Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., July 08, 2007 Tamuz 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:55 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A look outside the local pond
By Uzi Benziman

Many Israelis returning from even a short trip overseas share this feeling: The joy of homecoming is accompanied by a sense that home is not a normal place, in the bad sense of the expression.

The encounter with foreign countries, at least those that are not part of the Third World, is like a blow to the consciousness: In many states, people go about their daily life without Qassam or Katyusha rockets or terror attacks. There are places in the world where civilians are not exposed to news about the security situation from morning to night. There are nations that do not live with the constant moral unease deriving from the occupation of another nation. There are societies that are not surrounded by incessant violence. Public life in most developed states is not suffused with feverish preoccupation with fateful questions about their national survival.

Israel's insane lifestyle really hits those returning home. This is not just because, as tourists, they only superficially experience daily life abroad; it is because leaving Israel frees them from the local pond for a moment. When a society stews in its own juices, it cannot observe itself with a foreigner's eyes. On the contrary, it develops self-pity and self-righteousness and projects its own version of events onto reality.

Advertisement

Thus Israel sees itself as a victim of Arab violence, and all its violent acts are intended solely to defend itself, so that it can realize its right to self-determination. These include the checkpoints and the abuse of innocent, helpless Palestinians by brutal soldiers and policemen. They include preventive arrests in the territories, as well as blockades and closures that destroy the lives of women, old people and children. They include the assassinations and the separation fence, which arbitrarily expropriates the private property of poor farmers, as well as the Air Force bombardments, the demolition of houses and the uprooting of orchards. The feeling of constant threat with which Israelis live dulls their sight and their ability to distinguish between good and evil.

The growing view of Israel among a considerable part of the international community was recently reflected in an Amnesty International report and the British initiative for an academic boycott of Israel. Granted, local actors were behind both developments; international politics were also involved; and perhaps both show traces of anti-Israeliness per se, or even anti-Semitism. But curling up like a snail in a shell of self-righteousness is not the way to deal with them. Like the boycott initiative, the Amnesty report is another alarm bell. Israel's international standing is disintegrating; its moral image has been eroded; its military actions are indefensible.

The basic picture is simple. The world sees Israel as an occupier, and its increasingly sullied image in the conflict with the Palestinians is a result of this. But the Israeli sees himself a victim of Arab aggression. He is fighting for his life, and his enemies keep plotting to take it away. The world is against him and is trying to stop him from defending himself.

In his sallies abroad, the Israeli tastes the intoxicating flavor of an environment that exists without a bloody conflict and learns how he is seen by others. The Israel portrayed by the decisions of the British University and College Union is, as the UCU put it, an "apartheid state, engaging in crimes against humanity in the occupied territories." The Israel reflected in the Amnesty report for 2006, which focused on the Second Lebanon War, is a state that carried out "indiscriminate, disproportionate attacks on a large scale" and left about a million cluster bombs, as well as new minefields, behind in Lebanon.

The foreign and education ministers can raise a hue and cry about substantive inaccuracies, one-sidedness and cynicism on the part of both Amnesty and the UCU. But their main duty is to exert their influence as senior cabinet members to bring about a change in Israel's basic situation.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Up close and personal
Cutting-edge genetic tests now facilitate accurate medical diagnoses and therapy.
Poet of the revolution
Many articles and theories have surfaced regarding the death of Vladimir Mayakovsky.
  1.   JUST ASK THE GHOST OF JOSEF GOEBBELS HE IS LAUGHING IN HELL 09:48  |  paul harris 06/06/07
  2.   More Israelis should travel abroad 09:57  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/06/07
  3.   A decent assessment 10:01  |  Steven Wienberg 06/06/07
  4.   THE REST OF THE WORLD IS WRONG ?? 10:08  |  Bill. 06/06/07
  5.   It`s all Israel`s doing 10:28  |  Andrew Watson 06/06/07
  6.   A reason to look at the local pond. 10:29  |  David Nigel Braham 06/06/07
  7.   The world against us 10:43  |  Daniel 06/06/07
  8.   Israel morons 10:48  |  dave 06/06/07
  9.   #4 Bill 10:50  |  Joshua Rosenburg 06/06/07
  10.   # 4 God`s phone number 10:52  |  Andrew Watson 06/06/07
  11.   #5 watson why dont you leave the thinking TO SHERLOCK ?/ 10:55  |  paul harris 06/06/07
  12.   Thank you Uzi Benziman 11:03  |  Esther 06/06/07
  13.   "The rest of the world sees Israel as an occupier." 11:09  |  Thomas Jackson 06/06/07
  14.   Uzi Bentziman and this week`s torah portion 11:13  |  Seth Greenberg 06/06/07
  15.   If Jews are deluding themselves, why not everyone else 11:17  |  Sam 06/06/07
  16.   God`s phone number is 666, in fact, his lawyer`s. 11:18  |  Andreas 06/06/07
  17.   Israel will be a combat zone until 11:19  |  spyguy 06/06/07
  18.   At last the penny drops. Hoooraayyy 11:21  |  David 06/06/07
  19.   Outside view 11:33  |  bill 06/06/07
  20.   # 11 paul harris 11:34  |  Andrew Watson 06/06/07
  21.   Isarelis are loners when travelling abroad 11:34  |  MA 06/06/07
  22.   Cut from the same cloth 11:41  |  Observer 06/06/07
  23.   Joshua #9 -- I`m pretty sure Moses wasn`t on that ark 11:42  |  bbl 06/06/07
  24.   To 4/Could you tell me 11:49  |  Lena 06/06/07
  25.   #9 Joshua Rosenburg 12:00  |  Joseph of England 06/06/07
  26.   #10 Andrew Watson 12:05  |  Joseph of England 06/06/07
  27.   David Nigel Braham and others: this conflict is not local 12:14  |  Mark B. 06/06/07
  28.   One In One Thousand 12:16  |  John Smith 06/06/07
  29.   NOT ALL THE WORLD!! 12:19  |  Steven 06/06/07
  30.   The Israeli left is to Blame!!! 12:29  |  Dr Alon 06/06/07
  31.   But G-d gave HIS/HER speach to a Joint Session of Congress 12:29  |  El-Birawi 06/06/07
  32.   What a lot of people are forgetting 12:32  |  Chris Linthwaite 06/06/07
  33.   WE ARE OBLIGATED TO TELL THE TRUTH!! 12:34  |  Dr Alon 06/06/07
  34.   What the rest of the world doesn`t see 12:38  |  Hastaroth 06/06/07
  35.   Dr Alon from the faculty of Simple Minds: 12:45  |  Dr Andreas 06/06/07
  36.   THE REAL TRUTH RE: YEHUDA & SHOMRON!!!! 12:47  |  Dr Alon 06/06/07
  37.   Uzi and the rest of the World 12:48  |  Steven 06/06/07
  38.   The rest of the world. 12:52  |  Steven 06/06/07
  39.   Re: Daniel :The world is against us 12:57  |  Guy From NYC 06/06/07
  40.   to andrew watson the hebrew speaker 13:01  |  eli 06/06/07
  41.   THE REAL TRUTH - Continued 13:02  |  Dr Alon 06/06/07
  42.   to # 18, dave hurray, from london 13:05  |  eli 06/06/07
  43.   England, China , Russia etc.: Yes they are, to some extent 13:07  |  Andreas 06/06/07
  44.   # 30 Hastaroth Not only Israel is getting a beating..... 13:09  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/06/07
  45.   I`d rather be "alive", than "popular"! 13:13  |  Joel Stein 06/06/07
  46.   The Leading Antizionist Activists Are Jews 13:15  |  Rowan Berkeley 06/06/07
  47.   #39 Eli 13:16  |  Chris Linthwaite 06/06/07
  48.   To #18 and like minded "peacemakers" 13:16  |  Reuven 06/06/07
  49.   Guy from NYC -- Please explain 13:20  |  bbl 06/06/07
  50.   45 Joel 13:23  |  Steven 06/06/07
  51.   To Andrew and Dr andreas and DENNIS ROSS 13:30  |  Dr Alon 06/06/07
  52.   Israel Has To Do More Than Unblock Roads 13:31  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  53.   JERUSALEM WILL BE A BURDENSOME STONE FOR ALL NATIONS ?? 13:33  |  Bill. 06/06/07
  54.   Daniel, I am From America 13:34  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  55.   # 45 Joel Stein You could have it all...... 13:34  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/06/07
  56.   In the eyes of the `world`, Jews don`t have the right to life; 13:37  |  Uzi 06/06/07
  57.   #25 - to Joseph - Yes, land gien but ON CONDITION 13:38  |  David 06/06/07
  58.   TERRORIST ISLAM SEEKS THE ANNIHILATION OF THE jEWISH PEOPLE ?? 13:38  |  Bill. 06/06/07
  59.   only because we lost the pr war nothing to do with reality 13:40  |  ralph 06/06/07
  60.   # 5 David Nigel Braham 13:40  |  Nick Ferriman 06/06/07
  61.   #42 to Eli - BIIIG difference - the Falkanders WANT us there 13:43  |  David 06/06/07
  62.   WHAT DOES G-D COMMAND THE STRANGER TO DO IN ISRAEL ?? 13:43  |  Bill. 06/06/07
  63.   Bill, How Do The Palestinians Shorten .. 13:46  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  64.   WE KNOW HOW THE REST OF THE WORLD ACTED 13:47  |  paul harris 06/06/07
  65.   #48 to Reuven please stick to the issue 13:48  |  David 06/06/07
  66.   99% OF JEWISH HISTORY IS WORLD ACCUSING JEWS OF EVIL - OLD NEWS 13:49  |  Ben 06/06/07
  67.   well articulated Uzi Benziman! 13:49  |  peter 06/06/07
  68.   Joseph 2 Things 13:51  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  69.   To Run For President John Smith, 13:55  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  70.   # 26 Joseph of England 13:57  |  Nick Ferriman 06/06/07
  71.   I am From America Also (Post No. 54) 13:59  |  Johnny Weintraub 06/06/07
  72.   The Brand,Israel 13:59  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/06/07
  73.   Seeing the Forest from the Trees - 1 14:03  |  Alicia 06/06/07
  74.   Israel Supports Fanatics 14:03  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  75.   Thomas Jackson (Post No. 13) 14:08  |  Johnny Weintraub 06/06/07
  76.   All the world ? 14:11  |  observer 06/06/07
  77.   In 1988, The Soviets Crumbled Dr Alon 14:12  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  78.   #57 David 14:18  |  Joseph of England 06/06/07
  79.   Dino 2 14:24  |  Nik Miller 06/06/07
  80.   Stop whining 14:37  |  Roberto 06/06/07
  81.   Seeing Forest from Trees - 3 14:44  |  Alicia 06/06/07
  82.   The pot calling the kettle black 14:46  |  Dr David I. Gross 06/06/07
  83.   #80 Roberto 14:51  |  Joseph of England 06/06/07
  84.   Ronnie Wolman (Post No. 72) 15:02  |  Johnny Weintraub 06/06/07
  85.   No Bernie THE PROBLEM IS SURVIVAL 15:03  |  Dr David I. Gross 06/06/07
  86.   nick ferriman release yourself from the fleshpots of bangkok