Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., June 11, 2007 Sivan 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:15 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 10:22 08/06/2007
Five comments on the situation
By Yoel Marcus

1. The power of stuttering. When the "waiting period" that preceded the 1967 Six- Day War was at its height, and hundreds of thousands of reserve soldiers and Israeli citizens were sitting around in a funk, it was decided that the prime minister, Levi Eshkol, should get on the radio and speak to the nation. The speech was written by Yisrael Galili, who had tiny, cramped handwriting. The two Israel Radio secretaries had already gone home, and there was no one to type the speech. On top of that, one of the bulbs over the microphone was burned out.

While reading the text, Eshkol, who was known for his hemming and hawing (his nickname was "half-tea, half-coffee"), stumbled over a word. Galili had crossed out the word nesiga ("withdrawal of troops") and written over it hasaga (a fancier word for the same thing). Confused, Eshkol turned to his bureau chief and asked in Yiddish over the open mike: "What's this 'hasaga'?" The whole country heard him mumbling and got even more depressed. That was the turning point that led to the convening of an emergency government and Moshe Dayan being appointed defense minister. Within a few days, Israel went to war and won its greatest victory of all time. Looking back, Eshkol's indecisiveness put the Egyptians to sleep and allowed Israel to win big time. Wouldn't it be nice if we had leaders like that today, who would not go to war on two hours' notice and end up losing miserably? Sometimes, stuttering is also power.

2. The most justified war. As Haaretz's correspondent in Paris, I was at the Israeli Embassy when half a million people rallied in the streets to show their solidarity with Israel. There was a sense that the Arabs were about to wipe out the Jewish state. On television, people saw Egyptian troops marching into Sinai; they heard Nasser's warmongering speeches. Ahmed Shukeiry, the secretary of the Arab League, declared that the Jews of Israel would be sent back to the countries they came from and native Israelis would be slaughtered. Among the celebrities who showed up at the embassy to express their solidarity, the one who most touched our hearts was pianist Arthur Rubinstein, who wept aloud and infected everyone with his morbid prediction that Holocaust II was on the way. What those now denouncing the 40th anniversary of the occupation do not understand is that the Six- Day War was the most justified war Israel ever fought - because it knocked out of the Arabs' heads the idea that Israel could be destroyed by force.

Advertisement

3. Altitude sickness. After its victory, Israel came down with altitude sickness. By the eighth day of the war, this country of 21,350 square kilometers had become a country of 89,000 square kilometers - the same size as Austria. While the citizens of Israel were cheering and the victory albums were leaping hot off the press, only David Ben-Gurion and Professor Yeshayahu Leibowitz advised giving the territories back right away. And that was even before the word "occupation" had rolled off anyone's lips. Not only that, but the government, and that includes Menachem Begin, voted on June 19 to return the territories captured from Egypt and Syria in exchange for recognition of Israel.

The Arab response came in September, in the form of the Khartoum summit's three big nos: no recognition, no peace, no negotiations with Israel. Actually, the real pioneer of settlement in the territories was the Israeli left, supposedly on the pretext of security. Yisrael Galili of the Ahdut Ha'avoda faction declared that Israel would never part with Gaza. And so, little by little, the victory turned into an occupation studded with wars, to the point where the myth of Israel's deterrent power and ability to win has been shattered in the eyes of Islamic extremists and the world as a whole.

4. Drowning its sorrows. So who invented the story about a war this summer? The weather forecaster? And what about the story that Syria is planning an attack on Israel? Did we get a fax from Damascus? Or is the army just covering itself in case it really happens because it cannot claim once again that it didn't know? I wonder what goes on at those government meetings in Damascus. Are they quaking in their boots or laughing their heads off? Are they saying: If Israel says we're preparing to attack, maybe that means they're planning to attack? Is it any wonder that they are sharpening their sabers over there? And in the middle of all this, the papers are reporting secret talks between Israel and Syria. But maybe that is camouflage, too. Maybe there is some surprise attack in the offing, and the Syrians are honing their defenses? Actually, it sounds more as if the Winograd Committee's final report is drawing near and the government is drowning its sorrows.

5. Peretz's binoculars. This week, Amir Peretz was seen observing a military exercise without binoculars, while the generals standing next to him were all peering through theirs. The rumor about the army no longer handing out binoculars to guests was flatly denied. The truth is that Peretz is still observing military exercises, but now he uses contact lens binoculars that Rafael, the armament development authority, invented specially for him.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Slamming the court
Friedmann seeks to increase the politicization of choosing an attorney general.
He shoots, he scores
Gaydamak's latest financial moves are reminiscent of his soccer adventure.
  1.   DIDN`T TO GURION = DIDN`T LISTEN TO MOSES 10:42  |  indrajaya 08/06/07
  2.   The War Helped Al Quaeda 10:52  |  Bernie 08/06/07
  3.   a question which would be interesting concerning comment 3 10:53  |  saul a. readner 08/06/07
  4.   The war may have been justified, the aftermath was pure madness 11:00  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/06/07
  5.   Egypt, The Victim 11:02  |  Bernie 08/06/07
  6.   THE FUTURE IS ALWAYS THERE BUT IT TAKES GREAT MEN TO SEE IT 11:23  |  paul harris 08/06/07
  7.   Little correction to my # 4 12:14  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/06/07
  8.   Indrajaya - If the Palestinians... 12:34  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  9.   Bernie 12:39  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  10.   Swiss (Dino) 12:40  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  11.   to Somebody from Europe 13:25  |  Bernie 08/06/07
  12.   Somebody From Europe, Again 13:30  |  Bernie 08/06/07
  13.   Bernie 13:37  |  Nik Miller 08/06/07
  14.   The Six Day Fur Coat 13:45  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/06/07
  15.   # 10 Somebody from Europe 13:57  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/06/07
  16.   on Yoel Marcus - prattling 14:06  |  zeev 08/06/07
  17.   You have to be kiding 14:29  |  Dr David I. Gross 08/06/07
  18.   to Somebody from Europe #8 15:12  |  zeev 08/06/07
  19.   The Justified war 15:13  |  luke weyland 08/06/07
  20.   Bernie - response 1 15:16  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  21.   Bernie - response 2 15:19  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  22.   The Most Justified War 15:41  |  Johnny Weintraub 08/06/07
  23.   Ze`ev - What do you want to tell me by your quotes? 15:49  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  24.   saul a. readner #3 15:53  |  scallywag 08/06/07
  25.   Ronnie Wolman (Post No. 14) 15:54  |  Johnny Weintraub 08/06/07
  26.   Wouldn`t have made much difference 16:24  |  Walter 08/06/07
  27.   Ignoring Bernie, Gurion,Yoel 16:43  |  Ah 08/06/07
  28.   #19 LUKE IS UNCLEAR DOES HE MEAN 1948 WHEN 16:52  |  paul harris 08/06/07
  29.   Facts are Tough Nik 16:57  |  Bernie 08/06/07
  30.   Johnny Weintraub: They dont shoot animals in Texas 17:35  |  Ronnie Wolman 08/06/07
  31.   to Somebody from Europe #20 17:47  |  zeev 08/06/07
  32.   The most justified war? I don`t think so 17:52  |  Clickfool 08/06/07
  33.   Bernie - response 1, 2. attempt 18:19  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  34.   Bernie - response 2, 2. attempt 18:20  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  35.   to Bernie #5 18:41  |  zeev 08/06/07
  36.   The War Was Justified But... 19:07  |  Yosemite 08/06/07
  37.   to Somebody from Europe #30 19:36  |  zeev 08/06/07
  38.   Happy LIBERTY day!!! 19:49  |  goyboy 08/06/07
  39.   Yoel, there may have been 1/2 million 20:42  |  Lili Shi 08/06/07
  40.   100,000 troops Bernie, is a bit more than an aircraft carrier 20:43  |  Jacob Blues 08/06/07
  41.   Yoel Marcus, justify the unjustifiable in Israel 21:12  |  Dutch 08/06/07
  42.   to Somebody from Europe #23 21:20  |  zeev 08/06/07
  43.   SomeBody, They Were Never Closed 21:23  |  Bernie 08/06/07
  44.   SomeBody 21:27  |  Bernie 08/06/07
  45.   Zeev 21:40  |  Bernie 08/06/07
  46.   Like a thief trying to legalize his theft 21:44  |  Dutch 08/06/07
  47.   Zeev 21:46  |  Bernie 08/06/07
  48.   A Freudian Slip 21:55  |  Hyacinth Emerson 08/06/07
  49.   It wasn´t Israels most justified war, but it was sold as such 22:00  |  John 08/06/07
  50.   Zioinist Remember USS LIBERTY 22:28  |  John 08/06/07
  51.   John, face the facts 23:02  |  Jake 08/06/07
  52.   Hyacinth, because Israel fought a war on its own borders 23:06  |  Jake 08/06/07
  53.   To goyboy, while you`re at it... 23:11  |  Jake 08/06/07
  54.   Bernie 23:26  |  Tiran 08/06/07
  55.   Bernie - going back 23:31  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  56.   Bernie, Egypt carried out an act of war in 1967 23:40  |  Jake 08/06/07
  57.   Zeev explains 23:51  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  58.   Zeev and Nasser 23:52  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  59.   Dutch 23:56  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  60.   John/Netherlands 23:57  |  Somebody from Europe 08/06/07
  61.   h. emerson 00:01  |  daniela 09/06/07
  62.   Five comments on the situation 00:44  |  Tobin 09/06/07
  63.   To the dutch critics.. 00:52  |  Dan 09/06/07
  64.   Bernie 01:13  |  Inigo Montoya 09/06/07
  65.   laymen unprofessional talk 02:06  |  Sharif Hafez 09/06/07
  66.   The fault in Dino`s logic #4 03:36  |  Ronaldinho 09/06/07
  67.   On the 5th of June, HATE was born! 03:53  |  Sharif Hafez 09/06/07
  68.   Bernie and the Strait of Tiran, 2. attempt 04:35  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  69.   Sharif Hafez, Egypt was in state of war with Israel before 1967 05:32  |  Jake 09/06/07
  70.   To indrajaya #1 05:38  |  Stan 09/06/07
  71.   Sharif Hafez and the hate 05:41  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  72.   to Somebody from Europe #57 09:54  |  zeev 09/06/07
  73.   Israel Apologist read this 09:55  |  Samir Salameh 09/06/07
  74.   to Somebody from Europe #58 09:56  |  zeev 09/06/07
  75.   jake is right 10:41  |  volov 09/06/07
  76.   to Somebody from Europe #71 11:14  |  zeev 09/06/07
  77.   Tiran, I don`t care what your Name Is 12:36  |  Bernie 09/06/07
  78.   Inigo, What I am Saying 12:42  |  Bernie 09/06/07
  79.   Sharif 12:49  |  Bernie 09/06/07
  80.   somebody from europe, the facts 12:54  |  Bernie 09/06/07
  81.   Zeev (72) and the dreams 13:33  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  82.   Zeev and Nasser again 13:38  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  83.   The Arabs didn?t know what hit them nor their counterpart Israeli 13:58  |  Simon 09/06/07
  84.   back channels to Syria 14:28  |  MAURICE SAMUELSON 09/06/07
  85.   #77/8 BERNIE AND MORE FICTION EGYPT WAS AT WAR WITH ISRAEL SINCE 14:31  |  paul harris 09/06/07
  86.   To All Zionists A Simple Question 16:10  |  Bernie 09/06/07
  87.   Bernie and the facts 16:19  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  88.   Zeev again 16:35  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  89.   Somebody about Syria 17:18  |  Bernie 09/06/07
  90.   to Andi #88 18:16  |  zeev 09/06/07
  91.   Bernie and Syria 19:35  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  92.   a simple answer to Bernie`s simple question 19:38  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  93.   well written 20:52  |  paulo2005 09/06/07
  94.   # 66 Ronaldinho (2nd try) 21:25  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/06/07
  95.   to Andi #91 21:52  |  zeev 09/06/07
  96.   Zeev (90), 2. attempt 22:28  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  97.   Zeev and Anwar Sadat 22:39  |  Somebody from Europe 09/06/07
  98.   Swiss #94 23:01  |  Ronaldinho 09/06/07
  99.   80 Bernie: Wrong History & sorry to confuse you with facts 23:24  |  Michigan 09/06/07
  100.   Bernie: ?Nasser had nothing against Jews?, but he ethnically clea 23:31  |  Michigan 09/06/07
  101.   Bernie 23:39  |  Realistic 09/06/07
  102.   78 Bernie, provide proof for your history "claims" 23:41  |  Michigan 09/06/07
  103.   Ronaldhino,bounces the ball off of ...... 00:30  |  Ronnie Wolman 10/06/07
  104.   # 98 Ronaldinho 00:43  |  Swiss (Dino) 10/06/07
  105.   #65 ... Sharif Hafez 00:49  |  sel 10/06/07
  106.   #41 Dutch 00:52  |  sel 10/06/07
  107.   #59 My Response: THE GREAT IRONY OF THE 1967 WAR 01:11  |  Dutch 10/06/07
  108.   # 103 Ronnie Wolman No mercy !! 01:14  |  Swiss (Dino) 10/06/07
  109.   Somebody from Europe, I`m Sharif Hafez! 01:24  |  Sharif Hafez 10/06/07
  110.   Swiss #104 01:53  |  Ronaldinho 10/06/07
  111.   To Tiran on Bernie: it`s not really Bernie 02:25  |  Rory 10/06/07
  112.   1967 is the greatest moment in History that Israel Mised 03:53  |  Ben Bara 10/06/07
  113.   Yiddish Spoken by the Eshkols 04:27  |  Johnny Weintraub 10/06/07
  114.   to Andi #97 - part 1 05:52  |  zeev 10/06/07
  115.   to Andi #97 - part 2 05:54  |  zeev 10/06/07
  116.   #107 DORIS AND THE REVISED HISTORY AGAIN 06:13  |  paul harris 10/06/07
  117.   to Andi #96 06:22  |  zeev 10/06/07
  118.   #72, zeev 09:54  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/06/07
  119.   Dutch, again 10:04  |  Somebody from Europe 10/06/07
  120.   Sharif Hafez, again 10:11  |  Somebody from Europe 10/06/07
  121.   Zeev 10:18  |  Somebody from Europe 10/06/07
  122.   to C. J. Kohn #118 12:41  |  zeev 10/06/07
  123.   to Andi #121 13:25  |  zeev 10/06/07
  124.   Zeev (123) 16:02  |  Somebody from Europe 10/06/07
  125.   to Andi #124 08:33  |  zeev 11/06/07
 Today Online
Editorial: Jewish vandals, Palestinian graves
Responses: 7
Sliman al-Shafi: For Gazans, the only escape is death
Responses: 1
Ruth Sinai: Israel needs a woman president
Responses: 2
Yair Sheleg: What Burg and the right have in common
Responses: 3
Israel successfully launches Ofek-7 military spy satellite
Responses: 26
Rosner's Domain
* WTR: Israelis should thank the UN
* Retaliation against Britain! If we can only find a way
* Poll: What to do about the so-called "British boycott"
* The Six Days of Incompetence


More Headlines
09:16 Israel successfully launches Ofek-7 military spy satellite
08:15 Five Qassams strike western Negev; no injuries reported
09:19 Sources: PM would offer Ayalon Finance Ministry if elected Labor chair
08:56 Lauder elected president of World Jewish Congress
04:54 Bank Leumi to transfer NIS 20m to Holocaust survivors
08:57 Netherlands seek larger role in resolving Mideast conflict
06:41 Gaydamak's move to turn Tiv Taam kosher will cramp pork supply
05:35 Peres staff making final push for victory in presidential race
06:43 Report: Injuries due to violence up 40% in 7 years
08:44 Druze man urges vote against Barak over Border Policeman's death
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved