Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., June 21, 2007 Tamuz 5, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:54 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Poll: U.S. 'elites' support Israel, but aren't sure it wants peace
By Shmuel Rosner, Haaretz Correspondent
70 percent cited the need to be "a leader in working for peace" as heading the list of 13 qualities required of an American "ally." But only 16 percent saw this among Israel's traits.

A poll commissioned in April by The Israel Project indicates that the "opinion elite" in the United States has warm feelings for Israel but is not convinced Israel wants peace.

The survey's results are being published here for the first time.

TIP, an organization that strives to improve Israel's image in America and the rest of the world, polled 500 representatives of the "opinion elite": college graduates with annual incomes above $75,000, who vote in elections, and read newspapers and magazines.

Advertisement

They were asked, among other things, to rank their attitude toward Israel and Hamas, Syria, Iran and Hezbollah, on a scale of 1 to 100, with below 50 indicating a "cold" attitude and above it a "warm" attitude. Israel received a 66, while the others scored between 19 (Hezbollah) and 30 (Syria).

"Who is to blame for the instability in the Middle East?" the poll asked. Seventy-three percent blamed "Islamic extremism" and only 12 percent named "Israel and its policies."

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, who on Sunday begins his short visit to Washington, which will include meetings with the president and vice president, was already familiar with these survey findings several weeks ago when he hosted in Jerusalem the president of TIP, Jennifer Laszlo Mizrahi, Democratic pollster Stanley Greenberg and President Bush's former press secretary, Ari Fleischer.

They brought figures, data and also recommendations with them. Among the officials who granted the visitors some of their precious time were also Benjamin Netanyahu, Shaul Mofaz, Avi Dichter, Silvan Shalom, Avigdor Lieberman and many others.

TIP is a small but energetic organization that hires the best American pollsters to conduct public opinion surveys. They were initially greeted with distaste, even suspicion in the corridors of the Foreign Ministry, but relations are better now. Aviv Shir-On, the ministry's deputy director general for media and public affairs, delivered a short lecture at a TIP course when he was in Washington two weeks ago.

The poll contains some rather sad working assumptions: 57 percent "strongly agree" that "the Arab countries around Israel are hostile to its existence," and 85 percent overall said they "agree" with that statement. Some 75 percent said they agreed that "the Arabs don't really accept Israel's right to exist."

But there are also findings that suggest a possible course of action. For example, 70 percent cited the need to be "a leader in working for peace" as heading the list of 13 qualities required of an American "ally." But only 16 percent saw this among Israel's traits.

Sixty percent did not agree that "Israel is an obstacle for peace" - but 38 percent did, and 29 percent of them were Republican voters, while 42 percent said they were Democrats. The findings among the general public constitute an improvement over a poll from October 2005, in which 50 percent said Israel is not an obstacle for peace, compared with 43 percent who believed that it was.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Robbed breadwinners
The rabbis have truncated the ultra-Orthodox woman's employment options.
Plastic summer
Bizarre trends are nothing new and what was once off-limits may become ultra-chic.
  1.   You get out what you put in 05:58  |  Natallie Durson 18/06/07
  2.   I wonder what the percentages would be 06:22  |  jana 18/06/07
  3.   Where did they find this 16%??? 06:30  |  dennis 18/06/07
  4.   RE: "Among the officials who granted the visitors some of their 06:54  |  G. Stark 18/06/07
  5.   Natalie#1 Why Don`t You Move To a Typical Arab Country 06:58  |  Gene S. 18/06/07
  6.   Shumel Rosner is an absurd fool that embarrases all of us Jews 07:00  |  amir 18/06/07
  7.   Gene S.: Get out of USA affairs and stay in Israel 08:08  |  omolll 18/06/07
  8.   Part of Israel`s massive spin machine 08:51  |  Clickfool 18/06/07
  9.   Israel, Hamas, Iran, Hezbollah, Islamic extremism.......... 09:10  |  Swiss (Dino) 18/06/07
  10.   U.S. "Elites" 09:27  |  JordanisPalestine 18/06/07
  11.   IT MEANS ONE THING 09:55  |  indrajaya 18/06/07
  12.   indrajaya: you are not wrong, ... 10:06  |  S 18/06/07
  13.   jakarta`s indrajaya 10:38  |  Akiva Patysh 18/06/07
  14.   Thats because Republicans are Evangelicals 12:09  |  Tupac 18/06/07
  15.   US POLLS & ISRAEL 12:33  |  ADEDEJI OLADELE 18/06/07
  16.   #14 TUPAC HW ABOUT GIVING THE USA BACK ?? 12:48  |  paul harris 18/06/07
  17.   US POLLS & ISRAEL 12:51  |  ADEDEJI OLADELE 18/06/07
  18.   US POLLS & ISRAEL 12:51  |  ADEDEJI OLADELE 18/06/07
  19.   ISRAEL WANTS PEACE WHILE ARABS ONLY WANT PIECE 12:54  |  linda 18/06/07
  20.   #2 Jana: Icareaboutdarfur.com 13:50  |  Ronnie Wolman 18/06/07
  21.   Teach: 1 + 1 = 2 13:52  |  School of life 18/06/07
  22.   No surprise in poll 14:14  |  Mark Lincoln 18/06/07
  23.   polling average americans! 14:17  |  average american 18/06/07
  24.   Natallie, you`re in every talkback on this website. 15:13  |  martyrmaker 18/06/07
  25.   IN MESSIANIC TIMES ATTITUDE OF GOYIM CHANGES FROM HATRED TO LOVE 15:32  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 18/06/07
  26.   Read them and weep....US NOT sympathetic to terror 15:35  |  The Equalizer 18/06/07
  27.   U.S `elites aren`t sure Israel wants peace ? 15:44  |  kim segar 18/06/07
  28.   Dino the swiss irrelevance 16:01  |  angelique 18/06/07
  29.   ah, never trust the Jews hey Natalie? 16:04  |  Angelique 18/06/07
  30.   I am sure 16:17  |  John 18/06/07
  31.   Who`s To Blame? Hey! I know! I Know ! 16:29  |  Tony Anthony 18/06/07
  32.   #19, Linda - it`s quite the reverse 16:45  |  A Bethlehemite 18/06/07
  33.   Looking at it rationally.... 16:48  |  JES 18/06/07
  34.   Agree #19, LInda,... Hey Natalie suppose you.. 16:58  |  Michael Korn 18/06/07
  35.   Clickfool 17:25  |  sel 18/06/07
  36.   # 28 "angelique", the Phantom of the Opera 18:35  |  Swiss (Dino) 18/06/07
  37.   Well if you can`t even fool the americans 18:55  |  Tootsie 18/06/07
  38.   Incredible, they are smart at last!@! 18:58  |  Sharif Hafez 18/06/07
  39.   35 19:08  |  Elias 18/06/07
  40.   Keep trying, Sel in Dallas # 35 19:20  |  Clickfool 18/06/07
  41.   Tiny Dino mite 19:35  |  Angelique 18/06/07
  42.   Martyrmaker in Milan 20:17  |  CHGODMK 18/06/07
  43.   Swiss Dino and She-Males 20:21  |  CHGODMK 18/06/07
  44.   Angelique re: Swiss Dino 20:23  |  CHGODMK 18/06/07
  45.   Peace is very risky to Israel. 20:27  |  Ibrahim 18/06/07
  46.   @29 Angelique 21:35  |  Mark B. 18/06/07
  47.   the Israeli/American propaganda machine in action 21:35  |  peacelover 18/06/07
  48.   Well, Who`s To Blame For Burning 3000 Americans Alive? 22:08  |  Yosemite 18/06/07
  49.   Realizing that Peace comes in Pipes 22:14  |  Efox 18/06/07
  50.   Ibrahim 22:43  |  Danite 18/06/07
  51.   Cold feelings for Israel --the other survey 22:54  |  dutch 18/06/07
  52.   Israel once again, avoids the truth... 23:24  |  Dutch 18/06/07
  53.   Israel and War 00:24  |  matt hood 19/06/07
  54.   Mark B in EU re: Natallie Durson 00:31  |  CHGODMK 19/06/07
  55.   #23-Average American 00:58  |  Ben 19/06/07
  56.   With the interference of... 01:04  |  Edith 19/06/07
  57.   Assessing the risk!!!!!! 02:01  |  Blogowitz 19/06/07
  58.   Clickfool 02:07  |  American in NY 19/06/07
  59.   its clear that the u.s. ""elites"" 02:59  |  eric 19/06/07
  60.   US Elites are warm toward Israel 03:11  |  Richard Clark 19/06/07
  61.   When Israel elites learn to communicate 04:28  |  Lou 19/06/07
  62.   Mark B: Who Killed Van Gogh Over A Movie? 04:33  |  GeneRx 19/06/07
  63.   Who are these "elite"....? 04:53  |  Edward 19/06/07
  64.   TO KIM SEGAR #27 05:10  |  Steve Beikirch 19/06/07
  65.   TO IBRAHIM #45 05:17  |  Steve Beikirch 19/06/07
  66.   Better image in America? 06:17  |  Better freedom in Is 19/06/07
  67.   Ben 06:40  |  Silvienne 19/06/07
  68.   Time for doing politics is not now. 07:55  |  Akram Zekaria 19/06/07
  69.   #52 DORIS IS THTA THE SAM POPULATION THAT ELECTED GEORGE BUSH 08:09  |  paul harris 19/06/07
  70.   #67 ARE THEY THE SAME ONES WHO DONT BELIEV IN WORKING S 08:10  |  paul harris 19/06/07
  71.   TUPAC."Republicans are Evangelicalls".All of them? 10:33  |  PETER SM 19/06/07
  72.   IBRAHIM."Peace is risky" Look around at who kills most Arabs? 10:45  |  PETER SM 19/06/07
  73.   thanks Jana # 2 for www.ifamericansknew.org 11:39  |  suad 19/06/07
  74.   NO similarities in Australia 12:19  |  v 19/06/07
  75.   NO similarities in Australia 12:24  |  VIPER 19/06/07
  76.   #53, MATT HOOD, well said 12:26  |  VIPER 19/06/07
  77.   israel 13:09  |  Paul Artherton 19/06/07
  78.   Proof... Propaganda Works 15:18  |  JC 19/06/07
  79.   #7 omell, apparently you can`t read.. 15:28  |  John Allen 19/06/07
  80.   #23 Average American? 15:37  |  John Allen 19/06/07
  81.   U.S. elites? 15:49  |  John Allen 19/06/07
  82.   Isreal 18:39  |  Lisa DeCesare 19/06/07
  83.   #23 Avg Amer - you don`t know what youre talking about 19:21  |  sheri 19/06/07
  84.   Title is misleading - it twists the numbers 19:30  |  sheri 19/06/07
  85.   #76 - Viper so you agree Israel should exist 20:36  |  sheri 19/06/07
  86.   #45 - Peace isn`t risky to Israel 20:48  |  sheri 19/06/07
  87.   #2 Jana - careful about your data 20:53  |  sheri 19/06/07
  88.   #2 Jana - for instance did you know about tree burning 20:54  |  sheri 19/06/07
  89.   #86, sheri, i do and i don`t 02:19  |  VIPER 20/06/07
  90.   Viper 08:11  |  Silvienne 20/06/07
  91.   Sheri 08:12  |  Silvienne 20/06/07
  92.   Peace is a "Zionist plot" 17:58  |  Yaner 20/06/07
  93.   #90, silvienne, please accept my appoligy 12:48  |  VIPER 21/06/07
 Today Online
U.S. to increase military aid to Israel under new deal
Responses: 97
UN chief criticizes rights council for targeting Israel
Responses: 68
Abbas aide: Egypt to host Olmert-Abbas summit next week
Responses: 23
Editorial: The time has come to release Barghouti
Responses: 29
Moshe Arens: The carnage in Gaza resembles hell
Responses: 12
Israel Harel: Mahmoud Abbas is a fiction
Responses: 13
Rosner's Domain
* Bush & Olmert: Between a vision and a mirage
* Henry Kissinger got us, Warren Christopher didn't
* WTR: No circumcision for US boys
* Susan Schnur: Ambivalent about the Jewish mother


More Headlines
12:44 Syrian FM: We're 'more than ready' to renew talks
12:32 Egypt to host Olmert-Abbas summit next week
12:53 Judge: Suspected Natan-Zada killers likely won't be indicted
10:37 IDF evacuates Gazans to Egypt under deal struck with Cairo
10:19 Police to dispatch 7,000 officers to Jerusalem Gay Pride parade
09:22 Ban Ki-moon criticizes UN Human Rights Council for singling Israel out
04:20 U.S. to increase military aid to Israel in decade-long deal
12:06 Selection panel told Supreme Court candidates will favor bank sector
12:09 Police arrest 14-year-old on charges of sexual assault
03:37 Education Ministry nixes program for special needs kindergarteners
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved