Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., July 13, 2007 Tamuz 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 14:40 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 08:50 13/06/2007
ANALYSIS: Re-occupation of Gaza - is it the only way out?
By Danny Rubinstein, Haaretz Correspondent

The general collapse of government functions in the Gaza Strip Tuesday urged several senior Palestinian figures to seriously contemplate Professor Ali Jarbawi's advice to disband the Palestinian Authority.

Even before the civil war which Hamas and Fatah are starting in the Strip, Professor Jarbawi of Bir Zeit University maintained that the Palestinian Authority was a mere illusion of power: occupation under the guise of self government, and therefore useless.

On Tuesday, a Palestinian journalist likened the Palestinian Authority to a smoke-belching car wreck, adding that it was time to toss the keys to the Israelis. His view is shared by many Palestinian civilians in Gaza, who in recent days have told the media that they are fed up. "We've had enough, we should be so lucky as to see the return of the Israeli occupation."

Advertisement

The recent events we have been witnessing in Gaza are actually the disbanding of Palestinian rule. The primary reason for the break-up is the fact that Fatah, headed by Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, has refused to fully share the PA's mechanism of power with its rival Hamas - in spite of Hamas' decisive victory in the January 2006 general elections.

Fatah was forced to overrule the Palestinian voters because the entire world demanded it do so. The United States, the European nations, most of the Arab leaders and, of course, the State of Israel, warned Fatah not to share power with Hamas.

And so, after the Israeli pullout, instead of becoming a model for Palestinian self-rule, Gaza turned into the exact opposite. Matters have come to the point where Hamas operatives attempted all through Monday and Tuesday to take by force what they believe they rightfully deserve.

Abbas is maintaining that over the last couple of days, Hamas has been attempting to stage a coup. Everyone following the events share this opinion.

Hamas' military drive seems to have been meticulously planned in advance, including the targeting of headquarters, public facilities, and particular central figures.

There were signs of the approaching calamity. Over the past week, Hamas officials inveighed against Fatah without exercising any sort of restraint. They have slandered Mohammed Dahlan, Fatah's leader in Gaza, and his men with every conceivable accusation: traitors, thieves and Zionist agents.

They even said many of Dahlan's men had deserted and escaped to Israel, preferring Tel Aviv's bars and cafes to their native Gaza. These accusations certainly strike a note with many on the Gaza streets. One and a quarter million residents, embittered by their predicament.

The PA may be torn apart, rather than disbanded, as Jarbawi had hoped, but its death seems to be Fatah's only resort. Fatah founded the PA on the basis of the Oslo Accords which are no more. The time has apparently come for the PA to dissolve too.
It is the PA's only weapon against Israel, which will be forced to invade and fill the vacuum which the PA's disappearance will leave. The IDF will have to re-occupy the territories, and assume the responsibility that no one in Israel wants to accept.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Battling corruption
The World Bank says Israel leads Mideast countries in the fight against corruption.
It's not all cutthroat
Law schools and firms join forces in new educational program for students.
  1.   Poor analysis, as usual for Haaretz editorials 03:52  |  Michael 13/06/07
  2.   Rubinsteins FAULTY analysis 04:02  |  David 13/06/07
  3.   "Occupation" 04:08  |  Shmuelshachor 13/06/07
  4.   Hey Jimmy where are you? 04:19  |  Yusuf ibn Mohamed 13/06/07
  5.   The only pleasure in all this is ... 04:21  |  Jonathan 13/06/07
  6.   How Ironic 04:32  |  Dan 13/06/07
  7.   gaza must go under egypt 04:33  |  Realist 13/06/07
  8.   Referendum 04:39  |  Joseph S 13/06/07
  9.   hmmm, isn`t `occupation` illegal? 04:46  |  Jon 13/06/07
  10.   The more palestinian bloodshed , infightings , the more 04:54  |  Joseph E . 13/06/07
  11.   PA is nothing but a fig leaf for Israel 05:01  |  Neil 13/06/07
  12.   ONLY SOLUTION: GAZA TO EGYPT; W.BANK PARTITION WITH JORDAN 05:03  |  G. Marcus 13/06/07
  13.   Reoccupy Gaza? 05:04  |  Chasaboy 13/06/07
  14.   This Is The Most Sensible Article I`ve Read In Ha`aretz 05:05  |  GeneRx 13/06/07
  15.   they`re begging for occupation 05:10  |  Igor D. 13/06/07
  16.   It`s a trap... 05:15  |  Joseph 13/06/07
  17.   What Rubenstein failed to mention... 05:20  |  Ben 13/06/07
  18.   try something new 05:20  |  Harry 13/06/07
  19.   peanut farmer to the contrary responsible democracy is more count 05:26  |  ralph 13/06/07
  20.   Gaza Reoccupation? 05:33  |  JW 13/06/07
  21.   LIBERATION,NOT OCCUPATION!ANNEX GAZA,W.BANK,LET PALESTINIANS GO!) 05:38  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 13/06/07
  22.   Israel doenst need a worthless peaceplan but a pragmatic warplan 05:46  |  Joe 13/06/07
  23.   here`s an ideal... 05:52  |  Gary 13/06/07
  24.   Israel and the U.S. Murder A New Democracy. 05:56  |  Timothy 13/06/07
  25.   Hit the nail on the head 06:04  |  Baz Mann 13/06/07
  26.   RE-OCCUPATION 06:10  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/06/07
  27.   #9 Jon, on Arafat 06:10  |  Johnboy 13/06/07
  28.   #13 Chasaboy, when did it stop its occupation? 06:16  |  Johnboy 13/06/07
  29.   Are Folks Forgetting That Egypt Doesn`t Want Gaza? 06:47  |  GenerX 13/06/07
  30.   Timothy, #24, should know-only fools help their enemies 06:52  |  Voice of Reason 13/06/07
  31.   The Reality 06:52  |  Robin 13/06/07
  32.   Sad reality. 06:54  |  common sense 13/06/07
  33.   What`s your point, Mr. Rubinstein? 06:58  |  Fortuna Benmayor 13/06/07
  34.   ISRAEL CAUSED THIS PROBLEM 07:02  |  James 13/06/07
  35.   GIVE IT BACK 07:04  |  Kurt 13/06/07
  36.   Re-occupy Gaza ! FEH !! 07:06  |  moishe pipique 13/06/07
  37.   Excellent analysis and proposition 07:11  |  Leon Rosgarten 13/06/07
  38.   #28, john 07:14  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/06/07
  39.   Excellent analysis and proposition 07:15  |  Leon Rosgarten 13/06/07
  40.   Timothy & So Much of the World Doesn`t Understand 07:19  |  Brad 13/06/07
  41.   It Disturbs Me that Fatah is Doing This 07:21  |  Bernie 13/06/07
  42.   Israel Having Authority Over the Strip Is Nonsense 07:23  |  Brad 13/06/07
  43.   Johnboy - The Occupation Will Stop When 07:36  |  Phinias Whoppy 13/06/07
  44.   WRONG AGAIN 07:44  |  dave 13/06/07
  45.   Re-occupation 07:48  |  Vital 13/06/07
  46.   A Sad Day for Israel 07:48  |  Moshe 13/06/07
  47.   PA will let Gaza "break away" 07:52  |  Guesser 13/06/07
  48.   To #24 07:55  |  Boris 13/06/07
  49.   one country 08:04  |  Gene Warech 13/06/07
  50.   ISRAEL SHOULD REOCCUPY THE TERRITORIES ON IT`S TERMS 08:14  |  Meir Weinstein 13/06/07
  51.   Pals not ready for self rule!!!!! 08:21  |  Hassan 13/06/07
  52.   #35 BECAUSEE KURT THEY REFUSE TO DO SO !! 08:26  |  paul harris 13/06/07
  53.   READ MY OLD POSTS JUST AS I PREDICTED 08:27  |  paul harris 13/06/07
  54.   ISRAEL SHOULD NEVER EVER RE-OCCUPY GAZA!!! 08:29  |  Judith, Haifa 13/06/07
  55.   #7 Realist - OK, but will Egypt and Jordan obey your order? 08:31  |  velvl shmerlson 13/06/07
  56.   No! Just retake the Philidelphi Corridor 08:43  |  David Teich 13/06/07
  57.   Brad, As Long As Israel Controls the Borders 08:44  |  Bernie 13/06/07
  58.   No! Toss the keys to Egypt!! 08:48  |  Meron 13/06/07
  59.   SEND GAZANS TO LIVE IN EGYPT 08:48  |  The Prophet 13/06/07
  60.   What is Your Point Boris 08:51  |  Bernie 13/06/07
  61.   Gush Katif- Here we come!!!!! 08:58  |  Choni Davidowitz 13/06/07
  62.   `Occupation` ? - Sounds more like `liberation`. 09:04  |  redmike 13/06/07
  63.   Nifty bit of Israeli propaganda 09:04  |  Clickfool 13/06/07
  64.   Why not go all the way? 09:06  |  My Two Cents 13/06/07
  65.   #57 Bernie asks a question 09:08  |  Johnboy 13/06/07
  66.   #15 - liberation not occupation! Purge the word `occupation" ! 09:10  |  redmike 13/06/07
  67.   The toerags of Fatah are indeed Israeli agents 09:14  |  Clickfool 13/06/07
  68.   Voice of Reason #30. Palestinians didn`t have much of a choice. 09:15  |  Timothy 13/06/07
  69.   paul harris of tel aviv, how can we read your old posts? 09:17  |  Timothy 13/06/07
  70.   #42 Brad spouts rubbish 09:18  |  Johnboy 13/06/07
  71.   For Choni Davidowitz # 61 09:24  |  Clickfool 13/06/07
  72.   #38 No Cipora, you are wrong 09:33  |  Johnboy 13/06/07
  73.   #66 Ahh, a fan of George Orwell, Redmike?? 09:36  |  Johnboy 13/06/07
  74.   Re #40 Brad 09:41  |  Michael 13/06/07
  75.   #69 I PREDICTED THAT THE ARAABS OF GAZA WILL ASK ISRAEL TO RETURN 09:47  |  paul harris 13/06/07
  76.   Feed the people 09:58  |  Jasmine Murphy 13/06/07
  77.   gaza 10:00  |  habakook 13/06/07
  78.   Why not send in those humanitarians,the" Human shields"ISM, 10:21  |  PETER SM 13/06/07
  79.   WHEN QUASSAMS REACH TEL AVIV, THERE WILL BE NO CHOICE BUT OCCUPY 10:36  |  Ben 13/06/07
  80.   I suggest Amira Hass, Gideon Levy D. Rubinstein reoccupy Gaza 10:37  |  Shalom Freedman 13/06/07
  81.   #72, john 11:01  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/06/07
  82.   wanting Israel re-occupation 11:02  |  Ahmad of Ramallah 13/06/07
  83.   NOT one Israeli soldier in Gaza,Arabs killing each other. 11:07  |  PETER SM 13/06/07
  84.   Talking about democratic elections 11:19  |  Gil 13/06/07
  85.   63 Clickfool 11:39  |  ChanahS 13/06/07