Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., June 06, 2007 Sivan 20, 5767 | | Israel Time: 09:25 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Living the lives of others
By Akiva Eldar

Forty years ago today was the last day the citizens of Israel were a free people in their own land. It was the last day we lived here without living other people's lives. After that day, we started paying the price for living the lives of others.

German director Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck recently explored that price in his acclaimed movie "The Lives of Others" on the modus operandi of the Stasi - communist East Germany's secret police.

The threat that hovered over Israel on June 4, 1967, pertained to its actual survival. It erased from our consciousness the knowledge that our lives here used to be different. Four decades of creeping annexation and 20 years of violent confrontation contributed to this amnesia.

Advertisement

And so, our victory on the battlefield - which was meant to make our lives better and safer - is making both our lives and the lives of others miserable. The year 1966 saw an important chapter in Israel's short existence. It was also an important point in the Jewish recovery from the feeling of siege. In early December, Levi Eshkol's cabinet canceled the military rule that was practiced in Israel, based on the British Mandate's regulations.

In doing so, the government lifted the main hurdle that prevented Israel's Arab population from leading normal lives. Six months later, the government proceeded to make the Green Line indistinct, blurring the distinction between Israel proper and the recently conquered territories.

Subsequently, many Jews began regarding the Arabs of towns such as Baka al-Garbiyeh on the Israeli side of the Green Line much the same as the Arabs of Baka al-Sharkiyeh, which used to be on the Jordanian side. Recently healed wounds were reopened, and an incipient sense of identity began to fragment.

The need to exert authority over the large and alien population of the territories forced the government to recreate the military rule it had just abolished, and to employ it in the territories - tactics and methods included.

Professor Yeshayahu Leibowitz did not need 40 years to realize that this would transform Israel to a secret-police state, and the Israel Defense Forces into an "occupation army." As early as spring 1968, he warned against the occupation's effects on education, freedom of speech and thought, and on the democratic nature of the government.

Leibowitz predicted that the corruption that is characteristic of any colonialist regime would not spare Israel. He also warned against the collapse of social structures and the corruption of man - Arab and Jew alike.

But even the Jerusalemite prophet of apocalypse did not predict the scale of corruption and the corruption of values that the settlement enterprise generated, and the extent of the apartheid regulations that would allow and encourage the theft of lands.

No one could have foreseen the extent to which this enterprise damaged Israel's internal cohesion, nor could anyone have predicted the degree to which it compromised Israel's standing in the eyes of the free world.

In June 1967, tiny Jerusalem accommodated 13 foreign embassies. Following the passing in 1980 of the Basic Law on Jerusalem the Capital of Israel, the city was orphaned of all its embassies.

It has been suggested that the Palestinian territories expanded the security margins that "tiny" Israel had. Few recall that in the mid-1960s, several months before the war broke out, the government saw fit to reduce mandatory military service for men by two months. Very few soldiers benefited from this because the security challenges of the occupation forced the government to increase service by 14 months - putting it at three years.

But that's not all. During the Second Lebanon War, the citizens of Israel proper, within the Green Line, paid a steep price for the deterioration of the IDF's abilities. This was a result of its employment as a police force in the territories that Israel conquered in June 1967. This involved guarding the property of Jewish land robbers.

As the years progressed, short-sighted Israeli politicians and Jewish religious leaders transformed "the fight for home" into "the fight for other people's home."

It is true that there were times when the other side was unwilling to discuss anything, not even the borders of June 4, 1967. But nowadays, the 22 member states of the Arab league declare that they view this border as a basis for peace - an accomplishment no one would have dreamed of 40 years ago.

And so, Israel is missing the opportunity to transform its military victory into its biggest achievement ever. It is losing the war of independence from controlling the lives of others.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Future cuisine
Some believe molecular cuisine is here to stay, while others consider it an expensive fad.
Comptroller's mistake
Lindenstrauss was quick to slam the Wisconsin Plan, and the media followed suit.
  1.   ARMY MUST TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR ALL TERRITORIES.ESTABLISH ORDER 10:18  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 04/06/07
  2.   A few corrections 10:20  |  Shalom Freedman 04/06/07
  3.   Not a free people in their land,but other people`s looted land 10:36  |  Sami 04/06/07
  4.   Why Arabs get married? 10:48  |  Uzi 04/06/07
  5.   Minor problem.............. 10:49  |  bill Pearlman 04/06/07
  6.   WRONG PLACE FOR THE WRONG REASONS 11:01  |  indrajaya 04/06/07
  7.   Bill and Shalom 11:24  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  8.   Shalom, Yasser Arafat was not in Palestine 11:28  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  9.   Sami,is it a sin that Jews wanted a state in their ancestors` ho 11:40  |  Hastaroth 04/06/07
  10.   GODLESS MIDDLE EAST NEED WIPE OUT 11:41  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 04/06/07
  11.   the land of israel was given to her by G-d 11:55  |  terry 04/06/07
  12.   # 11, TERRY 12:17  |  indrajaya 04/06/07
  13.   Hastaroth, Analyze the Facts 12:26  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  14.   Right of ownership 12:32  |  Andrew Watson 04/06/07
  15.   Re: Hastaroth 12:38  |  Sami 04/06/07
  16.   #3 SAMI AND THE DELUSIONS OF A MIRAGE 12:40  |  paul harris 04/06/07
  17.   Paul Harris 12:56  |  Sami 04/06/07
  18.   Akiva: LISTEN UP! 13:01  |  Crow T. Robot 04/06/07
  19.   wisdom in the article! 13:15  |  Peter 04/06/07
  20.   Paul, Read Israel`s Declaration of Independence 13:20  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  21.   Hey Crow 13:23  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  22.   @17 the full title was sami the PALESTINE MANDATE FOR AJEWISH STA 13:28  |  paul harris 04/06/07
  23.   Living the Life of Othes 13:29  |  Hilda 04/06/07
  24.   It`s The Master/Slave Thing 13:47  |  George Hegel 04/06/07
  25.   Paul harris: stop making history 13:52  |  Sami 04/06/07
  26.   We need a Moratoriam on the Area 13:56  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/06/07
  27.   There has never been a distinct nation of Western Palestine Arabs 14:04  |  Uzi 04/06/07
  28.   Bernie #21 14:05  |  Crow T. Robot 04/06/07
  29.   Sami 14:25  |  Ky 04/06/07
  30.   Sorry Sami, your version of `history` is equally inaccurate. 14:27  |  Uzi 04/06/07
  31.   UZI 14:39  |  Sami 04/06/07
  32.   Look in the mirror! 14:41  |  Dr Alon 04/06/07
  33.   To Indrajaya 14:55  |  Dr alon 04/06/07
  34.   To Bernie - Detroit 14:57  |  Dr Alon 04/06/07
  35.   UZI and the other hardliners - annex the land then! 15:01  |  David 04/06/07
  36.   #18, Crow T. Robot, dream on 15:04  |  newageblues 04/06/07
  37.   Wake up lefties!! 15:08  |  Dr Alon 04/06/07
  38.   Time is running late for the Zionist leadership.... 15:16  |  Patriot 04/06/07
  39.   How can one argue 15:33  |  Zev 04/06/07
  40.   Agree with Andrew Watson(14) about the 15:35  |  lakshmi 04/06/07
  41.   #31 SAMI MIXES HIMSELF UP 15:36  |  paul harris 04/06/07
  42.   Sami, I say that there were always Jews and Arabs in Eretz Israel 15:37  |  Uzi 04/06/07
  43.   eldar`s naivete 15:38  |  david 04/06/07
  44.   to Sami and others who view Israel as ilegitimate 15:38  |  Avi Yerushalmi 04/06/07
  45.   #20 BEN GURION FAILED MISERABLY TO ESTABLISH ISRAEL 15:39  |  paul harris 04/06/07
  46.   Benign Islamic Tolerance 15:45  |  B 04/06/07
  47.   Sami and others who view Israel,as illegitimate 15:52  |  Avi Yerushalmi 04/06/07
  48.   #11 Nonsense 16:13  |  T A Sheppard 04/06/07
  49.   why not annex the west bank formally? 16:33  |  David 04/06/07
  50.   PAUL AND SAMI - AN IMPORTANT ACCIDENTAL EXCLUSION 16:39  |  Stephen Connor 04/06/07
  51.   PAUL IS LOSING THE THREAD AGAIN 16:46  |  Stephen Connor 04/06/07
  52.   Paul - switch to decaf 16:53  |  Stephen Connor 04/06/07
  53.   David it could never happen 16:55  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/06/07
  54.   David - Still waiting for the end of you post 16:56  |  Stephen Connor 04/06/07
  55.   The biblical land grant was to the "children of Israel" and not 16:58  |  jack 04/06/07
  56.   they can`t annex the west bank without giving citizenship to the 17:00  |  Jack 04/06/07
  57.   #48/9 CONNOR IN THE TWILIGHT ONCE AGAIN 17:12  |  paul harris 04/06/07
  58.   #47 IT HAS ALWAYS BEEN PART OF ISRAEL THERE IS NO NEED TO ANNEXE 17:13  |  paul harris 04/06/07
  59.   Akiva, vote for Lieberman 17:14  |  Gene 04/06/07
  60.   Akiva Eldar should be forced to live in Sderot. 17:16  |  Yael 04/06/07
  61.   Lives of others 17:17  |  Naim S. Mahlab 04/06/07
  62.   Sami #3 17:27  |  Polybios 04/06/07
  63.   Jack and the "biblical land grant" 17:29  |  Stephen Connor 04/06/07
  64.   #36 newageblues 17:32  |  Crow T. Robot 04/06/07
  65.   Sami #15 17:38  |  Polybios 04/06/07
  66.   Israelis and Romans! 17:50  |  Sharif Hafez 04/06/07
  67.   Only solution is an historically correct one. 17:52  |  Chick Corea 04/06/07
  68.   Self destruction...... 17:58  |  Zoe 04/06/07
  69.   #22 - ownership determined by Imperialists? 18:20  |  Rick 04/06/07
  70.   Sorry Crow 18:21  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  71.   Answer is obvious 18:27  |  C McCoy 04/06/07
  72.   Alon, You are Welcome 18:27  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  73.   The "biblical land grant" and Stephen Connor 18:34  |  Myer Rosen 04/06/07
  74.   I am a Descendent of David 18:36  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  75.   Relation between Terror and Occupation 18:43  |  Tosefta 04/06/07
  76.   Palestinean Arab state west of the Jordan is a cruel joke, 18:47  |  Uzi 04/06/07
  77.   Since when do the receivors of stolen property have more rights.. 18:49  |  Bernard A. Ross 04/06/07
  78.   # 45 Paul Harris 19:01  |  Nick Ferriman 04/06/07
  79.   Tosefta how many Qassams?????? 19:04  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/06/07
  80.   Myer Rosen 19:07  |  Stephen Connor 04/06/07
  81.   Akiva Eldar - will you read this? 19:14  |  Polybios 04/06/07
  82.   2nd Attempt- Proper historical solution only one possible 19:14  |  Chick Corea 04/06/07
  83.   Bernie 19:14  |  Avi Yerushalmi 04/06/07
  84.   Avi, I try to Say Practicer of Judaism ... 19:40  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  85.   continued 19:43  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  86.   One Last thing Avi 19:49  |  Bernie 04/06/07
  87.   Chick - Find something else 19:54  |  Stephen Connor 04/06/07
  88.   to Ferriman #75 20:08  |  Chick Corea 04/06/07
  89.   Ever notice? 20:09  |  Scharker Yid 04/06/07
  90.   #74 bernard + stolen land + romans 20:18  |  roman 04/06/07
  91.   #78 - "proper historical solution" 20:20  |  Rick 04/06/07
  92.   Bernie #71 20:24  |  Eli 04/06/07
  93.   Re: Ky and his pictures 20:29  |  Guy From NYC 04/06/07
  94.   TO TERRY #11 20:29  |  Steve Beikirch 04/06/07
  95.   One thing for sure 20:30  |  Abby 04/06/07
  96.   TA SHEPPARD #48 20:35  |  Steve Beikirch 04/06/07
  97.   #70 Divine command expulsion 20:39  |  ballistic 04/06/07
  98.   #64 God threw out the Jews 20:43  |  ballistic 04/06/07
  99.   One thing for sure 20:45  |  Abby 04/06/07
  100.   lakshmi gives us detailed percentages of palestine 20:59  |  indira 04/06/07
  101.   tosefta why the crap history with forced conclusions 21:05  |  katznelson 04/06/07
  102.   to Strephen Connor- 21:07  |  Chick Corea 04/06/07
  103.   Bernie 81 21:09  |  Inigo Montoya 04/06/07
  104.   comment on 66 21:12  |  Inigo Montoya 04/06/07
  105.   the view from the uk 21:13  |  seb widmann 04/06/07
  106.   ballistic you may as well say africans never had a large 21:15  |  slamdunk 04/06/07
  107.   ballistic i wonder so few afro americans 21:17  |  slamdunk 04/06/07
  108.   Abby 89 21:17  |  Inigo Montoya 04/06/07
  109.   nick ferriman is the eternal jew hater 21:19  |  baht 04/06/07
  110.   ballistic #88: inconsistent argument 21:27  |  Polybios 04/06/07
  111.   Bernie #81 21:41  |  Avi Yerushalmi 04/06/07
  112.   #12 21:55  |  Moshe 04/06/07
  113.   If its not Levy the child who didn`t grow up 21:59  |  Joseph E . 04/06/07
  114.   Thank you Akiva Eldar 22:09  |  Esther 04/06/07
  115.   #38 22:13  |  Moshe 04/06/07
  116.   The Land 22:16  |  Pauli 04/06/07
  117.   Bernie The Revisionist Historian 22:41  |  sg 04/06/07
  118.   Israel and Palestine 22:43  |  sara martindale-rapt 04/06/07
  119.   No. 29 22:44  |  W 04/06/07
  120.   #75 nick crosses the divide INTO UNREALITY 22:53  |  paul harris 04/06/07
  121.   HAARETZ AND THE B::::S:::: BRIGADE 23:00  |  Jorge 04/06/07
  122.   If you are arguing via the bible... 23:03  |  lets progress 04/06/07
  123.   #88 KNICKER E AND GOD COMBINE TO MAKE US ALL LAUGH 23:09  |  paul harris 04/06/07
  124.   Akiva Eldar is wrong 23:14  |  Democrat 04/06/07
  125.   stephen Connor #82 Cannot ignore history 23:17  |  Chick Corea 04/06/07
  126.   How far should the land extend? are you kidding? 23:21  |  slashing fangs 04/06/07
  127.   History repeats itself 23:23  |  Chick Corea 04/06/07
  128.   40 years ago Israel liberated Jerusalem and Judea and Samaria 23:29  |  David 04/06/07
  129.   Terror is a result of Anti-semitism, nothing about Israel 23:35  |  David 04/06/07
  130.   #100 RIP VAN JUST WOKE UP LOOK FOR1922 MANDATE 23:48  |  paul harris 04/06/07
  131.   #114 SARA I THOUGHT CATTLE IN THESE TIMES WERE TREATED WELL ?? 00:01  |  paul harris 05/06/07
  132.   to jack in richmond va. 00:12  |  citizen zero 05/06/07
  133.   Atilla Karagozoglu: An Even Happier World 00:27  |  CHGODMK 05/06/07
  134.   Sami 00:35  |  John 05/06/07
  135.   Hey Robot! 00:40  |  John 05/06/07
  136.   #123 Hey Paul; better be careful or you will give 00:44  |  ballistic 05/06/07
  137.   Patriot 00:49  |  John 05/06/07
  138.   #93Guy 00:49  |  Ky 05/06/07
  139.   Dear Akiva, The threat in 67 was hyped, spinned and used. 00:50  |  John 05/06/07
  140.   #110 Polybios; I didn`t post #88 00:52  |  ballistic 05/06/07
  141.   #4...Uzi 00:53  |  nemesis 05/06/07
  142.   #107 Slam dunk 00:54  |  ballistic 05/06/07
  143.   #48 00:57  |  Moshe 05/06/07
  144.   So PAUL 00:57  |  John 05/06/07
  145.   The Apocalypse. 00:58  |  Maureen Ann 05/06/07
  146.   #105..seb widmann 00:59  |  Nemesis 05/06/07
  147.   #20..Bernie 01:05  |  Nemesis 05/06/07
  148.   Corruption is a product of Israeli appeasement/retreat! 01:05  |  Chaim 05/06/07
  149.   Eldar, what is this gloom and doom ??? 01:07  |  TOMY 05/06/07
  150.   john the baptist and "the thieves from brooklyn" 01:49  |  adam 05/06/07
  151.   Esther #114 01:52  |  GABE! 05/06/07
  152.   Sami and Paul Harris 01:53  |  Paul 05/06/07
  153.   Paul Harris #120 01:54  |  GABE1 05/06/07
  154.   #131 02:24  |  Moshe 05/06/07
  155.   Others? 02:26  |  David 05/06/07
  156.   Israeli Arabs- Israeli or not? 03:34  |  MYBN 05/06/07
  157.   Well thought-out, researched, and written article. 04:14  |  Timothy 05/06/07
  158.   The Lives of Others 04:35  |  Geoff 05/06/07
  159.   TO MYBN #156 05:28  |  Steve Beikirch 05/06/07
  160.   #101 katznelson, right you are with your conclusion 06:01  |  Smadar 05/06/07
  161.   This blog 06:13  |  ...an outsider... 05/06/07
  162.   David #49 06:29  |  archangel 05/06/07
  163.   MYBN The Basic Right they Don`t Have 07:00  |  Bernie 05/06/07
  164.   From the Very Beginning there was... 08:00  |  Highlander 05/06/07
  165.   #136 KNICHER E PROVES STUPIDITY IS WINNING 08:03  |  paul harris 05/06/07
  166.   WANTED: Calling All Good Self-Hating Jews 08:18  |  Highlander 05/06/07
  167.   Akiva`s Nonsense 08:33  |  Marc Hamil 05/06/07
  168.   #166 HIGHLANDER IS THIS THE SAME GUILT BRITAIN SHOULD FEEL 08:51  |  paul harris 05/06/07
  169.   CHGODMK ! even much happier world... 08:57  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 05/06/07
  170.   CHGODMK is my (MY) friend ! 09:14  |  a.k 05/06/07
  171.   Paul Harris: 19:25  |  Highlander 05/06/07
  172.   #165 Oh Paul; get real; Israel is a half-arsed 19:36  |  ballistic 05/06/07
  173.   ballistic #140 21:48  |  Polybios 05/06/07
  174.   #173 Polybios 23:35  |  ballistic 05/06/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: 1967 - The war that ended Judaism
Send response
Shmuel Rosner: Republican tough talk on Iran touches on tactical nukes
Responses: 1
Uzi Benziman: The rest of the world sees Israel as an occupier
Send response
Peretz: IDF ready for Syria war, must give diplomacy a chance
Responses: 13


More Headlines
07:58 IDF kills two Palestinians in separate incidents in territories
08:46 Peretz says IDF ready for Syria war, but advocates diplomacy
09:24 PM: Israel ready to discuss Arab plan, but won't be dictated to
07:12 Evacuation of settlers in Hebron home unlikely in near future
06:30 Peres seeks majority for presidential vote among MKs
05:52 Civil Rights association protests Justice's revision of Basic Law
00:17 IDF probes soldiers' use of Palestinian human shields
06:27 Violent demonstrations threaten to cloud G8 summit in Germany
07:08 Lev Leviev richest man in Israel, fortune of over $6 billion
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved