Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., June 22, 2007 Tamuz 6, 5767 | | Israel Time: 03:42 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Separation at the Erez crossing
By Meron Benvenisti

Israel had to cook up a convincing reason to justify arbitrarily preventing some 200 people from crossing from the Gaza Strip to the West Bank. After all, this isn't an attempt to infiltrate Israel, but a demand that Israel uphold an old commitment regarding the provision of safe passage between Gaza and the West Bank.

The 40 minutes it takes to drive from the Erez crossing to Tarqumiya is the time that separates life from death for some of those imprisoned at the Erez terminal.

Many explanations are generated when Israel tries to cover up the real reason for its refusal. First they say that the passage poses a security risk, because Israel doesn't want experts in terrorism and the manufacture of Qassam rockets to go from Gaza to the West Bank. Then they say that Fatah officials oppose the move, unless they decide who gets to cross over and who has to go back. And, in general, the situation in Gaza has stabilized anyway, and there's nothing preventing the Gazans from going home.

Advertisement

But the real motivation peeps through the justifications: the fear that the Palestinians will take advantage of the situation and try to storm the crossing point to get to Israel. That was also the rationale for banning ambulances from going in to evacuate the wounded.

The scenario Israelis have dreaded for years, in which hundreds of thousands of refugees march to their destroyed former homes, has popped up once again to frighten Israelis. This scares them so much that they are prepared to cause a humanitarian tragedy and provoke international criticism that sets aside the ruthlessness of Hamas and once again focuses on the cruelty of Israel. The incident at the Erez crossing is just a side effect of the coup that took place in Gaza, but it is highly significant because it shows what Israel is prepared to do to separate the West Bank from Gaza - or, in other words, to continue fragmenting the Palestinian people.

Gaza's isolation, symbolized by the Erez crossing tragedy, is the latest in a series of actions to segregate and crush the Palestinians following the 1948 war. Ironically, these actions have continued with and been enabled by Palestinian assistance.

Israelis are so used to the idea of separating the West Bank from Gaza that their actions require no premeditation. The crossing is closed automatically, the old excuses are offered, and the separation itself is depicted as a major victory. After all, a large chunk has once again been cut off from the Palestinian people, among whom hostility and hared have been engendered.

That's what happened after 1948, when a rift was created between the "1948 Arabs" and the Arabs who remained outside of Israeli control. That's what happened after the 1967 war, when the residents of the territories were cut off from the Palestinian diaspora; this was later institutionalized in the Oslo Accords. And that's what happened in Jerusalem, when the separation wall was built, and the East Jerusalem Arabs were cut off from their surroundings. Now the physical segregation of the Gaza Strip is being institutionalized.

Each of these forms of fragmentation was accompanied by a distinction between "good Arabs" and "bad Arabs" - Israeli Arabs vs. the murderous fedayeen, Arabs in the territories vs. the refugees in the diaspora demanding to return and destroy Israel, East Jerusalem Arabs who live within the fence and oppose terrorism vs. the suicide bombers on the other side of the fence. And now, the Hamas hooligans in Gaza vs. Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas' government in the West Bank, which deserves all manner of aid.

The next step in the separation will be carried out with the full cooperation of the Palestinians - who, with astonishing submission (possibly due to having no choice in the matter), will accept the identity and the agenda dictated by Israel. Many would like to believe that the isolation of Gaza is destined to fail. But past experience shows that the strength of Israeli action is liable to shape the future. This means the West Bank will be annexed to Israel, and the next Erez refugees really will be infiltrators.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Professional help
Offering the finance portfolio to a successful businessman is tempting, but unwise.
Palm qualms
Palm trees planted along a stretch of Ibn Gvirol Street have irked residents.
  1.   convincing to me 11:23  |  joe 21/06/07
  2.   Israel always has evil intent 12:23  |  Tut Tut 21/06/07
  3.   Pssst..the pictures are appalling 12:48  |  Marilyn 21/06/07
  4.   Oslo - made for Israel 13:04  |  Dan 21/06/07
  5.   Benvenisti 13:12  |  CD 21/06/07
  6.   #3 Psssst why dont they... 13:59  |  itsik 21/06/07
  7.   Some Misken Palestinians Tempted By Quick Aid from Iran 15:12  |  HH Independence 21/06/07
  8.   #6 Tut Tut - If what you say is true why didn`t it happen? 15:16  |  Don Camillo 21/06/07
  9.   #4 Dan - that`s the problem - Israel hans`t and the Pals couldn`t 15:21  |  Don Camillo 21/06/07
  10.   What would happen if the tables were turned 15:56  |  Murray of Montreal 21/06/07
  11.   Benvenisti is just another self hating apologist 16:02  |  RightClick 21/06/07
  12.   Murray of Montreal - read history 16:47  |  Mike 21/06/07
  13.   Why should they let them in? Why do they need a reason? 18:24  |  McQueen 21/06/07
  14.   "safe passage" was in context of Pal. commitment to fight terror 18:26  |  McQueen 21/06/07
  15.   # 12 maybe you should read history, too 18:28  |  Johanna 21/06/07
  16.   Pogroms 19:10  |  Solomon 21/06/07
  17.   Meron,what do you think would happen should 15 million Germans 21:32  |  Absolute Sweden 21/06/07
  18.   To Don Camilo: Further on Sharon Proposal 23:12  |  Tut Tut 21/06/07
  19.   indrajaya, where is Alan Johnston you promised free last Sunday 03:03  |  Genuine Tosefta 22/06/07
  20.   indrajaya, where is Alan Johnston you promised free last Sunday 03:06  |  Genuine Tosefta 22/06/07
 Today Online
U.S. to increase military aid to Israel under new deal
Responses: 311
UN chief criticizes rights council for targeting Israel
Responses: 187
PM: Egypt summit could mark new beginning with PA
Responses: 117
Editorial: The time has come to release Barghouti
Responses: 131
Moshe Arens: The carnage in Gaza resembles hell
Responses: 67
Some 3,500 take part in Gay Pride parade in J'lem
Responses: 126


More Headlines
03:29 Syria: U.S. is blocking renewal of peace talks
03:31 PM: Egypt summit could pave way for new beginning between Israel, PA
03:20 Half of Gazans evacuated to Egypt by IDF decide to return
23:29 Netanyahu calls for deployment of Jordanian troops in West Bank
02:15 Police uncover weapons lab in home of West Bank settler
22:26 Some 3,500 march in Gay Pride parade in Jerusalem
23:16 Lebanon: Fatah al-Islam defeated, military operation is over
20:59 Few Gazans turn in weapons as Hamas deadline for arms collection expires
18:13 Syrian VP says 'not optimistic' on prospects for peace with Israel
02:53 Putin ally set to win European Jewish Congress presidential elections
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved