Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., July 20, 2007 Av 5, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:04 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Anglo File Rosner's Domain Real Estate Travel  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 08:15 13/07/2007
Back the boycott, kill the symphony
By Bradley Burston

Haters of Israel, take heart. Boycotters of Israel, rejoice. The Jewish state, ever wary of foreign intervention, has decided to begin boycotting Israel all by itself.

Following the example of the British academics' boycott campaign against Israeli professors and universities, an arm of our government has taken deadly aim at another Israeli institution that helps makes the world a better place, and can do a world of good for our image abroad: the Jerusalem Symphony Orchestra.

The Israel Broadcasting Authority, which oversees the symphony and funds much of its budget, plans to slash its subsidy - a move that will force the orchestra to disband.

Advertisement

This, despite the orchestra's unique role in Israel's cultural landscape: its efforts to reach younger audiences, for which classical music, and the seriousness, verve and excellence of the musicians come as a revelation and an inspiration; its association with public broadcasting in the United States, which has brought the orchestra's performances to millions of listeners; and its showcasing of Israeli composers, past, present and, in playing the works of a new generation, future.

This, despite the personal sacrifice and unflagging moxie of its principal conductor and musicians, whose efforts brought the orchestra to solvency within a matter of four years, after it had been mismanaged to the brink of bankruptcy.

This, despite the hard work and blind faith of musical director and main conductor Leon Botstein, who has refused a salary for those four years while revamping the orchestra's repertoire and raising funds abroad. This, despite the hardships of the musicians, many of them immigrants from the former Soviet Union, who took a 20 percent pay cut to help keep the orchestra alive.

This, despite the fact that the cut in the orchestra's subsidy will do nothing to offset the IBA's colossal financial problems. The $1.6 million cut in the $3.6 million existing annual budget - already laughably puny for a symphony orchestra ? represents barely 2 percent of the total IBA budget. The IBA won't feel the cuts. They will, however, be more than enough to kill off a great orchestra before it can celebrate its 70th anniversary next year.

The IBA decision to squeeze the orchestra is a masterwork of bureaucratic cynicism. It takes advantage of Israel's plight of permanent warfare, and a certain unstated wartime assumption that a symphony orchestra is one luxury the people of Israel can do without.

The IBA is betting that if truth is the first casualty of war, then civility, and the civilizing elements of a culture, will not be far behind.

The decision expresses the IBA's hope, without having to say so, that much of the public will have long ago dismissed the idea of an Israeli symphony orchestra, viewing it as the creature of another time and place. It hopes the public will conclude that if the orchestra is denied its meager allotment, the needs of the hungry and the homeless and the jobless and the infirm and the under-educated may then magically be addressed.

At the same time, the decision exploits and deflects the public's well-earned contempt for the IBA, the very model of modern major mismanagement.

IBA management is betting that the public will not view the orchestra's valiant battle to gain financial independence as a sterling example of public service, but as the quaintly Quixotic struggle of a freier, a sucker. The IBA, meanwhile, has long been under the thumb and the threat of muscular unions, which will not abide cuts to better-funded departments. Understandably, therefore, the IBA, with its stratospheric overhead and its elements of parasitical bureaucracy, is only too happy to sacrifice the sucker to save the leech.

The decision trusts the public to be too dazzled by the antics of the nation's suddenly rich and fleetingly fabulous, too fascinated by consumerism or too mired in the burgeoning underclass, to appreciate the ways in which this orchestra, their orchestra, embodies values that Israel cannot afford to allow itself to lose.

The Jerusalem Symphony Orchestra is an institution that celebrates collective achievement and personal brilliance. It is a bridge between Israel and the world, breaching barriers of language, culture and custom. It is an Israel that gives much more than it takes. It is an Israel that comes in peace. It is an underdog that fights the good fight.

It is a side that deserves to win.


_________________


Recent blogs:

Why can't Jews and Palestinians make peace?
Is terrorism on the way out?
Dual loyalty, baseball, and the Israeli psyche
Hamas as the new Israel

__________________



The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Filming the periphery
Salmona is new to the movie business, which may be why his plot resembles reality.
Between two worlds
First, Istanbul seems a sea of red and white flags. On closer look, nuances appear.
  1.   fascism and Music don`t go hand in hand 09:11  |  KMS 13/07/07
  2.   Wrong move 09:45  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 13/07/07
  3.   The Symphony 09:52  |  Judith 13/07/07
  4.   Since when are reversed priorities a new thing? 10:01  |  Natallie Durson 13/07/07
  5.   Why can`t it use some of the 24 million shekels a day the US give 10:34  |  Don Camillo 13/07/07
  6.   Self-sacrifice Israeli style 10:56  |  sh 13/07/07
  7.   KMS: Music and fascism don`t go hand in hand? 10:58  |  sh 13/07/07
  8.   Welcome change 11:03  |  Choni Davidowitz 13/07/07
  9.   #1 KMS - double fault 11:08  |  ScotGuy 13/07/07
  10.   sh - Do you ever have anything postive to say about anything or 11:26  |  Hannah 13/07/07
  11.   Take example from American funding of orchestras 11:33  |  S 13/07/07
  12.   #7, sh 11:35  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/07/07
  13.   Bradley:Unfinished and Nearly Finished Symphony 11:46  |  Ronnie Wolman 13/07/07
  14.   music and islam go hand in hand 12:11  |  Watcher 13/07/07
  15.   Killing off the orchestra? Israel shoots itself in the foot! 12:21  |  Nannette 13/07/07
  16.   Hannah 12:48  |  sh 13/07/07
  17.   #7 CJK 12:53  |  sh 13/07/07
  18.   #1 KMS: Fascism and Music don`t go hand in hand 13:34  |  Andrew 13/07/07
  19.   Desperate attempt at politicizing 13:36  |  Ronit 13/07/07
  20.   Hear hear 13:46  |  Shalom Freedman 13/07/07
  21.   How is Daniel Barenbaum`s orchestra funded? 13:48  |  Don Camillo 13/07/07
  22.   underdog? ...thats the palis now... 14:06  |  ravi 13/07/07
  23.   Public money for the Bourgeoise 14:13  |  What`s in aname 13/07/07
  24.   Once Upon A Time 14:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/07/07
  25.   WHAT DOES G-D PROMISE TO DO WITH ALL HIS HEART AND SOUL ?? 14:52  |  Bill 13/07/07
  26.   Now, what a Hyperboling.. 14:58  |  Boozaglow 13/07/07
  27.   21 Until 2006 he was funded by Chicago 15:01  |  Nannette 13/07/07
  28.   sh -A Blissful Existance 15:05  |  HANEM5 13/07/07
  29.   #27 Nannette - but didn`t Barenboim also establish.. 15:17  |  Don Camillo 13/07/07
  30.   BB and Grabbing at Straws 15:20  |  GABE1 13/07/07
  31.   # 25 If you believe 15:20  |  What`s in a name 13/07/07
  32.   What`s in aname 15:49  |  sh 13/07/07
  33.   Don Camillo and funding the Barenboim orchestra 16:00  |  sh 13/07/07
  34.   Elitism! Why not subsidize rap groups and garage bands? 16:09  |  Toronto`s Finest 13/07/07
  35.   I object to the fact that someone else is using my 16:20  |  Hannah 13/07/07
  36.   Sullivan, keep up the good work, but you seem to hate Israel even 16:22  |  Hannah 13/07/07
  37.   #1 WHEN WAS THE LAST TIME KMS WAS IN ISRAEL ? 16:25  |  paul harris 13/07/07
  38.   Orchestra Should Be Independent 16:31  |  Jane 13/07/07
  39.   Sh - Alternatives 16:43  |  Mark of Lewiston 13/07/07
  40.   #33 sh - thank you for the clarification. Is it still going? 16:45  |  Don Camillo 13/07/07
  41.   #32 You don`t get the point 17:08  |  What`s in a name 13/07/07
  42.   DOn and KMS (third attempt, how about posting this time?) 17:23  |  Nik Miller 13/07/07
  43.   a tested strategy for fighting budget reductions 17:36  |  Ernst 13/07/07
  44.   Mark of Lewiston 17:45  |  sh 13/07/07
  45.   Toronto`s Finest on Eminems 17:55  |  Ronnie Wolman 13/07/07
  46.   Don Camillo - yes 17:55  |  sh 13/07/07
  47.   41 What`s in a Name 18:00  |  Mark of Lewiston 13/07/07
  48.   What`s in a name 18:38  |  sh 13/07/07
  49.   Yaakov Sullivan Cant Escape 18:57  |  TOBIA 13/07/07
  50.   #45 You picked some real rubbishy films 18:58  |  What`s in a name 13/07/07
  51.   Bradley is complaining against the wrong people 19:07  |  Tosefta 13/07/07
  52.   Ronnie.Subsidies are wasteful, and useless 19:08  |  Toronto`s Finest 13/07/07
  53.   No big deal... 19:40  |  Ramzi, a Palestinian 13/07/07
  54.   Orchestra?? We dopnt need no stinking orchestras!! 19:59  |  Danite 13/07/07
  55.   To Jane and other "Free marketers" 20:05  |  Danite 13/07/07
  56.   # 35 do you think we care... 20:07  |  Misha 13/07/07
  57.   Wonderful music 20:12  |  Hannah 13/07/07
  58.   The best expression of Jewish sensibility 20:13  |  Hannah 13/07/07
  59.   I am proud of my country 20:14  |  Hannah 13/07/07
  60.   `46" Tobia re Yaakov Sullivan 20:51  |  Labhras 13/07/07
  61.   Mr. Burston vs. the Conservtive Age 20:59  |  Mark Lincoln 13/07/07
  62.   Israelis don`t deserve a symphony orchestra 21:12  |  Nathan 13/07/07
  63.   Danite #51 21:32  |  GABE1 13/07/07
  64.   Labhras, thank you #52 21:45  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/07/07
  65.   No surprise 22:05  |  European observer 13/07/07
  66.   Hannah-dana Spare us your nauseating nonsense 22:21  |  Danite 13/07/07
  67.   mark Lincoln 22:23  |  danite 13/07/07
  68.   #51 Tosefta - Music brings solace to our lives... 22:27  |  Smadar 13/07/07
  69.   gabe1 Its easy 22:34  |  Danite 13/07/07
  70.   Danite - neosocial darwinism 22:56  |  Mark Lincoln 13/07/07
  71.   Israel disbanding the symphony 23:40  |  Sharonelle 13/07/07
  72.   Israel killing their own symphony as retaliation to an academic b 23:42  |  Sharonelle 13/07/07
  73.   "64" Yaakov Sullivan 23:50  |  Labhras 13/07/07
  74.   FALSE HANNAH 23:55  |  Hannah 13/07/07
  75.   # 11 S. FROM YOUR MOUTH TO MINE!! 00:32  |  KATH` 14/07/07
  76.   "62" Nathan 00:35  |  Labhras 14/07/07
  77.   # 12 Cipora Julianna Kohn.re:sh and ... 00:36  |  KATH` 14/07/07
  78.   Danite there is more than one Hannah. 00:41  |  bev 14/07/07
  79.   # 8 Choni 01:32  |  A M 14/07/07
  80.   When Did Things Change Lebhras 02:00  |  Tobia 14/07/07
  81.   Hannah#72 02:07  |  Danite 14/07/07
  82.   mark Lincoln 02:08  |  Danite 14/07/07
  83.   US money 02:16