Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., June 10, 2007 Sivan 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:21 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Echoes of Joshua's spies
By Israel Harel

This Shabbat we will read the portion "Shlach" in the book of Numbers, and this week is the anniversary of the Six-Day War. As happened then, some people are spreading evil reports that the land to which we have come is a land that "eats up its inhabitants." More than 3,000 years after the story of Joshua and the spies, portions of the people influenced by a media that has for years fostered feelings of guilt, let out that old lamentation: "And all the congregation lifted up their voice and cried...why did the Lord bring us into this land, to fall by the sword?...Were it not better for us to return to Egypt?"

Euphoria reigned after the Six-Day War, say the "forgive-us-for-winning" people. That is not true. There was a feeling of relief; the human joy of victory, pure and simple. And yes, a feeling of elation because, in addition to having been saved from annihilation, we had also arrived - Moshe Dayan put those feelings best - at the places the people had longed for thousands of years. And there was also a rational conclusion: There would not be another opportunity to slice across our narrow hips, and that our security was assured for a long time to come.

Those were the justifiable, natural and rational reactions of millions of people in the three weeks before the war. People lived in existential anxiety and feared the worst, 22 years after the Holocaust.

Advertisement

The government did not assert, as it should have, the national rights of the Jewish people over its liberated homeland. It did not even treat them in this way, as it should have from a historical perspective. "Bargaining chips," it called them. By relying on this status, relating to areas of the homeland as bargaining chips, for 40 years most of our troubles and evils have come to us: the Yom Kippur War, the intifada, the terror war of September 2000, the deep rift among the people and the distancing of most of the world from identifying with Israel.

There is no precedent in the history of Israel of an army handing its rulers such a great military victory with the goal of deriving maximum political achievements. Neither is there a precedent of a government that so missed a historic opportunity, as the Levi Eshkol government did in 1967, to advance national, security and political interests. At historic junctures, when there is no understanding of the greatness of the achievement and the greatness of the opportunity, the greatest of victories is also missed.

America at that time, haunted by guilt feelings of a government and public opinion that did not - as they should have - come to Israel's aid when everyone thought the Jewish state might be destroyed, expected Israel to take significant steps in the matter of territory. In Europe, especially in treacherous France, no one dared to preach to Israel what to do. The Arab world, battered and defeated, could not prevent anything. But the strong man in the cabinet, Moshe Dayan, waited for a phone call from King Hussein of Jordan instead of pushing for a realization of the vision he touted.

The decision-makers did not have a super-ideology; and lacking this, they could not formulate a strategy. For example, the annexation of the liberated territories, which would have upgraded out position in the world and determined irreversible political, psychological and physical facts on the ground.

It is not the price of the occupation - a people is not an occupier in its homeland - that we are paying, and not the price of determining the facts on the ground. If we had determined them to a great and irreversible extent, the world would have come to terms with them. Lacking a leader who can call out that "we should go up at once...for we are well able to overcome," we are being carried on a wave of lack of self-confidence, "and we will be in our own sight as grasshoppers," just as in the days of the Joshua's spies.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Polish yoke
My mother hated racists and she hated Poles - because they were all racists.
What if...
If the Six-Day War had never taken place, would Mideast peace still be a pipedream?
  1.   Frightening 10:27  |  Lucy 07/06/07
  2.   Liberated homeland ? 10:28  |  Andrew Watson 07/06/07
  3.   Interesting, as always, are the things that are not said. 10:33  |  Andreas 07/06/07
  4.   Absolutely Correct 10:34  |  Yishai Kohen 07/06/07
  5.   So what should Israel have done ... 10:40  |  Abner Shnuzel 07/06/07
  6.   WELL SAID ISRAEL HAREL ? NOT TOO LATE TO ANNEX THEM NOW ?? 10:42  |  Bill. 07/06/07
  7.   after the next war, throw them out and lock the door, tight 10:43  |  Pavel 07/06/07
  8.   He Has Eyes But Does Not See 10:59  |  ERSB 07/06/07
  9.   Israel, You are Right! And Left! 10:59  |  Eyal 07/06/07
  10.   Is it too late now???? 11:05  |  Infidel 07/06/07
  11.   `the treachorous French` - 11:08  |  Jessie Coehn 07/06/07
  12.   #2 you Aussie always crack me up 11:27  |  bbl 07/06/07
  13.   A plausible counterfactual 11:28  |  Shalom Freedman 07/06/07
  14.   #3,5 and 8 said it very well 11:56  |  Fabio 07/06/07
  15.   YOU WISH... MR HAREL 12:10  |  Patriot 07/06/07
  16.   Human Rights 12:21  |  Steven 07/06/07
  17.   echoes of unrequited guilt 12:31  |  meir 07/06/07
  18.   Patriot #15 12:37  |  Avi yerushalmi 07/06/07
  19.   territories 12:51  |  isiaiah 07/06/07
  20.   HAREL YOU DONT HAVE TO ANNEXE THEY ARE 12:54  |  paul harris 07/06/07
  21.   This already happened to the Golan ... 13:04  |  Observer 07/06/07
  22.   Ko Hakavod - Excellent and true! 13:05  |  Kenny Fisher 07/06/07
  23.   Liberated Territories 13:10  |  Sam 07/06/07
  24.   true colors 13:18  |  rose 07/06/07
  25.   AVI#17... AGAIN, WISHFUL THINKING IS CHEAP 13:21  |  Patriot 07/06/07
  26.   ITS NOT TOO LATE. 13:33  |  IamJoseph 07/06/07
  27.   TO ANDREW WATSON 13:46  |  IamJoseph 07/06/07
  28.   Loads of none sense 14:07  |  Wael 07/06/07
  29.   This Poisonous article beggars belief 14:07  |  David 07/06/07
  30.   the jewish people occupy their own land 14:12  |  daniel yefet 07/06/07
  31.   Well, gosh, Harel... 14:29  |  Johnboy 07/06/07
  32.   If Israelis are Gods own people 14:54  |  Steven Wienberg 07/06/07
  33.   National Codependency (1) 14:55  |  Mike 07/06/07
  34.   National Codependency (2) 14:59  |  Mike 07/06/07
  35.   #2 andy doesnt tell us what are PALESTINIANS LANDS 15:24  |  paul harris 07/06/07
  36.   Andrew Watson, Thanks for the Tip 15:33  |  Fish 07/06/07
  37.   Excellent article - What would happen to the arabs??? 15:36  |  Norman 07/06/07
  38.   I AGREE 15:49  |  Ian 07/06/07
  39.   Annex Judea and Samaria now! 15:58  |  Chaim 07/06/07
  40.   ISRAEL, HAZAQ, HAZAQ, VENITHAZEQ!!!))))))))))))) 16:05  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 07/06/07
  41.   LIBERATED TERRITORY!!!!! 16:14  |  Ben Uziel 07/06/07
  42.   a relevant article in haaretz....FINALLY!!! 16:16  |  Trudy 07/06/07
  43.   Patriot #24 16:23  |  Avi yerushalmi 07/06/07
  44.   To Abner 16:31  |  Alison 07/06/07
  45.   annex now 16:33  |  michael 07/06/07
  46.   ALL Israel gives or will give will NEVER be enough- Endless War 16:35  |  Diana 07/06/07
  47.   Foreign occupation you say? 16:47  |  Dory 07/06/07
  48.   Annex Judea 17:18  |  Annex Judea 07/06/07
  49.   Brazil thats the way we live 17:20  |  ali 07/06/07
  50.   # 12 bbl.If the Aussies crack you up,there is no doubt.. 17:31  |  KATH` 07/06/07
  51.   Re #2 reading up on history 17:40  |  DJStahl 07/06/07
  52.   Martin Luther King`s letter about Zionism 17:52  |  Walter 07/06/07
  53.   #1Frightening 17:57  |  clearthinking 07/06/07
  54.   #35 Paul, Same UN that recognized Israel 17:57  |  A Bethlehemite 07/06/07
  55.   Joke: "He thinks, Israel is a SUPERPOWER!" 18:23  |  Sharif Hafez 07/06/07
  56.   to #49: country no1 in street violence? 18:24  |  Alain (ex uruguayan) 07/06/07
  57.   FACTS??? 18:45  |  Axel 07/06/07
  58.   # 39 Chaim.Anex Judea and Samaria now!.... 18:50  |  Kath` 07/06/07
  59.   annexation with regard to the local population 18:59  |  Axel 07/06/07
  60.   # 42 trudy 19:07  |  Axel 07/06/07
  61.   # 42 avi 19:08  |  Axel 07/06/07
  62.   # 50 kath 19:14  |  Axel 07/06/07
  63.   I COULD NOT AGREE MORE 19:30  |  TRUMPELDOR 07/06/07
  64.   # 31 Johnboy 19:37  |  Axel 07/06/07
  65.   Harel and his ilk 19:41  |  Mordechai 07/06/07
  66.   One-state solution! Yes! 19:44  |  syosset 07/06/07
  67.   The real world 19:47  |  Sam 07/06/07
  68.   ethnic proportions 19:49  |  Dr D 07/06/07
  69.   Gawd, and they reckon muslims have a death wish 19:54  |  Marilyn 07/06/07
  70.   A historical misunderstanding 20:04  |  Colin Wright 07/06/07
  71.   Harel, an uber-mensch 20:06  |  Esther 07/06/07
  72.   Ignoring the big gorilla in the room 20:13  |  Tosefta 07/06/07
  73.   Isser Harel is correct but... 20:15  |  Frank 07/06/07
  74.   LET US ARISE AND TAKE IT AT ONCE!!! 20:22  |  yonni ezra 07/06/07
  75.   Get rid of "Justice" Minister Friedmann 20:28  |  Tosefta 07/06/07
  76.   The problem with annexation 20:36  |  Clickfool 07/06/07
  77.   Annex the West Bank!!! 20:43  |  dan 07/06/07
  78.   Israel Could Not Annex Without Exposing Its Racist Intentions 20:44  |  Fred Farkelsteinman 07/06/07
  79.   The times they are a changin` 20:58  |  Clickfool 07/06/07
  80.   Joker makes it sound like the land was uninhabited 21:01  |  newageblues 07/06/07
  81.   Seeking an easy opponent 21:18  |  Natallie Durson 07/06/07
  82.   #2 Andrew Watson misrepresintation of history 21:28  |  Bob 07/06/07
  83.   Axel #61 21:32  |  Avi Yerushalmi 07/06/07
  84.   Avi#43....... A RESPONSE IN KIND 21:44  |  Patriot 07/06/07
  85.   One state whether you like it or not 21:47  |  The Other Alan 07/06/07
  86.   #52, Walter, but what would MLK say about Israel of today 21:49  |  newageblues 07/06/07