Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., June 23, 2007 Tamuz 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:21 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Unmoved by the humanitarian crisis
By Nehemia Shtrasler

From the perspective of Likud chief Benjamin Netanyahu, the Hamas takeover of the Gaza Strip proves that the right-wing stance was correct all along. Israel didn't have to quit Gaza in 2005 or withdraw from Lebanon in 2000, Netanyahu says. The conclusion of Netanyahu and National Union's Zvi Hendel is that Israel should not negotiate over either the Golan Heights or the West Bank, because Syrian President Bashar Assad is unreliable and Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas is weak.

Such a position makes it seem like rockets weren't being fired on Sderot when Israel was deep in Gaza, and Hamas wouldn't have taken control of the strip if the Gush Katif settlement bloc had remained in Israel's hands. Except that if Israel had not withdrawn from Gaza, the Palestinian fire would have been aimed at the settlers, and the Israel Defense Forces would have paid a heavy price to protect them.

But Netanyahu and Hendel are not moved by the death toll. According to their thinking, we will still be living by our swords in another hundred years. They are also unmoved by the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. They think Israel was charitable toward the Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza because the quality of their lives rose during the years of occupation.

Advertisement

But the facts indicate otherwise. In 1970, the gross national product in the West Bank was $250 per capita, and today it is $1,300 - five times as hi gh in nominal terms. During the same period, Jordan experienced 10-fold growth, going from $280 to $2,800.

Similarly, Gaza's GNP rose from $170 per capita in 1970 to $1,000 today, growing six times, while the figure in Egypt rose from $200 to $1,800 - nine times. In other words, the Palestinians' conditions under Israeli rule worsened compared with the region, not to mention the large gap between them and us. Israel's GNP per capita is 20 times larger than the Palestinians'.

Israel has used the resources of the West Bank and Gaza shamefully, taking full advantage of the occupied areas. For years, Israel prevented the Palestinian territories from developing and setting up factories due to opposition from Israeli industrialists, but exploited the cheap and humiliated labor pool. Palestinians stood on endless lines at the Erez Crossing starting at 2 A.M. to land a day's work in Israel. Israel also saw the 3.5 million residents of the West Bank and Gaza as a captive market for Israeli products, generally those of inferior quality. To this day, Israeli factories in the fashion industry continue to take advantage of the cheap labor in Gaza for simple sewing work.

In addition, Israel prevented the Palestinian Authority from setting up a large power station so that it could remain dependent on the Israel Electric Corporation. Israel also prevented the construction of a port so it could control all the imports and exports, and put Dor Energy in charge of supplying the territories with gas.

For 40 years, Israel imprisoned 1.4 million people in the large, neglected and backward refugee camp that is the Gaza Strip, turning them into "the poor that are cast out," as Isaiah would have it. There is a 60-percent unemployment rate in Gaza, and residents depend for sustenance on the rice and hummus they get from the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East. It is a hopeless situation. Parents are unable to provide their children with food, the housing is dismal, the poverty is humiliating, and the filth, neglect and overcrowding cause despair and aggression.

There is virtually no family in Gaza that has not had relatives killed or wounded, that has not suffered degradation. In such a situation, they have nothing to lose other than life itself. It has become clear that when despair goes sufficiently deep, even life holds no attraction. Last week a woman in her ninth month of pregnancy, a mother of eight children, was arrested on her way to carry out a suicide bombing.

When the Palestinians had a strong and widely accepted leader, Yasser Arafat, with whom one could arrive at a final-status solution, Israel depicted him as a monster and imprisoned him in his Muqata headquarters until his death. When Abbas, an easygoing leader, came along afterward, Israel humiliated him and weakened him and damaged the Palestinian Authority. Israel wouldn't agree to let him have even the accomplishment of the withdrawal from Gaza. No wonder then that Hamas won the elections.

There is a lot of talk over here about the large gaps between the income of the top Israeli decile and the bottom decile, gaps that are said to endanger the stability of Israeli society. But what about the gaps between us and the Palestinians? Don't they endanger us? After all, no one wants to live in a "villa in the jungle," as Labor Party leader Ehud Barak put it. No one wants his neighbor to be poor, unemployed and bitter, to be planning to take revenge on him. But that is precisely our situation. That is where our leaders have brought us. Netanyahu and Hendel, though, aren't bothered by this. They want to continue to lead the country on the path of destruction and bereavement - because Rachel's Tomb is more important.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Second to the saints
Neusner believes he's best suited to represent Judaism in its disputes with Christianity.
Spirit of the times
Author Yehudit Hendel merits a central place in the '1948 Generation' pantheon.
  1.   Gaza Analyst 13:45  |  Alex Barak 19/06/07
  2.   Absolutely dishonest 13:52  |  B. 19/06/07
  3.   Strassler,average lifespan for a Russian male is below 60 year 13:57  |  Absolute Sweden 19/06/07
  4.   silly article 13:59  |  joe 19/06/07
  5.   Finally Haaretz is showing it has a pair.. 14:30  |  Joseph 19/06/07
  6.   Forget the facts, your bigotry is key 15:02  |  harold 19/06/07
  7.   Dhimmitude par excellance 15:07  |  Teez El-Nabi 19/06/07
  8.   Just a lovely article 15:15  |  Johnboy 19/06/07
  9.   IS Nehemia from Lala Lala Land 15:17  |  Aaron 19/06/07
  10.   Every word of this... 15:17  |  Yakov 19/06/07
  11.   HAARETZ REMINDS OF THE NAZI PROPOGANDA 15:19  |  HOLOCAUST SURVIVER 19/06/07
  12.   Naive 15:20  |  Ron 19/06/07
  13.   Haaretz, Are You Nuts ?? 15:23  |  Agent Orange 19/06/07
  14.   Part Two 15:35  |  Agent Orange 19/06/07
  15.   It`s pitiful to watch the United States and Israel 15:49  |  George 19/06/07
  16.   even 15:51  |  barosh 19/06/07
  17.   Agree 100% . Thank you for the article 15:59  |  alf 19/06/07
  18.   chosen facts distort 16:09  |  Phil 19/06/07
  19.   HAARETZ HIDDEN AGENDA 16:09  |  AVRUM 19/06/07
  20.   Arafat Destroyed The Pals Economy, Not Israel 16:09  |  Ben Israel 19/06/07
  21.   good for you alf. 16:12  |  George 19/06/07
  22.   Where are the suicide bombers of Darfur and Cambodia? 16:19  |  ME 19/06/07
  23.   TAKE BACK GAZA,W.BANK,PUT AN END TO TERROR, CRISIS,LET ARABS FLEE 16:22  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 19/06/07
  24.   Dont give them and inch - The Rebbe 16:23  |  Lanthis 19/06/07
  25.   Unmoved by the Humanitarian Crisis 16:23  |  Ron Brown 19/06/07
  26.   George. Yes I know. but it is a shame 16:33  |  alf 19/06/07
  27.   Arabs don`t care about money 16:38  |  Tony Benson 19/06/07
  28.   lying with statistics 16:40  |  noah 19/06/07
  29.   Contradcition 16:41  |  Cole 19/06/07
  30.   The figures until 1987 prove Sthrastler wrong 16:55  |  Shalom Freedman 19/06/07
  31.   Enough of Iran sponsored lies 16:58  |  a Jew 19/06/07
  32.   Not analysis but a rant 17:06  |  mike 19/06/07
  33.   Nehemia Shtrasler`s fig leaf 17:07  |  Russian the Frank 19/06/07
  34.   Love your enemies 17:07  |  Garry 19/06/07
  35.   Rachél´s Tomb 17:12  |  Luis M . Fuentes 19/06/07
  36.   To Nehemia Shtrasler ...... 17:13  |  Dagma 19/06/07
  37.   alf thanks for the reply and maybe sanity and the pursuit of 17:24  |  George 19/06/07
  38.   Haaretz is Outrageous!!! Pure Garbage! 17:35  |  Ariel 19/06/07
  39.   Nehamia, Should We Get Brad Pitt.... 17:44  |  Yoram 19/06/07
  40.   What Shtrasler is right about 17:45  |  David Hoffman 19/06/07
  41.   humanitarian crisis 18:20  |  irwin 19/06/07
  42.   Haaretz your neutrality is shoking, how can U B so unbiased 18:26  |  Realy man 19/06/07
  43.   WOW 18:45  |  Baz Mann 19/06/07
  44.   Who`s the occupier now? 18:55  |  Sharpinchi-town 19/06/07
  45.   The time for tikun is upon us at last.... 18:56  |  Esther 19/06/07
  46.   To Holocaust Survivor 18:59  |  sharpinchi-town 19/06/07
  47.   to Nehemia Shtrasler 19:01  |  Sebastian 19/06/07
  48.   Avrum 19:02  |  sharpinchi-town 19/06/07
  49.   Cry me a river 19:10  |  Ron 19/06/07
  50.   " Allow them some dignity and the chance to see a brighter future 19:17  |  alf 19/06/07
  51.   us poor Jews 19:20  |  lb 19/06/07
  52.   to sharpinchi-town 19:22  |  Sebastian 19/06/07
  53.   grat article!! 19:36  |  peter 19/06/07
  54.   big compliments to you, Nehemia Shtrasler 19:40  |  Eva 19/06/07
  55.   Unmoved by the numbers 19:52  |  Jacob Blues 19/06/07
  56.   haha nice try "peter" 19:53  |  Sebastian 19/06/07
  57.   For Ron #49 20:00  |  Esther 19/06/07
  58.   Statistics? What statistics? 20:01  |  Yair ben Avraham 19/06/07
  59.   Unmoved by the humanitarian crisis 20:04  |  al 19/06/07
  60.   #silly article 20:19  |  ap 19/06/07
  61.   # 52 poor Sebastian and ... 20:38  |  Bob 19/06/07
  62.   Better off with Jews and their businesses in Gaza 20:38  |  Bridget 19/06/07
  63.   If Muslims renounced Antijewish hate, thered be no conflict 20:40  |  Hal 19/06/07
  64.   Yes, and we saw Arafat`s imports via the Keren A 20:43  |  Bridget 19/06/07
  65.   Unmoved By Facts - The Lunacy of the Jewish Left 20:57  |  Tod Zuckerman 19/06/07
  66.   Kill the messenger 20:59  |  Janice 19/06/07
  67.   re 59 "unmoved" 21:04  |  Dave 19/06/07
  68.   bobby bobby 21:22  |  Sebastian 19/06/07
  69.   The truth seems to be hurting many here 21:33  |  Mike 19/06/07
  70.   weak argument cause they could have had prosperity w peace, if... 22:12  |  Surgical RN 19/06/07
  71.   Israeli readers 22:55  |  Simply Palestinian 19/06/07
  72.   the well has run dry 23:05  |  NJ 19/06/07
  73.   Please Post my Response 23:32  |  Tod Zuckerman 19/06/07
  74.   Mike from Maryland 23:33  |  Agent Orange 19/06/07
  75.   Daring to think differently 00:06  |  Fiona 20/06/07
  76.   Why not just move? 00:48  |  Chuck 20/06/07
  77.   Good article, pity about the criticism 01:23  |  kevin 20/06/07
  78.   Idiotism 01:26  |  Frank 20/06/07
  79.   israel should pray for a two state solution 01:47  |  janet 20/06/07
  80.   re" 75 because it`s their land 03:29  |  Dave 20/06/07
  81.   Listen to all the dogs barking 05:03  |  Moe 20/06/07
  82.   Israel is guilty ! 05:22  |  Yaron Zohar 20/06/07
  83.   Israel is guilty ! 05:33  |  Yaron Zohar 20/06/07
  84.   An amazing article 08:02  |  very nice article 20/06/07
  85.   War is all Hell 08:25  |  Clayton Niehaus 20/06/07
  86.   Since 1994 09:21  |  Barry 20/06/07
  87.   A good article 09:31  |  David Palmer 20/06/07
  88.   humanitarian=missing IDF boys;stop katusas 2hizbzlz+pay damages 09:41  |  sam 20/06/07
  89.   Confused? 16:37  |  Steven 20/06/07
  90.   Chuck 16:50  |  Steven 20/06/07
  91.   A Bright Light... 16:58  |  jane 20/06/07
  92.   An eyeopener 18:45  |  patrick mcmullen 20/06/07
  93.   The Palestinian Humanitarian Crisis 19:29  |  Mike 20/06/07
  94.   finally a sane opinion 23:26  |  Bob 20/06/07
  95.   You`ve got all your facts & numbers wrong (& so does Netanyahu) 17:36  |  Yigal 21/06/07
  96.   natenyaho 16:37  |  ghazi 23/06/07
 Today Online
Burston: They're here, they're queer, be proud of Israel
Responses: 156
Move to back Abbas gov't blocked in Security Council
Responses: 186
Shmuel Rosner: Is there an alternative to a Palestinian state?
Responses: 145
Yossi Sarid: U.K. boycotters should boycott themselves
Responses: 215
Asher Maoz: ACRI must challenge view of Jewish state as 'foolish' idea
Responses: 52


More Headlines
15:04 IDF arrests founder of Hamas armed wing in West Bank
14:45 Hamas chief Haniyeh calls for fresh Hamas-Fatah talks
17:21 Mubarak calls Hamas' takeover of the Gaza Strip a 'coup'
12:36 3,000 join cycle rally to express support for abducted soldiers
16:56 Three Lebanese soldiers killed in explosion in refugee camp
22:42 Abbas sacks top Fatah security chief after Hamas victory in Gaza
05:43 Israel sends letters to UN criticizing human rights abuses in Iran
10:27 Key U.S. allies consider partial freeze on Iran's nuclear program
05:12 Abbas signals he may shut down private Hamas-affiliated groups
13:29 Mideast Quartet envoys due to meet in Jerusalem next week
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved