Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., July 26, 2007 Av 11, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:40 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Hadash Chairman MK Mohammed Barakeh. (Tomer Appelbaum)
Last update - 07:43 19/07/2007
Bill allocating JNF land to Jews only passes preliminary reading
By Yoav Stern and Shahar Ilan, Haaretz Correspondents

The Knesset plenum approved a bill Wednesday, in its preliminary reading, which calls for all lands under the Jewish National Fund (JNF) to be allocated to Jews only. The bill passed by a massive majority of 64 MKS to 16.

The bill, initiated by MK Uri Ariel (National Union-National Religious Party), MK Zeev Elkin (Kadima), and MK Moshe Kahlon (Likud), is geared to bypass a 2004 court ruling which annulled an Israel Lands Administration (ILA) policy that prevented Arabs from participating in bids to purchase land owned by the JNF.

As a result of the ruling, Attorney General Menachem Mazuz decided that all land managed by the ILA, including land owned by the Jewish National Fund, will be marketed without discrimination or limits including to non-Jews.

Advertisement

The JNF owns 13 percent of state land, purchased for Jewish settlement.

When the bill was discussed in the Knesset presidency, there were demands to nullify it because it was called racist, but Knesset legal advisor Nurit Elstein said a bill should only be rejected if the racism is explicit in the proposal.

Hadash Chairman MK Mohammed Barakeh called the bill an "abominable legislation" and added that "the Knesset's face is the face of Uri Ariel, the radical of the settlers." He maintained that, "this is another expression of a series of racist laws that are passed every day in the state of the Jews. The Arab population won't accept the theft of their rights to the lands that have been expropriated from them for years."

In response to the bill, MK Ahmed Tibi (Ra`am-Ta`al) said "this is institutionalized Jewish racism and ethnic democracy that is raging against anything Arab."

The Meretz faction said that the government's support in the racist bill exposes its real face. "The Knesset is giving an excellent excuse for whoever is asking to represent Israel as an apartheid state which must be destroyed," said the party's statement.

MK Wassel Taha (Balad) said, "Only an insane Knesset passes a racist law that perpetuates the 'great land robbery of 1948' and changes it into an only Jewish asset."

MK Jamal Zahalka, also of Balad, maintained that the law shows an increase in the level of racism, and a decrease in the level of democracy, and a sprint to the direction of institutionalized apartheid.

MK Elkin, however, said that the bill comes to prevent the state of Israel from breaching the basic treaty between the state and the JNF, and to make historical justice.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Sweet revenge
The number of Israelis obtaining German citizenship rose 50 percent in the past year.
Kfar abloom
The Kfar Blum festival offers chamber music, narrated Baroque concertos and more.
  1.   When we donated money, the receipts given were for land for Jews 19:50  |  Nannette 18/07/07
  2.   thank god, Israel isn`t a racist state 20:07  |  ricki bobbi 18/07/07
  3.   JNF Funds 20:08  |  Edifice 18/07/07
  4.   Jews should prohibited from buying property in Europe. 20:16  |  Andreas 18/07/07
  5.   WHO IS THE REAL RACIST: ISRAEL OR THE ARABS? 20:17  |  G. Marcus 18/07/07
  6.   Preliminary reading of another Apartheid law 20:18  |  Ronen 18/07/07
  7.   Arabs greedy property grabbers. 20:22  |  Chick 18/07/07
  8.   Has Barakeh`s family donated money to the JNF ever? 20:23  |  Martin 18/07/07
  9.   Let`s keep it this way 20:25  |  An Israeli 18/07/07
  10.   By the same token, money from the Vatican or Muslim Zakkat should 20:28  |  Martin 18/07/07
  11.   South Africa, Israeli Style 20:30  |  Lee Kaplan 18/07/07
  12.   Jews want to have a state that treats minorities in ways 20:31  |  Rational 18/07/07
  13.   ricki bobbi hypocritical stance 20:33  |  Matt 18/07/07
  14.   our families gave to JNF for 100years - to settle JEWS in Israel 20:48  |  jase 18/07/07
  15.   Well This Is Up To Israeli Jews And Arabs 21:01  |  Yosemite 18/07/07
  16.   JNF land 21:17  |  mg 18/07/07
  17.   The Apartheid Case grows stronger 21:19  |  Tim 18/07/07
  18.   Israel is Apartheid State 21:24  |  emad matahin 18/07/07
  19.   unreal 21:27  |  Frederico 18/07/07
  20.   to ricki bobbi 21:32  |  emad matahin 18/07/07
  21.   the opponents to this bill , High Court included 21:33  |  Joseph E . 18/07/07
  22.   Practice what you preach 21:37  |  Natallie Durson 18/07/07
  23.   Too bad you gave money to something so racist 21:39  |  Tim 18/07/07
  24.   As an Israeli Jew I find this law disgusting 21:39  |  Israeli guy 18/07/07
  25.   None of this land has been bought with Jewish money 21:48  |  Jerry Haber 18/07/07
  26.   And They Rose to Affirm This Injustice 21:51  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/07/07
  27.   Public Lands 21:51  |  yaakov 18/07/07
  28.   Arabs Lands 22:10  |  Steve 18/07/07
  29.   The Great Thing About Racists 22:13  |  Doug@usa.com 18/07/07
  30.   JNF shown preference? 22:14  |  Mark 18/07/07
  31.   Tim and the JNF 22:23  |  GZLives 18/07/07
  32.   SOMEONE EXPLAIN THE JNF TP THE BASHERS 22:25  |  GZLives 18/07/07
  33.   Question 22:27  |  Not in my name 18/07/07
  34.   Zionism or anti-semitism? 22:28  |  Mandela 18/07/07
  35.   G.Marcus, isnt this zionist double speak...#5 22:30  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/07/07
  36.   I`ll explain this slowly for you... 22:42  |  Eli 18/07/07
  37.   JNF= JEWISH National Fund .. cant they even read? 22:44  |  pace306 18/07/07
  38.   racism is not the problem 22:48  |  tony aron 18/07/07
  39.   Let`s see private Christian lands & Muslim lands handed to Jews 22:51  |  Nannette 18/07/07
  40.   JNF owned land paid 4 by jews 2 give 2 other jews is apartheid? 22:54  |  gary 18/07/07
  41.   Look at the antisemites posting on here! 23:00  |  Nannette 18/07/07
  42.   Would all you critics GIVE the home you paid for - to strangers? 23:02  |  Nannette 18/07/07
  43.   JNF is just a Jewish Wakf 23:04  |  Ariel 18/07/07
  44.   Most JNF Land was Expropriated and not Bought from the Arabs 23:11  |  Jerry Haber 18/07/07
  45.   JNF Lands 23:13  |  Jeff 18/07/07
  46.   Racism, pure and simple. 23:14  |  Guershom 18/07/07
  47.   Other country with similar laws 23:18  |  Josef Abrahamsson 18/07/07
  48.   The Apartheid Case? 23:20  |  Jeff 18/07/07
  49.   For once it`s admitted 23:26  |  Murray 18/07/07
  50.   Why is Ha`aretz allowing only the antisemites to post 23:28  |  Nannette 18/07/07
  51.   "4" Andreas 00:09  |  Labhras 19/07/07
  52.   Nannette 00:12  |  NanNOT! 19/07/07
  53.   Nannette remember its the Knesset who is passing this law, not.. 00:16  |  Don Camillo 19/07/07
  54.   this is not a racist law 00:18  |  david 19/07/07
  55.   Blatant apartheid, no different from S.Africa 1960s 00:20  |  Esther 19/07/07
  56.   Incorrect Jerry Haber 00:22  |  GZLives 19/07/07
  57.   Haaretz BE FAIR 00:25  |  GZLives 19/07/07
  58.   The law is racist, Nannette 00:43  |  Michael 19/07/07
  59.   Share with me 00:58  |  * BEN JABO 19/07/07
  60.   Arab countries have laws against selling land to Jews 00:58  |  Careful Reader 19/07/07
  61.   Look at this Picture in a Muslim Land 01:07  |  Peter 19/07/07
  62.   #4 - Why, is The Middle-East not enough for you? 01:09  |  B`Galil 19/07/07
  63.   #38 Camillo 01:28  |  * BEN JABO 19/07/07
  64.   #40 Esther TA 01:30  |  * BEN JABO 19/07/07
  65.   And then they say : We are not Apartheid 01:35  |  Amanda 19/07/07
  66.   42 - GZ lives 01:47  |  Ibn Musa 19/07/07
  67.   david #39 01:55  |  Darrien 19/07/07
  68.   Clarifications 02:01  |  Sam 19/07/07
  69.   "35" Nannette 02:31  |  Labhras 19/07/07
  70.   Jewish Losers on the loose 02:35  |  Danite 19/07/07
  71.   let`s calm down and read 02:38  |  Shimshon 19/07/07
  72.   #47 Amanda Just what part of 02:44  |  * BEN JABO 19/07/07
  73.   Do you feel the cold breath? 02:47  |  Mark Lincoln 19/07/07
  74.   re: Amanda 03:10  |  Efox 19/07/07
  75.   re: Sam 03:12  |  Efox 19/07/07
  76.   re: Lee Kaplan 03:17  |  Efox 19/07/07
  77.   What is Jewish is Jewish 03:20  |  Gene 19/07/07
  78.   re: Rational if Jews treated Arabs as Arabs treat Jews 03:22  |  Efox 19/07/07
  79.   Has that Jordanian who Sold his House to Jews been Executed yet? 03:23  |  Efox 19/07/07
  80.   tribal mythology still prevails 03:42  |  Mee Hung 19/07/07
  81.   #51 Historically correct 03:44  |  Not in my name 19/07/07
  82.   Not so simple 03:54  |  Peter 19/07/07
  83.   Wow! 04:17  |  Laughing with tears 19/07/07
  84.   Not a double standard !!!! 04:17  |  Avrum 19/07/07
  85.   Reply to Lee Kaplan (Post No. 11) 04:31  |  Johnny Weintraub