Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., March 26, 2008 Adar2 20, 5768 | | Israel Time: 12:03 (EST+7) web haaretz.com   Back to Homepage Rosner's Domain Diplomacy Defense Jewish World Opinion National Print Edition Advertising Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File

A new museum confronts an old mystery at Masada By Danny Rubinstein Tags: Israel travel  The exhibit at the end of the tour of the new museum at Masada consists of 11 tiny sherds bearing intriguing names. The exhibit at the end of the tour of the new museum at Masada consists of 11 tiny sherds bearing intriguing names. Hundreds of inscriptions on sherds were found at Masada, including some on earthenware jugs. Some are only a single letters, others contain names and numbers from the days of the rebellion and the Roman siege. The archaeologists, in particular Yigael Yadin, were reasonably good at decipher the inscriptions on the various sherds, but the inscription on these 11 sherds was unusual. They were all found in the same place, next to the network of internal gates that controlled the passage to the foodstores, and were not scattered over a wide area like the other sherds. They were all written in the same handwriting, and each sherd contained only one name. Advertisement Most important, the names were not regular names but rather nicknames, such as Ben Hanahatam (or Ben Hanahtum), Tzayda (or Hatzayad, "the hunter"), Ha'amaki (someone from a village in the Acre area). Among them was one well-known name - Ben-Yair, the name of the leader of the Masada rebellion, Elazar Ben-Yair. When these sherds were found, Yigael Yadin came up with the theory that this was evidence of the terrible story of the mass suicide on the top of Masada. The historian Josephus gave a detailed description of the words Ben-Yair used to persuade the almost 1,000 people entrenched there "to do a useful deed." "We shall die before becoming slaves to our enemies, we shall take leave of life while we are still free men, together with our children and our wives," he reportedly said. After embracing their wives and kissing their babies as their eyes filled with tears, the men chose from among them 10 men, who presented their necks for the terrible massacre. The 10 then chose one man, by casting lots, to be the last. He was to kill the other nine before killing himself. The last man standing, Josephus relates, examined everyone to verify their deaths and then lit a huge fire in the palace, before finally finding the courage to stick his entire sword into his own body, falling dead alongside members of his family. Are the names that appear on the 11 sherds the nicknames of those 10 men, under the command of Ben-Yair, who were the last to remain alive? Did they use these sherds to draw lots and find the last of their members who would finish off the matter of the massacre? This is a possibility but apparently we will never know. So far, researchers have not made many attempts to confirm or deny the dramatic assumption; they have mainly focused on determing the credibility of Josephus (Josephus Flavius) - Yosef Ben Matitayahu, whom Jewish tradition ignored for 2,000 years, just as it ignored the Masada story. The new museum, located at the foot of Masada and named after Yigael Yadin, was established with money from the Shuki Levy fund. (Levy is an Israeli who lives in Los Angeles who was one half of the Shuki and Aviva singing duo. He made a fortune from his partnership with Haim Saban in producing the TV series "Power Rangers," among others). The first room in the museum is devoted to Josephus Flavius. This is an obvious choice since without his reports we would not have known a great deal about Masada and we would have known a great deal less about the Great Revolt and the destruction of Jerusalem. The problem is that even our information about Josephus Flavius himself is taken from what he wrote about himself, and not from other sources. The story of Masada, like most of his other writing, was written in Rome, and while most of his descriptions of the fortress are fairly exact, it is reasonable to assume that he never actually visited the site. Other than his personal experience as one of the commanders of the rebellion in its early stages, his major sources were apparently the reports of the Roman commanders. Nevertheless, these reports appear to be fairly accurate, as was his report of the mass suicide, and the story of the two women and five children who hid, becoming the only survivors who lived to tell the story of the terrible end. Museum curator Gila Horowitz and the team from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem's Archaeology Institute, together with designer Eliav Nahlieli, understood that a museum of this type, located next to the most famous archaeological site in Israel, cannot compete with the site itself. For that reason, they decided to build it in a special format, which tries to give added value to the experience of visiting the plateau of the cliff. The museum consists of nine rooms, each devoted to a separate subject, and in these one can see the most important archaeological finds that were dug up at Masada in addition to figures and theatrical settings. All of these give the visitor the feeling that he is situated in the place where the events took place some 2,000 years ago. Three of the rooms are devoted to Herod. The first depicts a royal banquet in Herod's palace with the original table utensils used and a description of the choice dishes and drinks that were presented to the guests. The second tells the story of the port of Caesarea, which Herod built and through which the luxurious products were carried. The third shows the columns and the colorful wall decorations that remained in Herod's palace from which it is possible to learn about the luxurious and expensive building. When the rebellion broke out in 66 CE, the mountain was conquered by the zealots, the Sicarii (called after the short dagger they carried on them, known as "sica" in Latin ) and the rooms in the museum that are devoted to them depict their home utensils, the remnants of the scrolls that they used and a selection of the 4,000 woven bits that were found in the excavations and that remained intact at the site thanks to the dry desert climate. The zealots also brought with them to Masada a small trove of silver shekels that had been issued on the occasion of the revolt. An inscription on the shekels in ancient Hebrew writing reads: "Shekel Yisrael" and "Jerusalem the Holy." Their date of issue, which relates to the year of the revolt, also appears - from aleph for the first year throught hey for the fifth. Since the last year of the Great Revolt was short (from Passover until the 17th of Tammuz, when the work in the Temple ceased and the revolt coins were no longer issued), only a few coins have been found anywhere in the world from that year - less than 20 - compared to several thousand coins from the second and third years. Three coins from the fifth year were found at Masada, apparently brought by the rebels who escaped from Jerusalem when it was destroyed. This is an extremely rare find, for which collectors and museums are prepared to pay a fortune. Another rare find in the museum is displayed in the room devoted to the Roman army - the pay slip of a soldier in the Roman army. He was Gaius Messius, the son of Gaius, from the Fabia clan in Beirut, who had a series of expenses that were deducted from his salary. The salary slip was written on papyrus, and so far only one other such payslip has been found anywhere in the world, in Egypt. This soldier was obviously among the Roman soldiers whom Josephus Flavius says climbed up the mountain. "There they found a mass of dead people, and they were not joyous in this victory in the way one usually is with enemies but rather gazed in wonder at the nobility of their deed and its execution without flinching, as a group and with total disdain for death. Bookmark to del.icio.us   Love story Israel permits gay Palestinian to join his lover in Tel Aviv. Interfaith get-together Saudi King plans first interfaith conference to include Jews.   1.   No anti-Semites read this? 01:11  |  Amnon 10/07/07   2.   # 1 amnon 03:10  |  eric 10/07/07   3.   to #2 05:11  |  Henry 10/07/07   4.   2,000 YEARS FROM NOW 05:13  |  Yossi Adler 10/07/07   5.   masada museum 13:01  |  daniel gavron 10/07/07   6.   Masada reality check 13:31  |  Joe Zias 10/07/07   7.   Racist abure 15:51  |  arthur Oppenheimer 10/07/07   8.   Eric, Amnon, and Joe Zias 17:25  |  bbl 10/07/07   9.   # 7 is right 17:29  |  Yossef 10/07/07   10.   stinking arabs, stinking jews..... 18:48  |  nadir 10/07/07   11.   "stinking".. 20:02  |  Jacob 10/07/07   12.   ARAB MASADA 22:05  |  CAMENON BAZED 10/07/07   13.   Glad to see that you all can only complain about the "stinking" 22:27  |  Amnon 10/07/07   14.   Zias has an agenda 23:04  |  archaeologist 10/07/07   15.   To # 12 23:42  |  Abelgati 10/07/07   16.   To # 10 23:46  |  Gad 10/07/07   17.   "Biblical Archaeology" charlatanry 06:52  |  Jessica 11/07/07   18.   Actually, bbl, genetics conclusively proves that the Palestinians 20:02  |  Jack 12/07/07   19.   Clarification 20:12  |  Jack 12/07/07   20.   archaeological finds 16:43  |  sw 13/07/07

Today Online Blair: Middle East peace process a 'race against time' Responses: 78 Mubarak: Gaza tension brings Iran threat closer Responses: 30 PA fails in fight against terror, U.S. officials determine Responses: 27 Zvi Bar'el: Keeping Iran from 'members-only' Arab club Responses: 10 Top Fatah official: Housing Min. inviting Palestinians to start a fresh Intifada Responses: 14 Rosner's Domain Obama advisor blasts 'NY, Miami' for failed peace process Slight preference for Clinton among Jewish Democrats Kurtzer: The pro-Israel lobby, not obstacle for peace Is bar mitzvah more important than Christmas tree? Govt. to appeal ruling on classified material in AIPAC trial More Headlines 11:52 Israeli hurt by Palestinian fire on Negev kibbutz 07:11 Mubarak: Gaza tension brings Iran threat closer 11:41 Safed chief rabbi calls on state to exact 'revenge' against Arabs 11:50 Officials: Israel to supply PA forces with security equipment 11:47 PA fails in fight against terror, U.S. officials determine 07:18 Barak approves five mobile homes for Hebron Hills settlement 10:31 Haaretz.com's Rosner, Kashti get B'nai B'rith journalism prizes 03:30 ANALYSIS: Keeping Iran away from 'members-only' Arab club 07:20 Blair: Middle East peace process is a race against time 02:06 Israeli study provides first proof that raising dogs helps kids' health 02:29 Eight social organizations to get Israel Prize on country's 60th 09:26 Traditional Hebrew calligraphy swirls into cutting-edge font 08:31 Rubinstein Piano Competition / The heat that shuffled the deck Previous Editions Select Day 25 mar 24 mar 23 mar 21 mar 20 mar 19 mar 18 mar 17 mar 16 mar 14 mar 13 mar 12 mar

Special Offers Advertisement FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer Free the Palestinians from: Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy Long-term Israel programs MASA is your gateway. More programs. More grants. NEW! Dan Boutique Jerusalem Hotel Hip Dan Hotel in Jerusalem. Attractive Introductory Rates 7589 rockets fired so far HELP US TO HELP THEM Marina Royale Herzelia Pituach Your Luxurious Suite While Staying in Israel Fattal Hotel Chain Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel. ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th Eldan Rent a Car Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations Junkyard Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt

Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.

© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved