Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., July 10, 2007 Tamuz 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 01:33 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Gaza is not Algeria
By Ahmed Yousef

The Abbas leadership has poorly calculated its political strategy, choosing to align itself with the Israeli regime and its Washington patrons in a bid to retain its hold on power. Yet it has compromised its legitimacy in the eyes of a large swath of the Palestinian public, and it has fallen into Israel's Machiavellian trap of sowing discord among Palestinians to avoid dealing with the real issue: ending the occupation, fairly and justly.

Voters in the occupied territories are under no illusions about who planted the seeds of the current strife, particularly as Hamas made offers - but was repeatedly rebuffed - to form a unity government as soon as it won the elections in 2006. Despite increasing intransigence by hard-line Fatah activists, Hamas even adhered to a unilateral cease-fire for 18 months in a bid to neutralize tensions.

For over a year, the Islamic movement's leadership has tried to avoid conflict with Fatah, yet confrontation was inevitable because American neoconservatives, the Israelis and even some Arab officials are determined to undermine a Palestinian government with an Islamic hue.

Advertisement

The economic blockade was the first blow. Then American neoconservative officials, led by Deputy National Security Advisor Elliott Abrams, machinated against the Hamas government. Finally, Fatah tried, illegally, to call for premature elections in January; when this failed, it initiated plans to strengthen its hold on security forces in preparation for a coup, receiving arms and training from both Israel and foreign governments.

The combined economic blockade and militarization of Fatah forced Hamas to undertake preemptive measures aimed at preserving the integrity of Palestine's fledgling democracy.

Abbas' current moves to unilaterally declare an emergency government in the West Bank is a political gamble doomed to fail. First, Parliament will not approve deposing Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh. Therefore the only options Abbas has are to amend the constitution without a parliamentary vote, or to stage a military coup bolstered by Israeli arms and secret-service support in a move reminiscent of Algeria's FLN negating moderate Islamist victories at the ballot box in 1991.

The rational choice would be to engage with Hamas - as it has been trying to do since coming to power - within the framework of the law, and jointly to work toward ending economic terrorism and irredentist occupation. Western powers would do more for the cause of stability by releasing their chokehold on the Palestinian economy and finding more plausible representation than Tony Blair to act as an envoy in the interests of peace.

Hamas itself has proven its ability to enforce and preserve peace when left unhindered to do so, by securing the release of BBC correspondent Alan Johnston. The entire apparatus of the legitimate Palestinian government focused its energies on Mr. Johnston's release for humanitarian and practical reasons. Journalists like Alan are brave, honorable people who have risked much to alleviate our suffering or report the truth.

Hamas was limited in its ability to exercise security controls until recently; however, now that the security apparatus is genuinely geared toward the safety and well-being of the general population, Hamas will pursue all avenues to ensure that thugs and hoodlums, regardless of purported ideology, are neutralized.

Our efforts must remain focused on rectifying the misguided actions of our colleagues in the unity government and refocusing our political energies exclusively on ending the occupation. We have learned from the experiences of Turkey, and will conduct ourselves in a manner that reflects the national interest without compromising our principles.

The alternative is open, internecine conflict - something abhorrent to Hamas, yet a necessary evil if the peaceful alternative is not pursued. Civil war is tragic, permanently affecting a nation's psyche if not its geography. Yet when there are forces that reflect the majority's will, their victory can lead to national reconciliation and prosperity, as demonstrated in the decades following the French Revolution and U.S. Civil War. Hamas would, by any measure, be justified in defending itself given the assassinations of Hamas officials and supporters, attempts on the life of the elected prime minister, and kidnappings and bombings by some members of Chairman Mahmoud Abbas' paramilitary groups. And defend itself it shall.

Ahmed Yousef is the political adviser to deposed Palestinian premier Ismail Haniyeh.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Good Israeli cinema
Dieter Kosslick, director of the Berlin Film Festival, is excited about the local movie industry.
Democratization of evil
Internet talkbacks are setting a new level of malice and evil in human expression.
  1.   Like, Duh! 10:25  |  Mark Lincoln 09/07/07
  2.   Good Quality Post 10:52  |  Natallie Durson 09/07/07
  3.   YOUR THREATS OF CIVIL WAR SURPRISE NOT 10:59  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/07/07
  4.   "economic terriorism" says it all-give Hamas money!!! 11:02  |  Dona 09/07/07
  5.   glimmer of hope... snuffed out? 11:07  |  ravi 09/07/07
  6.   Gaza is so much like Algeria and most African countries 11:08  |  Jo 09/07/07
  7.   Dear Ahmed Yousef, What Hamas is now experiencing has much to do 11:10  |  Virginia 09/07/07
  8.   Haretz dredging the bottom of the sewer 11:41  |  Adrian de Klerk 09/07/07
  9.   `Ahmed Yousef` - an honest article with no ulterior motives 11:45  |  WWACD 09/07/07
  10.   OMG! I didn`t even see the explanation of who this guy is! 11:53  |  WWACD 09/07/07
  11.   # 9 Israel`s refusal to make peace 11:56  |  Andrew Watson 09/07/07
  12.   !. AND HOWS THAT MARK? HAMAS IS GOOD 12:00  |  paul harris 09/07/07
  13.   gaza is not algeria 12:04  |  yasen soliman 09/07/07
  14.   OH REALLY? 12:05  |  ADAM 09/07/07
  15.   Andrew Watson # 11 12:05  |  ChanahS 09/07/07
  16.   TALK ABOUT FREEDOM OF PALESTINE 12:25  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 09/07/07
  17.   #13, No One Cares About Their Internal fights 12:27  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/07/07
  18.   # 15 ChanahS 12:35  |  Andrew Watson 09/07/07
  19.   Mark Lincoln #1 - Is it really bad news? 12:41  |  dana 09/07/07
  20.   Question to Haaretz: Is Killing Jews a Good Thing? 12:48  |  Scientist 09/07/07
  21.   The Puppeteers:Not one word about Iran and the Saudis 13:16  |  Ronnie 09/07/07
  22.   Will corruption and lawlesness ever return? 13:23  |  Phillies Wright 09/07/07
  23.   WHAT LIES! Its Own Interests/Power, Iran, Media Threats, Etc. - 1 13:42  |  Proud Pal Defender 09/07/07
  24.   One fundamental matter is not mentioned by Ahmed Yousef: The 13:54  |  Avihu 09/07/07
  25.   Why does Haaretz give tribune to these mafiosi? 13:55  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 09/07/07
  26.   WHAT LIES! Its Own Interests/Power, Iran, Media Threats, Etc. - 2 13:57  |  Proud Pal Defender 09/07/07
  27.   A brilliant and hopeful article and Ahmed should have added the 13:58  |  lakshmi 09/07/07
  28.   Good analysis 14:00  |  Ben Alofs 09/07/07
  29.   Watson # 18 14:04  |  ChanahS 09/07/07
  30.   #18 - Unilateral Andrew 14:16  |  WWACD 09/07/07
  31.   WHAT LIES! Its Own Interests/Power, Iran, Media Threats, Etc. - 3 14:32  |  Proud Pal Defender 09/07/07
  32.   Why conflict with Iran is inevitable 14:45  |  Jonathan S 09/07/07
  33.   #28 drben and democratic values from islam 15:13  |  victor hardman 09/07/07
  34.   A Repost--FATAH/MODERATES: Unite/Train/Prepare & GET STRONG! - 1 15:16  |  Proud Pal Defender 09/07/07
  35.   A Repost--FATAH/MODERATES: Unite/Train/Prepare & GET STRONG! - 2 15:19  |  Proud Pal Defender 09/07/07
  36.   Ahmed Yousef 15:20  |  Sami 09/07/07
  37.   EVEN MACHIAVELLI WOULD CRY 15:54  |  indrajaya 09/07/07
  38.   Dana - why it is bad news 15:59  |  Mark Lincoln 09/07/07
  39.   Hamas Needs Walter Ulbricht! 16:07  |  HH Truth 09/07/07
  40.   Typical Arab Response--you made me do it 16:17  |  Joseph 09/07/07
  41.   Hamas & co 16:30  |  Bensaid M 09/07/07
  42.   # 24 One fundamental mistake ! 16:42  |  Moshe Ben Aharon 09/07/07
  43.   Avihu, 24: I wish the critiques of Israel were willing to 16:51  |  Amit 09/07/07
  44.   # 36 Ahmed Yousef 16:54  |  Maria 09/07/07
  45.   32Jonathan S,you are advocating a foolish & dangerous policy 17:10  |  lakshmi 09/07/07
  46.   Indrajay 17:11  |  Albert Seligman 09/07/07
  47.   You`re wrong, Ben Alofs #28 17:40  |  Polybios 09/07/07
  48.   A lot to think about 17:44  |  Rick 09/07/07
  49.   # 37 Indrajay & Machiavelli 17:48  |  Maurice 09/07/07
  50.   # 28 a distorted analysis 17:59  |  Alan 09/07/07
  51.   #8 I sort-of almost agree, but think airing views is good 18:14  |  Rick 09/07/07
  52.   Ben Alofs 18:40  |  Gina 09/07/07
  53.   #28: Ben Alofs, thanks for putting it so well. 18:45  |  Thomas Jackson 09/07/07
  54.   Rick 18:45  |  Gina 09/07/07
  55.   #47 Polybios 18:47  |  Ben Alofs 09/07/07
  56.   Rick 18:49  |  Gina 09/07/07
  57.   #28 Alan 18:56  |  Ben Alofs 09/07/07
  58.   Lakshmi wrong on all points 19:00  |  Jonathan S 09/07/07
  59.   Rick - something you should know 19:03  |  Polybios 09/07/07
  60.   A very good and moderate program (Dana #19, Mark Lincoln #38) 19:04  |  Tosefta 09/07/07
  61.   #27: lakshmi, thanks for mentioning again Yousef`s other article 19:06  |  Thomas Jackson 09/07/07
  62.   Ben Alofs 19:08  |  Gina 09/07/07
  63.   Thomas Jackson 19:12  |  Gina 09/07/07
  64.   Tosefta 19:16  |  Gina 09/07/07
  65.   jo UK # 6 true Both Algeria and Gaza have been destroyed by Jews 19:18  |  Disgusted by IDF 09/07/07
  66.   The way for Israel to handle Hamas 19:19  |  Tosefta 09/07/07
  67.   Virginian Number 7 I have an advice 19:24  |  Disgusted by IDF 09/07/07
  68.   Thomas Jackson 19:31  |  Albert Seligman 09/07/07
  69.   The way things work in reality (Gina #64) 19:35  |  Tosefta 09/07/07
  70.   #17: Cipora Julianna Kohn, did you know you told a joke here? 19:36  |  Thomas Jackson 09/07/07
  71.   Quite a slick article. 19:49  |  Tarek 09/07/07
  72.   Ahmed Yousef 20:00  |  S 09/07/07
  73.   #60: Tosefta - on Hamas, Turkey, and borders 20:04  |  Thomas Jackson 09/07/07
  74.   Wolf in sheep`s clothing fools no one 20:09  |  Leo King 09/07/07
  75.   #59 Polybios - Good points 20:17  |  Rick 09/07/07
  76.   #68: Albert Seligman 20:22  |  Thomas Jackson 09/07/07
  77.   # 57 Ben Alofs 20:28  |  Alan 09/07/07
  78.   #27 lakshmi - thanks for your viewpoint 20:36  |  Rick 09/07/07
  79.   Thomas Jackson& Ben Alof,there is a relevant piece in Palestine 20:39  |  lakshmi 09/07/07
  80.   # 57 Ben Alofs 20:40  |  Alan 09/07/07
  81.   What Yousef means (Thomas Jackson #73) 20:47  |  Tosefta 09/07/07
  82.   Likewise Natalie Durson.... 21:13  |  bbl 09/07/07
  83.   "ending economic terrorism" 21:19  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/07/07
  84.   Andrew Watson -- don`t believe everything you think 21:22  |  bbl 09/07/07
  85.   Hamas and the secular state 21:23  |  Polybios 09/07/07
  86.   Hey Tosefta -- stop dodging my question 21:24  |  bbl 09/07/07
  87.   Lakshmi -- If they did.... 21:30  |  bbl 09/07/07
  88.   Ad hominem sapiens 21:34  |  Albert Seligman 09/07/07
  89.   "preserving the integrity of Palestine`s fledgling democracy" 21:35  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/07/07
  90.   More Islamic Brotherhood `democracy` 21:36  |  Polybios 09/07/07
  91.   Yes Rick -- that makes it much easier 21:38  |  bbl 09/07/07
  92.   "open, internecine conflict" 21:44  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/07/07
  93.   Tosefta 21:45  |  Gina 09/07/07
  94.   Why Israel-Hamas conflict inevitable? 21:50  |  Polybios 09/07/07
  95.   # 20 Scientist 21:53  |  Chico B 09/07/07
  96.   bbl -- copy/paste from a word document 21:55  |  Gina 09/07/07
  97.   #38: dana and Mark Lincoln - What`s good for Israel? 22:09  |  Thomas Jackson 09/07/07
  98.   Ahmed Yousef 22:16  |  Rin 09/07/07
  99.   Gaza 22:18  |  P. J. Casey 09/07/07
  100.   Question to Haaretz ? 3rd try 22:27  |  Alberto Cohen 09/07/07
  101.   Haaretz doesn`t pay me.. (BBL #86) 22:29  |  Tosefta 09/07/07
  102.   #19, dana 22:43  |  Thomas Jackson 09/07/07
  103.   Thomas Jackson #73 re Tosefta #60 and the Turkey analogy 23:14  |  dana 09/07/07
  104.   Lakshmi #79 - references 23:30  |  dana 09/07/07
  105.   benevolent hamas 23:42  |  MLK 09/07/07
  106.   Hamas 23:43  |  Abu Yusuf 09/07/07
  107.   87bbl,Tosefta,Polybios,bbl I have plenty of experience in 00:23  |  lakshmi 10/07/07
  108.   To Haaretz editors .... 00:35  |  William 10/07/07
  109.   Tosefta - Hamas still wants unity government 00:37  |  Mark Lincoln 10/07/07
  110.   Thomas Jackson #93 - on passing ships and shape shifters 00:39  |  dana 10/07/07
  111.   Tarek - it is a slick article 00:40  |  Mark Lincoln 10/07/07
  112.   I imagine Haaretz would have printed an article by Goebbels too 00:40  |  Marvin 10/07/07
  113.   So modest about so much Lakshmi 00:42  |  Mark Lincoln 10/07/07
  114.   wrong. self serving. so long as hamas engages in terrorist activo 00:47  |  ralph 10/07/07
  115.   To racist#65 Not true at all. 00:49  |  Jo 10/07/07
  116.   Talk about freedom of Palestine 00:55  |  Cowboy 10/07/07
  117.   Thanks for the article (Lakshmi #94) 01:02  |  Tosefta 10/07/07
  118.   Mark Lincoln # 1 01:03  |  Philippe 10/07/07
  119.   #16 Attila-FREEDOM for THE KURDS 01:04  |  Gabriel 10/07/07
  120.   Mark Lincoln # 1 P2 01:05  |  Philippe 10/07/07
  121.   Algerian history - Ottoman occupation from 1517, then ....... 01:05  |  dona 10/07/07
  122.   Haaretz doesn`t pay me.. (BBL #86) 01:11  |  Tosefta 10/07/07
  123.   Would A. Schocken`s father have published an interview with an SS 01:22  |  Absolute Sweden 10/07/07
  124.   IT WAS INEVITABLE BECAUSE MUSLIMS DON`T IDENTIFY WITH DEMOCRACY 01:22  |  steve 10/07/07
  125.   Ahmed Yousef 01:33  |  Linda 10/07/07
  126.   Gaza is not Algeria ? 01:35  |  Hami 10/07/07
  127.   1001 ARABIAN NIGHTS:GAZA- HATE MIGHT YET TRIUMPH? 01:39  |  Gabriel 10/07/07
  128.   95Mark Lincoln,thanks,Tosefta,am going to take a second look at 01:44  |  lakshmi 10/07/07
  129.   Excellent article, also enjoyed Washington Post article 02:01  |  moll 10/07/07
  130.   lakshmi #79 - references - 2nd TRY 02:06  |  dana 10/07/07
  131.   Thomas Jackson #73 Re Tosefta #60 Turkey analogy 2nd TRY 02:10  |  dana 10/07/07
  132.   Ahmed Yousef, how dare you speak about 02:17  |  Nicolas from Paris 10/07/07
  133.   Tosefta #101 Re bbl - Is that True? 02:20  |  dana 10/07/07
  134.   Truthful Journalism 02:20  |  Not in my name 10/07/07
  135.   129Moll greetings! & Dana the references,Moll, the rest of the 04:09  |  lakshmi 10/07/07
  136.   Hamas position (Mark Lincoln #109) 04:42  |  Tosefta 10/07/07
  137.   The check (Dana #133) 04:51  |  Tosefta 10/07/07
  138.   Gina -- That has never worked for me 04:51  |  bbl 10/07/07
  139.   Tosefta #101 -- Now were talking! 04:54  |  bbl 10/07/07
  140.   Philippe - not necessary 05:00  |  Mark Lincoln 10/07/07
  141.   Philippe you clearly are smoking 05:02  |  Mark Lincoln 10/07/07
  142.   Lakshmi, how did Ghandi defeat the British? 05:04  |  Mark Lincoln 10/07/07
  143.   No laughing matter (Thomas Jackson #70; re Cipora JK) 05:04  |  Tosefta 10/07/07
  144.   "Israeli regime"? Go to school, Ahmed Yousef! 05:09  |  civilized Reader 10/07/07
  145.   "Israeli regime"? Go to school, Ahmed Yousef! 05:09  |  civilized Reader 10/07/07
  146.   Evolution (Gina #93) 05:26  |  Tosefta 10/07/07
  147.   #79, 130: lakshmi and dana, on references 05:34  |  Thomas Jackson 10/07/07
  148.   YOU YOUSEF YOURSELF! 05:35  |  GO(O)D 10/07/07
  149.   Thomas Jackson, et al. 05:45  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/07/07
  150.   Tosefta - Cipora 05:55  |  Mark Lincoln 10/07/07
  151.   Gina - reality check 05:59  |  Mark Lincoln 10/07/07
  152.   Tosefta, not in America 06:01  |  Mark Lincoln 10/07/07
  153.   AHMED YOUSEF, VERY WELL SAID, BRAVO 06:03  |  Clickright 10/07/07
  154.   What a crock of S__T!!! 06:09  |  Larry 10/07/07
  155.   #149 Cipora JK - getting better 06:13  |  dana 10/07/07
  156.   142Mark Lincoln,Gandhi is a phenomenon that happens once in a 06:16  |  lakshmi 10/07/07
  157.   #150, Mark Lincoln 06:19  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/07/07
  158.   150 Mark Lincoln,that`s just T`s style,can`t imagine him without 06:30  |  lakshmi 10/07/07
  159.   yet, the bottomline remains.... Hamas, as a political player 06:34  |  Smadar 10/07/07
  160.   # 49, MAURICE 06:37  |  indrajaya 10/07/07
  161.   # 49, MAURICE 06:37  |  indrajaya 10/07/07
  162.   Mark Lincoln # 141 06:37  |  Philippe 10/07/07
  163.   Mark Lincoln # 140 06:45  |  Philippe 10/07/07
  164.   Mark Lincoln # 142 06:47  |  Philippe 10/07/07
  165.   Hamas`s true objective 07:05  |  Paolo 10/07/07
  166.   Mark Lincoln and his love of Hamas 07:38  |  Gina 10/07/07
  167.   #149, Cipora Julianna Kohn 07:44  |  Thomas Jackson 10/07/07
  168.   Tosefta 07:49  |  Gina 10/07/07
  169.   bbl 07:57  |  Gina 10/07/07
  170.   Tosefta pays Haaretz to publish his rantings!? 07:57  |  Jewboy 10/07/07
  171.   Paolo 08:12  |  Gina 10/07/07
  172.   bbl -- as you can see in my previous post 08:14  |  Gina 10/07/07
  173.   #168, Gina 08:15  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/07/07
  174.   #110, dana 08:31  |  Thomas Jackson 10/07/07
  175.   Cipora 08:43  |  S 10/07/07
  176.   Cipora # 173 08:45  |  Philippe 10/07/07
  177.   Gina, post script 08:51  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/07/07
  178.   Cipora Julianna Kohn 09:01  |  Gina 10/07/07
  179.   #176, Philippe 09:05  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/07/07
  180.   #175, S 09:10  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/07/07
  181.   #167, Thomas Jackson 09:58  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/07/07
  182.   # 29 , # 30 Words do not mean anything 10:28  |  Andrew Watson 10/07/07
  183.   # 84 Oslo accord was never implemented by Israel 10:37  |  Andrew Watson 10/07/07
  184.   A rational commentary 11:19  |  Raymond Deane 10/07/07
  185.   170Jewboy,about Tosefta paying Haretz,don`t you recognise a joke 13:44  |  lakshmi 10/07/07
  186.   Dana,Thomas Jackson,Mark Lincoln and the brigade,let`s get back 13:49  |  lakshmi 10/07/07
  187.   Thomas Jackson #174 - Appearances 19:36  |  dana 10/07/07
  188.   Cipora # 179 20:39  |  Philippe 10/07/07
  189.   #186, lakshmi 22:59  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/07/07
  190.   Polybios,re: your copious quotations from obscurantist islamic 00:04  |  lakshmi 11/07/07
  191.   189 a rhetorical weak defence of S ! 00:06  |  lakshmi 11/07/07
 Today Online
Jewish leaders concerned by trend to delegitimize Israel
Responses: 578
Corrie's parents press Caterpillar suit over 2003 Gaza death
Responses: 306
Rosner: Gazans don't deserve water from Israel, or do they?
Responses: 256
PM to Assad: Open talks, without U.S. mediation
Responses: 50
Yoel Marcus: This summer make peace not war with Syria
Responses: 59


More Headlines
23:19 Netanyahu: Barak brought Hezbollah to our border
23:09 Blair holds 'positive, practical' discussion with Quartet envoys
01:11 Most Gaza evacuees won't get permanent housing for 3 years
21:48 Olmert at Jewish conference: Not all Jews want to make aliyah
22:54 Gaza parliamentary official says was detained by Hamas gunmen
22:56 New envoy to U.K.: Jews must do more to put Iran on the agenda
00:28 Jury deadlocked in fraud trial of former Jerusalem Post owner
19:17 Palestinian militants fire at least 11 mortar shells at Israeli targets
22:25 First man on moon meets with children during visit to Israel
22:21 Attorney banned from Knesset for striking ultra-Orthodox MK
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved