Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., July 09, 2007 Tamuz 23, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:50 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Prime Minister Olmert speaking during a cabinet meeting last week. (Ariel Jerozolimski)
Last update - 19:03 08/07/2007
PM: Freeing prisoners may help bring abducted soldiers home
By Aluf Benn and Avi Issacharoff, Haaretz Correspondents, Haaretz Service and News Agencies

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said Sunday that the release of 250 Palestinian prisoners, approved by the cabinet as a gesture to Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, could speed up the return of three Israel Defense Forces soldiers kidnapped in cross-border raids from the Gaza Strip and Lebanon.

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said the measure would not hurt efforts to free Corporal Gilad Shalit, held by Hamas since June 2006, or reservists Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev, snatched by Hezbollah in a move that triggered the Second Lebanon War in July 2006.

"Without a doubt, this move won't hurt the chances to bring about the release of Gilad Shalit, Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldwasser, and it might even create conditions that will ease the process," Olmert said.

Advertisement

Six ministers voted against the move: Itzhak Aharonovich of Israel Beiteinu, Kadima's Shaul Mofaz and all four ministers from ultra-Orthodox party Shas.

According to Olmert, the approval comes after thorough deliberations and consultations with ministers and security officials.

"I think that this gesture is a fitting one, and not a product of some illusion," said Olmert.

Also Sunday, Saeb Erekat, a top aide to Abbas, said he was in discussions with Israel to schedule a summit between Olmert and Abbas in the near future, but no firm date has been set. At the prodding of the U.S., the two men promised months ago to meet regularly, but the talks have repeatedly sputtered.

The issue of the prisoner release and other confidence-building steps came up in a meeting last week between Abbas' prime minister, Salam Fayad, and Defense Minister Ehud Barak, Palestinian officials said.

The officials said Fayad pushed for the release of prisoners serving long sentences, asked Israel to withdraw forces from West Bank cities and halt its pursuit of wanted Palestinian militants. The officials, who spoke on condition of anonymity because they weren't authorized to talk to the press, said no decisions were made at the meeting.

Defense Ministry officials did not immediately comment.

Explaining the motives behind the prisoner release, Olmert said, "We want to make use of all means to strengthen moderate forces within the Palestinian Authority, and to encourage them to follow the path that we believe can create conditions for real talks."

The list of prisoners slated for release is not yet final. It will follow criteria set by Ariel Sharon's government four years ago, starting with the ban on releasing any prisoners "with blood on their hands," meaning any who have murdered Israelis.

The prisoner release would be the first since February 2005, when Israel freed 500 in a similar move aimed at bolstering Abbas, who had just been elected PA chairman.

Shas Chairman Eli Yishai responded to the vote by saying, "If terrorists are being released, there is no reason not to also free Jews who have killed Arabs."

Shas has lent its support recently to a Jewish group actively pursuing this call.

Mofaz maintained that the release would not strengthen Abbas, while MK Gideon Sa'ar (Likud) said the government decision was irresponsible and would harm the security of Israeli citizens.

Israel will consider releasing on humanitarian medical grounds several longtime prisoners from Fatah who were convicted of serious crimes and served in jail for many years. Similar gestures were made under Sharon.

Olmert on Saturday sent back the list of the Palestinian prisoners slated for release to the Shin Bet and Justice Ministry, demanding the removal of several dozen names. He ordered that a new list be drawn up of prisoners with more time to serve of their jail sentences.

Erekat urged Israel to coordinate the release with the Palestinians. "We have not been consulted on this release, he said," adding that Israel has rejected calls to convene a joint committee on prisoners.

The Palestinians have urged Israel to release some of the most prominent prisoners, including Marwan Barghouti, a top official in Abbas' Fatah movement who is serving life sentences for involvement in five murders. Israel has rejected calls for Barghouti's release.

Riad Maliki, the information minister in Abbas' new government, said he expected the 250 prisoners to be former military men from pro-Fatah security forces. "If it was in our hands to choose...we would have chosen a group that more fairly represented the body of Palestinian prisoners, from all political groups," Maliki said.

In Gaza, where Hamas seized control last month, after which Abbas dismissed the militant group from the PA government, Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri said a release of Fatah prisoners signaled that Abbas is collaborating with Israel. "He should have refused any release unless it includes all Palestinian prisoners," he said.

A political source in Jerusalem said that the criteria for release will favor prisoners who have served two-thirds of their sentence, but that if not enough prisoners were found who met the rules, Israel would be flexible and release prisoners who had completed less than two-thirds of their sentence.

Spokeswoman for Olmert, Miri Eisin, said Israel would allow 48 hours for the releases to be challenged in petitions to the high court.

A team headed by Justice Ministry Director General Moshe Shilo will put together the list of prisoners with input from the Shin Bet, the police, Prisons Service and the army.

In a related development, The Palestinian daily Al-Ayyam reported Saturday that Ofer Dekel, Olmert's point man in the matter of Israel's kidnapped and missing soldiers, met with Samir Kuntar 10 days ago at Hadarim Prison.

Kuntar was jailed by Israel in 1979, following his conviction for murdering the Haran family in a terrorist attack in Nahariya. Hezbollah is demanding Kuntar's release in return for the release of the kidnapped Israeli reservists Udi Goldwasser and Eldad Regev.

Dekel reportedly told Kuntar that there had been progress in the German-brokered negotiations with Hezbollah, which Dekel said had been held up by Hezbollah's demand that Israel release Palestinian prisoners.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The state in is control
The state is not actually the weaker side in the battleground of the judicial system.
Private sector allure
How government officials become millionaires after years in public service.
  1.   Waiting for just ONE "humanitarian" to condemn THIS child killer 05:46  |  PETER SM 08/07/07
  2.   Do not release a single Lebanese (terrorist and loser) prisoner 06:09  |  Tamir Gaza 08/07/07
  3.   SO WHAT HAPPENS TO THE ISRAELI WITH BLOOD ON THEIR HANDS 06:30  |  CONCERNED 08/07/07
  4.   RON ARAD OR NO DEAL 06:39  |  NEIL GOLAN 08/07/07
  5.   3 FREE OR NO DEAL 06:41  |  NAJI BENAJI 08/07/07
  6.   DEAL FOR RON ARAD????????? 06:43  |  EQUALIZER 08/07/07
  7.   FREE RON ARAD 06:46  |  NJG 08/07/07
  8.   Where is Ron Arad 06:52  |  Nachum Weizmann 08/07/07
  9.   ASK NASERALLA 06:56  |  Gaza Boy 08/07/07
  10.   OMERT RESIGN 07:04  |  M.DAYAN 08/07/07
  11.   OLMERT?? 07:12  |  BUSH 08/07/07
  12.   DO IT NOW 07:14  |  TAMI 08/07/07
  13.   No Kuntar Without Ron Arad 07:15  |  Tal 08/07/07
  14.   FOREVER LOST 07:16  |  Yuval 08/07/07
  15.   Kuntar the barbarian 07:52  |  Connie 08/07/07
  16.   WAS IT NECESSARY TO SHOW THIS ..... 08:00  |  Miriam Davidowitz 08/07/07
  17.   kintar case 08:08  |  angelo 08/07/07
  18.   HE HAS THE EYES AND THE LOOK OF A MURDERING SAVAGE 08:24  |  Eli 08/07/07
  19.   Israeli Justice 08:37  |  Steve 08/07/07
  20.   Olmert your not capable to handle any negotiation 08:41  |  Shepherd 08/07/07
  21.   CONCERNED, why are you concerned? 08:50  |  Dan 08/07/07
  22.   Response for Peter SM 09:20  |  Esther 08/07/07
  23.   # 21 09:31  |  Hunter 08/07/07
  24.   #22, Esther 09:58  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/07/07
  25.   #20, Shepherd 10:03  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/07/07
  26.   MORE OF OLMERT AND NITWITTERY 10:13  |  paul harris 08/07/07
  27.   PM of Israel 11:03  |  Steve 08/07/07
  28.   PM to seek permission 11:31  |  Stuart M. Sheiman 08/07/07
  29.   4500 more for gilad shalit.... 11:42  |  density 08/07/07
  30.   #18 response 11:46  |  Steve 08/07/07
  31.   freing kuntar! have they lost their mind? 11:51  |  richard 08/07/07
  32.   A perversion of justice!!!! 12:21  |  ben uziel 08/07/07
  33.   It`s a Communist Tactic Called " Pressure From Below " 12:31  |  Klaudia 08/07/07
  34.   To # 32 -ben uziel ...New Elections ??? 12:39  |  Klaudia 08/07/07
  35.   Gaza Withdrawl was Painful "Gesture" 12:44  |  Stan 08/07/07
  36.   Israel should demand Shalit, Goldwasser and Regev before release 12:49  |  x 08/07/07
  37.   X marks the Not 14:01  |  Mark Lincoln 08/07/07
  38.   An utterly pointless gesture 14:02  |  Clickfool 08/07/07
  39.   When was the last time anyone saw Ron Arad? 14:02  |  Mark Lincoln 08/07/07
  40.   # 35 JHB 14:04  |  Axel 08/07/07
  41.   Olmert to free 250 Fatah terrorists 14:06  |  Mark Lincoln 08/07/07
  42.   You are quite wrong Stan 14:08  |  Mark Lincoln 08/07/07
  43.   NOBODY HAS EVER RECOGNIZED ISRAEL`S GOODWILL GESTURES BEFORE! 14:09  |  Ben 08/07/07
  44.   Goodwill gesture? 14:22  |  Child advocate 08/07/07
  45.   Same old bad ideas 14:36  |  Jon 08/07/07
  46.   #38 the man with x ray vision from the downs 14:42  |  victor hardman 08/07/07
  47.   what are the pms real motives ? 14:45  |  yahn goodey 08/07/07
  48.   What, I wish to ask, does Israel receive in return for the releas 14:55  |  Yadi 08/07/07
  49.   Congratulations To The 6 14:58  |  Yoram 08/07/07
  50.   Free all Jews convicted of terror! 15:29  |  Jonathan S 08/07/07
  51.   #1 Peter, I will when... 15:43  |  Tim 08/07/07
  52.   how many jews will be killed by these 250 15:47  |  chaim schonbrun 08/07/07
  53.   And pigs fly- why it could hurt chances 16:01  |  Jon 08/07/07
  54.   Dealing with the wrong problem 16:07  |  Jonathan S 08/07/07
  55.   Why not just paint targets on every Jews back. 16:41  |  Dr David I. Gross 08/07/07
  56.   Bold moves 16:44  |  Baz Mann 08/07/07
  57.   Press, press, press 16:53  |  Nora 08/07/07
  58.   I feel sorry for Israel and her future.. 16:57  |  John Allen 08/07/07
  59.   Esther.my point is"moralists" who hurl insults at Israel suddenly 17:00  |  PETERSM 08/07/07
  60.   #32 Do it and do it now!!!!! 17:00  |  John Allen 08/07/07
  61.   #36 Yes 17:01  |  John Allen 08/07/07
  62.   MAY THEIR BOXS RUNETH OVER 17:04  |  YUVAL 08/07/07
  63.   RON ARAD??????? 17:11  |  NACHUM WEIZMANN 08/07/07
  64.   17 Angelo 17:14  |  Lebanese Christia 08/07/07
  65.   RON ARAD 17:17  |  Yuval 08/07/07
  66.   TIM Please quote"hundreds"where Pal children were captured & 17:27  |  PETERSM 08/07/07
  67.   goodwill 17:29  |  citizen zero 08/07/07
  68.   WHAT PARRALEL WORLD DOES OLMERT 17:31  |  LOST 08/07/07
  69.   Mark Lincoln # 42 Slight Corrections 17:36  |  Jeff Northridge 08/07/07
  70.   Freeing Prisoners 17:46  |  Steve 08/07/07
  71.   how 17:49  |  Avi Dresner 08/07/07
  72.   A fool feeding a rabid dog 17:50  |  BobUSA 08/07/07
  73.   Freeing prisoners 17:58  |  Ros Kaplan 08/07/07
  74.   #40 Axel 18:09  |  * BEN JABO 08/07/07
  75.   "Ocuppied" Gaza and now Westbank 18:09  |  Bernd 08/07/07
  76.   They may or may not. Government fantazises 18:10  |  Sal 08/07/07
  77.   Time for reciprocal Arab Gestures 18:13  |  * BEN JABO 08/07/07
  78.   Redicilous comments 18:19  |  Bernd 08/07/07
  79.   Baz Mann # 56 Checkpoints Help Abbas 18:26  |  Jeff Northridge 08/07/07
  80.   Israeli soldiers should be released first 18:27  |  Brod 08/07/07
  81.   An Advice, Free the Freedom Fighters 18:27  |  Freedom Fan 08/07/07
  82.   Kuntar should be hanged, not freed or traded 18:32  |  Richard S 08/07/07