Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., July 19, 2007 Av 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:07 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Anglo File Rosner's Domain Real Estate Travel  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 05:07 18/07/2007
Dozens of classical musicians issue joint peace manifesto
By Noam Ben Ze'ev

For the first time in the history of academic and musical life in Israel, dozens of musicians, scholars and educators from the field of classical music have come out with a joint call against the occupation and in favor of peace, rapprochement and a two-state solution.

"We protest the prolonged occupation that is destroying our country's image," declare the signatories in a written statement. "Our continued control over the territories and their Palestinian inhabitants is morally wrong. The only positive option is an attempt to conduct responsible negotiations with Hezbollah, the Palestine Liberation Organization, Hamas, Lebanon and Syria."

The document will be read publicly for the first time at a modern electronic and live music concert, scheduled to coincide with the ninth issue of "Tav Plus," the music and society periodical edited by Dr. Bat-Sheva Shapira. (The concert will be held in Shelter 209 at 116 Levinsky Street in Tel Aviv, on Thursday at 9:00 P.M.)

Advertisement

Among the over 40 musicians signed onto the manifesto, one can also find leading figures in other fields: Avner Itai, Anat Morag, Itay Talgam, Maya Shavit and Yuval Ben-Ozer (conducting); David Halperin, Yehudit Cohen, Edwin Seroussi, Shoshana Weich-Shahak, Veronika Cohen, Shulamit Feingold and Shai Burstein (musicology); Zohar Eitan, Michael Wolpe, Nadav Ziv, Reuven Seroussi, Arik Shapira and Hagar Kadima (composition); Claudia Gluschankof, Fuad Jubran and Dutchi Lichtenstein (pedagogy and teaching); as well as singer Mira Zakai, pianist Zecharia Plavin, flutist Michael Meltzer and radio personality Dan Orstav.

"The separation between involvement in music on the one hand and ideology on the other is unacceptable to me," says Dr. Lichtenstein, who spearheaded the initiative together with composer Hagar Kadima. "Music is not divorced from the social context in which it operates; it does not come from outer space. Someone here creates and performs it, someone receives and hears it, and someone decides how to support it and teach it and disseminate it, according to a certain order of priorities. This entire experience is political; and if we don't understand the political contexts and work for change, we will probably continue to be involved in study, and will delve into semiotic analysis and into performing the fine points of the work. But in the end they will remain on the shelf covered with dust."

The document primarily expresses the Israeli point of view, discussing the damage Israel suffers in the area of security and the waste of essential resources on wars of choice, and makes little reference to the suffering on other side.

"Peace is made with enemies," the document states. "We wanted the manifesto to express the opinion of as many people as possible, and therefore we were flexible about its contents," says Lichtenstein.

"And I really did discover many colleagues who believe not necessarily in the power of music to bring peace, but in the important place of music in the experience and the political contexts of Israeli society."



Bookmark to del.icio.us
Tantura to St. Tropez
Israeli beach fashion has moved from stylish strengths to haute couture heights.
Setting sail
Beijing 2008 sailing hopefuls boast a loner mentality, and plentiful state support.
  1.   Arabs are occupying Jewish Homeland , end arab occupation , 05:14  |  Joseph E . 18/07/07
  2.   Where are the Palestinians organizing for peace with Israel? 05:58  |  Sam 18/07/07
  3.   These Few Minstrels Should Stick To Their Little Ditties 06:12  |  Yishai Kohen 18/07/07
  4.   morality....? 06:19  |  ravi 18/07/07
  5.   "Joint" peace manifesto ? 06:25  |  Dov 18/07/07
  6.   Stick to Music stay out of diplomacy 06:30  |  Arthur 18/07/07
  7.   What is wrong with these people? 06:32  |  ANIceFellow 18/07/07
  8.   musical politicans 06:58  |  A Classic Musician 18/07/07
  9.   Dozens of classical musicians issue joint peace manifesto 06:59  |  Sylvia 18/07/07
  10.   THESE MUSICIANS ARE SUICIDAL FOOLS 07:09  |  G. Marcus 18/07/07
  11.   Ducking to Brit boycotts or encouraging them? 07:13  |  SupportOrSubversion? 18/07/07
  12.   Are These Musicians On Crack? 07:21  |  Gene Stark 18/07/07
  13.   So much for classical music causing evil spirits to flee. 07:28  |  Virginia 18/07/07
  14.   If Talkbackers are allowed to express opinions 07:40  |  sh 18/07/07
  15.   Congratulations to these musicians 07:42  |  wibism 18/07/07
  16.   The mission of classical music is to bring one to the place where 07:53  |  Virginia 18/07/07
  17.   musical fools 07:53  |  classical musician 18/07/07
  18.   So, maybe the intentions were good; We all know what is said 08:01  |  Virginia 18/07/07
  19.   if music be the food of love,these idiots are lovesick 08:11  |  victor hardman 18/07/07
  20.   Musicians" Manifesto 08:16  |  Garry 18/07/07
  21.   Since when is a letter by 40 irrelevant people important? 08:19  |  Channa 18/07/07
  22.   Manifesto 08:37  |  Maxim 18/07/07
  23.   Classical-Shmassical? Its time to Rock and Roll! 08:37  |  Scientist 18/07/07
  24.   No separation between art and poltics 09:07  |  Loomis Pound 18/07/07
  25.   Who`s gonna be next? 09:08  |  Mark Fradkin 18/07/07
  26.   musicians issue joint peace manifesto 09:11  |  A Grunfeld 18/07/07
  27.   Jello wrestling time 09:51  |  Natallie Durson 18/07/07
  28.   to all those who so clearly fail to see... 09:53  |  eric 18/07/07
  29.   Living the Lie 09:58  |  Paul 18/07/07
  30.   TIME for the Brit "Intelligencia" to call a boycott 10:07  |  PETER SM 18/07/07
  31.   Self-Criticism 10:08  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  32.   When politicians are so rubbish others have to speak 10:13  |  Michael 18/07/07
  33.   Artsy fartsy types 10:39  |  Eliezer 18/07/07
  34.   Isn`t it "morally wrong" for Palis to keep killin us even after 10:42  |  Reuven 18/07/07
  35.   A FINE RED LINE 10:46  |  indrajaya 18/07/07
  36.   Healthy declaration 11:01  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  37.   sh 11:36  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  38.   clasical musicians 12:06  |  Silvia 18/07/07
  39.   the musicians are experts on MUSIC, not on Israel`s Security, so 12:07  |  Pavel 18/07/07
  40.   does the expression" a classical idiot" ring any bells 12:31  |  victor hardman 18/07/07
  41.   COINCIDENCE 12:55  |  concert violinist 18/07/07
  42.   Rightous Jews 13:09  |  Doris 18/07/07
  43.   My sincere thanks 14:10  |  Nick Ferriman 18/07/07
  44.   #43 NICK AND MUSIC ! IT WAS PLAYED 14:53  |  paul harris 18/07/07
  45.   Well done , in spite of the "Anti peace` chorus 15:04  |  Labhras 18/07/07
  46.   An accomodation of peaceful coexistence will not come about just 15:35  |  Zvulun 18/07/07
  47.   A bit of artistic talent doesn`t qualify one as wise 15:49  |  Chaim 18/07/07
  48.   Musicians forgot al-Qaida 16:56  |  Chick 18/07/07
  49.   Nice start ...but 17:15  |  Tim 18/07/07
  50.   this is why the Brits boycott Israeli academics? 17:36  |  Aston 18/07/07
  51.   Thank you to these people of peace. 17:55  |  Deborah 18/07/07
  52.   Peace NOT PIECE 18:26  |  pace306 18/07/07
  53.   Dozens of classical............ 18:33  |  tbora 18/07/07
  54.   Let them play Wagner 18:46  |  Herbert Kaine 18/07/07
  55.   FALSE HANNAH ALERT! #31, #36 & #37 18:50  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  56.   Right wing war mongers 19:34  |  Mitch Cohen 18/07/07
  57.   Peace will come...God`s way and God`s way only. 21:02  |  Sh`ma 18/07/07
  58.   Hannah give it a break 21:11  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  59.   `41" Victor Hardman pushing his "Gluck" 21:44  |  Labhras 18/07/07
  60.   "54" Herbert Kaine from his temporary address. 21:48  |  Labhras 18/07/07
  61.   #56 MITCH WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A RIGHT WING 22:08  |  paul harris 18/07/07
  62.   FALSE HANNAH ALERT! #58 22:31  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  63.   Thinking is good; however, more thinking is better 22:40  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  64.   Music to my ears! 23:07  |  Ivar 18/07/07
  65.   Whichever Hannah 23:21  |  sh 18/07/07
  66.   #3 - move on you say - to what? More violence? 00:04  |  Don Camillo 19/07/07
  67.   This some thing even the enemy of Israel agrees. 00:09  |  Ah 19/07/07
  68.   FALSE HANNAH ALERT! #58 00:27  |  Hannah 19/07/07
  69.   "3` Yoishai Kohen 00:34  |  Labhras 19/07/07
  70.   `46" Zvulun 00:46  |  Labhras 19/07/07
  71.   "40" Victor Hardman pushes his "Gluck". 01:05  |  Labhras 19/07/07
  72.   WHY DON`T THEY SPEAK OUT AGAINST ARAB OCCUPIED LAND? 01:43  |  THE PALESTINIAN MYTH 19/07/07
  73.   labrhas 01:44  |  Danite 19/07/07
  74.   classical musicians 02:00  |  Connie 19/07/07
  75.   Don Camillo re Yishai 02:05  |  Danite 19/07/07
  76.   It`s the Dixie Chicks all over again... 02:18  |  Pssd Off American 19/07/07
  77.   #62, whichever sh 03:50  |  Hannah 19/07/07
  78.   #36 Hannah re Palestinian arab classical musicians 05:45  |  Ben Alofs 19/07/07
  79.   #63 CAMILLO ITS IN THE ARABS HANDS 05:51  |  paul harris 19/07/07
  80.   musicians manifest 08:00  |  Gabe 19/07/07
  81.   the wise fringe.. 08:11  |  ravi 19/07/07
  82.   #74, Ben Alofs 08:33  |  Hannah 19/07/07
  83.   Ravi, Ivar salutes you. Right on! 09:51  |  Ivar 19/07/07
  84.   TOUCHE` Ivar, that`s weilding the Sword!!!(At the looney masses) 20:44  |  TruthCutsDeep 19/07/07
 Today Online