Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., July 12, 2007 Tamuz 26, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:08 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
An aerial photograph of a settlement in the West Bank. (Archives)
Last update - 07:00 07/07/2007
Report: Settlers use just 9% of state-allocated West Bank land
By Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondent

West Bank settlements have been allocated huge amounts of land, but use very little of it, according to a Peace Now report.

Only nine percent of the area under settlement jurisdiction has been built on, and only 12 percent is being used at all, the report said, citing Civil Administration figures.

But despite their huge unused land reserves, 90 percent of the settlements exceed their boundaries, and about one-third of the territory they do use lies outside their jurisdiction, the report added.

Advertisement

The findings attest to the government's ongoing cooperation with the settlements' expansion, Peace Now charged: On one hand, the state earmarks huge tracts for the settlements, out of all all proportion to their size, in order to prevent Palestinian construction in those areas. Yet once an area is closed to Palestinians, the settlers begin seizing adjacent Palestinian lands, often privately owned, that lie outside their jurisdiction.

For years, the settlements' borders were concealed: The Civil Administration and other agencies refused to provide this information to nongovernmental organizations and the media, although within the Green Line, such data is readily available. The figures in this report were obtained only after Peace Now and the Movement for Freedom of Information petitioned the courts under the Freedom of Information Act last year.

The report, compiled by Dror Etkes and Hagit Ofran of Peace Now's Settlement Watch, found that Israel's policy violates the state's commitments under the Oslo Accord. This agreement stipulated that no party would take unilateral steps to change the situation in the territories until final-status negotiations status were completed. Yet even before peace talks stalled, Israel acted methodically to expand the settlements' jurisdiction, the report said.

Israel's acts also contradict official government statements, including Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's statement, following a meeting with King Abdullah of Jordan in May, that "construction in the settlements takes place only within the authorized boundaries."

The report lists 164 settlements, outposts and industrial zones in the West Bank. Of these, 92 saw their areas of jurisdiction expanded or redefined after the Oslo Accord was signed in 1993, as part of a construction drive that doubled the number of West Bank settlers in the subsequent decade.

Several settlements' areas of jurisdiction have still not been demarcated, probably because sizable portions of their built-up areas are located on private Palestinian land, as is true of the two veteran settlements of Ofra and Psagot near Ramallah.

Etkes charged that Israel uses the term "jurisdiction" in a misleading and manipulative way to enable the settlements to expand almost without limits and block Palestinian construction in these areas.

The lands assigned to Ma'aleh Adumim, for example, were an attempt to form a barrier between Palestinian communities in the northern and southern West Bank, he said. The Judea and Samaria police station is now being built in the E-1 area between East Jerusalem and Ma'aleh Adumim, which was annexed to the settlement's territory, even though this area is far from Ma'aleh Adumim's built-up areas, which are located on the other side of the Jerusalem-Jericho road. This reflects Israel's efforts to create Jewish territorial contiguity in the region. There are also plans to build a commercial and tourism center in E-1. Yet 76 percent of Ma'aleh Adumim's land is currently not being used for any purpose.

The huge area allocated to the settlements is most conspicuous in the small communities of the Jordan Valley and Judean Desert. Kibbutz Mitzpeh Shalem, population 180, for instance, has jurisdiction over 35,408 dunams - about the size of Petah Tikva. Kibbutz Kalia, population 271, on the Dead Sea shore, has jurisdiction over 25,304 dunams.

Illegal construction outside a settlement's area of jurisdiction is often encouraged by the state, as demonstrated by the illegal outposts, Etkes said. The Civil Administration prevents Palestinians from building in areas under settler jurisdiction. Yet virtually no legal action is taken against illegal settler construction, and such structures are rarely demolished, he charged.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Science is the way
Previous IDB Holdings owner breaks media silence to say kids must learn science.
Grilled haloumi dream
A searing grill prompts mediterranean treats to be their very best.
  1.   These "Peace Never" reports are always from fantasy land 03:24  |  Genuine Tosefta 06/07/07
  2.   Etkes is the same liar form their November "report" 03:42  |  Genuine Tosefta 06/07/07
  3.   And if Fatah think Israel intends to stop at the West Bank... 03:46  |  Maureen Ann 06/07/07
  4.   still illegal 03:46  |  Omar 06/07/07
  5.   So What? 04:24  |  Johnny Weintraub 06/07/07
  6.   blah blah blah 04:37  |  Jon 06/07/07
  7.   So called settlers 04:41  |  Atoo 06/07/07
  8.   Omar- bigger obstacle to peace 04:41  |  Jon 06/07/07
  9.   peace now needs a brain transplant lots of empty space to fill 05:39  |  ralph 06/07/07
  10.   It really doesn`t matter 05:58  |  Natallie Durson 06/07/07
  11.   Why cant 06:22  |  Ali 06/07/07
  12.   this settlement movement = blight 06:35  |  david 06/07/07
  13.   9 percent? How does this relate? 06:39  |  rachel 06/07/07
  14.   #11 Ali -good quetion 06:49  |  Jon 06/07/07
  15.   what % do palestinians settlers use in Jordan (Palestine)? 06:54  |  Chick 06/07/07
  16.   #12 David from Wisconsin 07:00  |  Jon 06/07/07
  17.   Unused land, PN looks for new facts:They also 07:04  |  dov 06/07/07
  18.   peace now 07:05  |  david 06/07/07
  19.   #8 Jon masters the orwellian newspeak 07:23  |  Johnboy 06/07/07
  20.   Report: W. Bank settlers use 9 percent of their land 07:23  |  alex 06/07/07
  21.   "Peace Now" also lives in settlements 07:26  |  Yehuda 06/07/07
  22.   another unwanted article about Peace Now ! 07:41  |  redmike 06/07/07
  23.   normal Israelis are sick of EU-funded "Peace" now lies 07:43  |  Moshe 06/07/07
  24.   Settlers and Land 07:45  |  Garry 06/07/07
  25.   State organized robbery?! 08:00  |  Esther 06/07/07
  26.   Yes, we all know how credible "Peace" Now is 08:36  |  Leo 06/07/07
  27.   and therefore.....? 09:08  |  lars 06/07/07
  28.   Peace Now 09:16  |  Avraham 06/07/07
  29.   #7 Atoo - Your house is sitting on land stolen from the Indians 09:17  |  Daniel 06/07/07
  30.   Israel bild on stolen land 09:17  |  Dav 06/07/07
  31.   More and more Israelis are turning to the Right 09:19  |  Daniel 06/07/07
  32.   Illegal Arab invading settlers on Biblical Lands 09:35  |  sam 06/07/07
  33.   Good ole Sam reads the Funnies section of the Bible # 32 09:51  |  Clickfool 06/07/07
  34.   #29, Daniel 10:04  |  Hannah 06/07/07
  35.   Peace now is always dealing with DIRT 11:16  |  SPTZ 06/07/07
  36.   what about us canaanites ? 11:26  |  melchizedek 06/07/07
  37.   INSTEAD OF MORE HAARETZ CRAP TELL ME WHERE 12:03  |  paul harris 06/07/07
  38.   For Paul Harris, who suffers from poor comprehension # 37 12:16  |  Clickfool 06/07/07
  39.   Agreed 12:18  |  Yonatan 06/07/07
  40.   While Mr Magoo Israel permits this.... 12:22  |  Clickfool 06/07/07
  41.   Pressure and helplessness 12:28  |  Yonatan 06/07/07
  42.   #39, Yonathan - this gets us to the conclusion.... 12:31  |  Burkhardt 06/07/07
  43.   #40 click goes another prediction by the silly fool 12:36  |  victor hardman 06/07/07
  44.   #34 Hannah 12:38  |  Sarah 06/07/07
  45.   zionism does not belong to have a future 12:46  |  John 06/07/07
  46.   APPEASE NOW IS FUNDED BY EURABIA!!!!! 12:46  |  Ben Uziel 06/07/07
  47.   The APPEASE NOW crowd of no intellectual honesty!!!! 13:10  |  Jerome 06/07/07
  48.   #44 john and the road to hell from tulip time 13:33  |  victor hardman 06/07/07
  49.   Jerome # 47 13:36  |  melchizedek 06/07/07
  50.   "most conspicuous in the small communities of the Jordan..." 13:37  |  Michael A. Shoemaker 06/07/07
  51.   #45 John, I`ve got news for you 13:44  |  Yonatan 06/07/07
  52.   land grab continua 13:49  |  Josh Goldman 06/07/07
  53.   Oslo accords?? 13:50  |  Zev 06/07/07
  54.   Would the PNO like the settlers to build on the other 81% 13:52  |  Berni 06/07/07
  55.   Excuse me 91% 13:53  |  Berni 06/07/07
  56.   Michael Shoemaker - you`re kidding right? 14:10  |  Josh Goldman 06/07/07
  57.   No Jon, your making it up and you know it 14:29  |  Omar 06/07/07
  58.   It is Israel`s Land 14:41  |  Brod 06/07/07
  59.   #36 Canaanite 14:53  |  Dav 06/07/07
  60.   #52 josh and cyclops contend for impaired vision 14:59  |  victor hardman 06/07/07
  61.   Truth Now! 15:00  |  Ronen 06/07/07
  62.   And There Shall Be One Law for Jews and Another for Arabs 15:09  |  Yaakov Sullivan 06/07/07
  63.   Civil Administration refused to provide this information... 15:19  |  Galit 06/07/07
  64.   Esther, Re : State Theft 15:20  |  Dutch 06/07/07
  65.   #19 Johnboy 15:30  |  Jon 06/07/07
  66.   Peace not Apartheid 15:31  |  Yariv 06/07/07
  67.   Violates the Oslo accords?? are they joking?? 15:33  |  bernard ross 06/07/07
  68.   Mr. Shoemaker and His Misperceptions#50 15:33  |  Yaakov Sullivan 06/07/07
  69.   Victor? 15:35  |  Josh Goldman 06/07/07
  70.   Josh Godlman getting out.... 15:36  |  Maimon 06/07/07
  71.   Clicky 15:37  |  blackhighlander 06/07/07
  72.   #64 DORIS WHY DIDNT YOU QUOTE JULIUS STONE 15:38  |  paul harris 06/07/07
  73.   Pal. Land 15:46  |  Dav 06/07/07
  74.   Don`t shoot the messenger 15:56  |  Benny 06/07/07
  75.   Maimon - reality check 16:01  |  Josh Goldman 06/07/07
  76.   Yaakov sullivan...you preach that exact philosophy 16:09  |  SHIMON 06/07/07
  77.   Esther in TA 16:15  |  GABE 1 06/07/07
  78.   Time to encourage evacuation now 16:16  |  Tosefta 06/07/07
  79.   Malchi read a book and turn off the Al jazeera!!!!! 16:17  |  Jerome 06/07/07
  80.   THE DESPICABLE APPEASE NOW CROWD!!!! 16:20  |  Jeff 06/07/07
  81.   #1 you have evidence for this? Which reports 16:24  |  Don Camillo 06/07/07
  82.   #69 josh you are not serious are you ? 16:32  |  victor hardman 06/07/07
  83.   #19 Johnboy 16:46  |  Legally Speaking 06/07/07
  84.   Relation between Terror and Occupation