Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., June 20, 2007 Tamuz 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:43 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 09:59 17/06/2007
ANALYSIS / Hamas is a wolf in moderate clothing
By Avi Issacharoff and Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondents

In a press conference in Damascus on Friday, Hamas political chief Khaled Meshal looked like an abusive husband trying to convince his wife to return home.

"We have no plans to control Gaza," Meshal claimed. "We were forced to take over as an emergency measure." He explained that "Hamas plans to cooperate with Mahmoud Abbas for the good of the Palestinian people."

Hamas Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh, for his part, claimed that his organization is still committed to Palestinian unity.

Advertisement

The statements sound less than honest less than 24 hours after Hamas militants conducted a murderous political purge of the Gaza Strip. The past three days have included the arrests of dozens of senior Fatah officials, the looting of the Presidential Palace, and the robbing of
homes of anyone ever associated with Fatah.

Not only Yasser Arafat's residence, but the home of businessman Ihab Al-Askhar who hasn't been active in Fatah for 13 years and that of Mohammed Dahlan's mother.

Hamas is trying to bring routine back to Gaza's streets. Once again, Hamas is wrapping itself in moderate garb and explaining that it didn't act against Fatah, only against Dahlan's branch.

Hamas even promises the imminent release of abducted BBC journalist Alan Johnston as part of law and order measures.

But despite efforts to create the appearance of business as usual, Hamas leaders face a complex task.

Meshal, Haniyeh and particularly the leaders of the military wing green-lighted not only the civil war, but also atrocities like the execution of Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigade militant Samiah Al-Madhoun.

Hamas militants who abused corpses, threw fellow Palestinians off high-rises, burned and looted, will have trouble getting up the next day looking like a law-abiding public.

And it is not just the street Hamas will have trouble controlling. The organization's supposed mainstream also has a prominent extremist group that sees Fatah as a gang of heretics.

Fatah officials, too, are trying to create the impression of business as usual. Salam Fayad was appointed to head a Palestinian emergency government that probably no one understands how will function and may only emphasize the rift between the West Bank and Gaza. Many in Fatah believe their last hope after the serious blow to Dahlan is in an Israeli prison.

However, it seems restoring Fatah to its former glory in Gaza will be too big a job, even for a freed Marwan Barghouti.

The Israeli defense establishment had two approaches to the situation over the weekend: one viewed the events gravely and claimed that Fatah's defeat would lead to a serious deterioration of Israel-PA relations. The second sought a ray of light. They said it comes from the fact everything is clearer now in Gaza. There are no more "bad" and "good" Palestinians. There is one address in Gaza; Hamas, with which it is possible to speak only with force.

Either way, the defense establishment assumes Hamas will be interested in the short term in calm with Israel to stabilize its hold on the strip. The central dilemma for Israel is opening the border crossings. In a few days, reports will appear in the media about the suffering of Gaza residents. It is unlikely it will be possible to dump the problem on Egypt's doorstep, since that country is not enthusiastic to let most of the goods into Gaza from its territory via the Rafah crossing.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Killer pussycat
Looks can deceive: Ehud Barak looks harmless, but his claws are as sharp as ever.
Lame duck quandary
During his last year in office, Bush will have to decide whether to strike Iran or not.
  1.   This article is both inflammatory and dishonest,because it omits 03:27  |  lakshmi 17/06/07
  2.   Analysis by Avi Issacharoff &Amos Harel 04:11  |  sandra chitayat 17/06/07
  3.   #1 lakshmi 04:32  |  Bill 17/06/07
  4.   Hamas is trapped 04:59  |  B 17/06/07
  5.   #1 spread your propaganda elsewhere 05:12  |  McQueen 17/06/07
  6.   Lakshmi why this big love to Hamasi? 05:16  |  Sayani 17/06/07
  7.   #1..Lakshmi 05:19  |  Nemesis 17/06/07
  8.   lakshimi 05:20  |  Jon 17/06/07
  9.   The Logical Next Step For Hamas 05:20  |  Tony Anthony 17/06/07
  10.   time to take responsibility #1 05:21  |  real vision 17/06/07
  11.   egypt allowed weapons drugs smuggled in why not food electricity 05:25  |  ralph 17/06/07
  12.   atrocities? 05:28  |  jbennett 17/06/07
  13.   to laksmi - sorry buddy, looks like 100 were killed 05:37  |  Jon 17/06/07
  14.   Master Blaster 05:41  |  NJ 17/06/07
  15.   blame israel 06:19  |  rico 17/06/07
  16.   50% chance 06:37  |  dr danielito 17/06/07
  17.   arafat 06:51  |  matthew 17/06/07
  18.   Shut down Gaza border crossings 07:46  |  Gili 17/06/07
  19.   To number 4 07:51  |  Asaf 17/06/07
  20.   For lakshmi #1 08:03  |  Esther 17/06/07
  21.   Disguising Itself In Moderate Garb? 08:19  |  Terry 17/06/07
  22.   HAMAS WILL BE TAKEN OUT 08:24  |  JON FIGENBAUM 17/06/07
  23.   #4 - and Hamas is also totally `dependent` on Israel and Egypt ! 08:34  |  redmike 17/06/07
  24.   dr. danielito 50% chance!! 10:06  |  S 17/06/07
  25.   A routine response from Israel and its spinmeisters 10:16  |  Clickfool 17/06/07
  26.   moderateclothes, who believes that??? 10:30  |  michel 17/06/07
  27.   Analysis Hamas 10:38  |  John Bloom 17/06/07
  28.   #18, S 10:45  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/06/07
  29.   Atrocities is when the other guy does it? 10:46  |  Eyal 17/06/07
  30.   If David Copperfield would only be Israeli..... 10:59  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/06/07
  31.   Its all gone Matthew: Arafat has officially expired.. 11:26  |  Egypt 17/06/07
  32.   #31, Egypt 11:57  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/06/07
  33.   EGYPT Israel should ask Egyptian help they have been executing 12:22  |  PETER SM 17/06/07
  34.   8Jon,and other critics,yes a 100 in such situations is surprising 12:39  |  lakshmi 17/06/07
  35.   Yet again for Cliclfool of Sussex #25 12:52  |  Esther 17/06/07
  36.   Cipora #28 13:03  |  S 17/06/07
  37.   Coalition partners? 13:25  |  Ben Azai 17/06/07
  38.   Sure? 13:29  |  Angelo Tito Anselmi 17/06/07
  39.   Lakshmi: There is something I must be telling you 13:41  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  40.   Lakshmi , those you want to excuse.. 13:49  |  Karl 17/06/07
  41.   #34, S 13:50  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/06/07
  42.   Swiss #30 - Christ, you`re such a nerd! 13:54  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  43.   Egypt where the Moslem brotherhood has been killed and impisoned 14:01  |  PETER SM 17/06/07
  44.   Amos, Israel is the real wolf in poor victim clothing... 14:07  |  Dutch 17/06/07
  45.   Analysis / Hamas are terrorists in outdated clothing 14:27  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  46.   #42, WWACD 14:31  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/06/07
  47.   How much is the Judas money the Gaza men receive? 14:44  |  HH Humanity 17/06/07
  48.   To Cipora: Not just pseudonym, acronym - that`s why 14:45  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  49.   #44 DORIS HAVE YOU ACOPY OF WEBSTERS ?? 15:02  |  paul harris 17/06/07
  50.   WOW! 15:17  |  Danite 17/06/07
  51.   Cipora #41 15:33  |  S 17/06/07
  52.   # 46 Cipora Julianna Kohn Which is it...??? 15:34  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/06/07
  53.   Gaza is Egypt 16:01  |  Herbert Kaine 17/06/07
  54.   Gaza is Egypt 16:01  |  Herbert Kaine 17/06/07
  55.   Cipora Julianna Kohn re: WWACD 16:14  |  CHGODMK 17/06/07
  56.   Hamas, with which it is possible to speak only with force? 16:15  |  Fritz 17/06/07
  57.   Swiss Dino: You Are Wrong 16:20  |  CHGODMK 17/06/07
  58.   WWACD re: Swiss Dino 16:30  |  CHGODMK 17/06/07
  59.   # 54 CHGODMK alias WWACD 16:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/06/07
  60.   Cheers CHGODMK 16:57  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  61.   A Chimp in a Suit Is Still a Chimp 17:00  |  Jane 17/06/07
  62.   Swiss Dino 17:27  |  CHGODMK 17/06/07
  63.   Swissmiss: can`t you have your mommy check your spelling? 17:28  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  64.   Clickfool Is A Wolf In Moderate Clothing 17:33  |  Tony Anthony 17/06/07
  65.   WWACD "keeping you in check on this board." 18:02  |  David Burst 17/06/07
  66.   # 60 / # 61 CHGODMK / WWACD Time for a new hobby ??? 18:22  |  Swiss (Dino) 17/06/07
  67.   #63 18:31  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  68.   A shallow non-analysis 18:34  |  Tosefta 17/06/07
  69.   Palestian Dependancy is the root cause 18:56  |  Joel in Albany 17/06/07
  70.   Gaza is Palestine and not Egypt:Herbert Kaine 19:18  |  Egyptian 17/06/07
  71.   it is FATAH who is a wolf in the moderate garb 19:22  |  Bob 17/06/07
  72.   Peter SM: Hamas is a wasp... 19:25  |  Egyptian 17/06/07
  73.   Swiss Neutrality 19:28  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  74.   The Swiss mind`s acumen penetrating my web of lies 19:44  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  75.   68Tosefta, the reasons?with abbas receving additional funds and 19:47  |  lakshmi 17/06/07
  76.   Thanks for the chuckle, Esther # 35 19:49  |  Clickfool 17/06/07
  77.   Gaza is Egypt 19:51  |  Herbert Kaine 17/06/07
  78.   get rid of Gaza 20:21  |  Al 17/06/07
  79.   Classifieds: Swiss laughing stock in dire need of translator 20:28  |  WWACD 17/06/07
  80.   61 Jane, the chimp in a suit is your man Dahlan,the quisling 20:38  |  lakshmi 17/06/07
  81.   Lakshmi #75 20:49  |  Tosefta 17/06/07
  82.   Egyptian, what are the "policies against fatah and Arafat" 20:58  |  Bruce 17/06/07
  83.   53 - Egypt has assisted the PA in smuggling weapons 21:03  |  Bruriah Sarah 17/06/07
  84.   Lakshmi the Apologist 21:08  |  Zebulonguy 17/06/07
  85.   #4 you nailed it on the head 21:18  |  Marcus