Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., June 18, 2007 Tamuz 2, 5767 | | Israel Time: 16:47 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The bystanders
By Avi Issacharoff

On Monday, civil war broke out in the Gaza Strip. Over the next 24 hours, atrocities were perpetrated there. Shifa Hospital in Gaza City was shelled with mortars, four people were killed in a gunfight at Beit Hanun's hospital, and the Fatah chief in the northern Gaza Strip was executed barbarously.

However, the prime time TV newscasts in Israel dealt with the Labor Party primary to be held the next day. Somewhere during their newscasts, Channels 2 and 10 mentioned the fighting in Gaza. The two mass-circulation dailies Yedioth Ahronoth and Ma'ariv found no room Tuesday for even one word about the fierce fighting in Gaza, in which 11 Palestinians were killed on Monday.

It is difficult to fathom why such major media outlets utterly ignored the developments in the Palestinian arena. Undoubtedly, if the Israel Defense Forces had shelled a Palestinian hospital, even accidentally, a huge furor would have arisen in Israel, the international community would have condemned the action - with calls for a boycott and punitive measures - and the newspapers would have reported the terrible event extensively. But if it's a case of Palestinians shooting at other Palestinians, even if dozens of hospital patients are under attack, who cares?

Advertisement

Perhaps the Israeli media's disinterest at the beginning of the week stems from a weariness of the Palestinian issue. For the umpteenth time, they are killing each other. The Israeli occupation, which is considered only slightly more attractive as a news item, had nothing to do with it, so apparently there was no reason to deal with the neighbors in Gaza. Maybe Labor's power struggle between Ami Ayalon and Ehud Barak was considered better for ratings.

Probably, though, the disregard of the Palestinian question by the papers and TV stems in part from the Israeli dream of making the Palestinian problem go away and disengaging from Gaza. It's the continuation of Israel's policy of the past few years for the territories' residents: disengagement, separation fence, convergence.

No one wants to hear about what's happening "there," on the other side of the fence - the suffering, the distress, the dead and the wounded - as long as it has nothing to do with Israelis. As long as it doesn't affect the stock market. Getting involved with Gaza returns Israelis to the alleys of the place they wanted to forget about after the disengagement.

The same people who found time this week to report at length about Paris Hilton took no interest even in the dramatic implications of Hamas' takeover of the Gaza Strip: the death of the diplomatic process, which had been dying in any case, the blow to Israel's peace camp and the Palestinian Authority, and the death of the "moderate Hamas" concept (the Hamas one can talk to), which died on the 18th floor of the building from which immoderate Hamas activists threw a Fatah man.

Neglect of any serious discussion on the subject is part of the Israeli attempt to create the illusion of a well-ordered Western country, lacking enemies or worries, and preoccupied with the character of the newly elected Labor Party chairman, the exploits of the national under-21 soccer team and the struggle between the justice minister and the Supreme Court president.

The Palestinians do not meet the criteria of "entertainews" - entertaining, light news that attracts Israeli viewers who have had their fill of wars, terrorism and casualties, and certainly if the victims are residents of Gaza.

But unfortunately for many people in Israel, the desperate attempts to disengage from the Palestinians are not very successful. The desire to avoid the tough questions about the region's future after the fall of Gaza to Hamas recalls Israel's disregard of what happened in Lebanon after the IDF withdrawal in 2000 and Hezbollah's takeover of the south of the country.

The grim future that looms for Gaza's 1.3 million inhabitants threatens to have implications for Sderot and the surrounding area, and may even pull Israel back "there." If not just now, then after Hamas completes its takeover of the Gaza Strip.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
White-and-blue beat
Despite high hopes, Israel finishes last in U-21 UEFA championship in Belgium.
Divine theft
Private Haredi schools receive state funding public school desperately need.
  1.   THE ARABS HAVE BEEN KILLIN EACH OTHER FOR A1000 YEARS 11:29  |  paul harris 15/06/07
  2.   Why should I care? 11:51  |  Big Al 15/06/07
  3.   HEY INDRAJAYA & Cie, THE IDF 5th COLUMN, YOU ARE IN LATE! 11:59  |  MOSHEH 15/06/07
  4.   Just wondering why 12:33  |  Cato 15/06/07
  5.   Killing the "own" people and killing the "other" people 12:34  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/06/07
  6.   Of course not 12:44  |  Dr David I. Gross 15/06/07
  7.   Ostrich mentality 12:54  |  Boris 15/06/07
  8.   It only confirms... 13:26  |  Lena 15/06/07
  9.   pass the candies and sweets around!!! 13:34  |  JL 15/06/07
  10.   TO #6 DINO. SOME PEOPLES ARE HONOURED, SOME OTHERS ARE IGNORED 13:35  |  MOSHEH 15/06/07
  11.   # 3, MOSHEH 13:36  |  indrajaya 15/06/07
  12.   they are killing infedils the say 14:07  |  paul 15/06/07
  13.   Not even one word... 14:20  |  akiva P 15/06/07
  14.   HI INDRAJAYA, MASTERPIECE OF IDF 5th COLUMN! NICE TO READ YOU... 14:23  |  MOSHEH 15/06/07
  15.   TOILET PAPER AND HUMAN RIGHTS 14:57  |  Julia M. 15/06/07
  16.   Bystanders- Is it good for the Jews? 14:57  |  colman 15/06/07
  17.   #15 JULIA WAS THER AND HANDED OUT THE PAPER 15:21  |  paul harris 15/06/07
  18.   If it wasn`t so pathetic, it would be a riot! 15:33  |  Nechama 15/06/07
  19.   opportunity created 15:36  |  bobby 15/06/07
  20.   to Julia M 15:39  |  Geoff 15/06/07
  21.   To Julia # 15 15:43  |  smeze75 15/06/07
  22.   Maybe The Bystanders Are Disgusted With Them. 15:43  |  Tony Anthony 15/06/07
  23.   How many died in Darfur this week 15:57  |  Jacob Blues 15/06/07
  24.   #16 Don`t Hold Your Breath. 16:02  |  Tony Anthony 15/06/07
  25.   Disengagement&Road Map gave us anarchy 16:18  |  sam 15/06/07
  26.   We do care 16:26  |  Walter 15/06/07
  27.   Bravo to no.17!!! 16:48  |  Sara 15/06/07
  28.   Julia is right, the condition in Gaza are treeeible 16:59  |  Ana 15/06/07
  29.   Swiss (Dino) - there is plenty of coverage 17:01  |  Sonia 15/06/07
  30.   # 23 Jacob Makes A Good Point 17:17  |  Tony Anthony 15/06/07
  31.   Of course nobody cares 17:30  |  TT 15/06/07
  32.   The Brit Academics on Islamic War Crimes 17:42  |  HonestAbe 15/06/07
  33.   Avi - the media has grown up? 18:14  |  Anonymous 15/06/07
  34.   Julia #15 18:17  |  Mickey 15/06/07
  35.   Not indifferent - just Leftist 18:21  |  William 15/06/07
  36.   Cato - Just wondering #4 18:26  |  William 15/06/07
  37.   Have you truly watched these channels? - Dino#5 18:30  |  William 15/06/07
  38.   BBC 18:49  |  Ben Azai 15/06/07
  39.   Palestinians killing each other dont bother Amira and Gideon Levy 19:04  |  Ken Jurist 15/06/07
  40.   Actually it has huge coverage in Australia 19:07  |  Marilyn 15/06/07
  41.   The Killing of Palestinians. 19:09  |  David Nigel Braham 15/06/07
  42.   #2 - decent Palestinians 19:09  |  Rick 15/06/07
  43.   BE FAIR.. 19:11  |  MIKE 15/06/07
  44.   Why should anyone care? 19:16  |  Mark Lincoln 15/06/07
  45.   Julia M 19:37  |  John 15/06/07
  46.   #29, William 19:43  |  Hannah 15/06/07
  47.   #30, Ben Azai 19:50  |  Hannah 15/06/07
  48.   to 1. Big Al & others 19:59  |  Eva 15/06/07
  49.   USA Media didn`t really cover either 20:18  |  David 15/06/07
  50.   # 10 Moshe Which "club" you want Israel to be a member ??? 20:22  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/06/07
  51.   We can`t afford not to care. 20:32  |  sg 15/06/07
  52.   # 31 William, we are not behind the times in Switzerland..... 20:41  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/06/07
  53.   Gaza beoble will always back the winner, regardless of ideology 20:51  |  Jalal 15/06/07
  54.   The bystanders 20:52  |  Luiz Felipe Haddad 15/06/07
  55.   #44 Hannah and the BBC 21:42  |  Ben Azai 15/06/07
  56.   # 26 Sonia 21:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/06/07
  57.   Jalal #51- u R poor & hungry, but u have computer & internet :-) 21:55  |  Sonia 15/06/07
  58.   #41 Rich 22:10  |  Eva 15/06/07
  59.   Nobody cares unless a Jew is involved. 22:32  |  ronit 15/06/07
  60.   To Rick from Garland 23:00  |  WWACD 15/06/07
  61.   to Mosheh # 10 23:00  |  kameel 15/06/07
  62.   to Mosheh # 10 23:16  |  kameel 15/06/07
  63.   It`s our fault 23:51  |  WWACD 15/06/07
  64.   Kameel 23:58  |  ChanahS 15/06/07
  65.   #54 - You misunderstood 00:06  |  Rick 16/06/07
  66.   #57 - not all anyone`s fault 00:32  |  Rick 16/06/07
  67.   You`re goddamn right we don`t bloody care!!! 00:44  |  WWACD 16/06/07
  68.   #62 No, Rick from Garland, you misunderstood 01:01  |  WWACD 16/06/07
  69.   Ms Zonia, forgive me, but I am in Rafah on the Egybtian side 01:02  |  Jalal 16/06/07
  70.   pals only news when jews involved otherwise just a footnote in hi 01:11  |  ralph 16/06/07
  71.   To indrajaya # 11 01:30  |  Bob 16/06/07
  72.   #44, ben Azai 02:03  |  Hannah 16/06/07
  73.   @15, julia, @17, paul. and it is good for the nature, less destr 02:13  |  vladimir 16/06/07
  74.   Arab Muslims make a farse out of "peace activists" 02:30  |  Hal 16/06/07
  75.   In Response To Cato #4 04:11  |  Vicki 16/06/07
  76.   Hannah 04:26  |  Vicki 16/06/07
  77.   #31 Dino 04:32  |  Vicki 16/06/07
  78.   israel won`t annihilate the remnants of 05:15  |  maria 16/06/07
  79.   RE:22 (Tony Anthony) Arabs killing arabs 06:01  |  Mohamed 16/06/07
  80.   No peace in our time, no independent palestinian state(s) 06:27  |  Voice of Reason 16/06/07
  81.   Mohamed-the civil war ended slavery 06:33  |  Me 16/06/07
  82.   Indra 06:48  |  Gary Lea 16/06/07
  83.   #79 Bob 07:02  |  Willy 16/06/07
  84.   I disagree!!! 07:06  |  Willy 16/06/07
  85.   killing the "own" people and killing the "other" people 07:41  |  david 16/06/07
  86.   Until Pals start placing value on human life.... 08:12  |  Klaudia