Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., July 22, 2007 Av 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:36 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Beware of Oslo's destructive route
By Meron Benvenisti

As opposed to the forecast, energetic diplomatic activity - which in the distant past was called the "peace process" - began during the July-August vacation, of all times. Summit meetings, a prisoner release, economic gestures, optimistic declarations and diplomatic plans are all making us feel that something serious is really happening. Because if not, such important people would not be devoting so much time to involvement in the diplomatic process, especially during the summer vacation.

Even Tony Blair is starting to strengthen Palestinian institutions in preparation for establishing a state, but in the meantime he has not yet found a suitable building for his office in Jerusalem "because of the high real estate prices." Haim Ramon is in a hurry: He hasn't even had time to warm up the vice premier's chair, and is already hastening to publicize that he has initiated a new diplomatic plan called "disengagement lite," although he admitted that "it hasn't even gotten off the drawing board."

Many explanations have been offered for the sudden outburst of diplomatic energy: U.S. President George W. Bush's need for a plan to rescue the last vestige of his honor in the region toward the end of his failed term in office; Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's need to present a diplomatic achievement on the eve of the publication of the full Winograd report; the need to heed the demand to "strengthen Abu Mazen" (Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas) that is being heard from all sides; and the profound need to lift the peace camp out of its despair and give it a dose of optimism so it will continue to believe that most Israelis in fact support the two-state solution, and that the Greater Israel ideology is a thing of the past, even in the rightist camp.

Advertisement

The diplomatic process being conducted by Olmert and Bush serves as a peg on which to hang this optimism. The problem is that the reality does not show signs of surrendering to theories and desires. Israeli construction on the West Bank continues at a rapid pace and infrastructure networks are covering the entire area; a regime that is severing and crushing the Palestinian community is taking root; the separation fence is being built; the isolation of the West Bank from the Gaza Strip is taking on the character of a quasi-permanent geopolitical separation; and the chances that Abu Mazen will succeed in establishing a stable government in the West Bank seem distant.

The possibility that the Ramon-Olmert "disengagement lite" will spawn a durable Palestinian state is simply a deception. This gap between theory and reality is leading the Palestinians to believe that the Israelis, whether intentionally or not, "are injecting morphine into their veins to paralyze them until they complete their project," in the words of former Palestinian minister Ziad Abu Zayyad. And in fact, the so-called "diplomatic process" and the optimism it is creating have a price, and in the not-so-distant past we already paid a high price for nurturing illusions that were shattered - see the Oslo Accords.

The illusion of the Palestinians, who saw how under Oslo the settlements were doubled and a draconian occupation regime was installed, evaporated in a violent manner, shattering the Israeli illusion that the conflict could be ended without paying the price. The current diplomatic process is liable to repeat the destructive route of Oslo, creating an illusion of progress fueled by a natural need to nurture hope, a hope that will be exploited by cynics who believe they have the power to dictate the rules of the game and decide who will lose it.

Those who are amusing themselves with the process, those who are exploiting it to promote their political aims, those who are becoming addicted to it to fulfill their heart's desire, and those who want to use it to improve their grievous condition under the occupation should all recall that it is easy to create illusions, and it is easy to err because of them. But the price will be paid by everyone, including those who are moving the process forward through mere words. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict cannot tolerate another shattered illusion, and those who are engaging in diplomatic activity during the July-August vacation should be aware of the responsibility they are assuming.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Men in shorts
Who said shorts are not cool for men? Shorts are in vogue, proving less is more.
Isaiah's advice
The portion of the week deals with the future of Zion and improvement of society.
  1.   Bush and Peace 10:00  |  Hannah 19/07/07
  2.   MORE LEFT WING TRIPE AND BLUSTER 10:13  |  paul harris 19/07/07
  3.   STRENGTHEN ABU MAZEN FOR WHAT? 10:23  |  indrajaya 19/07/07
  4.   Actions speak louder than words 10:30  |  Ivar 19/07/07
  5.   The Bush & Tony Show 10:36  |  Dutch 19/07/07
  6.   There is no need of another Palestinian state 10:43  |  Bo 19/07/07
  7.   Time to preen and pose 10:48  |  Natallie Durson 19/07/07
  8.   ISRAEL IS BRILLIANT 11:01  |  American 19/07/07
  9.   New weapons from U.S will eliminate desires to talk to terrorist. 11:33  |  Tom D Jones 19/07/07
  10.   Nuts and Idiots On Both Sides Deserve Each Other 12:25  |  Dyinglikeflies 19/07/07
  11.   Criticizing and finding cracks is easy 12:55  |  ScotGuy 19/07/07
  12.   Men of failed wars = Men of failed peace! 13:08  |  Sharif Hafez 19/07/07
  13.   #8 American 13:13  |  ScotGuy 19/07/07
  14.   FALSE HANNAH ALERT! #1 13:14  |  Hannah 19/07/07
  15.   THE HANNAH IDENTITY CRISIS 13:52  |  Brant 19/07/07
  16.   AMERICAN 13:55  |  Brant 19/07/07
  17.   #10, dyinglikeflies, you sure got that right 13:56  |  newageblues 19/07/07
  18.   Ridiculous! 14:12  |  Ronnie Wolman 19/07/07
  19.   What Meron Benvenesti forgets 14:55  |  David Hoffman 19/07/07
  20.   Beware of the Benvenisti dangers of false diplomacy 15:00  |  Joseph E . 19/07/07
  21.   #7 Time to yawn and sleep 15:00  |  Joel Weltman 19/07/07
  22.   INDRAYAYA IS A TERRORISRT! 15:13  |  Harry 19/07/07
  23.   to No.1 : Bush and War i.e Peace 15:17  |  Jock 19/07/07
  24.   #5 The Mahmood Amenidijad and Ismail Haniyeh Show 15:20  |  Joel Weltman 19/07/07
  25.   # 1 Hannah: Is this supposed to be a Joke? 15:21  |  Sharif Hafez 19/07/07
  26.   #19 Bravo David ! 15:38  |  Joel Weltman 19/07/07
  27.   What defines palestinians? 15:39  |  Walter 19/07/07
  28.   Rv. Shimon Bar Yohai is buried in Meron 15:41  |  Benveniste 19/07/07
  29.   The Only Country Interested in Palestinians Welfare is Israel 15:42  |  Jane 19/07/07
  30.   Time to Pull American Support 15:59  |  Matthew 19/07/07
  31.   False Hannah #1, on spelling... 16:14  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  32.   Jane....you are in a fantasy land of denial... 16:16  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  33.   Ronnie, Where is Israel`s desire.... 16:19  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  34.   #24, Walter 16:20  |  Palestinian 19/07/07
  35.   Israel should just exterminate any armed Palestinian 16:20  |  arthur 19/07/07
  36.   to jane 16:46  |  rose 19/07/07
  37.   #1 Hannah -- Huh?? Bush who? 16:48  |  Rick 19/07/07
  38.   Benvenisti need not worry 16:52  |  Mark Lincoln 19/07/07
  39.   # 27 Walter. What defines the Palestinians is Israeli violence. 16:53  |  Nick Ferriman 19/07/07
  40.   Leftist junk 16:53  |  SLAVO 19/07/07
  41.   Mark Lincoln Wrong 17:29  |  Danite 19/07/07
  42.   Dearest Meron 17:57  |  Benveniste 19/07/07
  43.   No Truer Words Have Been Spoken 18:03  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/07/07
  44.   Walter on Cultures #27 18:09  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/07/07
  45.   Sanme Old BS from Burg`s Buddy 18:09  |  Tod Zuckerman 19/07/07
  46.   Ibrahim and being Shameless 18:10  |  Ronnie Wolman 19/07/07
  47.   What other contributions do they have? Pt. 1 18:10  |  Walter 19/07/07
  48.   What other contributions do they have? Pt. 2 18:13  |  Walter 19/07/07
  49.   FAKE Hannah !# 18:17  |  JOHNJOHN 19/07/07
  50.   Jane 18:18  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  51.   #35 ferriman is of course joking he couldnt be that ignorant ? 18:23  |  victor hardman 19/07/07
  52.   So You Have a Better Idea? 18:34  |  Eli 19/07/07
  53.   to Natallie Durson 18:37  |  MLK 19/07/07
  54.   Ibrahim-Arabs Use Palestinians and Don`t Help Them 18:39  |  Jane 19/07/07
  55.   Walter #44 - one minor correction 18:39  |  Polybios 19/07/07
  56.   Who needs enemies? 18:40  |  Uri 19/07/07
  57.   Ronnie, more shameless dribble... 18:47  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  58.   Palestinian #24 18:47  |  Polybios 19/07/07
  59.   #44 Walter - Canaanites, Mennonites, etc? 18:50  |  Rick 19/07/07
  60.   #29 Jane of FL 18:50  |  ballistic 19/07/07
  61.   The REAL Possibility for a Peace Plan 18:51  |  Larry 19/07/07
  62.   Todd Zuckerman, come on and admit it! #42 18:53  |  Yaakov Sullivan 19/07/07
  63.   The REAL Possibility for a Peace Plan Part 2 18:56  |  Larry 19/07/07
  64.   Jane #29 18:57  |  Polybios 19/07/07
  65.   Palestinian # 32 18:57  |  Richard 19/07/07
  66.   The REAL Possibility for a Peace Plan Part 3 19:00  |  Larry 19/07/07
  67.   #15 Brant on Hannah 19:21  |  My View 19/07/07
  68.   BEWARE OF THE RAVINGS FROM THE IVORY TOWER!!! 19:33  |  Ben Uziel 19/07/07
  69.   Ibrahim 19:36  |  Sarah 19/07/07
  70.   Ibrahim,On the Ground,In the Air 19:50  |  Ronnie Wolman 19/07/07
  71.   Ibrahim: Sunnis 19:55  |  Ronnie Wolman 19/07/07
  72.   Yes, Meron Beware, Beware.... 20:04  |  Dutch 19/07/07
  73.   Sarah, slinging the Nazi comparisons... 20:20  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  74.   Ronnie, you are fixated on permanent conflict. 20:24  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  75.   Larry vs. Ronnie in Toronto 20:27  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  76.   Benvenisti is right - but how does this "trick" work? 20:29  |  Sensible 19/07/07
  77.   To Larry 20:31  |  British Leftie 19/07/07
  78.   Ibrahim - Jane said it right 20:35  |  David Israel 19/07/07
  79.   To Larry #2 20:36  |  British Leftie 19/07/07
  80.   Larry: Fantasy #4? 20:38  |  Dyinglikeflies 19/07/07
  81.   Rose - If Palestinian Arabs would stop terror 20:41  |  David Israel 19/07/07
  82.   To Ibrahim 20:45  |  British Leftie 19/07/07
  83.   Ibrahim - #46 20:56  |  David Israel 19/07/07
  84.   Ibrahim: Action not Intellectualism 21:05  |  Ronnie Wolman 19/07/07
  85.   #36 ferriman and a comic posting about arabs 22:01  |  victor hardman 19/07/07
  86.   Ibrahim why Peace will fail 22:02  |  Danite 19/07/07
  87.   Ronnie...exactly... 22:08  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  88.   David Israel....of course, Israel cares about Palestinians... 22:11  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  89.   Ibrahim 22:23  |  Larry 19/07/07
  90.   Ibrahim,where is the Lebanese Border? 22:37  |  Ronnie Wolman 19/07/07
  91.   Ibrahim #78 22:41  |  David Israel 19/07/07
  92.   Danite`s back.... 22:44  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  93.   Ballistic-What Other Country Helps Its Sworn Enemy? 22:47  |  Jane 19/07/07
  94.   Ibrahim &9 to Larry 22:51  |  David Israel 19/07/07
  95.   To the Author 22:59  |  TonyL 19/07/07
  96.   Ibrahim #78 23:18  |  David Israel 19/07/07
  97.   To Larry (Missing Part 2) 23:28  |  British Leftie 19/07/07
  98.   David Israel, incorrect... 23:31  |  Ibrahim 19/07/07
  99.   Ibrahim 23:32  |  Danite 19/07/07
  100.   British Leftie 23:42  |  Danite 19/07/07
  101.   Talk Back is Looking up these days 23:45  |  Danite 19/07/07
  102.   #3 Indraja 23:46  |  larry from maine 19/07/07
  103.   Dutch 23:50  |  larry from maine 19/07/07
  104.   British Leftie, Ibrahim, David Israel 23:59  |  Larry 19/07/07
  105.   David Israel 00:01  |  Gershom Masters 20/07/07
  106.   British Leftie, Ibrahim, David Israel Part2 00:03  |  Larry 20/07/07
  107.   Larry 00:13  |  Gersh 20/07/07
  108.   Ronnie....hopelessly misguided... 00:20  |  Ibrahim 20/07/07
  109.   Danite, Larry, Ibrahim, etc. 00:27  |  British Leftist 20/07/07
  110.   Ibrahim #98 00:30  |  David Israel 20/07/07
  111.   And Ibrahim one more thing 00:36  |  David Israel 20/07/07
  112.   #93 wake up Jane 00:54  |  Pssd Off American 20/07/07
  113.   Gershom Masters and Ibrahim 00:54  |  David Israel 20/07/07
  114.   Ibrahim,Only a Relationship can help 00:59  |  Ronnie Wolman 20/07/07
  115.   Ibrahim - I don`t want to bicker but you make me so 01:00  |  David Israel 20/07/07
  116.   Ibrahim, David Israel #1 01:02  |  British Leftie 20/07/07
  117.   Ibrahim, David Israel #2 01:07  |  British Leftie 20/07/07
  118.   #37, Rick.... 01:13  |  Silvienne 20/07/07
  119.   For all moderates reading... 01:14  |  British Leftie 20/07/07
  120.   David Israel #1 01:25  |  British Leftie 20/07/07
  121.   David Israel #2 01:28  |  British Leftie 20/07/07
  122.   `85` Victor Hardman 01:30  |  Labhras 20/07/07
  123.   David Israel 01:34  |  Ibrahim 20/07/07
  124.   `92` Jane 01:38  |  Labhras 20/07/07
  125.   Gershom Masters and Ibrahim 01:42  |  David Israel 20/07/07
  126.   larry in toronto 01:46  |  bev 20/07/07
  127.   #124, Labhras... 01:51  |  Silvienne 20/07/07
  128.   Israel needs a Churchill. Not more Chamberlains. 01:57  |  Chaim 20/07/07
  129.   Ibrahim 02:00  |  British Leftie 20/07/07
  130.   British leftie, Ibrahim and all of you in that forum 02:01  |  David Israel 20/07/07
  131.   British Leftist 02:02  |  Larry 20/07/07
  132.   British Leftist Part 2 02:08  |  Larry 20/07/07
  133.   Ibrahim well.... 02:09  |  Danite 20/07/07
  134.   Now when we all got it, when will Abbas? 02:17  |  Jonathan 20/07/07
  135.   Labhars-That`s Not the Point 02:24  |  Jane 20/07/07
  136.   David Israel 130 02:30  |  British Leftie 20/07/07
  137.   British leftie #129 02:30  |  Danite 20/07/07
  138.   Durson #7 02:48  |  JJ 20/07/07
  139.   #1 02:53  |  JJ 20/07/07
  140.   Israel Has the Obligation to Defend Its People 02:59  |  Jane 20/07/07
  141.   British Leftie on Arafat 03:11  |  Ronnie Wolman 20/07/07
  142.   Ibrahim 03:21  |  Brad 20/07/07
  143.   British leftie #136 - As you wrote 03:42  |  David Israel 20/07/07
  144.   Jane #140 04:03  |  JJ 20/07/07
  145.   meron benvenisti 04:22  |  Gemeinde in the Reic 20/07/07
  146.   Whose land is this? 04:24  |  Mark Bernadiner 20/07/07
  147.   Chaim, You would do well to note.... 04:32  |  Dutch 20/07/07
  148.   writer7 04:48  |  oz 20/07/07
  149.   to: Tom D Jones (#9) 04:58  |  joshua aviv 20/07/07
  150.   147 04:58  |  anthony lynch 20/07/07
  151.   `135" Jane 05:06  |  Labhras 20/07/07
  152.   151 05:32  |  roy blair 20/07/07
  153.   action speaks louder than words 05:47  |  hugh dennis 20/07/07
  154.   #152, Labhras, I can second that... 06:03  |  Silvienne 20/07/07
  155.   Roy Blair 06:04  |  Silvienne 20/07/07
  156.   Jane... 06:08  |  Silvienne 20/07/07
  157.   Meron, Your Points Are Well Made -Beware!! 06:22  |  Dutch 20/07/07
  158.   The author of this article has a good point 06:39  |  Voice of Reason 20/07/07
  159.   Let`s give Abbas/Fayad a chance 08:33  |  Infidel Too 20/07/07
  160.   #119 WHER HHAVE I HEARD ALL THIS CRAP BEFORE ? 08:45  |  paul harris 20/07/07
  161.   #157 DORIS IN THE LAND OF MAKE BELIEVE AGAIN 08:47  |  paul harris 20/07/07
  162.   Oedipal hatred fuels identifier with the aggressor 09:20  |  Shalom Freedman 20/07/07
  163.   156. Silvienne 10:21  |  Jim 20/07/07
  164.   154 Silvienne 10:23  |  Jim 20/07/07
  165.   159 12:54  |  roger clemens 20/07/07
  166.   Joshua aviv, You make no sense. 13:10  |  Tom D Jones 20/07/07
  167.   #158 I wish to remind the voice of reason 15:08  |  Dutch 20/07/07
  168.   162 THere`s Nothing to Love About a State ........ 17:05  |  Dutch 20/07/07
  169.   # 85 Victor Hardman 18:31  |  Nick Ferriman 20/07/07
  170.   # 2 have a magic mushroom, paul harris... 2nd try 01:00  |  eric 21/07/07
  171.   Jim 01:51  |  Silvienne 21/07/07
  172.   Jim 2nd.. 01:53  |  Silvienne 21/07/07
  173.   barak offered 4 bantustans not a palestinian state 01:54  |  cristina 21/07/07
  174.   "Peace in our time" 04:38  |  Chinese Gordon 22/07/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: What self-hating Jews can teach Muslims
Responses: 257
Abbas: We'll continue to seek the release of all prisoners
Responses: 341
Editorial: JNF law makes Israel a racist Jewish state
Responses: 400
Natan Sharansky: Iraqis more optimistic about future than U.S.
Responses: 94
Maram Masarwi: An Arab Martin Luther King, Jr. is needed
Responses: 97


More Headlines
04:31 IDF says Hezbollah hiding rockets from UN forces
05:19 Witnesses: IDF kills two Hamas gunmen in northern Gaza Strip
02:21 Hamas outlines basis for reconciliation with rival Fatah
04:33 Security Forces set to prevent march to ex-settlement Homesh
03:48 Israel to EU: We oppose giving political role to PA donor states
04:39 Foreign Ministry concerned about Iran's ties with South America
04:08 Jordan blocks visits to inmates transferred from Israeli jail
00:45 PFLP member freed from Israeli jail decries Hamas takeover of Gaza
04:12 Israel among top 10 countries selling counterfeit pharmaceuticals
01:52 Bookstores fined for Sabbath launch of final Harry Potter book
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved