Mark Lincoln 28/07/07
  69.   Yeah right US support to Israel , like Condi barking at Olmert 03:38  |  Joseph E . 28/07/07
  70.   #69, Joseph E....there`s gratitude for you... 05:16  |  Silvienne 28/07/07
  71.   Jewish Men 06:43  |  NYC 28/07/07
  72.   Jewish Men 07:52  |  Silvienne 28/07/07
  73.   Any Volunteers? 08:01  |  Yosemite 28/07/07
  74.   # 70 Silvienne @ Darien / CT 08:17  |  Joseph E . 28/07/07
  75.   # 15 Yaakov Sullivan - `Sectarians` 11:22  |  Paul Henzen 28/07/07
  76.   A solution: make Judaism more accessible 11:58  |  Paul Henzen 28/07/07
  77.   A Question 13:44  |  Fred Willis 28/07/07
  78.   intimidation 14:50  |  truth 28/07/07
  79.   20-50 years 14:52  |  no superpower 28/07/07
  80.   TO ALL Antisemites a personal apology. 15:34  |  PETER SM 28/07/07
  81.   The Sly Fox 15:48  |  Double Click 28/07/07
  82.   #77 for the same reason as you read the bibles 16:41  |  victor hardman