Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., June 17, 2007 Tamuz 1, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:49 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
In the path of the founding fathers?
By Israel Harel

The Labor Party, declared Ehud Barak in his victory speech, will follow the path of the founder of the state and the generation of founders. Even if victory speech promises are greeted with skepticism, the choice of these words and their timing are worth noting. Especially encouraging were his remarks that the State of Israel is "the home of the Jewish people, its historic bastion, the homeland of our people."

On the backdrop of the post-Zionist voices in academia, the media and politics, it is considered bad form these days to utter words like "homeland" and "the national home of the Jewish people." These terms have become rare - or illegitimate - among those who consider themselves among the progressive, cultured, liberal sector of society. Therefore there was something refreshing, certainly daring, when Barak uttered them in his speech. Time will tell whether the Labor Party under his leadership will return to the positions and ideas it held while leading the Yishuv [Jewish settlement] in Mandatory Palestine, preceding the establishment of the state and during the state's first 29 years of existence.

The extent to which Barak's declarations should not be taken for granted can be seen, for example, in the Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee. While preparing a constitution for Israel in recent months, the committee has discussed the identity of the state and its symbols. The Labor Party members, MKs Colette Avital and Matan Vilnai, like their new party head, are in favor of the constitution declaring that the State of Israel is "the national home of the Jewish people." Others, however, among them committee chair MK Menahem Ben-Sasson (Kadima), are opposed to this. The commitment to "follow the path of the founder of the state" is liable to remain hollow if Barak does not follow through with action, setting a personal example. No one is demanding he live in a modest apartment like David Ben-Gurion did. However, if his words are sincere, Barak is expected to abide by the total commitment of "the Old Man" and his peers to bring the identity of the state as Jewish, Zionist and democratic to its fullest interpretation.

Advertisement

Given the devaluation of the Zionist identity in recent years, this persistence is not to be taken for granted. However, without it, Israel will not be able to survive for very long as a Jewish state, as it was envisioned by the founding fathers from the labor movement.

Not only the Arab representative bodies are declaring openly that they deny the Jewish identity of the state. Such streams of thought exist among Jews as well, and their influence is not negligible. Post-Zionist views have become influential in part because the central Zionist parties, and above all Labor, have divested themselves of their ideological assets, and their leaders have begun to prophesize in fashionable language very far from that of the country's founders - in whose footsteps Barak has promised to follow. Only last week, during the days of self-laceration to mark 40 years since the Six-Day War, we were able to see the prominence of the position, "forgive us for winning."

Deterrent capability, which Barak promised to bring back as well, does not depend only on restoring the army's professionalism. If the citizenry's willingness to bear the cost of independence and sovereignty is restored, the Israel Defense Forces will also become stronger.

When Barak was prime minister, our ability to stand firm was at a nadir. Instead of elevating the country's spirit, Barak rode the waves of weakness and led the panicked flight from Lebanon. We can hope that the things he said yesterday, along with his promises to learn from his mistakes, show that this time he intends not to come to terms with these weaknesses, but rather to overcome them. Only in this way will he be able to help extricate the people and the state from their crisis.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The feminine side
Religious feminist Ora Cohen's book probes what Jewish law really says about women and why.
Leaping the gap
An Israeli's dance dreams come true abroad, but cost much and yield little at home.
  1.   BARAK VS BURG 14:55  |  indrajaya 14/06/07
  2.   about bloody time TO STOP PRETENDING 14:58  |  paul harris 14/06/07
  3.   Homeland 15:07  |  Daniel W 14/06/07
  4.   homeland 15:33  |  detlef 14/06/07
  5.   Political correctness is 16:07  |  Star of David 14/06/07
  6.   indrajaya is enough reason to reject burg 16:10  |  israeli humanist 14/06/07
  7.   That`s weird, I thought Jews came from Africa? 16:36  |  Africanus Homo Sapie 14/06/07
  8.   ONLY TORAH CAN DETERMINE AND SAVE THE JEWISH STATE AT CROSSROADS) 16:38  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 14/06/07
  9.   At Taba, I offered Arafat the Kotel: Vote for me again next time! 17:03  |  Ehud Barak 14/06/07
  10.   The Jewish Homeland 17:15  |  Shmuelshachor 14/06/07
  11.   the african conexion 17:26  |  Shmuelshachor 14/06/07
  12.   Indrajaya where do you work? 18:40  |  Curious 14/06/07
  13.   New Israeli ? More like Same Old Jew 19:56  |  Tod Zuckerman 14/06/07
  14.   hollow phrases 20:07  |  Axel 14/06/07
  15.   Self-comfort by repeating `homeland` mantra? 20:12  |  Don Camillo 14/06/07
  16.   #15 NO DON CAMILLO IT WAS CREATED IN 1917 20:36  |  paul harris 14/06/07
  17.   With an Islamic Republic in Gaza, Israel can openly be Jewish! 21:40  |  Alicia 14/06/07
  18.   16- Paul Harris please see message 4 u at #12 21:42  |  West Ham 14/06/07
  19.   Path 21:45  |  P. J. Casey 14/06/07
  20.   # 17 21:58  |  Axel 14/06/07
  21.   Palestine is also the Palestinians homeland 22:17  |  Acorn 14/06/07
  22.   Israeli Humanist 22:20  |  Me 14/06/07
  23.   To # 6 22:21  |  Indrajaya 14/06/07
  24.   #21 ACORN AND ACCURACY ARE MILES APART 22:34  |  paul harris 14/06/07
  25.   INDRAJAYA HAVE YOU MADE AN APOINTMENT WITH A HEAD DOCTOR 22:40  |  paul harris 14/06/07
  26.   PAUL the capital 23:11  |  Axel 14/06/07
  27.   Bravo Barak and Harel !!! 23:21  |  Claudia Loria 14/06/07
  28.   Talk Back as Nut House 23:34  |  Dyinglikeflies 14/06/07
  29.   24# Paul Harris - your post is lacking accuracy 23:41  |  Don Camillo 14/06/07
  30.   Who trusts this man? 23:46  |  Shalom 14/06/07
  31.   That may be so, but the entire world... 00:18  |  Edith 15/06/07
  32.   A rose by any other name... 00:25  |  Hannah 15/06/07
  33.   acorn....these modern palestinians 00:27  |  maria 15/06/07
  34.   Harel - time to move on 00:54  |  Josh Goldman 15/06/07
  35.   Hannah @32 01:10  |  Zelkha 15/06/07
  36.   paul harris,on Indrajaya`s head-case... 01:43  |  akiva P 15/06/07
  37.   maria 02:07  |  Mario 15/06/07
  38.   paul harris - Wrong! 02:11  |  Pete 15/06/07
  39.   Will not be voting for Ehud Barak? 02:12  |  De 15/06/07
  40.   Paul Harris 02:15  |  Pete 15/06/07
  41.   .`25 Harris 05:10  |  Labhras 15/06/07
  42.   `24 Hareez 05:12  |  Labhras 15/06/07
  43.   DON`T MAKE ME SICK WITH SUCH A REFERENCE .... 06:30  |  Dutch 15/06/07
  44.   #35, Zelkha 06:30  |  Hannah 15/06/07
  45.   * To #9 Ehud Barach & Indraja** 07:29  |  Gary Pineda 15/06/07
  46.   # 12, CURIOUS 08:59  |  indrajaya 15/06/07
  47.   # 36, AKIVA PATYSH 09:23  |  indrajaya 15/06/07
  48.   # 45, GARY PINEDA 09:38  |  indrajaya 15/06/07
  49.   2nd attempt to answer pete and camillo ERRORS 10:30  |  paul harris 15/06/07
  50.   #41 YES LAB RAT IRISH IGNORAMUSES SHOULD NO WRITE HERE 10:31  |  paul harris 15/06/07
  51.   When the 22 Arab states call themselves "Islamic" 10:40  |  Hastaroth 15/06/07
  52.   Shmuel Shachor (Post No. 10) 10:54  |  Johnny Weintraub 15/06/07
  53.   AT LAST POLITITIANS CONFIRMING THE TRUTH OF G-D AND HIS WORD ?? 12:02  |  Bill. 15/06/07
  54.   Axel, no Israel before 1948? 18:19  |  Frank 17/06/07
 Today Online
Gov't source: Int'l troop deployment in Gaza is off the agenda
Responses: 102
Coalition launches campaign to combat U.K. academic boycott
Responses: 165
Report: Barak planning operation in Gaza within weeks
Responses: 129
Analysis: Hamas is a wolf in moderate garb
Responses: 67
Uzi Benziman: Israel contributed to the Gaza conflict
Responses: 44


More Headlines
18:49 At least two Katyusha rockets hit Kiryat Shmona; damage but no injuries
17:43 Fayad sworn in as PM, vows to restore security to Palestinians
16:33 Olmert: We won't allow Gaza to slide into a humanitarian crisis
17:02 PA Chairman Abbas issues decree outlawing Hamas armed militias
15:46 Man held for murder of Arab cab driver ruled unfit to stand trial
16:26 Hamas official says BBC reporter to be freed Sunday
18:23 Police grill politico Uzi Cohen over suspected kickbacks, fraud
17:40 Court okays school budget reforms to replace discriminatory system
18:44 Police: Suspected Golan teen killer learned methods on Web
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved