Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., July 22, 2007 Av 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:10 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Real Estate Arts & Leisure Jewish World National Sports Advertising  
Magazine Week's End Opinion Business Rosner's Domain Anglo File Travel
Q&A
 
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 03:55 07/06/2007
Palestinians will sue Israel in U.S. if 'intifada law' repassed
By Haaretz Staff

Palestinian residents intend to sue the State of Israel for damages in U.S. courts and in other countries if the Knesset repasses a law barring suits in Israeli courts over damages incurred in non-warfare incidents.

Palestinians with grounds for suits against the Israeli army over bodily harm and property damage sustained during the armed conflict since September 2000 have already contacted American law firms through Adalah-Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel. U.S. law permits suits against countries responsible for "humanitarian damages" in situations where the victims have no legal recourse in the offending country.

According to Adalah's director, attorney Hassan Jabareen, the possibility of filing suits overseas has come up again in view of the initiative by Justice Minister Daniel Friedmann to legislate anew the so-called "intifada law," which was tossed out by the High Court of Justice half a year ago.

Advertisement

Until now, Israelis were the ones to take advantage of the U.S. law permitting damages suits against state entities where these suits are not allowed. Such proceedings are ongoing against Arab Bank, which operates in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, and which the plaintiffs claim bankroll terrorists who cause mass carnage among Israelis.

Adalah last year approached several prominent New York law firms about the possibility of Palestinian suits in the U.S. and elsewhere, in case the High Court throws out the petition to abolish the law.

"It seems the justice minister does not grasp the judicial possibilities at hand," Jabareen said. "If the law is repassed, we will initiate individual claims overseas."

He added that Friedmann's legislative effort severely violates the rights of Palestinians. "It conveys a grave message that the lives and property of the Palestinians are up for grabs, and that nobody will pay the price even if he harms the lives of Palestinians, something that is contrary to international humanitarian justice and to Israeli law," he said.

Meanwhile, the Association for Civil Rights in Israel has sent Friedmann a protest letter.

"Amending a Basic Law to enable repassage of a law that was abolished by the High Court for violating human rights is a dangerous and unprecedented step," ACRI's legal adviser, Dan Yakir, wrote to the minister.



Bookmark to del.icio.us
Men in shorts
Who said shorts are not cool for men? Shorts are in vogue, proving less is more.
Isaiah's advice
The portion of the week deals with the future of Zion and improvement of society.
  1.   US Courts will throw suits out by terrorists 04:09  |  Mordechai 07/06/07
  2.   Law 04:32  |  Shmuelshachor 07/06/07
  3.   huh, lets sue the pals for their damage, apply against taxes owed 05:42  |  ralph 07/06/07
  4.   assoc for human rights must now sue pals for rocket damage i`m wa 05:44  |  ralph 07/06/07
  5.   pals will sue...??? 05:45  |  ljf-canada 07/06/07
  6.   #1 and #2: Racism/Ignorance 05:46  |  US Citizen 07/06/07
  7.   Mordechai and Shmuelshachor - Don`t be Naive 06:08  |  Mark of Lewiston 07/06/07
  8.   Sue be or not sue Be- not even a question!! 06:20  |  EGW 07/06/07
  9.   Mordechai, Bush is Done 06:30  |  Bernie 07/06/07
  10.   This is a joke right? 06:33  |  jake 07/06/07
  11.   High Court Veto 06:46  |  Jim 07/06/07
  12.   # 1 Mordechai: Terrorists??? 06:54  |  Jim 07/06/07
  13.   If they do, that is an easy fix 07:53  |  Jar 07/06/07
  14.   Bernie of #9 08:05  |  Jim 07/06/07
  15.   #13 Jar`s easy fix 08:52  |  Johnboy 07/06/07
  16.   Google the Alien Tort Claims Act 09:00  |  Legal Expert 07/06/07
  17.   For Mordechai # 1 09:07  |  Clickfool 07/06/07
  18.   Big Deal - Meretz & Peace Now have done it for years 09:37  |  Binyamin DIssen 07/06/07
  19.   you can file the suit BUT CAN YOU SUCCEED 09:40  |  paul harris 07/06/07
  20.   I`m confused. 09:41  |  sg 07/06/07
  21.   #17 CLIKKY EVER HEARD OF SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY 09:43  |  paul harris 07/06/07
  22.   #19 Paul Harris: OJ was found innocent 09:52  |  Bill 07/06/07
  23.   #20 Confused indeed, sg 09:55  |  Johnboy 07/06/07
  24.   To Palestinians 10:23  |  warrior 07/06/07
  25.   #20 - I`m even more confused! 10:56  |  The next Naqba 07/06/07
  26.   THERE IS NO JUSTICE IN AMERICA...FORGET IT PALS 12:15  |  Messaoud 07/06/07
  27.   # 20 sg. A great line in satire 12:28  |  Nick Ferriman 07/06/07
  28.   IDF and Settlers are within the reach of law 13:10  |  El-Birawi 07/06/07
  29.   For Paul Harris # 21 13:23  |  Clickfool 07/06/07
  30.   For Bill # 22 13:26  |  Clickfool 07/06/07
  31.   response to mordechai 13:33  |  anonymous 07/06/07
  32.   #22 THER ARE NO JURIES IN THESE SUITS BILL 13:43  |  paul harris 07/06/07
  33.   Ans US will sue Pals for copyright infringement/Farfur 13:44  |  NoSympathy 07/06/07
  34.   # 12 Jim: Terrorists??? 14:03  |  Jew Terrorist 07/06/07
  35.   Jim It Was Cheney That Made Liberal a 14:10  |  Bernie 07/06/07
  36.   Jim of #14 14:15  |  Good Bye Saddam 07/06/07
  37.   The Lawsuits Would Fly Out of Any US Court 14:19  |  Jane 07/06/07
  38.   So all Palestinians are "terrorists" now, Clickfool? 14:21  |  Terrorist 07/06/07
  39.   sg, I `m confused. 14:32  |  Innocent Idiot 07/06/07
  40.   Mordechai is the example of hatefull people 14:35  |  Mark B. 07/06/07
  41.   #23, the people who are fighting against Israeli occupation. 14:40  |  Occupant 07/06/07
  42.   #25, Don`t wage wars and you will be free under Egypt&Jordan 14:44  |  Terrorist 07/06/07
  43.   #6 So called U.S. citizen 15:18  |  John Allen 07/06/07
  44.   #29 CLICK REALLY MAKES A FOOL OF HIMSELF 15:29  |  paul harris 07/06/07
  45.   #7 YOU MUST BE A LAWYER! 15:33  |  John Allen 07/06/07
  46.   What you worried about 15:37  |  Steve Weinberg 07/06/07
  47.   #12 Jim from Tenn. 15:40  |  John Allen 07/06/07
  48.   "Repassed"?? it was tossed out by the High court. 15:42  |  PETER SM 07/06/07
  49.   EL BIRAWI.Homicide bombers,Qassem launchers,Arab lynch mobs 15:48  |  PETER SM 07/06/07
  50.   If the counter suit doesnt fit you must acquit 16:15  |  Ronnie Wolman 07/06/07
  51.   Terrorists Suing in US Courts 16:41  |  Rick Geiger 07/06/07
  52.   45 John Allen - Just a Realist 16:50  |  Mark of Lewiston 07/06/07
  53.   not worth salt 16:51  |  Space 07/06/07
  54.   Waste of time..... 17:31  |  Rufus 07/06/07
  55.   #28 very interesting BIRIANI YOU HAVE TO NAME SOMEONE 17:54  |  paul harris 07/06/07
  56.   #54 NO RUFUS ITS INDIVIDUAL STYLE 17:57  |  paul harris 07/06/07
  57.   Recognition 18:06  |  Murray 07/06/07
  58.   "non-warfare incidents" 18:26  |  Sharif Hafez 07/06/07
  59.   20 Confused? 18:46  |  Nabil 07/06/07
  60.   Sovereign immunity 18:52  |  lawprof 07/06/07
  61.   Will they also sue Lebanon for "crimes against humanity"? 19:20  |  Alicia 07/06/07
  62.   Counter sue the Palestinians 19:28  |  Daniel 07/06/07
  63.   Hey Occupant 19:50  |  Bernie 07/06/07
  64.   I like Jews and their Beliefs 19:55  |  Bernie 07/06/07
  65.   Alicia, There are 400,000 Israeli Refugees 20:17  |  Bernie 07/06/07
  66.   Get rid of "Justice" Minister Friedmann 20:37  |  Tosefta 07/06/07
  67.   Billions upon Billions of Dollars 20:49  |  Mr. Knowitall 07/06/07
  68.   Israel liable to pay Billions upon Billions of Dollars 21:01  |  Mr. Knowitall 07/06/07
  69.   63 - Where is the peace partner? 21:04  |  Bruriah Sarah 07/06/07
  70.   Let Jews and Palestinians square off in US federal courts 21:08  |  El-Birawi 07/06/07
  71.   Prey tell me... 21:10  |  Boozaglow 07/06/07
  72.   Worst than war: Loosing money!!!!!!! 21:27  |  Pepe 07/06/07
  73.   Bernie he already arised,it was the second coming 21:50  |  Ronnie Wolman 07/06/07
  74.   America Should Arrest Palestinian Plaintiffs 21:50  |  Efox 07/06/07
  75.   Palestinians have right to defend themselves too 21:52  |  joefiasco2007 07/06/07
  76.   Law Suits 22:25  |  P. J. Casey 07/06/07
  77.   # 65 Bernie 22:34  |  Alicia 07/06/07
  78.   #72 HOW LOOSE IS THE MONEY ? DOES IT SLIP FROM THE FINGERS PEPE 23:07  |  paul harris 07/06/07
  79.   #12 Jim - No constitution in Israel 23:22  |  Mats Nilsson 07/06/07
  80.   What the Iraqis are doing to the Pals 23:30  |  Alicia 07/06/07
  81.   Counterclaim vs. Murderous Pals 23:34  |  Atticus 07/06/07
  82.   Joefiasco2007 #75 - myopic ramblings 00:01  |  William 08/06/07
  83.   Raise our Taxes!! 00:01  |  Goldie 08/06/07
  84.   El-Birawi #70 - Pals already have a voice in Israeli courts 00:05  |  William 08/06/07
  85.   El-Birawi #28 - average Pals have a chance in hell 00:19  |  William 08/06/07
  86.   The blind racism 00:30  |  Goldie