Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., July 13, 2007 Tamuz 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 22:01 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
State schools are dying, and we know why
By Yossi Sarid

State schools are dying. The number of pupils in those schools will fall to 50 percent by 2012, and every third pupil will be in an ultra-Orthodox school, according to a projection for elementary schools published in Haaretz this week.

The ultra-Orthodox parties have been disconnecting the terminally ill patient from the life support machines. This is not mercy killing, it's deduction killing: They're deducting from the state education system and adding to the ultra-Orthodox education.

About a month and a half ago, the Knesset enacted the Nahari Law, which requires local authorities to finance the ultra-Orthodox schools. This week the Knesset passed in preliminary reading the bill presented by United Torah Judaism abolishing the link between state financing and the core study program, and paving the road for generous budgetary increments.

Advertisement

How many times has it been said that the future is in education and nothing is more important than our children's education Not a bit of it. A stupid war and Qassams fired at Sderot bring people onto the streets, albeit not enough. A wretched decision by the attorney general brings demonstrators to the city square. The slogan, 'You're corrupt; we're fed up with you' generates a minor protest here and there. But when national education is handed to plunderers, no one utters a squeak. What do we care if our children are raised as ignoramuses, and our grandchildren as illiterates?

The mercy killing is not carried out by ultra-Orthodox Knesset members alone. Without the support of secular MKs, they would not have succeeded in pulling it off. Again they're kowtowing to Shas and UTJ. For without Shas in the coalition and without UTJ in reserve, Ehud Olmert has no government, just as Benjamin Netanyahu and Ehud Barak have no chance of setting up their own governments.

Thus they are willing to sell their own mothers for their personal ambitions, and her grandchildren and great-grandchildren too, while they're at it. Oh, mother, mother, what children you have raised, they are sinning against us.

All that is going on now inevitably flows from the original sin. When David Ben-Gurion abolished the various pre-state education 'streams' in favor of state education, in reality all he scrapped was the Histadrut schools, affiliated with the Labor Movement. The National Religious Party's state religious education remained, as did Agudat Yisrael's independent system, and in due course Shas ultra-Orthodox schools joined the wreckers of state education.

Children and their parents are trapped in the ultra-Orthodox school system, not from some great love of tradition, but simply for the goodies they hand out. Words of temptation, like jokes, sound better in Yiddish. State education has long run out of goodies to offer.'

It seemed in recent years that Eli Yishai and his colleagues' ravenous hunger had subsided. Tommy Lapid was their punishment. As his memory fades, they are up to their old tricks again. Amnon de Hartog will be punished for slapping an ultra-Orthodox MK, but they should be punished as well: For years they have been vilifying him only because he was blocking them from devouring excessive state allocations.

The bill exonerating ultra-Orthodox institutions from the core program will pass its first reading next week, and by the end of summer vacation the job will be completed. From now on, tens of thousands of pupils will be exempt from studying sciences, English and civics. They are being returned to the Ashkenazi's ghetto or the Moroccan Melah, which they will not be able to leave for the rest of their life. These children are lost. And the ultra-Orthodox parties will ensure their Knesset seats for a long time.

This government, too, declares that education tops its priorities. In reality, it is dragging it to the lowest depths.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Battling corruption
The World Bank says Israel leads Mideast countries in the fight against corruption.
It's not all cutthroat
Law schools and firms join forces in new educational program for students.
  1.   Appalling. We might as well be under shariah law. 12:18  |  Reuven 12/07/07
  2.   Let us at least acknowledge the incongruous 12:48  |  Esther 12/07/07
  3.   What about Democracy and Personal Choice Yossi??? 13:05  |  Yaakov Ish Tam 12/07/07
  4.   State Schools are dying 13:37  |  Roxy 12/07/07
  5.   yaakov is correct, and yossi should emigrate 14:15  |  henry 12/07/07
  6.   So our expert in Education has decided 14:52  |  D Hirod 12/07/07
  7.   A disgrace. 15:32  |  DkS 12/07/07
  8.   Send your money to ORT 15:48  |  send your children 12/07/07
  9.   It`s true, and this will destroy the state 15:59  |  McQueen 12/07/07
  10.   Yossi Sarid is full of hate 15:59  |  Dan 12/07/07
  11.   Schools 16:00  |  Shachar 12/07/07
  12.   The Death of Israel 16:19  |  Moshe 12/07/07
  13.   Hamas spokesman welcome but not settlers or Haredim ! 16:32  |  Alberto Cohen 12/07/07
  14.   Its the secular contempt for religion that blinds seculars .. 16:43  |  Joe 12/07/07
  15.   Sarid`s hate masks real issues 16:44  |  consorts 12/07/07
  16.   RELIGIOUS SCHOOLS PRODUCE THE BEST CITIZENS 16:51  |  BILL HANDEL 12/07/07
  17.   Some religious schools on list? 17:08  |  to receive ORT money 12/07/07
  18.   We need sanity!!!!!! 18:49  |  Gary 12/07/07
  19.   state schools are dying 18:57  |  sheila dotan 12/07/07
  20.   Homeschooling and State Exams 19:47  |  Kevin Minailo 12/07/07
  21.   existential threat 19:53  |  outraged 12/07/07
  22.   We are closing gaps with our neighbours 21:51  |  Morah 12/07/07
  23.   To #1 Reuven 22:08  |  Moshe Gornstein 12/07/07
  24.   instead of admitting 22:34  |  yechiel 12/07/07
  25.   Obviously the State Schools failed 22:35  |  S Judah 12/07/07
  26.   The religious schools produce their own downfall 22:52  |  Yael 12/07/07
  27.   no hope 23:05  |  irwin 12/07/07
  28.   Private religious schools produce the best students 09:23  |  MIRIAM 13/07/07
  29.   #15, consorts, seems to me you quite agree with Sarid 17:15  |  newageblues 13/07/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Back the boycott, kill the symphony
Responses: 62
Marcus: 2006 war is only one remembered as a failure
Responses: 37
Ghada Karmi: Boycotts are the weapons of the weak
Responses: 109
Jerome M. Segal: How to reach Palestinian statehood in a year
Responses: 85
Zvi Bar'el: French talks on Lebanon kowtow to Hezbollah
Responses: 49
PM: Syria's Assad wants talks, but only with Bush
Responses: 72


More Headlines
21:40 Abbas appoints Fayad as PM of new interim PA government
21:35 IDF lifts gag on arrest of militant implicated in Shalit abduction
18:32 Vilnai: Israel should give serious consideration to Hawatmeh visit
21:19 New chair of Yesha Council says will 'renew dialogue' in society
22:00 Jordan: Next few weeks are crucial for Mideast peace
17:15 Report: India, Israel to jointly develop $2.47b. missile system
21:30 UN: Mideast mediators to confer with Blair at Lisbon Quartet meeting
18:03 Jerusalem mayor asks Turkey to return ancient Judean tablet
19:49 Ex-Jerusalem Post owner Conrad Black convicted of mail fraud
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved