Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., June 23, 2007 Tamuz 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:58 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Mahmoud Abbas is a fiction
By Israel Harel

George W. Bush and Ehud Olmert looked pathetic giving their "full backing" to the broken-down crutch that is Mahmoud Abbas. Contrary to the talk in Washington, nothing has changed to open a new opportunity for negotiations over a final settlement. It is impossible to hold talks with Abbas, just like it was impossible to hold talks in the past on any kind of arrangement, and certainly not on a permanent settlement. The Hamas victory in the Gaza Strip and the establishment of a "moderate" government in Ramallah do not divide the territory into Hamastan in the Gaza Strip and Fatahstan in Judea and Samaria. This is only another illusion in the basket of Israeli illusions - a fallacy that's part of the same belief that there is an Arab leader (it used to be Yasser Arafat, and now it is Mahmoud Abbas) who wants to sign an agreement with us, and one that entails relinquishing the right of return and recognizing Israel's right to exist as a Jewish and Zionist state.

It is not only the Palestinians in Judea and Samaria and their leadership who do not recognize the right of Israel to exist as a state with a Jewish and Zionist character, but as a number of recently published documents have revealed, it is a view shared by entities representing the Arab citizens of Israel too.

The Palestinian government sworn in earlier this week is a fiction, even if the United States and Israel support it. In Ramallah, where this fictitious government sits, Hamas won a decisive victory in the last elections: four seats in parliament for Hamas, and only one for Fatah. In Nablus, four seats went to Hamas and two to Fatah. In Hebron: nine to Hamas and none for Fatah. In Jerusalem: four to Hamas and two for Fatah. In the cities of Judea and Samaria Hamas won 30 parliamentary seats. Fatah got only 12.

Advertisement

Given the circumstances, the new government does not represent the Palestinians - only Israeli illusions, and possibly also those of the Americans and the Europeans. The Israel Defense Forces cannot prevent the erosion of Fatah's military power, and it is doubtful whether it is even worth investing efforts in such futility. The experience of recent years proves that our "allies," Mohammad Dahlan among them, are only boisterous characters - corrupt and lacking any real power. They are certainly no ally of Israel.

In any case, Hamas will defeat them, and Israel should prepare well for the confrontation ahead. And in a confrontation of this nature, the various Dahlans would bring no benefit, only a burden.

Abbas' men lost in the fight not because Hamas militants are more brutal or better trained. If Fatah could, it would have adopted the same methods. Hamas won because the vast majority of the Gaza Strip population supports it, and this is first and foremost support for the religious ideology of the movement, which calls for the destruction of the Zionist entity. And as the elections have shown, this call is shared by the vast majority in Judea and Samaria, the area which Israeli analysts and politicians have designated for a Fatah state.

Certainly since the elections, areas A and B have been controlled by Hamas. As the events in the Gaza Strip show, the fact that many countries around the world have opposed the Hamas regime did not weaken support for the group. While in Judea and Samaria, thanks to the "occupation," Israel is able to prevent, and it is important that it prevent, some of the bloodletting, it is unable to prevent the weakening, and even the disappearence of Fatah as a significant force.

It is therefore time to let the truth out: Abbas is a fiction, and he cannot be saved.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Second to the saints
Neusner believes he's best suited to represent Judaism in its disputes with Christianity.
Spirit of the times
Author Yehudit Hendel merits a central place in the '1948 Generation' pantheon.
  1.   So what? "Palestinian people" are a fiction too. 10:41  |  Nathan 21/06/07
  2.   fear of Godis the winer 11:28  |  Dr.R.Steinbaum 21/06/07
  3.   Abbas needs a holiday 11:29  |  Big Al 21/06/07
  4.   It`s time to recoginie reality 11:36  |  Fred 21/06/07
  5.   That`s probably it 11:41  |  Uri 21/06/07
  6.   A fiction indeed...just like the "palestinians" 11:50  |  SLAVO 21/06/07
  7.   A statement of the absolute truth 11:52  |  Clickfool 21/06/07
  8.   You have completely missed the point 11:56  |  Natallie Durson 21/06/07
  9.   The way forward 12:05  |  Louis 21/06/07
  10.   #8 NATALLIE WHAT HAS ABBAS ACTUALLY DONE SINCE BEING IN POWER ?? 12:09  |  paul harris 21/06/07
  11.   Abu Mazen must be belligerent 12:28  |  Kalman 21/06/07
  12.   #10 Paul Harris 12:33  |  Natallie Durson 21/06/07
  13.   Mutual recognition 12:38  |  Andrew Watson 21/06/07
  14.   #13 my dear watson what ARE YOU ON ABOUT ?? 13:34  |  paul harris 21/06/07
  15.   Mahmoud Abbas 13:42  |  Sam 21/06/07
  16.   Finally Some Common Sense in Ha`aretz 13:44  |  Yoram 21/06/07
  17.   we Israelis are amazing 13:50  |  Omri 21/06/07
  18.   Mostly accurate analysis, though not complete 13:52  |  AK 21/06/07
  19.   Democratic hypocrisy 14:20  |  Nick Ferriman 21/06/07
  20.   #4 YOU FACE FACTS,FRED 14:25  |  Ian 21/06/07
  21.   Abbas is not a fiction 14:54  |  peace lover 21/06/07
  22.   Louis from Malta - The first step 15:11  |  Michael Jacobs 21/06/07
  23.   The palestinians didn`t vote for him 15:20  |  Walter 21/06/07
  24.   To Fred 15:36  |  Gene 21/06/07
  25.   To Fred (cont.) 15:52  |  Gene 21/06/07
  26.   Israel Does Not Act, It Reacts 16:02  |  Tony Anthony 21/06/07
  27.   How can anyone who uses the terms "Judea" and "Samaria" complain 16:14  |  Apartheid 21/06/07
  28.   The Ultimate Brilliant Plan...Oh Yeah 16:17  |  Tony Anthony 21/06/07
  29.   Abbas teacher Husainie started the the Hollacast;insane leaders 16:28  |  sam 21/06/07
  30.   Fictions create realities sometimes 17:35  |  Fortuna Benmayor 21/06/07
  31.   Filasteens are as fictional as Abbas`s PhD thesis on Shoa 17:43  |  Jo 21/06/07
  32.   Even Golda Meir understood that Filastines are a fiction 17:50  |  Drori 21/06/07
  33.   Why are some holocaust deniers more popular than others? 17:51  |  David Irving 21/06/07
  34.   Fiction 18:03  |  Lupe 21/06/07
  35.   Israel, a fiction ? 18:03  |  Dennis Loh 21/06/07
  36.   Israel should be serious in Politics as it was serious in Wars. 18:36  |  Akram Zekaria 21/06/07
  37.   HAMAS won elections because ARAFAT appeared to be a Thief. 18:44  |  Vittorio 21/06/07
  38.   ABU QUISLING & HIS OPPORTUNISTS 19:00  |  Arik Silverman 21/06/07
  39.   indrajaya, where is Alan Johnston you promised free last Sunday 20:27  |  Genuine Tosefta 21/06/07
  40.   to 22 from the Nederlands 21:17  |  Louis 21/06/07
  41.   A Complete Illusion 22:51  |  David 21/06/07
  42.   Louis from Malta - From fiction to reality 23:06  |  Michael Jacobs 21/06/07
  43.   # 8 Pal`s desire to fight other pal`s ..... 00:22  |  misha 22/06/07
  44.   Israel Harel, A pointed piece!!! 00:45  |  Dutch 22/06/07
  45.   Thanks to Israel Harel: realist and frank comment 01:38  |  nobodysacred 22/06/07
  46.   The Absolute Truth... 06:34  |  Edward 22/06/07
  47.   To all you Fictionalists 09:45  |  Filo 22/06/07
  48.   Filo from New York - The Palestinian Extortion Racket 13:30  |  Michael Jacobs 22/06/07
  49.   hamas, fatah, democracy 14:49  |  allan 22/06/07
  50.   Poor PA leadership 05:09  |  Scorpio 23/06/07
 Today Online
Burston: They're here, they're queer, be proud of Israel
Responses: 132
Move to back Abbas gov't blocked in Security Council
Responses: 152
Shmuel Rosner: Is there an alternative to a Palestinian state?
Responses: 115
Yossi Sarid: U.K. boycotters should boycott themselves
Responses: 178
Asher Maoz: ACRI must challenge view of Jewish state as 'foolish' idea
Responses: 45


More Headlines
00:18 IDF troops shoot and kill Palestinian near Hebron
01:57 Deposed Palestinian PM Haniyeh calls for renewed Hamas-Fatah talks
05:26 Key U.S. allies consider partial freeze on Iran's nuclear program
22:42 Abbas sacks top Fatah security chief after Hamas victory in Gaza
05:43 Israel sends letters to UN criticizing human rights abuses in Iran
05:12 Abbas signals he may shut down private Hamas-affiliated groups
21:33 Mideast Quartet envoys due to meet in Jerusalem next week
17:08 House okays Egypt aid cut over Gaza smuggling, human rights
20:39 Hamas says will not block deal to drill for natural gas off Gaza shore
04:49 Woman killed, two seriously injured in blaze in southern Tel Aviv
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved