Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., July 01, 2007 Tamuz 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 16:33 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Stolen olive trees replanted at a West Bank outpost. (Nir Kafri)
Last update - 09:27 27/06/2007
Settlers return olive trees stolen from Palestinian-owned grove
By Yuval Azoulay, Haaretz Correspondent

Residents of the West Bank settlement outpost of Adei Ad began replanting hundreds of olive trees on Tuesday that they had uprooted from Palestinian lands last week.

The trees were returned to their Palestinian owner, a resident of Kafr Karyut, at the insistence of the Civil Administration. After the farmer complained that some 300 of his trees had been stolen by settlers, the Civil Administration investigated and found that not only had the trees been stolen, but some of them had been replanted in Adei Ad or along the access road to the outpost. It then ordered the settlers to return the trees by on Tuesday.

The settlers prepared the ground at Kafr Karyut for the replanting, laid the infrastructure for an irrigation system, and replanted the first few trees.

Advertisement

"We are dealing with this incident in a focused manner ensuring that the land's Palestinian owner can access them freely, and we are in constant contact with him," a source in the Civil Administration said Tuesday. "We are continuing to monitor the issue and the implementation of our instructions."

Pinhas Wallerstein, chairman of the Benjamin Regional Council where Adei Ad is located, said that the settlers agreed to replant the trees in order to avoid a confrontation with the security forces, but continue to insist that the trees are actually Jewish-owned.

"This is an olive grove near the settlement of Ahiya that has been worked for years by employees and relatives of Yossi Shukar, who died a few months ago," Wallerstein said.

Since the trees bore no fruit this year, he continued, the family decided it was a good time to move them, and at the request of Adei Ad residents, they agreed to let some of the trees be replanted there. Nevertheless, in order to avoid a clash with the Civil Administration, the family later agreed to restore them to their original location, Wallerstein said.

A senior Civil Administration source responded that the agency investigated the claim that the grove was owned by Jews, but concluded that the land was in fact Palestinian-owned.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Trio of trysts
On Michael Handelzalts' three cultural and, for the most part, unrequited loves.
Artistic immortalization
Margolies' works may revolve around the morgue, but their value is above sensationalist.
  1.   Crazy settlers- i`ll send you the money for the tees 22:06  |  Avrum 26/06/07
  2.   what a shamful act 22:09  |  James Mosely 26/06/07
  3.   In the civilised world, theft is punished 22:11  |  Isaac Hassen 26/06/07
  4.   settlers sure take Israeli and US support for granted 22:12  |  newageblues 26/06/07
  5.   HOORAY ! 22:19  |  megnoon 26/06/07
  6.   deniers 22:40  |  Pablo B 26/06/07
  7.   With any luck 22:42  |  Fred Michaelsberg 26/06/07
  8.   See, Democracies do work!! 22:48  |  Lynn 26/06/07
  9.   Typical Israeli Settlers 22:54  |  Charlotte Sorge 26/06/07
  10.   The tree theives 22:57  |  Mordechai 26/06/07
  11.   This is not a major story 23:03  |  Tina Rosenberg 26/06/07
  12.   Fair enough 23:05  |  Mark Lincoln 26/06/07
  13.   The Laugh of the day 23:06  |  Natallie Durson 26/06/07
  14.   tit for tat 23:17  |  Boris 26/06/07
  15.   Why is the government not removing these lunatics 23:34  |  elj 26/06/07
  16.   #14 Boris 23:46  |  elj 26/06/07
  17.   A civil dispute resolved civilly 23:51  |  Jacob Blues 26/06/07
  18.   # 12 Mark Lincoln 23:53  |  Axel 26/06/07
  19.   No title 23:56  |  Jesse James 26/06/07
  20.   Boris 00:00  |  Jesse James 27/06/07
  21.   I generally support the "right`s of settlers" but this appears... 00:19  |  bat yam 27/06/07
  22.   #3 Well Isaac, if I had to take a wild guess 00:24  |  ballistic 27/06/07
  23.   Typical 00:31  |  Rachel C. 27/06/07
  24.   Stealing olive trees instead of 00:37  |  sh 27/06/07
  25.   Natallie`s laugh #13 00:41  |  William 27/06/07
  26.   Shame on YOU, 00:44  |  Arik 27/06/07
  27.   #23 rachel 00:45  |  Axel 27/06/07
  28.   #23 You dont have to make excuses 00:47  |  Tobia 27/06/07
  29.   why don`t they take cuttings 00:47  |  Bibi 27/06/07
  30.   Elj #16 - a pot calling the kettle black 00:47  |  William 27/06/07
  31.   These stolen Olive trees will never grow again 00:47  |  moshe 27/06/07
  32.   #21 No diligent work needed - the act speaks for itself. 00:51  |  Don Camillo 27/06/07
  33.   Thieves 00:52  |  Jim 27/06/07
  34.   Jesse James #20 - hilarity EU style 00:53  |  William 27/06/07
  35.   WHAT A HYPOCRISY! 01:08  |  nobodysacred 27/06/07
  36.   Baruch Hashem 01:11  |  Joel 27/06/07
  37.   Degenerates 01:22  |  Danite 27/06/07
  38.   # 30 William 01:39  |  Axel 27/06/07
  39.   olive trees 01:43  |  Thomas Sweet 27/06/07
  40.   LEAVE TREES ALONE: REPLANT ARABS!!! 02:39  |  May Gordon 27/06/07
  41.   Disputed Trees 02:51  |  Efox 27/06/07
  42.   re: Danite 02:52  |  Efox 27/06/07
  43.   Mark Lincoln and "fair enough" 02:55  |  Aaron Levitt 27/06/07
  44.   Take note Olmert 02:56  |  maoriboy 27/06/07
  45.   re: Jim 02:56  |  Efox 27/06/07
  46.   Would the Arab conquerors ever behave like the Jewish settlers? 04:00  |  Genuine Tosefta 27/06/07
  47.   Re 43 Levitt 05:13  |  Alan the real one 27/06/07
  48.   NICE 05:27  |  FRED 27/06/07
  49.   Now let them return the Palestinian land they`ve stolen... 05:45  |  peacelover 27/06/07
  50.   How Ironic. First land now trees. 05:47  |  Randy Cook 27/06/07
  51.   # 41 06:24  |  melchizedek 27/06/07
  52.   tosefta # 46 06:27  |  melchizedek 27/06/07
  53.   #21 06:27  |  READER 27/06/07
  54.   Planting people??? #40 06:44  |  plant trees not ppl 27/06/07
  55.   Where`s any notice of the settlers being arrested and tried? 08:03  |  David Teich 27/06/07
  56.   54: Get a grip, "the Pals" weren`t the only ones there 08:07  |  David Teich 27/06/07
  57.   This is not the way to treat trees 08:58  |  English Resident 27/06/07
  58.   Never again another dime...to American settler`s religious causes 09:12  |  Mea 27/06/07
  59.   Arabstine 10:25  |  Lea de Lange 27/06/07
  60.   civil society 11:07  |  Ernst 27/06/07
  61.   Okey Guys ! I got a better story to smile :) 11:20  |  Atilla Liman 27/06/07
  62.   No 58 et al 11:22  |  Baruch Nili 27/06/07
  63.   #25 William 11:30  |  Ernst 27/06/07
  64.   Taking law and judgement into their own hands 11:42  |  Tzfonit 27/06/07
  65.   Calculating justice 11:50  |  Ernst 27/06/07
  66.   English Resident on the way to treat trees 12:04  |  sh 27/06/07
  67.   # 61 Atilla, keep smiling! 12:05  |  Alicia 27/06/07
  68.   #11.Tina ROSENBERG. So you condoned THIEVING as a fait accompli? 12:08  |  Joshua 27/06/07
  69.   Taken out of proportion 12:12  |  Jonathan S 27/06/07
  70.   #14 One sided BORIS.Any idea how much damaged 12:13  |  Haroon al Rash 27/06/07
  71.   Responsible Acts 12:13  |  Daniel 27/06/07
  72.   What is going on??? 12:17  |  Edith 27/06/07
  73.   Princess Alicia ! 12:29  |  Atilla Liman 27/06/07
  74.   this is totally unacceptable behaviour 12:38  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/06/07
  75.   "8 Lynn 12:53  |  Labhras 27/06/07
  76.   `13 Natalie Durson 12:58  |  Labhras 27/06/07
  77.   `7 Fred Michaelsburg 13:02  |  Labhras 27/06/07
  78.   ERNEST.40 years etcYou mean there were no Arab terrorists before? 13:03  |  PETER SM 27/06/07
  79.   No doubt 13:05  |  Jim 27/06/07
  80.   SOS to the tree transplanters 13:08  |  Klaudia 27/06/07
  81.   # 11 You are the thief 13:21  |  suad 27/06/07
  82.   # 12 if the Palestinians would have ..... 13:23  |  suad 27/06/07
  83.   # 52 Now, Now Melchizedek, 13:30  |  Jim 27/06/07
  84.   # 14 Did we Palestinians steal their "wealth"? 13:32  |  suad 27/06/07
  85.   `8" Lynn " Correction 13:32  |  Labhras 27/06/07
  86.   # 28 What do you want back? 13:44  |  suad 27/06/07
  87.   Natallie #13, William #25, and Haaretz 13:47  |  Close Watch 27/06/07
  88.   #80, Klaudia: growing uprooted ancient trees 13:53  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/06/07
  89.   # 75 Labhras 13:54  |  Jim 27/06/07
  90.   Israelis stealing from Palestinians again? 14:01  |  yashuveh 27/06/07
  91.   To Cipora 14:13  |  Klaudia 27/06/07
  92.   Why does Israel Support Settlesrs Anyway? 14:16  |  Sharif Hafez 27/06/07
  93.   "89 Jim 14:25  |  Labhras 27/06/07
  94.   "86 suad 14:29  |  Labhras 27/06/07
  95.   "Since the trees bore no fruit this year." 14:39  |  Maureen Ann 27/06/07
  96.   Has the price of trees gone up ?? 14:41  |  Benjamin 27/06/07
  97.   I don`t remember reading about the Palestinians returning stolen 14:42  |  John 27/06/07
  98.   The other side from mitnight 14:42  |  Dav 27/06/07
  99.   Cipora 14:43  |  GABE1 27/06/07
  100.   Settlers 14:47  |  Sam 27/06/07
  101.   The settlers do not have to steal Arab olive trees 14:50  |  Beni 27/06/07
  102.   Klaudia #91 15:00  |  GABE1 27/06/07
  103.   # 86 suad 15:04  |  Lynn 27/06/07
  104.   #69#JonathanSof Germany. THIS is no hate mail 15:16  |  Benyamin 27/06/07
  105.   Close Watch#87 - you see much! 15:22  |  William 27/06/07
  106.   To Gabe .... Very Fishy Indeed 15:35  |  Klaudia 27/06/07
  107.   # 80 KLAUDIA : SaveOurTreeSouls! 15:39  |  Alicia 27/06/07
  108.   The Wild West (Bank) 15:44  |  Tosefta 27/06/07
  109.   Settlers: leave the innocent olive-trees out of politics! 15:50  |  Alicia 27/06/07
  110.   some harvest 16:07  |  edgar 27/06/07
  111.   the army must arrest them 16:23  |  Zebulonguy 27/06/07
  112.   I hear you Axel 16:23  |  Mark Lincoln 27/06/07
  113.   Olive trees are part of the landscape and scenery 16:26  |  Zebulonguy 27/06/07
  114.   I understand Moshe 16:27  |  Mark Lincoln 27/06/07
  115.   Aaron Levitt - fair enuogh 16:30  |  Mark Lincoln 27/06/07
  116.   Beni - the real goal of grove destruction 16:33  |  Mark Lincoln 27/06/07
  117.   I Just Went to Some of My Gardening Forums 16:44  |  Klaudia 27/06/07
  118.   genuine tosefta 16:44  |  michael 27/06/07
  119.   `109` Alicia 16:44  |  Labhras 27/06/07
  120.   `107 Alicia 16:53  |  Labhras 27/06/07
  121.   `117 Klaudia 17:09  |  Labhras 27/06/07
  122.   #56 Real people are not abstractions 17:09  |  Rick 27/06/07
  123.   Putting Marc Lincoln wise 17:16  |  Alicia 27/06/07
  124.   Justice would require more. 17:27  |  Hadas 27/06/07
  125.   # 120 Labhras: right! 17:32  |  Alicia 27/06/07
  126.   The real purpose 17:34  |  Danite 27/06/07
  127.   Alicia #123 - answer to Mark Lincoln 17:35  |  William 27/06/07
  128.   danite #126 - just another settler-hater 17:41  |  William 27/06/07
  129.   Settlers return stolen olive trees 17:44  |  tbora 27/06/07
  130.   Where is the IDF??? 17:47  |  Joe 27/06/07
  131.   all in the name of judiahism!!!!! 17:51  |  jimmy 27/06/07
  132.   William the big talker 18:00  |  Danite 27/06/07
  133.   Ernst #63 18:13  |  Sweeping 27/06/07
  134.   "These religious settlers are not good citizens" 18:41  |  Sam 27/06/07
  135.   Most settlers are extremists, especially the American ones! 18:54  |  Aaron 27/06/07
  136.   Danite #126 19:00  |  Ibrahim 27/06/07
  137.   Live trees and dead trees 19:06  |  Janice 27/06/07
  138.   "they think they own all the land and will not hear of peace" 19:35  |  Sam 27/06/07
  139.   danite#132 - Interesting reply 19:37  |  William 27/06/07
  140.   # 69 Jonathan S 19:40  |  Axel 27/06/07
  141.   115: Poor Mark, so close to sentience 19:41  |  David Teich 27/06/07
  142.   129: Tbora, when are you returning Hindu land? 19:44  |  david Teich 27/06/07
  143.   more than olive trees 20:21  |  Lauren 27/06/07
  144.   William try to think abit okay? 20:26  |  Danite 27/06/07
  145.   Ibrahim 20:28  |  Danite 27/06/07
  146.   # 138 Sam 20:35  |  Axel 27/06/07
  147.   #141 - Please study history & reality 21:17  |  Rick 27/06/07
  148.   Promises versus realities 21:21  |  Goldie 27/06/07
  149.   do all of these experts think there is ashortage of olives in 21:22  |  victor hardman 27/06/07
  150.   #141 David on settlements 21:26  |  Janice 27/06/07
  151.   Katsav and settlers 21:28  |  Goldie 27/06/07
  152.   #138 - Dear Sam 21:31  |  Rick 27/06/07
  153.   # 150 Janice 21:39  |  Axel 27/06/07
  154.   #149 - Victor - olive market not the issue 21:41  |  Rick 27/06/07
  155.   Olive Trees 22:00  |  Paz Niente 27/06/07
  156.   colonization now! (please answer) 22:23  |  peter 27/06/07
  157.   Oh how sweet of them those settlers 22:29  |  Jay 27/06/07
  158.   the settlers are ok 22:37  |  Ernst 27/06/07
  159.   Every Israeli is a settler 22:48  |  Jonathan S 27/06/07
  160.   #154 rick would you please provide real evidence of your claim 22:50  |  victor hardman 27/06/07
  161.   These settlers got away with .... 23:26  |  Pssd Off American 27/06/07
  162.   #158 Jonathan 23:38  |  ballistic 27/06/07
  163.   "Only 160" responses to this "high criticality topic"??? funny... 23:47  |  Luis 27/06/07
  164.   The illegal settlement should be bulldozed flat 23:55  |  Fred Farkelsteinman 27/06/07
  165.   Mark Lincoln #115 00:10  |  Aaron Levitt 28/06/07
  166.   #160 - Gladly I will answer 00:31  |  Rick 28/06/07
  167.   #160 - further answer 00:41  |  Rick 28/06/07
  168.   Uprooting 300 trees is no small feat 01:10  |  Guy From NYC 28/06/07
  169.   Danite #144 01:33  |  GABE1 28/06/07
  170.   Danite -Freakishly Demented #144 01:35  |  GABE1 28/06/07
  171.   # 163 Finkenstein take the G. conv and shovit... 01:39  |  misha 28/06/07
  172.   How to steal trees with Halakhic impunity 01:46  |  Tosefta 28/06/07
  173.   #159 Johnathan 01:47  |  Janice 28/06/07
  174.   Setlers and palis 01:55  |  Twogunz 28/06/07
  175.   settlements & olive trees-Natalie Durson 02:08  |  Lillian Tobin 28/06/07
  176.   Good. 02:39  |  sg 28/06/07
  177.   Danite #144 03:02  |  GABE! 28/06/07
  178.   How to steal trees with Halakhic impunity 03:03  |  Tosefta 28/06/07
  179.   Lillian from New Jersy 03:07  |  Ibrahim 28/06/07
  180.   #167 Lillian and history 03:27  |  Janice 28/06/07
  181.   167 Do you really think Jews are that different? 03:46  |  Rick 28/06/07
  182.   #22 & 162 Good to see you Ballistic 03:52  |  Rick 28/06/07
  183.   #175 Arabs not all terrorists 04:03  |  Rick 28/06/07
  184.   Toseftas ravings 04:25  |  Danite 28/06/07
  185.   More stealing huh? What else is new? 04:26  |  Nick W 28/06/07
  186.   Gabe1 Copyright infringement 04:27  |  Danite 28/06/07
  187.   The US will Surely Compensate the Settlers 04:38  |  robin 28/06/07
  188.   Ibrahim ON BALIS & HISTORY pt1 04:42  |  GABE1 28/06/07
  189.   Ibrahim ON BALIS & HISTORY pt2 04:47  |  GABE1 28/06/07
  190.   Ibrahim ON BALIS & HISTORY pt3 04:50  |  GABE1 28/06/07
  191.   Settlers take trees back 05:07  |  Michael 28/06/07
  192.   # 180 not smart, Janice.... 05:19  |  misha 28/06/07
  193.   #187 Robin 05:25  |  Janice 28/06/07
  194.   #164 FRED FRANKENSTEIN AND TREATIES 05:51  |  paul harris 28/06/07
  195.   #182 RICK UNAWARE OF PLIGHT OF 700 MILLION MUSLIM WOMEN 05:53  |  paul harris 28/06/07
  196.   #194 Misha 06:03  |  Janice 28/06/07
  197.   Michael #191 06:13  |  Night Watch 28/06/07
  198.   Natalie Durson 06:17  |  Connie 28/06/07
  199.   #188-190 - Semantics is not history 06:20  |  Rick 28/06/07
  200.   For once I have to agree with David Teich #55!!! 06:33  |  Silvienne 28/06/07
  201.   #195 Huh? I am also critical of Islam. 06:59  |  Rick 28/06/07
  202.   #198, Connie 07:29  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 28/06/07
  203.   #201 RICK IM CONCERNED ABOUT YOU 07:42  |  paul harris 28/06/07
  204.   Jonathan S #149 AND this relates to Palestinians? 08:03  |  Elias Khoury 28/06/07
  205.   The Parable of the Olive Trees 08:16  |  Passerby 28/06/07
  206.   PAUL HARRIS 08:44  |  Janice 28/06/07
  207.   #203 Thanks for your concern 08:55  |  Rick 28/06/07
  208.   and Janice 206, what do you know? 09:35  |  bbl 28/06/07
  209.   # 202 Janice you incorrectly informed 13:15  |  Axel 28/06/07
  210.   # 94 Labhras it`s hard to remain cool 14:23  |  suad 28/06/07
  211.   #209 Axel 15:13  |  New Post 28/06/07
  212.   Stolen LAND? Attention PLEASE 16:24  |  StarAngel 28/06/07
  213.   #195 Okay Paul---still doing the two step eh? 18:11  |  ballistic 28/06/07
  214.   # 41 clearly NOT the case, efox 21:36  |  eric 28/06/07
  215.   212 22:32  |  sara 28/06/07
  216.   the rude awakening is long overdue! 07:38  |  eric 29/06/07
  217.   216: Eric, you`re rude, but you`re still not awake 15:44  |  David Teich 29/06/07
  218.   # 217 to david teich; of wishes and dreams 03:35  |  eric 30/06/07
  219.   218: Thank you, Eric, for proving my point 16:12  |  David Teich 01/07/07
  220.   200: Of course, Silvienne, proving my point about you (3rd try) 16:13  |  David Teich 01/07/07
 Today Online
Zvi Bar'el: Israel security depends on the occupation
Responses: 28
PM: IDF to continue crackdown on Palestinian militants
Responses: 28
Human rights group: Palestinian rockets, IDF fire against law
Responses: 30
UN chief: Threat to lives of abducted IDF soldiers increasing
Responses: 54
U.K. gov't: Britain is at 'critical' risk of terrorism
Responses: 87
Rosner's Domain
* The afternoon plans of Bush, Blair and Olmert
* WTR: "Blair should talk to Jewish Americans"
* The Giuliani road show finds a receptive Jewish crowd
* Look who's the better party on Israel now...


More Headlines
14:30 PM: Israel will push forward with crackdown on PA militants
15:55 Israel to pay first installment of tax revenues to PA by Monday
14:17 Petitions submitted to High Court delay hearing on Katsav plea deal
16:13 Human Rights Watch: Palestinian rockets and IDF fire violate the law
13:30 Finance Minister resigns in wake of police graft probe
14:58 Jordan's king rejects confederation with Palestinians
14:48 MDA to launch aerial evacaution service for car accident victims
13:37 British PM tells Britons terrorist threat they face is 'long-term'
16:08 Gov't okays transfer of 4 Jordanian prisoners who killed IDF soldiers
12:06 Police show video of suspect re-enacting murder of Tair Rada
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
LEUMI
Mortgages in Israel tailor made to your specific needs and currency
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved