Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., June 20, 2007 Tamuz 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:18 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 11:04 11/06/2007
1967 - The war that ended Judaism
By Bradley Burston

Lord, save us from miracles.

Like compliments, we crave them, but when they do come our way, we don't always know how to respond. We are let out of Egypt with nothing less than a full parting of the Red Sea, and what thanks will God get? A rave in Sinai, to which He is uninvited, and blasphemy in the form of a golden calf.

Forty years ago this week, just when it seemed that it would take nothing short of a miracle for Israel to survive the coming war, the betting here was that the miracle bank had run dry. Amid the pre-emptive grave-digging and the fraught goodbyes, this was a constricted, panic-choked, border-phobic gas chamber of a country - literally, the ghetto to end all ghettos.

When the miracle came, few stopped to recall the real motto of this nation: Be careful what you pray for.

From this distance, one could conclude that while the Jewish state survived the war, Judaism as we knew it - Orthodox Judaism in particular - did not. Rabbinic Orthodoxy, the Jewish people's sworn bulwark against change, would never be the same.

1967 was the war that would persuade rabbis that they could be generals - even, or especially, if they lived in Brooklyn. The taste of power being what it is, many rabbis would soon conclude that government - and occupation - were much too important to be left to elected officials.

If absolute occupation corrupts absolutely, no group would be more corrupted by Israel's presence in the territories than rightist rabbis.

Of course, that's the last way they would see it. Cloaked in a shawl of ideological purity, spiritual erudition and lawyerly one-sidedness, right-wing rabbis went to work utterly convinced that they were the one last incorruptible group of Jewish leaders.

With Messianic zeal, they set to dictating new commandments and enunciating new prohibitions, revolutionizing Judaism by casting the settlements as the building blocks of a Third Temple - all the while turning the settlement enterprise and territories as a whole into a new Golden Calf, a god to which the people as a whole would be forced to sacrifice.

The change had been immediate, and shocking. The Temple Mount had only been in Israeli hands for a few hours before then-IDF chief rabbi Shlomo Goren pleaded with the general who had captured Jerusalem's Old City, to order that the magnificent gold-domed Mosque of Omar be blown to bits.

"I was alone for a moment, lost in thought, when Rabbi Goren approached me," Uzi Narkiss told Haaretz in an interview a few months before his death in 1997. "'Uzi,' Rabbi Goren said to me. 'Now is the time to put 100 kilograms of explosives into the Mosque of Omar so that we may rid ourselves of it once and for all.'

"I said to him, 'Rabbi, enough.'"

But Goren persisted. "'You don't grasp what tremendous significance this would have. This is an opportunity that can be taken advantage of now, at this moment. Tomorrow it will be too late.'

"I said, 'Rabbi, if you don't stop, I'll take you to jail.'"

Goren wasn't through. After the smoke had cleared, he addressed a military convention, calling it a "tragedy" that Israel had left the Temple Mount in control of Muslims: "I told this to the defense minister [Moshe Dayan] and he said, 'I understand what you are saying, but do you really think we should have blown up the mosque?' and I said, 'Certainly we should have blown it up.'"

"It is a tragedy for generations that we did not do so," Goren said. "I myself would have gone up there and wiped it off the ground completely so that there was no trace that there was ever a Mosque of Omar there."

A principle had been planted, one that would transform Orthodox Judaism even as it would permanently alter the relationship between most Orthodox Jews and the rest of the Jewish public.

Long dismissed as passive politically, militant religious Judaism came to set policy for the settlement movement as a whole, and, in effect, for the rest of us. Because we let them. We coddled the settlements with our tax revenues, we protected them with our army service, and knowingly, impotently, we tolerated their intolerance of Arabs.

If fundamentalist Muslim Palestinians taught their children that all of the Holy Land belonged to them alone, and that it was permissible that all of the Jews should be killed or expelled, entire Jewish organizations would make their livings detailing the baseness of the incitement.

But if fundamentalist rabbis in Israel taught Jewish children that all of the Holy Land belonged to them alone, and that it was permissible that all of the Palestinians should be killed or expelled, how did we respond?

We continued to pay their salaries as civil servants.

The most recent example: The Friday issue of Olam Katan [Small World], a weekly pamphlet handed out at Orthodox synagogues in Israel, contains a remarkable commentary by former Sephardi chief rabbi Mordechai Eliyahu. In fact, it is a declaration of war.

And not just any war. In the battle against Hamas and Qassam attacks, the rabbi said, the civilians of Gaza who fail to stop the attacks share responsibility for the actions of the militants, and must not be spared in operations directed at gunmen and terrorists.

Asked to expanding on his words, his son, Shmuel Eliyahu, the current chief rabbi of Safed, told the Jerusalem Post last week that his father, who opposes a ground offensive that would endanger IDF troops, advocates, in the Post's paraphrase, "carpet bombing the general area from which the Qassams were launched, regardless of the price in human life."

"If they don?t stop after we kill 100, then we must kill a thousand," Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu was quoted as saying.

"And if they do not stop after 1,000, then we must kill 10,000. If they still don't stop, we must kill 100,000, even a million. Whatever it takes to make them stop."

It may take us another 40 years before we realize that what will make both sides stop, is for fundamentalist holy men on both sides to stop lobbying for "warfare until victory" which is to say, permanent war - these same men who piously rule out and, in the end, stamp out, the possibility of a permanent peace.

Lord, save us from those who preach death in Your name.

_____________


Recent blogs:
Boycotting Israel as moral masturbation
U.K.-based humanists who don't care for Jews
Hamas' latest conquest, The Walt Disney Co
Talkbacks are for cowardly bigots


__________________



The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Killer pussycat
Looks can deceive: Ehud Barak looks harmless, but his claws are as sharp as ever.
Lame duck quandary
During his last year in office, Bush will have to decide whether to strike Iran or not.
  1.   There is extremism on both sides of the conflict 09:25  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/06/07
  2.   not so simple 09:28  |  joe 06/06/07
  3.   The words of r.Goren are very appalling 09:51  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 06/06/07
  4.   As an Orthodox Jew... 09:52  |  ERSB 06/06/07
  5.   BRADLEY AND JEWISH SURFACES AGAIN 09:55  |  paul harris 06/06/07
  6.   Israel needs Help, Judaism needs Help 10:17  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 06/06/07
  7.   JUDAISM IS EVERLASTING 10:17  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/06/07
  8.   BLOWN UP THE MOSQUE? (2nd TRY, EDITED) 10:22  |  indrajaya 06/06/07
  9.   I wonder if there is a parallel here. 10:41  |  Thomas Jackson 06/06/07
  10.   It is SAD to hear The Sodom`s wishes İn Israel ! 10:46  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 06/06/07
  11.   Self Righteous Indrajaya 10:47  |  ERSB 06/06/07
  12.   # 7: To Cipora re "JUDAISM IS EVERLASTING" 10:52  |  Thomas Jackson 06/06/07
  13.   #1, Dino 10:54  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/06/07
  14.   Lets dont take Religions too Hard ! 11:01  |  a.k 06/06/07
  15.   We value stones more than people 11:01  |  Daniel Leopold 06/06/07
  16.   Slander of Rav Goren based on false report in `Haaretz` 11:11  |  Shalom Freedman 06/06/07
  17.   ERSB from Tel Aviv 11:12  |  Daniel Leopold 06/06/07
  18.   #9 jackson and the perpetual error OF OCCUPATION 11:13  |  paul harris 06/06/07
  19.   many SERIOUSLY ILL CHLDREEN in world 11:17  |  a.k. 06/06/07
  20.   The true story of Rabbi Goren on the `Temple Mount` 11:18  |  Shalom Freedman 06/06/07
  21.   Judaism no longer a religion 11:21  |  KA 06/06/07
  22.   The unproved allegation against Rabbi Goren 11:23  |  Shalom Freedman 06/06/07
  23.   Bradley, assuming you`re a Jew. . . 11:26  |  JW 06/06/07
  24.   Judaism is alive and well 11:26  |  Shalom Freedman 06/06/07
  25.   The Messiah Subjects ! 11:29  |  a.k. 06/06/07
  26.   The war... to# 9 11:29  |  Gabe 06/06/07
  27.   why do we need arabs? 11:31  |  kevin 06/06/07
  28.   The Wooden Houses 11:37  |  a.k. 06/06/07
  29.   Cipora Julianna Kohn # 7 11:40  |  Gina 06/06/07
  30.   The Orthodox 11:46  |  Sam 06/06/07
  31.   Thomas Jackson #9 - Share that hope 11:46  |  dana 06/06/07
  32.   Preach Life, not Death 11:50  |  TZfonit 06/06/07
  33.   You are the reason I have bad life ! Lets smile :) 11:54  |  a.k. 06/06/07
  34.   Bradley looking to shock 11:58  |  Jasmine Murphy 06/06/07
  35.   Terror 12:00  |  Murray 06/06/07
  36.   The War G-d won, and Jews lost. 12:00  |  Paul 06/06/07
  37.   An Excellent Article 12:01  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  38.   ERSB, Now I`m Confused 12:04  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  39.   Zionism is the new religion for Jews 12:24  |  El-Birawi 06/06/07
  40.   # 13 Cipora Julianna Kohn 12:32  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/06/07
  41.   Atila - seriously ill children - Save a Child`s Heart 12:35  |  Nik Miller 06/06/07
  42.   KA - some minor modifications 12:40  |  Nik Miller 06/06/07
  43.   west bank is sovereign jewish land 12:44  |  harold 06/06/07
  44.   Jewish self-hatred 12:46  |  Yehudit 06/06/07
  45.   Thomas Jackson 12:49  |  Nik Miller 06/06/07
  46.   #37, Dino 12:53  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/06/07
  47.   If?? "If fundamentalist Muslim Palestinians taught their childr 12:54  |  pragmatist 06/06/07
  48.   ignorance is no excuse 12:55  |  yonah 06/06/07
  49.   Bradley Burston questions for you 12:56  |  Steven 06/06/07
  50.   As a Jewish atheist ... 12:58  |  Boris 06/06/07
  51.   As a Jewish atheist ... 12:58  |  Boris 06/06/07
  52.   Israel´s guilty conscience 13:13  |  Alicia 06/06/07
  53.   Boris from one Jew to another 13:17  |  Steven 06/06/07
  54.   Hurray for Judaism! 13:30  |  Boozaglow 06/06/07
  55.   Steven#53.... which Jews you are talking about? 13:32  |  Haim 06/06/07
  56.   Religious fundamentalists 13:35  |  Mitch Cohen 06/06/07
  57.   Yes Bernie, you are confused 13:35  |  ERSB 06/06/07
  58.   Rabbi Goren was right! 13:40  |  Joel Stein 06/06/07
  59.   Peace 13:44  |  Mars 06/06/07
  60.   A Four State Solution 13:45  |  Ronnie Wolman 06/06/07
  61.   Alicia, I Always Thought We Had The Same 14:26  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  62.   Burston: Alll the news thats UNFIT to print 14:32  |  Dr David I. Gross 06/06/07
  63.   Very insulting article! 14:34  |  Josh 06/06/07
  64.   #45: Reply to Nik Miller re How to handle fanatical rabbis 14:36  |  Thomas Jackson 06/06/07
  65.   ERSB, What Is a Lubevitcher 14:38  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  66.   judaism 14:41  |  habakook 06/06/07
  67.   ERSB, One More Thing 14:42  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  68.   Joel, You Know Why Arabs Speak Hebrew 14:47  |  Bernie 06/06/07
  69.   This Aint Utopia Bernie 14:51  |  ERSB 06/06/07
  70.   What is Judaism? I always understood it to be 15:01  |  Virginia 06/06/07
  71.   Goren was right 15:02  |  Pinchas ben Elazar 06/06/07
  72.   #31 Reply to dana re "Share that hope" 15:04  |  Thomas Jackson 06/06/07
  73.   # 61 Dear Bernie, go with peace! 15:05  |  Alicia 06/06/07
  74.   G-d, through the prophet Zecharaiah says that 15:10  |  Palestinian 06/06/07
  75.   #18 Reply to paul harris re "the perpetual error OF OCCUPATION" 15:19  |  Thomas Jackson 06/06/07
  76.   Hiam 55, you ignorance makes me laugh. 15:19  |  Steven 06/06/07
  77.   Re: Thomas Jackson 15:26  |  Nik Miller 06/06/07
  78.   Non-sense and misdirection 15:29  |  Randal Blanchette 06/06/07
  79.   #26 Reply to Gabe re "The war" 15:33  |  Thomas Jackson 06/06/07
  80.   # 59 Mars, Zionism and Jewishism are same. Read my prior post. 15:33  |  Virginia 06/06/07
  81.   Jewish ignorance and arrogance on DISPLAY!!!! 15:43  |  Ben Uziel 06/06/07
  82.   hearsay