Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., July 19, 2007 Av 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:00 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Anglo File Rosner's Domain Real Estate Travel  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
How to stop Hamas
By Ephraim Sneh

The most urgent and important mission for Israel at this time is preventing a Hamas takeover of the West Bank. It is possible to do this by weakening Hamas through visible diplomatic progress; helping the effective and successful functioning of Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayad's government; and the creation of conditions for the total failure of the Hamas regime in the Gaza Strip.

The failure of Israeli policy thus far derives from the refusal to recognize two facts of life: The first is that Hamas is an uncompromising historic enemy, part of the Iranian system that has condemned us to destruction. It is necessary to vanquish it, and in order to emerge victorious, military campaigns and arrests are not enough - it is imperative to bring about its political-public defeat via another Palestinian element.

The second fact of life is that the Fatah movement, with all its known weaknesses, is the only political factor in the Palestinian arena that is capable of presenting a secular and pragmatic alternative to the Hamas.

Advertisement

It was not the recognition of the historic justice of the Zionist movement that made moderates of the heads of Fatah, but rather the recognition that there is no chance for a modern Palestinian state that has a growing economy without close cooperation with Israel. People who gave all the years of their lives to the Palestinian national issue prefer an independent state alongside Israel to seeing their dream go up in the clouds of smoke of a third Islamic intifada. Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) and Fayad are therefore the only conceivable partners shaping a reality that is acceptable to us between the Jordan River and the sea.

What steps does Israel need to take to stop Hamas and to strengthen the moderate alternative?

First of all, it is necessary to release a large number of Fatah prisoners, headed by Marwan Barghouti. The number of Israeli victims who will be spared by his exit to political activity outside of prison is many times greater than the number of those for whose deaths he was convicted. Of the 11,000 prisoners who are held by Israel, 6,000 are Fatah people. The political benefit in freeing many of them is immeasurably greater than the security risk entailed in doing so.

The tax monies that Israel collects for the Palestinians must be released without delay for use by the Fayad government. A comprehensive "security package" must be built for this government. This must include the removal of Tanzim and al Aqsa Brigades wanted men from the circle of terror and the strengthening of the government security organizations, including equipping and reorganizing them in accordance with the Dayton plan and in coordination with Israeli security elements. If these measures are carried out successfully, it will be possible to ease significantly the regime of roadblocks, especially in the northern West Bank.

It is also necessary to encourage economic initiatives from the Palestinian private sector, and from international elements to establish industrial zones and investments in the West Bank. It is necessary to increase significantly the number of Palestinians working in Israel.

During the past year, thousands of inhabitants of the West Bank stayed regularly and for prolonged periods in Israel, especially in agricultural jobs, without there having been even a single case of hostile action perpetrated by them. With respect to the Israeli economy, Palestinian workers are preferable to foreign workers.

And last but not least: It is necessary to embark on a discussion with the Palestinian president about the principles of the permanent status agreement. As for Gaza, it is necessary to maintain the strict avoidance of any contact with elements of the Hamas government.

Humanitarian activity by international aid organizations should not be prevented nor should electricity and water be cut off, but it is necessary to destroy the Hamas perception that sees contact with Israel as a religious and national sin. They must not be allowed to enjoy the best of both worlds, and it is necessary to reveal the price that this perception is exacting from the inhabitants of the Gaza Strip. That price is preventing any trade activity at the crossing points as long as there are Hamas people or their representatives on the Gaza Stripside.

In the creation of the Palestinian entity in the West Bank, there is not only an Israeli interest, but also a regional interest. Iran has already gained control of southern Iraq, and it is on its way to a violent takeover of Lebanon.

The countries of the region that do not want to be next in line to be swallowed up by the new Persian empire must seriously help in the effort to stop Hamas.

Ephraim Sneh is a Labor MK and until recently served as deputy defense minister.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Tantura to St. Tropez
Israeli beach fashion has moved from stylish strengths to haute couture heights.
Setting sail
Beijing 2008 sailing hopefuls boast a loner mentality, and plentiful state support.
  1.   FIGHT HAMAS OR DIE 09:49  |  indrajaya 17/07/07
  2.   #1 Indrajaya 10:13  |  Hannah 17/07/07
  3.   With a left wing like this, who needs a right? 10:15  |  Natallie Durson 17/07/07
  4.   # 2, HANNAH (PROBABLY FAKE) 10:27  |  indrajaya 17/07/07
  5.   I got to `release Marwan Barghouti` and stopped reading ! 10:31  |  redmike 17/07/07
  6.   There is no Arab moderate, real peace loving or innocent civilian 10:36  |  Uzi 17/07/07
  7.   #3 - Gaza is now the Gazan`s problem .. 10:37  |  redmike 17/07/07
  8.   Indrajaya.Hamas won 75% of the seats NOT the votes 10:48  |  PETER SM 17/07/07
  9.   Recognise reality 10:54  |  Fred 17/07/07
  10.   Sneh has been given the task to fool the Israelis to accept this 10:54  |  Pavel 17/07/07
  11.   Ephraim, you contradict yourself: 11:16  |  Uzi 17/07/07
  12.   No Indrajaya! That Is Hannah! 11:16  |  Yosemite 17/07/07
  13.   Fred-#9 -Recognise reality 11:16  |  Daniel Leopold 17/07/07
  14.   Fatah needs to clean up its act 11:20  |  Angelique 17/07/07
  15.   Propping up Fatah will not bring peace 11:20  |  Tzfonit 17/07/07
  16.   NDURSON With Islamist,maximalist,Hamas.No left is possible. 11:34  |  PETER SM 17/07/07
  17.   Ephraim Sneh - Tell This To The Boycotters (1) 11:36  |  Gil 17/07/07
  18.   Ephraim Sneh - Tell This To The Boycotters (2) 11:37  |  Gil 17/07/07
  19.   Really an irony: Without Hamas there would be no progress. 11:39  |  Andreas 17/07/07
  20.   #1: don`t you pray 5 times a day INDIE? 11:41  |  Hannah 17/07/07
  21.   # 14, ANGELIQUE 11:41  |  indrajaya 17/07/07
  22.   Palestinians Were Tricked Into Voting For Hamas By... 11:43  |  Yosemite 17/07/07
  23.   Ephraim Sneh ? You want to stop Hamas ? Very Simple 11:53  |  Gil 17/07/07
  24.   HASHEM IS HARDENING THE HEART OF HAMAS 12:06  |  PALESTINIAN MYTH 17/07/07
  25.   @E. Sneh & M. Barghouti 12:10  |  Judge 17/07/07
  26.   Settlements? 12:15  |  Mariam 17/07/07
  27.   Defending Failed Policies. 12:16  |  Terry 17/07/07
  28.   A lot of wishful thinkin,most of the money will go into the 12:16  |  lakshmi 17/07/07
  29.   THANKS TO HAMAS 12:20  |  Teresia 17/07/07
  30.   to Indrayaya 12:27  |  Harry 17/07/07
  31.   # 30, HARRY 12:48  |  indrajaya 17/07/07
  32.   RE.8 PETER SM, You are wrong 12:53  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  33.   IT IS ISRAEL THAT MUST BE STOPPED 13:00  |  Dutch 17/07/07
  34.   do not forget in the to do list 13:05  |  cool 17/07/07
  35.   How Hamas will not be stopped 13:07  |  Jonathan S 17/07/07
  36.   how to close THE REFUGES CAMPS ? 13:08  |  Atilla Liman 17/07/07
  37.   33# doris and the bells of natick ring out again 13:09  |  victor hardman 17/07/07
  38.   Teresia : This is why we Thank Hamas? 13:16  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  39.   shame on world FOR PALESTINIANS REFUGE CAMPS ! 13:17  |  Atilla Liman 17/07/07
  40.   Indrayaya on terror 13:18  |  pantai 17/07/07
  41.   # 39, PANTAI 13:24  |  indrajaya 17/07/07
  42.   # 39, PANTAI 13:24  |  indrajaya 17/07/07
  43.   Rehabilitation for Israel. 13:24  |  Nick Ferriman 17/07/07
  44.   Hamas needn`t be stopped, they must be destroyed to the very last 13:30  |  Uzi 17/07/07
  45.   Sneh, it is the first time I here u Sane! 13:35  |  Sharif Hafez 17/07/07
  46.   Re;;how 2 stop hamas 13:36  |  sampson 17/07/07
  47.   #41 Who pays the Ferriman 13:39  |  Hastaroth 17/07/07
  48.   Indrayaya on Abbas 13:50  |  pantai 17/07/07
  49.   The most urgent and important mission, why? 13:53  |  Fritz 17/07/07
  50.   The first paragraph makes sense 13:56  |  Mark Lincoln 17/07/07
  51.   PHILASTIN Sorry you are wrong see below.Hamas won 44% 14:02  |  PETER SM 17/07/07
  52.   RE42:UZI Hamas can`t be blamed if Israel has the same agenda 14:05  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  53.   RE 39, Pentai on terror 14:30  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  54.   PHILASTIN Here is the OFFICIAL agenda of Hamas NOT an individual 14:31  |  PETER SM 17/07/07
  55.   to Philistin 14:33  |  Harry 17/07/07
  56.   #41nick quotes blunt and arrives at a fox hunt 14:38  |  victor hardman 17/07/07
  57.   PHILASTIN Sorry you are wrong Hamas won about 46% of the vote 14:38  |  PETER SM 17/07/07
  58.   # 44 Hastaroth 14:42  |  Nick Ferriman 17/07/07
  59.   Philistine #47, nobody can be blamed for defending themselves. 14:48  |  Uzi 17/07/07
  60.   Tzfonit #15 14:50  |  GABE1 17/07/07
  61.   Historic Enemy? Israel helped create Hamas! 14:52  |  Tim 17/07/07
  62.   30/Harry: You have a weiry definition of Democracy 14:54  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  63.   It should be up to the mothers, fathers and grandparents 14:54  |  The Equalizer 17/07/07
  64.   52/PETER SM 15:15  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  65.   # 3 Durson 15:17  |  Lynn 17/07/07
  66.   you missed the most important point... 15:26  |  ravi 17/07/07
  67.   to Philestin 15:27  |  Harry 17/07/07
  68.   50/Harry 15:27  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  69.   PETER SM, 46% doesn`t allow Hamas to occupy 70% of Parliman seats 15:34  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  70.   Sneh of the genus "Bush" 15:40  |  Tosefta 17/07/07
  71.   54/Uzi, I can read the criminal issue behind your conclusion 15:41  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  72.   # 57 Philistine 15:41  |  Lynn 17/07/07
  73.   to Philistin 15:42  |  Harry 17/07/07
  74.   to ravi 15:43  |  Harry 17/07/07
  75.   # 64 Everybody in this talk back knows propaganda 15:48  |  Lynn 17/07/07
  76.   58/The equalizer 15:51  |  Philistin 17/07/07
  77.   What Hamas can do 16:05  |  Tosefta 17/07/07
  78.   Right Tzfonit 16:10  |  Angelique 17/07/07
  79.   Such hypocrisy 16:13  |  Angelique 17/07/07
  80.   Fritz 16:14  |  Hannah 17/07/07
  81.   #57 Philistine: Democracy? In whose name? 16:15  |  Softwalker 17/07/07
  82.   Philistine 46 don`t embarress yourself...45% of pop.vote 16:16  |  The Equalizer 17/07/07
  83.   How to stop Olmert -it is better question ??? 16:36  |  Sal 17/07/07
  84.   `65` tosefta 16:40  |  Labhras 17/07/07
  85.   #64 so-called Philistin 16:44  |  Rebekah S 17/07/07