Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., July 03, 2007 Tamuz 17, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:55 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 12:52 03/07/2007
Hamas as the new Israel
By Bradley Burston

Imagine, if you will, a lightning Middle East war, over in a matter of days. An armed force that is thought to be outnumbered and outgunned rolls with ease over a long-entrenched enemy.

Stunned, humiliated, utterly defeated, the former rulers melt away. The victors, left to administer the newly conquered territory, feel elation at first. Soon, however, it dawns on them that the world sees them very differently. No longer do their friends abroad uniformly view them as an underdog, brave, uncorrupted. No longer do their admirers see them as supremely competent, pure in their dedication, clear in their goals, innovative and effective in their actions.

In fact, no sooner do they take control, are they denounced as brutal occupiers. Human rights organizations focus on their excesses in trying to establish order, branding their military policies war crimes. The international community - even many nations they once considered to be sympathetic allies - progressively distances itself from them. The brief war and its repercussions split their own people into two irreconcilable political camps.

Is this the Israel that emerged in June 1967, or is it the Hamas which conquered Gaza exactly four decades later? The answer, of course, is Yes.

It is the worst nightmare of any radical Islamist, and it has shown signs of coming true: Hamas is taking on some of the history, and even some of the traits, of Israel.

Perhaps, before it's too late, Hamas can learn something from Israel's errors. But first, back to our story:

The party of conquest - once a well-oiled, Spartan machine, making up in dedication what it lacked in trappings, addressing the world with a clear voice and an unswerving vision, attending to the needs of its people in a comprehensive, if makeshift, welfare state - is now a splintered unit pulling in a number of directions at once, with perhaps the signal discernable common goal at this point being the drive to maintain its rule. Corruption, once a hated common enemy, has already wormed its way in. So has callousness to the plight of ordinary people.

As the new reality begins to hit home within the ruling party, long-established principles, narratives, credos are re-examined. There is new dissension. Hard-liners at home and in the Diaspora demand that the Holy Land never be shared with the other side, and that the other side never be formally recognized. Pragmatists at home and in the Diaspora begin to move toward recognition of and talks with the enemy, and eventual partition into two states, one Israeli, one Palestinian.

Hamas, like Israel after the Six-Day War, is at a terrible crossroads. The temptation, as it was for Israel, is to resist taking any of the difficult paths. There is apparent safety in marching in place, hoping for the best, or at least, hoping for nothing worse, hanging on to a power whose ultimate goal is no longer clear.

Like Israel after the 1967 war, Hamas must come to grips with the price of what passes in the Middle East for victory. Hamas has been left the lord of one of the world's most challenging manors, an economic ruin, a social welfare nightmare, looked down upon even as it is pitied by the brother Palestinians of the West Bank, which has become, effectively, a different state-without-a-state.

Moreover, Hamas is beginning to display some of the same lack of finesse in decision-making, long-term strategy, and even public relations, that has become a hallmark of post-1967 Israel.

So, entirely unbidden, herewith a few suggestions for Hamas, based on what has gone wrong, and right, in the 40 years since conquest took over our lives in Israel.

1. You are no longer an underground movement. Stop acting like one.

Begin speaking and acting with one voice. Begin speaking and acting as you would if you were a full member of the community of nations. Act to heal the rift within your people by recognizing the consensus which favors a permanent solution through compromise, rather than catering to unbending, scripture-distorting militants and their delusions of full victory, the fulfillment of all pipe dreams, the realization of an impossible ideal.

Resist the temptation to put too much stock in the opinions of your military men. In the international legal no man's land of conquered territory, resist the temptation to believe that a state undeclared can remain indefinitely ungoverned. Resist the temptation to believe that human beings can indefinitely accept a permanent state of war and the deprivation, grief, and despondency that are part and parcel of it.

2. Stop reveling in your pariah status

Listen to your critics. They may have a point. Just because the whole world seems to be against you doesn't mean that you're necessarily doing anything right.

Fool your enemy ? approach him. You have offered a cease-fire of 50 years' duration. A positive step. Now try this: Make the same offer, without immediately following it with a renewed commitment to the destruction of Israel.

3. The world owes you. So what?

Of course, the world owes you for your suffering, for your deprivation, for your loss of homeland and livelihood and property.

Here's how it works in practice, though: The world owes a lot of people. Maybe that's why the world does not pay its moral debts.

It's up to you now. Fatah is too corrupt, too decayed, too broken to take the actions needed to create a real Palestine. An independent Palestine will come not through a cataclysmic military defeat of Israel, but through a bitter and intelligent diplomatic accommodation that gives each side the most it can expect under impossible circumstances.

4. The other side is a fact. Relate to it as permanent.

Golda Meir waved away the idea of a Palestinian people, Meir Kahane and Rehavam Ze'evi nursed dreams of expelling the Palestinian people. You're still here.

And so are we. Both sides have their separate readings of thousands of years of history, but the moral is the same. Both sides will do absolutely anything to remain here.

Perhaps one day, we might even go so far as to make peace.


_________________


Recent blogs:

They're here, they're queer - be proud of Israel
Hamas wants Israel to starve Gaza
Why there is no Palestine
REFERENDUM: Return of a bilateral peace plan


__________________



The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Negev growth industry
Bedouin and Jewish Israelis are working together to bring tourism to the Negev.
Raising champions
Triathlon teams for adults and children as young as 9 are a growing trend in Israel.
  1.   very corrupt analogy 10:36  |  Khalid 29/06/07
  2.   there is one vital difference....which bradley misses 10:36  |  ravi 29/06/07
  3.   In the name of reason 10:40  |  Cord H. Kaldrack 29/06/07
  4.   Saw Off One Leg Then Tell Hamas To Jump 10:44  |  Rowan Berkeley 29/06/07
  5.   #2, ravi 10:59  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 29/06/07
  6.   High time for Palestinians to stop living off P.R. 11:03  |  ScotGuy 29/06/07
  7.   SHE IS NOT A PARIAH, NO SIR 11:16  |  indrajaya 29/06/07
  8.   The article show one thing only: 11:25  |  martyrmaker 29/06/07
  9.   Nice sentiment, but practical? 11:31  |  Natallie Durson 29/06/07
  10.   #2and that ravi is why there can never be peace 11:38  |  victor hardman 29/06/07
  11.   39 NATALLIE AGAIN MISSES THE REAL POINT 11:42  |  paul harris 29/06/07
  12.   Indrajaya 7 12:08  |  Daniel W 29/06/07
  13.   Cipora 12:21  |  S 29/06/07
  14.   Burston omits the real problem 12:58  |  Jonathan S 29/06/07
  15.   Indrajaya ? from Jakarta (2) 13:01  |  Gil 29/06/07
  16.   is anyone listening?? 13:12  |  a wandering Jew 29/06/07
  17.   Indrajaya ? from Jakarta (1) 13:15  |  Gil 29/06/07
  18.   "Pitied", Bradley? 13:24  |  Clickfool 29/06/07
  19.   A curious comparison 13:32  |  Mark Lincoln 29/06/07
  20.   Confidential to BB... From the Gaza Employment Agency 13:35  |  Klaudia 29/06/07
  21.   The parallels are not accurate,israel both at its establishment 13:35  |  lakshmi 29/06/07
  22.   #7 Indra 13:54  |  Benny 29/06/07
  23.   We are all children of Darwin 13:59  |  Tosefta 29/06/07
  24.   You are really twisted...what makes you think Hamas cares about 14:05  |  Reuven 29/06/07
  25.   Khalid`s obfuscations 14:05  |  Samil 29/06/07
  26.   Khalid (second attempt) 14:15  |  Nik Miller 29/06/07
  27.   Burston as the new Hamas! 14:58  |  Barry 29/06/07
  28.   A good article! 15:07  |  Bob 29/06/07
  29.   # 24 Reuven 15:42  |  Bob 29/06/07
  30.   Bizarre analogy - Here is the real road to peace! 15:55  |  Bo 29/06/07
  31.   # 14 Jonathan S 16:01  |  Bob 29/06/07
  32.   Peace 16:02  |  Dani 29/06/07
  33.   Why don`t compare Hamas to nazi Germany? 16:29  |  Gene 29/06/07
  34.   Haniyeh`s Curse - PEACE 16:31  |  Tony Anthony 29/06/07
  35.   Unbelievably simplistic 16:38  |  Richard 29/06/07
  36.   Bad taste 16:40  |  Shalom Freedman 29/06/07
  37.   HAMAS is not much better than the KKK 16:44  |  GF Moral 29/06/07
  38.   LESSONS FOR ISRAEL 17:06  |  Igor D. 29/06/07
  39.   Positive 17:11  |  Choni Davidowitz 29/06/07
  40.   peace will only happen when 17:17  |  Igor D. 29/06/07
  41.   Wrong 17:40  |  Danite 29/06/07
  42.   # 28 Bob, and His Spiritual View (Spirtitual ?) 17:50  |  Tony Anthony 29/06/07
  43.   Most of "Haaretz" journos dream about becoming advisors to mortal 17:53  |  Absolute Sweden 29/06/07
  44.   Mr Burstyn Rehavam Za`evi & Rabbi Kahana 18:05  |  Mary S Ashkelon 29/06/07
  45.   lasting peace is the only goal worth trying,one based on fairness 18:21  |  arab 29/06/07
  46.   Iakshmi # 21 I Agree That The Analogy Is Lame 18:47  |  Jeff Northridge 29/06/07
  47.   #45 Arab - Fairness? 18:49  |  Bo 29/06/07
  48.   ironic, Arab #45 19:06  |  Polybios 29/06/07
  49.   # 28 Bob, The spirits of alcohol is not the answer. 19:12  |  SoberUp 29/06/07
  50.   Articles best sentiment;we should all think long and hard on this 19:18  |  Virginia 29/06/07
  51.   Haaretz got its Erwin Rommel 19:22  |  christoph 29/06/07
  52.   # 42 Tony Anthony 19:26  |  Bob 29/06/07
  53.   I agree with Bo & Polybios.The land God left to the Arabs 19:40  |  Virginia 29/06/07
  54.   # 45 Arab, Don`t hold your breath for that "better offer" or 19:44  |  Virginia 29/06/07
  55.   #23: 1st question for Tosefta, re "pressure" on Hamas (1) 19:46  |  Thomas Jackson 29/06/07
  56.   Brad is Acting Weird Again 19:46  |  Tod Zuckerman 29/06/07
  57.   Amazing, Bradley! 19:51  |  Denton 29/06/07
  58.   #23: 1st question for Tosefta, re "pressure" on Hamas (2) 19:51  |  Thomas Jackson 29/06/07
  59.   "SAME OLD STORY, SAME OLD SONG AND DANCE" - S. TYLER 19:55  |  StephenConnor 29/06/07
  60.   #23: 1st question for Tosefta, re "pressure" on Hamas (3) 19:56  |  Thomas Jackson 29/06/07
  61.   The art of the impossible 19:57  |  Daniel 29/06/07
  62.   # 56 Tod Zuckerman. Brad is Acting Weird Again. RIGHT YOU ARE!! 19:57  |  KATH` 29/06/07
  63.   Klaudia, Klaudia, Klaudia 20:04  |  StephenConnor 29/06/07
  64.   IF Israel were similar to Hamas; or: How to get Shalit released 20:04  |  Tosefta 29/06/07
  65.   Gene - Scary and Disturbing 20:06  |  StephenConnor 29/06/07
  66.   Rehavam Za`evi & Rabbi Kahana: To Ms. Ashkelon 20:11  |  StephenConnor 29/06/07
  67.   Bo? 20:15  |  StephenConnor 29/06/07
  68.   You sound very humanistic (Thomas Jackson #60) 20:16  |  Tosefta 29/06/07
  69.   Virginia 20:18  |  StephenConnor 29/06/07
  70.   #23: 2nd question for Tosefta, Who wants moderation? (1) 20:25  |  Thomas Jackson 29/06/07
  71.   Shabbat Shalom, Priase God for peace within and 20:28  |  Virginia 29/06/07
  72.   #23: 1st question for Tosefta, re "pressure" on Hamas (2) 20:31  |  Thomas Jackson 29/06/07
  73.   # 47 Bo 20:33  |  Bob 29/06/07
  74.   # 67 Stephen, Children believe all things, I`ve since grown up... 20:43  |  Virginia 29/06/07
  75.   IF Israel were similar to Hamas; or: How to get Shalit released 20:45  |  Tosefta 29/06/07
  76.   Thomas Jackson,agree with your 3 posts to T,although he may have 20:45  |  lakshmi 29/06/07
  77.   Hamas is Israel without the morality 20:46  |  Settler Babe 29/06/07
  78.   #65 StephenConnor? 21:12  |  Bo 29/06/07
  79.   #66: Tosefta, regarding humanism vs. "pressure" 21:44  |  Thomas Jackson 29/06/07
  80.   Bob, I think the Jordains would handle that themselves and should 21:49  |  Virginia 29/06/07
  81.   Tosefta, my #72 has wrong title. Check it. 21:58  |  Thomas Jackson 29/06/07
  82.