Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., June 24, 2007 Tamuz 8, 5767 | | Israel Time: 06:42 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Focus on the West Bank
By Yoel Marcus

Remember Steven Spielberg's moving film "Saving Private Ryan"? You could say that Ehud Olmert has returned from Washington with the mission of "Saving Chairman Abu Mazen."

In retrospect, it is clear that both Ariel Sharon and President George Bush were wrong. Sharon's mistake was unilateral disengagement from Gaza. He believed, as many of us did, that the Palestinians would rehabilitate Gaza. He thought they would build apartment buildings for the refugees, and establish tourist attractions along the coast, as the Egyptians did in Sinai. Sharon never imagined that the territory we evacuated would become a launching pad for attacks on Israel.

If he were conscious now, maybe he would say: "So Arabs are killing Arabs. What does that have to do with us?" It would never have occurred to him that one of the most vicious civil wars ever seen in these parts would erupt there. And yet Israel cannot be neutral when Arabs are killing Arabs. We cannot dismiss it as "their business and none of ours." In the eyes of the world, everything that happens in the territories is our responsibility.

Advertisement

Bush's mistake was insisting on importing democracy to the Middle East, Gaza included, before there were signs of stability. We did not cause what is happening in Gaza, and we could not have stopped the lunacy there. It is part of a process that is raging now all over the Islamic world. Wherever you find pockets of Islamic fundamentalism, the Koran as the code of law and qadis ruling the roost, bringing in democratic procedures is "from the devil," as the Arabs like to say. This is what the Gulf states, which have secular regimes, are afraid of. Their motto is: "Be a good Muslim at home, but not in the government."

Israel, and especially Bush, sped up democracy in the territories, never imagining that Hamas would win the elections. That is how Israel woke up one morning and found itself not with a partner for an agreement, but face to face with a fanatic enemy. Professor Bernard Lewis said that in parts of the world where Islamic fundamentalism reigns, there is no place for democracy.

My late colleague, Ze'ev Schiff, with whom I shared a room at Haaretz and whom I loved like a brother, could not understand how powerful, self-confident Israel could be beaten day after day by Qassam rockets fired at Sderot. "The enemy that defeated Sderot is a terror organization that is militarily weak," he wrote in his last article, "yet in spite of its weakness, it has managed to achieve a state of mutual deterrence vis-a-vis Israel similar to that achieved by Hezbollah." Moreover, David Ben-Gurion's strategic principle of quickly moving combat into enemy territory has been struck from the books. "Now it is the enemy who is shifting combat into Israeli territory," Schiff wrote.

Hamas-controlled Gaza is in a serious state of crisis. Olmert announced in Washington that we have no intention at the moment of launching a wide-scale ground operation. At the same time, we cannot allow political progress to screech to a halt because of Hamas, as that would only encourage it to slip into the West Bank and use it as a base for suicide bombings in the heart of the country.

We did not cause the showdown in Gaza and could not prevent it. But in the wake of the horrifying killings in Gaza and the humiliating blow suffered by Fatah, Israel must ensure that what is happening in Gaza does not spread to the West Bank. That is what Bush was referring to when he said that moderate elements in the West Bank need strengthening.

Israeli cabinet ministers are wrong to keep saying that we have no partner for an agreement. They are foolish to keep repeating the mantra that PA Chairman Mahmoud Abbas is weak. The government must choose two routes right now: generosity and dialogue. Israel should invite the Palestinian Authority to sit down and talk about a permanent-status agreement with international backing, and at the same time, take steps to strengthen Abu Mazen - with money, with arms, with political and military support. Israel should help turn the West Bank into a living, flourishing model of administrative order and community life, and show the inhabitants of Gaza that there is another way.

One of the most effective measures we can employ today is being generous in releasing prisoners. Minister Gideon Ezra, who has proposed freeing Marwan Barghouti, described him to me as a charismatic man who, from his jail cell, played a pivotal role in the appointment of Salam Fayyad as prime minister. This is an important posting, considering that Fatah lost the election mainly due to corruption. There is no question that letting Barghouti go, along with a few hundred other prisoners, would give Fatah and the moderates in the West Bank a much-needed boost.

Olmert once said that a prime minister does not need an agenda. Well, here is one staring him in the face: Focus on the West Bank.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
48 Hours in Eilat
Eilat is rich in nature and scenery, but finding a good place to eat can be hard.
Family Affair
Newlyweds Eitan and Yamit Levitt spending a weekend at the Dan Accadia Hotel.
  1.   Let the Palestinians select their own leaders 11:40  |  Natallie Durson 22/06/07
  2.   THE DIFFERENT BETWEEN RYAN AND ABBAS 11:48  |  indrajaya 22/06/07
  3.   NATALLIE HAS APOINT THE UNIQUE ARABS WILL FIND THEIR OWN LEADERS 11:59  |  paul harris 22/06/07
  4.   Reasons why Barghouti is not, and will not be released 12:11  |  Thomas Jackson 22/06/07
  5.   natallie durson 13:36  |  scallywag 22/06/07
  6.   indrajaya 13:37  |  scallywag 22/06/07
  7.   thomas jackson 13:41  |  scallywag 22/06/07
  8.   in view of this difficult situation, described well by... 14:01  |  saul a. readner 22/06/07
  9.   Scallywag (Post No. 7) 14:46  |  Johnny Weintraub 22/06/07
  10.   democracy in territories 15:06  |  m e r 22/06/07
  11.   # 1 Everyone did, and they butchered everyone. 15:45  |  Greg 22/06/07
  12.   johnny weintraub 15:53  |  scallywag 22/06/07
  13.   "Sharon never imagined that the territory..." 16:03  |  bat yam 22/06/07
  14.   Turning A Mite Into A Giant 16:41  |  Tony Anthony 22/06/07
  15.   Will Free Elections Silence Natallie? 17:13  |  Tony Anthony 22/06/07
  16.   Russia, South Africa, Indonesia and Qatar object it. 17:27  |  Claudia Loria 22/06/07
  17.   Focus on the West Bank 17:30  |  Andi 22/06/07
  18.   Focus on 18:55  |  Yishai 22/06/07
  19.   Durson 22:16  |  Michael 22/06/07
  20.   to Yishai # 18 22:34  |  Clickfan 22/06/07
  21.   Marcus` Suggestion - Amazing and Repulsive 23:18  |  Tod Zuckerman 22/06/07
  22.   Affairs in Gaza 09:58  |  Ghulam Muhammed 23/06/07
  23.   to Ghulam Muhammed 14:03  |  Andi 23/06/07
  24.   Supporting Abbas Is Compounding Your Mistakes 17:28  |  Yoram 23/06/07
  25.   Focus on the West Bank 19:00  |  Howard Scheer 23/06/07
  26.   You did start it for god`s sake 19:59  |  Marilyn 23/06/07
  27.   Israelis are just the biggest idiots of the western world. 20:16  |  Andreas 23/06/07
  28.   good idea...but 20:30  |  ravi 23/06/07
  29.   no 13... bat yam 20:41  |  ravi 23/06/07
  30.   good things don`t come to Jewkillers 21:22  |  BobUSA 23/06/07
  31.   to Marilyn 21:36  |  Andi 23/06/07
  32.   to Andreas 21:41  |  Andi 23/06/07
  33.   to Ravi 21:47  |  Andi 23/06/07
  34.   The difference between fatah and Hamas 21:56  |  Israel Israeli 23/06/07
  35.   A normal child could have predicted Disengagement disaster. 01:37  |  Chaim 24/06/07
  36.   Indrajaya: Indonesia is a big part of the problem 05:22  |  jk 24/06/07
  37.   Marilyn the LIAR 05:29  |  jk 24/06/07
  38.   Ravi: Israel should use the Indian solution to the Pal problem 05:37  |  jk 24/06/07
 Today Online
Burston: They're here, they're queer, be proud of Israel
Responses: 188
Move to back Abbas gov't blocked in Security Council
Responses: 253
Shmuel Rosner: Is there an alternative to a Palestinian state?
Responses: 203
Yossi Sarid: U.K. boycotters should boycott themselves
Responses: 289
Asher Maoz: ACRI must challenge view of Jewish state as 'foolish' idea
Responses: 84


More Headlines
05:51 Olmert set to resume transfer of funds to PA
05:56 PM shelves U.S. proposal for negotiations with Abbas
02:09 Holocaust heirs own NIS 240 million in Bank Leumi shares
03:53 Number of E. Jerusalem residency revocations surges
05:45 Iranian media cracks consensus over Hamas' actions in Gaza
02:49 Zahar: Hamas willing to renew talks over release of Shalit
01:36 Hamas: Kidnappers of BBC reporter afraid to release him
01:36 Report: IDF believes Hamas has rockets that can reach Ashkelon
06:13 Tensions in Kadima run high ahead of finance minister appointment
06:15 Justice Min., Chief Justice fail to strike deal on Supreme Court nominees
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved