Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., June 22, 2007 Tamuz 6, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:20 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Julian Soufir during his arraignment in Tel Aviv court. (Nir Kider)
Last update - 19:54 17/06/2007
Man held for murder of Arab cab driver ruled unfit to stand trial
By Nir Hasoon, Haaretz Correspondent

Julian Soufir, accused of murdering taxi driver Taysir Kariki in Tel Aviv in May has been ruled unfit to stand trial according to a psychiatric evaluation presented to the Tel Aviv regional court on Sunday.

The evaluation, which was written by three psychiatrists at the Abarbanel Hospital ruled that at the time of the murder Soufir was in a psychotic state and was not aware of his actions. The evaluation also ruled that Soufir is today still in a psychotic state and therefore unfit to stand trial.

Prosecutors have announced that they intend to examine the evaluations in order to possibly appeal the court's ruling and force Soufir to stand trial for his offenses.

Advertisement

Family member of Kariki's who were present at the time of the ruling erupted in outrage shouting at the Judges that the ruling was a case of discrimination.

An attorney for the Kariki family Mayson Zahalkha said that "they were outraged and fear that he [Soufir] will not receive the punishment he deserves. The way he planned and carried out the murder show that he was fully aware of what he was doing, and his nationalist intentions for doing so only further illustrate this point."

Zahalkha added that "If this was a case of an Arab murdering a Jew, we would never have seen a ruling like this in regard to the mental or emotional state of the accused."

Last week Zahalkha petitioned the High Court of Justice to gain access to the full contents of the police investigation of the murder, including the psychiatric evaluation.

The indictment against Soufir reads that on May 14 Soufir hailed a cab driven by an Arab driver and had him take him to Netanya. When they arrived at Soufir's apartment, Soufir said he had to run upstairs to grab some money, and he returned to the car concealing a knife he had taken from the apartment. Soufir then asked Kariki to take him to Tel Aviv.

According to the indictment, after arriving at the apartment, Soufir invited Kariki to come upstairs so he could use the bathroom and give him something to drink. The driver entered the bathroom in the apartment, and after he came out, Soufir was waiting for him with the knife he had taken from the apartment in Netanya.

The indictment reads that "when the victim exited the bathroom, the accused stabbed him in his neck and back 24 times with the intent to kill."

Soufir then stole NIS 60 from the driver's pocket as well as the keys to the taxi.

The indictment ruled that the murder was carried out for nationalistic and racist motives, and because of the hatred of the accused towards Arabs.

In his confession to police, Soufir said that when he stabbed Kariki, he "didn't feel anything, it was like slaughtering an animal. That's all the Arabs are, they have no soul."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Professional help
Offering the finance portfolio to a successful businessman is tempting, but unwise.
Palm qualms
Palm trees planted along a stretch of Ibn Gvirol Street have irked residents.
  1.   psychotic state vs psychotic 16:06  |  Kate 17/06/07
  2.   What a surprise 16:36  |  Emilio 17/06/07
  3.   "Taxi, taxi, taxi" 16:39  |  Rd Rubin 17/06/07
  4.   Unfit to stand trial? 16:42  |  Rebekah S 17/06/07
  5.   "If this was a case of an Arab murdering a Jew ... 16:43  |  Binyamin Dissen 17/06/07
  6.   He wasn`t wearing a uniform 16:52  |  Benny Weiss 17/06/07
  7.   One of many reasons why Pals behave the way they do 17:19  |  An Arab Neighbor 17/06/07
  8.   Getting away with murder 17:35  |  Chris Linthwaite 17/06/07
  9.   No doubt he is a psycho 17:51  |  Bruce 17/06/07
  10.   Not at all surprised. 17:55  |  Deborah 17/06/07
  11.   If all crazy Jews 18:09  |  Mohammed Hussein 17/06/07
  12.   Well he was sane enough 18:15  |  Kenneth Brown 17/06/07
  13.   A hero to many Israelis 18:18  |  Cancer grows 17/06/07
  14.   Race makes a difference 18:34  |  Erik 17/06/07
  15.   As a fairly right-wing Israeli.... 18:39  |  Noa 17/06/07
  16.   #12 I agree 19:31  |  FlimFlamNY 17/06/07
  17.   #15 They will probably pin a medal on him and 19:34  |  FlimFlamNY 17/06/07
  18.   As a Zionist Jew 19:36  |  Bill 17/06/07
  19.   No Act Of Discrimination Goes Unnoticed 19:44  |  World Opinion 17/06/07
  20.   HITLER WAS PSYCHOTIC TOO.. 19:45  |  DAN THE MAN 17/06/07
  21.   Self Righteous Europeans 19:47  |  Binyamin Dissen 17/06/07
  22.   From an American Jew 19:51  |  Ben 17/06/07
  23.   #13 Not a Hero in this state! 19:53  |  Kate 17/06/07
  24.   now what? 19:59  |  sal 17/06/07
  25.   Justice Israeli style... 20:03  |  moll 17/06/07
  26.   I hope prosecutors are able to appeal 21:07  |  Gina 17/06/07
  27.   Chris Linthwaite 22:46  |  Gina 17/06/07
  28.   The family is correct 08:58  |  David Teich 18/06/07
  29.   To Gina #27 17:39  |  The Judge 19/06/07
  30.   To Gina #27 17:39  |  The Judge 19/06/07
  31.   30: A judge from Hollywood? right... (3rd try) 17:26  |  David Teich 22/06/07
 Today Online
Burston: They're here, they're queer, be proud of Israel
Responses: 80
Move to back Abbas gov't blocked in Security Council
Responses: 29
Shmuel Rosner: Is there an alternative to a Palestinian state?
Responses: 28
Yossi Sarid: U.K. boycotters should boycott themselves
Responses: 79
Asher Maoz: ACRI must challenge view of Jewish state as 'foolish' idea
Responses: 23
Rosner's Domain
* WTR: Last look at the skeletons of Kurt Waldheim
* Susan Schnur: Ambivalent about the Jewish mother
* Henry Kissinger got us, Warren Christopher didn't


More Headlines
18:08 Abbas sacks top Fatah security chief after Hamas victory in Gaza
17:08 House okays Egypt aid cut over Gaza smuggling, human rights
15:47 Lieberman slams plan to free PA tax funds as gesture to Abbas
16:43 Envoys from Mideast Quartet to meet in Jerusalem on Tuesday
14:36 Security forces nab 'Hezbollah-trained' suspect in W. Bank raid
13:36 U.S.-led move to back Abbas gov't blocked in Security Council
14:46 Report: Iran says it has 100 kg 'enriched uranium materials'
17:55 Woman killed, four seriously injured in blaze in southern Tel Aviv
15:59 Scholars mark 60th anniversary of publication of Anne Frank`s Diary
13:37 Two men killed in separate car accidents over weekend
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved