Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., July 22, 2007 Av 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:20 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Power like the king of England
By Amira Hass

At the end of the week, 256 families will celebrate the release from prison of their dear ones, and mothers are already relieved that the manhunt for their wanted sons has ended. In the cities where the wanted men live, there is also a sense of relief: The armed men - particularly those from Fatah - prided themselves on their weapons in the context of internal power games. They endangered their own surroundings rather than the Israeli occupation. We can gauge the extent to which the gestures will strengthen Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas not by the praise that Prime Minister Ehud Olmert is getting from U.S. President George W. Bush, but by how the gestures are received in Palestinian society.

The intensive public relations campaign regarding the "gestures" reinforces the Palestinians' understanding that Israel is buying its ability to continue with the policy of occupation at a bargain price. After all, it is not planning to return the land it robbed from every Palestinian. The network of roadblocks and separate roads - which is destroying the fabric of Palestinian society - will not be removed, and the angry soldier at the roadblock will not stop turning every simple trip into torture.

The Palestinians are sufficiently experienced to know that all the smiles being exchanged by Abbas and Olmert are not stopping the bulldozers, which continue to imprison them in enclaves among the growing settlement blocs. The declarations by Saeb Erekat about adhering to "a state within the 1967 borders" do not convince the public that a government led by the Palestinian Liberation Organization and Fatah will manage to do what it has not done since 1994: to fight against the Israeli project of occupation and colonization.

Advertisement

The concept of "amnesty" that is being used to describe the agreement to stop chasing wanted men demonstrates to what extent Israel is entrenched in its position of domination. According to the law, the president is allowed to pardon "criminals." According to the law, a "criminal" is someone who was tried and convicted. It's true that the late president Chaim Herzog pardoned leading members of the Shin Bet security service before they were tried for the murder of the hijackers of bus no. 300, after the majority opinion in the High Court of Justice ruled that the president of Israel has the same power to pardon as the king of England and the president of the United States.

But here it is a "pardon" of the Shin Bet and the army in the field. The ease with which the concept "pardon" was accepted in the media is additional proof of the sweeping approval that Israelis grant the Israel Defense Forces and its soldiers to act as prosecutor, judge and executioner. Is it any wonder that they are given the power of a king of England, to pardon before a trial?

Even the fate of the prisoners to be released in the context of the gestures had been sealed, even before they were tried in the big show called "the Israeli military court." A show, because the same military establishment that occupies and destroys and oppresses the civilian population is the body that decides that opposing the occupation (even by popular demonstrations and stone throwing) is a crime. Its judges are loyal to the interest of defending the occupier and the settler. The gesture of the prisoner release is therefore a very minor repair of a substantial legal flaw.

The Palestinians cannot forget that thousands of Israeli commanders and soldiers who killed women and children, broke hands and feet and defended the robbery of lands with their weapons, are walking around free. Had Olmert sincerely wanted to strengthen Abbas, he would at least have agreed to the request that Fatah representatives have been making for years: Demonstrate some degree of equality, release all those who were imprisoned for life for activity against the occupation, prior to the signing of the Oslo Accords. Release those who have been sitting for 20 and 30 years, and those whose dispatchers at the time are among the senior negotiators today. The failure to release them after 1994 was one of the important contributing factors to weakening the status of the PA and Fatah.

But after all, the "gestures" are being made in the concept of Israeli supremacy, of throwing a few crumbs to Abbas in anticipation of his obedience and of a grade of "good behavior" befitting a loyal subject. When that is the plan, it is also a surefire recipe for weakening Abbas.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Men in shorts
Who said shorts are not cool for men? Shorts are in vogue, proving less is more.
Isaiah's advice
The portion of the week deals with the future of Zion and improvement of society.
  1.   Amira throws red meat to the jackels 10:40  |  Natallie Durson 18/07/07
  2.   Democracy 10:45  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  3.   AMIRA AND THE 1922 MANDATE HAVE NEVER BEEN INTRODUCED ? 10:57  |  paul harris 18/07/07
  4.   Amira, Amira, .... 11:13  |  Bandar Michael 18/07/07
  5.   Amira 11:18  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  6.   # 5 Hannah 11:44  |  Andrew Watson 18/07/07
  7.   NATALLIE#1. INSTEAD OF RED MEAT REMEMBER THE GREEN NUMBER PLATES… 12:16  |  MOSHEH 18/07/07
  8.   AMIRA, ARIMA 12:18  |  indrajaya 18/07/07
  9.   #6 WATSON IS GOING TO TELL US THE TREATY THAT MAKES 12:19  |  paul harris 18/07/07
  10.   Playing politics with Arabs is waist of time 12:20  |  CM 18/07/07
  11.   # 7 Just remember the settlement expansion 12:32  |  Andrew Watson 18/07/07
  12.   # 10 CM 12:38  |  Andrew Watson 18/07/07
  13.   They forgot to" release "Haas to palestinians 12:53  |  Sal 18/07/07
  14.   Amira, why aer you unhappy ? 12:54  |  ziggurat 18/07/07
  15.   INDRA#8. AMIRA IS RESPECTED BY PERSONS WHO DON’T AGREE WITH HER.. 12:54  |  MOSHEH 18/07/07
  16.   Useless Gestures 13:09  |  J of Hollywood 18/07/07
  17.   ANDREW WATSON#11. PLEASE, NOT JUST WORDS! A CONCRETE EXAMPLE!! 13:13  |  MOSHEH 18/07/07
  18.   # 15, MOSHEH 13:16  |  indrajaya 18/07/07
  19.   Objectivity 13:42  |  Julie 18/07/07
  20.   Here we go again, more Pali propaganda from Ha`aretz! 13:58  |  Nannette 18/07/07
  21.   #8 Indraya Very Perceptive 14:01  |  17 18/07/07
  22.   No. 20 "No, No, Nanette" 14:27  |  Mitch Cohen 18/07/07
  23.   Amira Hass = RESPECT 14:27  |  JB 18/07/07
  24.   Amira : are you serious ? 14:50  |  Maureen from Belfast 18/07/07
  25.   Abbas, A Loyal Puppy 14:57  |  Nipur 18/07/07
  26.   A Sop Meant To Maintain the Occupation 15:09  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/07/07
  27.   Amira, stop incitement against peace! 15:17  |  British Leftie 18/07/07
  28.   if Israel left every inch of the occupied areas 15:19  |  bob 18/07/07
  29.   #9 Paul Harris wants to know the name of the treaty 15:19  |  Johnboy 18/07/07
  30.   #17 MOSEH 15:26  |  Johnboy 18/07/07
  31.   Nannette #20 15:32  |  British Leftie 18/07/07
  32.   british leftie 15:43  |  bev 18/07/07
  33.   #26 THE ONE DIMENSIONAL YAAKOV! 15:45  |  paul harris 18/07/07
  34.   Amira Continues to ignore Israel`s intention 15:45  |  Daniel Friedman 18/07/07
  35.   Indrajaya # 8 15:45  |  Avrum 18/07/07
  36.   to Indrajaya, Durson, or anyone else that hates Israel 15:51  |  Daniel Friedman 18/07/07
  37.   Spinning a deed to look bad 15:56  |  Avrum 18/07/07
  38.   JOHNBOY#30. THANKS FOR YOUR ANSWER IN PLACE OF ANDREW WATSON BUT… 15:58  |  MOSHEH 18/07/07
  39.   British Leftie 16:00  |  Lynn 18/07/07
  40.   Bev 16:02  |  British Leftie 18/07/07
  41.   # 35, AVRUM 16:03  |  indrajaya 18/07/07
  42.   #11. Because the last time we kept to the 16:08  |  Chayim 18/07/07
  43.   JOHNBOY#29. YOU SHOULD READ FLAVIUS JOSEPH, OR JUST READ… 16:17  |  MOSHEH 18/07/07
  44.   To Lynn 16:25  |  British Leftie 18/07/07
  45.   Mr. harris on 150% #33 16:31  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/07/07
  46.   Daniel Friedman, your assertion is mindboggling 16:35  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/07/07
  47.   To Lynn #2 16:45  |  British Leftie 18/07/07
  48.   Amira - Hush 16:45  |  Ka 18/07/07
  49.   yawn! 16:45  |  harold 18/07/07
  50.   ANDREW WATSON#11. WHAT ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT??? 16:46  |  MOSHEH 18/07/07
  51.   Hey British Leftie: Stop pretending you want Israel to have peace 16:56  |  Steve Holden 18/07/07
  52.   @8, indra, amira passed age of childbearing many many years ago 16:57  |  vladimir 18/07/07
  53.   Steve #51 17:04  |  British Leftie 18/07/07
  54.   A.WATSON the settlement issue openly discussed is a first step. 17:08  |  PETER SM 18/07/07
  55.   It appears that Salim Fayed was correct 17:08  |  Jacob Blues 18/07/07
  56.   IT`S EVIL WHAT THE ISRAELIS HAVE DONE TO THE PALESTINIANS 17:13  |  Dutch 18/07/07
  57.   Amira has a solid backbone and a natural capability 17:15  |  Clickright 18/07/07
  58.   Jacob Blues Can Only Distort. It`s All That`s Left. 17:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 18/07/07
  59.   JOHNBOY 1948. YOUR side grabbed,Israel agreed to partition. 17:21  |  PETERSM 18/07/07
  60.   @40, british lefty 17:29  |  vladimir 18/07/07
  61.   Amira -- worth reading 17:35  |  Josh Korn 18/07/07
  62.   Thank goodness for Amira. 17:38  |  Deborah 18/07/07
  63.   RE: british lefty 17:51  |  Victor 18/07/07
  64.   DUTCH#56. WHAT PAL’S DO TO BROTHERS, EVIL ISRAELIS CANNOT COMPETE 18:06  |  MOSHEH 18/07/07
  65.   #62 deborah 18:13  |  tbora 18/07/07
  66.   I support Amira Hass - she is one of my best friends 18:18  |  Shaik Nasrallah 18/07/07
  67.   # 48 Hush 18:23  |  Claire G 18/07/07
  68.   Amira, IT`S SO BLOODY AWFUL ... 18:44  |  Dutch 18/07/07
  69.   #6, Andrew Watson 18:45  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  70.   If Amiras lies were any more crooked, they`de be straight 18:45  |  pace306 18/07/07
  71.   Stating the known and obvious 18:45  |  Michael N 18/07/07
  72.   FALSE HANNAH ALERT! #2, #5 18:46  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  73.   #43 MOSHEH 19:00  |  Boycott 18/07/07
  74.   Arab Hannah 19:02  |  Hannah 18/07/07
  75.   Well said brithish leftie 19:22  |  Jonathan 18/07/07
  76.   Shame on you Haaretz for this anti Israel propaganda 19:31  |  Chris 18/07/07
  77.   True Jewish soul 19:40  |  Mitch Cohen 18/07/07
  78.   Palestinians see themselves as eternal victimc 19:56  |  Sensible 18/07/07
  79.   #73 BOYCOTT, THE BOY ODD! 20:00  |  MOSHEH 18/07/07
  80.   Amira I resent you..... 20:02  |  Esther 18/07/07
  81.   Amira Hass ? with friends like you who needs any enemies 20:07  |  Gil 18/07/07
  82.   Jihadi Hannah 20:27  |  Gina 18/07/07
  83.   Yaakov # 46....what do u propose israel do?? 20:35  |  SHIMON 18/07/07
  84.   Congratulations to the terrorists? families 20:53  |  Al-AqsaMurderersBrig 18/07/07
  85.   DEAR PARENTS....from my homesick heart 20:56  |  Dutch 18/07/07
  86.