Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., July 15, 2007 Tamuz 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:15 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
It has ended its mission
By Yossi Sarid

Until this week, we thought the Sharm el-Sheikh summit was nothing but a vaudeville show from the light summer repertoire. But once again, we were mistaken. In recent days, it has become clear that serious matters were in fact decided there, and first and foremost, gates were closed. The prime minister of Israel and the president of Egypt met privately and hardheartedly decided on the fate of the Darfur refugees. To date, the genocide in Darfur has claimed about half a million victims, with more to come, and has scattered 2 million refugees in all directions. But who is counting? To date, about 2,000 have arrived in Israel - and they are being counted.

This week, Ehud Olmert ordered escape routes blocked. Whoever manages to infiltrate will be returned immediately to Egypt. Order must be maintained, and let us stop the anarchy on the border. Israel's citizens are convinced, because that is how it was explained to them, that without this dike, the country will be flooded with hundreds of thousands of refugees, perhaps millions: All of Africa will gather here. How fortunate that Olmert stuck his finger in and saved us from being flooded.

Jews were also about to flood entire countries when they fled the sword hanging over them. And responsible statesmen met then, too, and decided that these people knocking on the door would not be allowed to cross en masse. The reasons given then are the same as those being given today. First, our country is small, like neutral Switzerland, and will not be able to take in so many people, as the flight will go on endlessly. Second, they are coming to us from an enemy country, or from occupied areas, and are liable to endanger our security: Who knows how many planted agents are hiding among them? Third, we have our own problems, and your own poor come first. And fourth, we will not extradite them to Germany, but to Austria and Italy and Vichy France - not to Sudan, God forbid, but only to Egypt.

Advertisement

It is all true, and it is all despicable. First, despite the disgraceful inaction by the international community, headed by America, the genocide in Darfur will not continue forever, and most of the victims who are still alive have run out of physical and emotional strength, so they will not have enough strength to endure the long journey from there to here. Second, they are not coming from an enemy country, they are fleeing from it, and it is possible that hostile agents were also planted among Jewish refugees at that time. Third, one would think that Israel's poor were being cared for devotedly until the Darfurians befell them and us, and that this dedicated treatment of poverty will be resumed even more energetically the moment the uninvited guests are expelled. Fourth, returning the refugees to Egypt is like returning them to Sudan, as that is our neighbor's policy. It also expels; human rights are not its strong suit.

American Jews have recently placed themselves on the front line of assistance for Darfur. They have promised to neither rest nor remain silent until it is redeemed. That is a hollow commitment. Bush's America will not take in new survivors, just as it did not take in old ones, our grandmothers and grandfathers. It is slamming the door even in the face of the Iraqi refugees, who are refugees of its own war, people who cooperated with the United States and are now being thrown to the dogs of terror.

So let the good Jews from America donate several hundred million dollars for temporary absorption of the refugees in Israel, and maybe even in Egypt, until the fury has passed. They know how to get their act together, as they proved in their struggle for the lost tribes from India to Ethiopia, who, after a campaign of persuasion, came to Israel and built up the settlements. And they were not even sure that they were Jews, these lost ones.

When Israel locks its gates and expels refugees, it ends its mission as a Jewish state. The light unto the nations has been extinguished, and where is the light unto the Jews? From now on, Israel is just another country, with the same unacceptable and selfish considerations. And what will Olmert do next Yom Kippur, which is not far away, when the entire congregation calls out in a loud voice: "Open the gate for us, for the day is nearly past."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
What follows
Public repertory theater exists for the production of challenging plays like 'Hebron.'
Paradise lost
Dr. Khassan Baiev treated the wounded of both sides int he Chechen war until a rocket left him comatose.
  1.   60 years past his bris, little Israel is still irresponsible 11:18  |  Hannah 06/07/07
  2.   So,Mr.Sarid,in your opinion........... 11:28  |  Hastaroth 06/07/07
  3.   Hanna 11:52  |  Sarah 06/07/07
  4.   Yossi Sarid is nuts 12:08  |  John 06/07/07
  5.   zionism is another word for judeofascism, sarah 12:13  |  John 06/07/07
  6.   The world loves a cheerful giver 12:16  |  Natallie Durson 06/07/07
  7.   #5 John,I suppose you are not a member of the Jewish people... 12:41  |  Hastaroth 06/07/07
  8.   SUDAN SHOULD PAY FOR REFUGEES. 12:44  |  Terry 06/07/07
  9.   To Yossi Sarid, with love 12:45  |  Realistic 06/07/07
  10.   John#5 13:08  |  Sarah 06/07/07
  11.   nice one yossi....how the ivory tower!!! 13:13  |  Ben Uziel 06/07/07
  12.   Ethiopians and Indian tribes 13:16  |  michael3k 06/07/07
  13.   Not surprising 13:43  |  Chris Linthwaite 06/07/07
  14.   #5 reamarkable the gentile john speaks out for the jewish people 13:45  |  victor hardman 06/07/07
  15.   Yossi Sarid has left out one element 13:49  |  Yonatan 06/07/07
  16.   Why,Why,Why??????? 13:52  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/07/07
  17.   Ronnie`s 3 whys 14:50  |  sh 06/07/07
  18.   Let`s pay a flight ticket to Sarid (1 way) 14:54  |  Alberto Cohen 06/07/07
  19.   Yossi Sarid 15:11  |  Sarah 06/07/07
  20.   Hannah&Sarid,an NK and Left Israel-haters join hands 15:40  |  Absolute Sweden 06/07/07
  21.   Old news - Jews have to pay for everything 15:53  |  Boris 06/07/07
  22.   They aren`t even from Darfur! 16:04  |  CC 06/07/07
  23.   How About Putting the Squeeze on Some of Your Own Billionaires? 16:05  |  mike 06/07/07
  24.   #20, Absolutely non Sweden 16:14  |  Hannah 06/07/07
  25.   What? Who`s to blame?...Us...but...but... 16:36  |  Tony Anthony 06/07/07
  26.   #21 WHEN IS HANNAH GOING TO TELL US WHATIS A ZIONIST POINT OFVIEW 16:39  |  paul harris 06/07/07
  27.   Poor Hannah,do you "know Sweden" from Swedish dogooders pals chas 16:40  |  Absolute Sweden 06/07/07
  28.   #23 Hannah - the pot calling the kettle black 16:53  |  Yonatan 06/07/07
  29.   #6 Natallie D. 17:10  |  Itsik 06/07/07
  30.   Hannah is dana 17:14  |  Danite 06/07/07
  31.   Hey Hannah! or should I say dana 17:16  |  Danite 06/07/07
  32.   #26, Absolutely not Swedish 17:19  |  Hannah 06/07/07
  33.   Can`t understand - critizing the US on refugees? 17:33  |  Sensible 06/07/07
  34.   Hanna from Malmo alias 17:38  |  Muhammad 06/07/07
  35.   Sudanese Christians to Yanatan 17:39  |  JewishHeart 06/07/07
  36.   Yonatan # 15 17:43  |  Veritas 06/07/07
  37.   NK Hannah,I must disappoint you 17:49  |  Absolute Sweden 06/07/07
  38.   Beta Israel Ethiopians WERE and ARE Jews 18:01  |  Polybios 06/07/07
  39.   John - two issues 18:08  |  Polybios 06/07/07
  40.   #33 Sensible - read up on history 18:09  |  Yonatan 06/07/07
  41.   #36 Veritas - I would`t object at all 18:13  |  Yonatan 06/07/07
  42.   #15 JewishHeart - this changes the picture, if true 18:16  |  Yonatan 06/07/07
  43.   #25 JewishHeart - how do you explain this? 18:24  |  Yonatan 06/07/07
  44.   Jewish heart 18:30  |  Sarah 06/07/07
  45.   Dear Mr Yosi Sarid 18:50  |  Gil 06/07/07
  46.   Israel & America did not cause the problem 18:53  |  Ron 06/07/07
  47.   its not the job of the US jews to solve Sudans refugee prblem 19:03  |  zionist forever 06/07/07
  48.   Who do I make out the check to? 19:07  |  Lev 06/07/07
  49.   un should also and take it from theiving pals 19:07  |  ralph 06/07/07
  50.   # 6 Sure, you are one lucky pal.... 19:08  |  misha 06/07/07
  51.   plenty of aid money for sudanse arabs in Paris 19:14  |  zionist forever 06/07/07
  52.   As usual, with the small people on Talk-back 19:24  |  Brian Freund 06/07/07
  53.   sarah - 39 19:27  |  zionist forever 06/07/07
  54.   This is just weird. 19:32  |  Athena 06/07/07
  55.   Has anyone asked them? 19:36  |  Mark Lincoln 06/07/07
  56.   How will Olmert repay Mubarak? 19:48  |  Tosefta 06/07/07
  57.   Darfur 20:02  |  Bruce 06/07/07
  58.   A depressing article and what it says about Israeli Jews 20:08  |  Czarkazem13 06/07/07
  59.   Hi Mark Lincoln - Big Campaign Within Jewish Community 21:11  |  Jane 06/07/07
  60.   one important item missing from article: common sense 21:11  |  ralph 06/07/07
  61.   www.genocideindarfur.net 21:12  |  Jane 06/07/07
  62.   Much ado about...what? 21:17  |  Polybios 06/07/07
  63.   Jane of Palm Beach 21:33  |  Polybios of Miami 06/07/07
  64.   Hannah 21:40  |  Connie 06/07/07
  65.   In support of Sarid, part 1 21:48  |  HS 06/07/07
  66.   In support of Sarid, part 2 21:49  |  HS 06/07/07
  67.   In support of Sarid, part 3 21:50  |  HS 06/07/07
  68.   JewishHearth - question? 22:07  |  Gil 06/07/07
  69.   Switzerland 22:11  |  Beatrice 06/07/07
  70.   JOHN 22:14  |  Connie 06/07/07
  71.   Polybios - You Are Kidding 22:36  |  Jane 06/07/07
  72.   hannah 22:41  |  evaI was for 35 yea 06/07/07
  73.   Jane of Palm Beach 23:03  |  Polybios 06/07/07
  74.   Hannah #1 Get over yourself! 23:14  |  bbl 06/07/07
  75.   Jane and Mark Lincoln -- American Jews and Darfur 23:22  |  bbl 06/07/07
  76.   Deja Vu... all over again 23:25  |  ariel 06/07/07
  77.   Interesting 23:26  |  Omar 06/07/07
  78.   There are a few weaknesses in Yossi`s argument 23:31  |  bbl 06/07/07
  79.   Dufar 23:36  |  Dovid Yanna 06/07/07
  80.   A correction on my earlier post 23:37  |  bbl 06/07/07
  81.   Gil From Haifa #1 23:38  |  JewishHeart 06/07/07
  82.   Gil #2 23:42  |  JewishHeart 06/07/07
  83.   Natalie D #6 -- you need a class in economics 23:46  |  bbl 06/07/07
  84.   HOW ABOUT CHURCH SENDING MONEY 01:01  |  TOBIA 07/07/07
  85.   # 69 Omar 01:10  |  Lynn 07/07/07
  86.   Hastaroth: I am just asking a question 01:10  |  John 07/07/07
  87.   # 1 Hannah 01:13  |  Lynn 07/07/07
  88.   Sarah: thet is the core business of a talkback forum 01:14  |  John 07/07/07
  89.   Connie: read your comment again 01:19  |  John 07/07/07
  90.   The Stereotype is Right 02:25  |  J Olson 07/07/07
  91.   A Modest Proposal 03:02  |  The Golem 07/07/07
  92.   B...S,, 04:15  |  Doc 07/07/07
  93.   Exactly my point Jane 04:26  |  Mark Lincoln 07/07/07
  94.   #24 Hannah 04:45  |  Blackhighlander 07/07/07
  95.   not a bad way to spend money, but let sarid dig into his pockets 05:01  |  dante 07/07/07
  96.   #1, Hannah 07:22  |  Silvienne 07/07/07
  97.   #96 silvienn and another libel posted 08:05  |  victor hardman 07/07/07
  98.   #1 Since when Darfur is Israel`s responsibility? 08:31  |  Terry 07/07/07
  99.   Victor Hardman 09:27  |  Silvienne 07/07/07
  100.   Terry 09:30  |  Silvienne 07/07/07
  101.   Hannah & Silvienne & all their sociopath friends 10:42  |  Gil 07/07/07
  102.   To Silvienne - Tax money 11:11  |  Gil 07/07/07
  103.   #99silvienne and figures from mars 11:23  |  victor hardman 07/07/07
  104.   why should american jews subsidize you? 12:15  |  eric 07/07/07
  105.   RUSSIA should foot the bill 13:40  |  Israeli taxpayer 07/07/07
  106.   There are plenty of petro billions for Islamsing the world 15:49  |  PETER SM 07/07/07
  107.   It`s Reported Most are NOT from Sudan. France`s Experience (1) 16:30  |  Linda Rivera 07/07/07
  108.   It`s Reported Most are NOT from Sudan. France`s Experience (2) 16:31  |  Linda Rivera 07/07/07
  109.   It`s Reported Most are NOT from Sudan. France`s Experience (3) 16:33  |  Linda Rivera 07/07/07
  110.   Hannah # 1 16:37  |  ChanahS 07/07/07
  111.   Huamanitarian Reasons Only 17:30  |  Jane 07/07/07
  112.   #107, Sylvienne 18:44  |  Terry 07/07/07
  113.   Linda 19:14  |  Terry 07/07/07
  114.   Honestly 19:20  |  Don 07/07/07
  115.   Sarid`s Chutzpah 19:44  |  Joseph 07/07/07
  116.   Israel Can Not Take In Every Moslem Ever Abused By Another Moslem 19:56  |  Efox 07/07/07
  117.   100. Silvienne 20:46  |  Eylo 07/07/07
  118.   foolish yosi belin should pay from his account 20:57  |  reuven 07/07/07
  119.   Ronnie Wolman: Darfur 21:04  |  CHGODMK 07/07/07
  120.   99. Silvienne 22:41  |  MAP2 07/07/07
  121.   #104 ERIC SEES APACHES IN NM 23:37  |  paul harris 07/07/07
  122.   Sarid - It`s not Amer. Jews & it`s not 1935 again 01:38  |  sheri 08/07/07
  123.   darfur refugees 02:46  |  tom 08/07/07
  124.   Let Yossi Sarid`s European backers pay for them! 02:52  |  Nannette 08/07/07
  125.   # 121 paul, i see ospreys, cobras, and hueys, too 02:59  |  eric 08/07/07
  126.   It has ended its mission 04:18  |  Steve 08/07/07
  127.   Yossi Sarid 04:22  |  Steve 08/07/07
  128.   @18, alberto, call me: 22677771, 91446648 05:27  |  vladimir 08/07/07
  129.   Darfur refugees 05:32  |  Shmuelshachor 08/07/07
  130.   WHY is there not a special UNWRA for others than Pals? Apartheid? 06:20  |  PETERSM 08/07/07
  131.   lets send them all to where? denmark, finland, england think they 06:27  |  ralph 08/07/07
  132.   they really want to go to denmark, finnland, england lets help th 06:28  |  ralph 08/07/07
  133.   why don`t they want to go to cairo, saudi arabia, libbya, syri 06:30  |  ralph 08/07/07
  134.   @36, veritas, your country has no moral obligations for jewish 06:38  |  vladimir 08/07/07
  135.   polibios, sarid is the nazi in his heart, always was 06:42  |  vladimir 08/07/07
  136.   Let them come..... 06:52  |  Michael Katz 08/07/07
  137.   shmuel, @129 see 128. call me. 06:59  |  vladimir 08/07/07
  138.   #101, Gil from Haifa 07:48  |  Silvienne 08/07/07
  139.   #102, Gil from Haifa 07:56  |  Silvienne 08/07/07
  140.   #103, Victor Hardman, never mind Mars.... 07:58  |  Silvienne 08/07/07
  141.   Say Whaaat? 08:01  |  Denise 08/07/07
  142.   darfur refugees 08:06  |  Mark 08/07/07
  143.   #112, Terry 08:07  |  Silvienne 08/07/07
  144.   #113, Terry 08:09  |  Silvienne 08/07/07
  145.   #117, Eylo 08:12  |  Silvienne 08/07/07
  146.   #102, MAP2.... 08:15  |  Silvienne 08/07/07
  147.   #121, Paul Harris`s rose-coloured glasses... 08:19  |  Silvienne 08/07/07
  148.   #125 ERIC AND THE PETRIFIED THINKING IN NM 08:36  |  paul harris 08/07/07
  149.   Yossi Sarid 08:54  |  Steve 08/07/07
  150.   #146 SILVIENNE IS RIGHT ITS AN OIL GRAB 09:06  |  paul harris 08/07/07
  151.   #148, Paul Harris and the colossal scam... 09:14  |  Silvienne 08/07/07
  152.   #151SILVIENNE TAKE A LONG JUMP INTO AHISTORY BOOK 09:21  |  paul harris 08/07/07
  153.   Let them come to Canada 10:04  |  VoiceOfReason 08/07/07
  154.   Terry-Where your money goes- 10:16  |  VoiceOfReason 08/07/07
  155.   Bless you Yossi Sarid 12:40  |  Daniel 08/07/07
  156.   What of our own refugees 15:28  |  Evelyn 08/07/07
  157.   Silvienne 17:31  |  Gil 08/07/07
  158.   # 148 but paul, the petrified forest is in arizona 19:51  |  eric 08/07/07
  159.   Don`t Wish UNWRA on Those Poor People 22:44  |  Jane 08/07/07
  160.   #130 The answer is pretty obvious, PETER SM 04:21  |  Johnboy 09/07/07
  161.   #150, Oh, excellent response, Paul Harris.... 04:26  |  Silvienne 09/07/07
  162.   #152, Paul Harris 04:28  |  Silvienne 09/07/07
  163.   #156, Evelyn.... 04:30  |  Silvienne 09/07/07
  164.   Gil from Haifa... 04:37  |  Silvienne 09/07/07
  165.   Gil from Haifa... 06:09  |  Silvienne 09/07/07
  166.   This is chutzpah first-class Mr. Sarid! 11:05  |  Marlene 12/07/07
  167.   Sarah and all other anti-Sarid comments 16:02  |  Gia 12/07/07
  168.   More people like Yossi 16:07  |  Gia 12/07/07
  169.   no illegal settlements 07:40  |  barney 15/07/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Back the boycott, kill the symphony
Responses: 131
Marcus: 2006 war is only one remembered as a failure
Responses: 105
Ghada Karmi: Boycotts are the weapons of the weak
Responses: 373
Jerome M. Segal: How to reach Palestinian statehood in a year
Responses: 269
Zvi Bar'el: French talks on Lebanon kowtow to Hezbollah
Responses: 138
PM: Syria's Assad wants talks, but only with Bush
Responses: 132


More Headlines
07:46 Amnesty for Fatah men; Hawatmeh bid stirs ire
07:55 France to raise issue of fate of abducted troops with Hezbollah
07:59 Sudan refugees to be kept in jail while 'hospitality facility' built
05:55 Peres to take oath of office as 9th president of Israel Sunday
03:14 IDF: We did not okay lawyers' offer to represent our interests
04:45 Cabinet set to okay expansion of Nativ agency's operations to Germany
06:02 Lawmakers commission production of promotional movie for Knesset
03:52 Newly appointed Interior Min. Sheetrit sets out to push reforms
08:13 Iranian Jews blast offer of cash for immigrating to Israel
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved