Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., May 11, 2008 Iyyar 6, 5768 | | Israel Time: 19:48 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

The new/old anti-Semitism By Ioram Melcer "The Resurgence of Anti-Semitism: Jews, Israel, and Liberal Opinion," by Bernard Harrison. Rowman and Littlefield, 219 pages, $24.95 This time last year, when one million Israelis were spending their days in bomb shelters, when the north of the country was being bombarded with rockets and Israel was pounding to a pulp considerable parts of southern Lebanon and Beirut, many among us expressed a longing for what is known in Hebrew as hasbara, a state-organized PR campaign explaining Israel's situation to the world. A vague wave of yearning for hasbara, that elusive goddess, swept through the country. To the outside observer, it seemed as though Israelis were gazing up at the media heavens and muttering: If only they understood us, if only they knew the truth, then they wouldn't be saying such terrible things about us. In their despair, they might then well add: they're all anti-Semites, anyway. In "The Resurgence of Anti-Semitism," the American philosopher Bernard Harrison offers a foreigner's perspective on the sense, which haunts many Jews and non-Jews, in Israel and abroad, that anti-Semitism has increased, its two-millennia-old essence unchanged despite the different exterior. Being an analytical philosopher, Harrison approaches the subject as a reader of texts. The subtitle of his book attests to the focus of his reading: "Jews, Israel and Liberal Opinion." That is, Harrison explores neither the murky waters of the radical right in Europe, nor the distinctly anti-Semitic hues with which certain extremist Islamic group have colored some of their messages. Advertisement What interests Harrison, rather, is the anti-Semitism he identifies in the left, among those who hold liberal opinions. Indeed, that is the most problematic area for the northern Israeli being bombarded in the summer of 2006, and for any Israeli or Jew with sensibilities, opinions and a conscience. After all, it is no wonder that the radical right continues to embrace racist positions and rhetoric toward Jews as individuals, as a group, as a people and as a race. Nor is it very surprising that some of the Arab anti-Semites use racist and even Nazi imagery and propaganda as a tool in their struggle against their perceived enemy. Harrison's wonder increases when he encounters distinctly anti-Semitic images, the most crude and offensive kind of prejudice, in, of all things, the discourse of his own natural habitat, the American and European liberal left. Harrison's book asks "Why?," but the answers are not easily found. He presents contemporary cross-sections of politics, morality and culture in the West, especially in the left, and uses them to understand attitudes toward Israel, Zionism and Jews in general. For example, if in the past the left focused on questions of history, society and culture, today it emphasizes the moral dimension. Obviously, the political and international reality of the Israeli- Palestinian conflict presents that left with ample opportunities for moral judgment. Harrison shows that in more than a few cases, when criticism is directed at the Israeli side, the imagery, concepts and underlying assumptions are derived from the "old" anti-Semitism. In an interesting confluence of factors, the moralizing discourse is only intensified by the American right led by President George W. Bush, with his claims about an "axis of evil." According to Harrison, the very emphasis on evil as a genuine presence in international affairs is not only simplistic. It also leaves greater room for this evil to be linked to one side or another. At the other end of the continuum of approaches to political-cultural reality lies the relativism that has become pervasive in so many circles, and certainly in those of the left. This way of thinking, which might have been used for a well-reasoned judgment of either side, is often employed to dim the criticism of phenomena such as the Palestinian suicide bombings, or even to justify them; it is not, however, enlisted to justify the radical measures concocted by the Israeli defense establishment. Bernard Harrison is a philosopher, not a historian, sociologist or political scientist. He does not seek to explain the Arab-Israeli conflict, attitudes toward Israel, or anti-Semitism itself. His descriptive approach leads him to identify fundamental problems in how the objects of critique - Jews, Israel, Zionism - are handled. To him, the main problem is that in their dogmatic, didactic, political zeal, many leftists choose to apply existing categories and longstanding concepts to aspects of reality that involve Jews and Israel. Essential fallacies then emerge. Say "apartheid," and you must immediately present a detailed comparison between the characteristics of the old South African state and the one that you are now accusing of apartheid. Say "Nazis," and you must debate issues such as the comparison between besieged Ramallah and Auschwitz. Say "racism," "evil," "colonialism," and you find yourself in a narrow intellectual corridor: If you cannot define, describe in detail and prove, point by point, that the analogy and the application of the concept are legitimate, then you will find yourself on shaky ground indeed. Harrison believes that speakers and writers often take the easy way out: They make analogies but do not prove them, draw crude lines and take shortcuts to their unequivocal conclusions. This is certainly the case in a media culture that demands sound bytes, clearcut headlines and a crisp distinction between "good guys" and "bad guys." Along the way, people tend to forget that analogies have a limited value. They have the power to underscore questions, but not to provide answers. Bernard Harrison knows that the questions are much more complex than any Manichean portrayal. Many acts perpetrated by Israel are reprehensible. Quite a bit of what the Palestinians do is abhorrent. One of the book's most lucid and frustrating moments comes courtesy of a line Harrison quotes from a piece by Linda Grant in the Guardian, in which she explained to her readers: "The most important word in Hebrew is balagan (mess)." The balagan of the Middle East gives those who discuss it endless opportunities to slip instinctively into laziness, despair and the dark terrain of the old anti-Semitism. This slippage, especially when it comes up against the backdrop of justified accusations mixed with poorly substantiated slander, provides many Israelis with the familiar refuge: to tell themselves that the world hates them, "it just does," so that even the goddess of hasbara can offer no salvation. Nevertheless, Israelis face a vital and difficult intellectual and moral task: to make their own lucid distinctions between good and evil. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Siniora vs. Hezbollah The Lebanon prime minister accuses Hezbollah of staging a coup. Powerless in Gaza Palestinians say tha Gaza power plant has closed due to a fuel shortage.   1.   Anti Semitism 12:27  |  Naim S. Mahlab 28/07/07   2.   Anti-semitisim 15:03  |  Mitch Cohen 28/07/07   3.   in relation to israel the more israel appeases 16:07  |  victor hardman 28/07/07   4.   the new/old 17:23  |  Shmuelshachor 28/07/07   5.   The new/old anti-Semitism 17:33  |  Shelly Wallman 28/07/07   6.   Another Gentile Cheapens the Word 17:48  |  Ari Sheckner 28/07/07   7.   #2 that jew mitch is talking out of his rrrs 18:02  |  victor hardman 28/07/07   8.   Why antisemitic imagery? 18:27  |  Robbins 28/07/07   9.   "EVERYONE IS ANTI-SEMITE" CANARD CAMPAIGN CONTINUES 18:42  |  JACKAL 28/07/07   10.   confused... 19:37  |  ravi 28/07/07   11.   Confusing anti-semitism with anti-zionism 21:44  |  Ted 28/07/07   12.   the other side 22:32  |  Shana 28/07/07   13.   Anti Semitism 17:20  |  Sleven 29/07/07   14.   Antisemitic Stereotypes 16:21  |  Susan 19/08/07   15.   Read Posts: Clearly Antisemitic 21:41  |  Semsem 11/09/07   16.   Why not be honest and just call `anti-Semitism` anti-Jewishness? 00:25  |  Jake 12/09/07   17.   isreali hate 08:32  |  yakov 12/09/07   18.   Quite a bit versus Many? 15:02  |  Tovli 12/09/07   19.   anti-semitism in a nutshell 16:03  |  believer 12/09/07   20.   How easy to label criticism as "Anti Semitism" 18:08  |  Matthias 12/09/07   21.   The charge of anti-semitism is running out of steam 00:34  |  Tim 13/09/07   22.   i guess i am an anti-semite then 04:24  |  janet 13/09/07   23.   it is not antisemitism to oppose occupation of Palestinian land 05:10  |  nobodysacred 13/09/07   24.   Equality for Palestinians =Antisemitism 05:12  |  Tim 13/09/07   25.   the world is tired of the "antisemitism" trick 05:28  |  nobodysacred 13/09/07   26.   nobodysacred 07:40  |  sweis Melbourne 13/09/07   27.   inffiltration... 14:11  |  Timandagan 13/09/07   28.   #26, sweis Melbourne to #25 nobodysacred 14:49  |  zmogus 13/09/07   29.   Michèle fromBrussels 19:00  |  Brussels 13/09/07   30.   To #9: The I`m not an anti-Semite canard 21:19  |  Frank 13/09/07   31.   "Sloganising Is Forbidden"? 21:40  |  Rowan Berkeley 13/09/07   32.   Mitch "Cohen" and other respondents 13:12  |  Robbins 14/09/07   33.   credibility issues 17:01  |  jrob 14/09/07   34.   So people are sick of the term "anti-Semitism"? 18:25  |  Global Citizen 14/09/07   35.   The massacre of Sabra-Shatilla 00:57  |  Bernd 15/09/07   36.   Bernd in Germany 05:01  |  Apter 15/09/07   37.   Anti-Semitism/Anti Zionism 14:14  |  Rafael 15/09/07   38.   # 36 23:55  |  Bernd 15/09/07   39.   #30, Frank. A patient giving a diagnosis? 12:13  |  zmogus 17/09/07   40.   anti-JEW, NOT anti-SEMITE 19:21  |  indigenous Israelite 11/05/08   41.   Jew-hate is huge by sheer math odds 19:42  |  seer 11/05/08

Read & React Lebanese PM: Hezbollah is worse than Israel Responses: 186 Gideon Levy: PM probe raises serious questions about U.S. Jewry-Israel relations Responses: 54 Zvi Bar'el: Israel is ignoring the possibility Hezbollah may soon run Lebanon Responses: 36 Tales from a N.Y. cabby: 'My first wife was Muslim, my second was Jewish' Responses: 45 Editorial: For the first time it seems Olmert's hard core of loyalists is collapsing Responses: 21 More Headlines 19:08 Lebanese PM: Hezbollah is worse than Israel 19:03 Three Qassams hit Negev, one explodes near schoolbus 16:55 Olmert: Israel will take 'strong action' to ensure Gaza quiet 18:29 Vice Premier Ramon: Lebanon must be viewed as a 'Hezbollah' state 18:52 Jerusalem planners okay route of new bridge to Mugrabi Gate 17:35 Israel gets first look at prototype of revolutionary electric car 17:08 Cartoon film on Nakba describes Jews as 'enemies of homeland' 17:55 UN asks Israel to probe raid which killed Gaza teacher last week 19:30 Report: Talansky paid Olmert's $4,717 hotel bill in U.S. in 2005 19:41 World War II veterans mark VE day in Jerusalem march 19:25 Chelsea draw with Bolton makes Man. United Premier League champions 14:50 Gov't official accused of forging entry visas for Russian mafia 17:35 Tourism Min. seeks to open Ben-Gurion Airport at night 15:00 Israeli industrialist, peace advocate Benjamin Gaon dies at age 73 Previous Editions Select Day 09 may 08 may 07 may 06 may 05 may 04 may 02 may 01 may 30 apr 29 apr 28 apr 27 apr

Special Offers Advertisement Dead Sea Products Buy Dead Sea mineral skin care and beauty products. Coupon code Haaretz for 10% off. Together Celebrating Israel's 60th The Jewish Agency and You - together making history Pardes Institute Summer Sessions http://www.pardes.org.il/ FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer The interest rates haven't changed But your profits will! Learn Hebrew online with Israel's best teachers Sign up for a trial lesson today Free the Palestinians from: Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

Real Estate in Israel

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved