Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., June 01, 2007 Sivan 15, 5767 | | Israel Time: 04:17 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 20:44 31/05/2007
Knesset Constitution Cmte. Chair: Israeli Arabs to have collective rights
By Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondent

Israeli Arabs will receive certain collective rights that will be guaranteed by a future constitution said Menachem Ben-Sasson, chairman of the Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee on Thursday.

According to Ben-Sasson, the rights would be similar to those granted to minority groups by other nations' constitutions, and relate to language, culture, education, as well as proportional representation in state institutions.

"Jews in the Middle Ages, who lived under Islamic rule, had collective rights, and therefore the Arab public in Israel should also enjoy such rights," said Ben-Sasson, during a Tel Aviv conference on the issue organized by the Musawa Center for Arab Rights in Israel.

Advertisement

"Citizens succeed when they have an attachment to their community," he said. "The issue of collective rights must be at the heart of the constitution and not marginal."

"Citizens have obligations, and if the Arab citizens do not serve in the army, then it is possible that they will have to participate in a civilian national service," he added.

Ben-Sasson called on Arab Israeli leaders to take part in writing the constitution, or in legislative preparations carried out by the Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice Committee before its implementation.

"Those who don't attend the preparatory sessions will have no right to complain in the future that the rights granted aren't sufficient," he said.

MK Taleb al-Sana of Ram-Tal, who is also a member of the Knesset constitution committee, said in response that Arab Israeli rights could not be granted by an intrinsically racist government body.

Dr Yussuf Jabarin presented the Knesset committee 10 collective rights issues on which the Arab Israeli community demands future legislation, outlined in a document by the Musawa Center.

Chairman of the Higher Arab Monitoring Committee of Israel, Shuweiki Hatib said "In Israel there are two realities, that of the weakened Arab population and that of the Jews."

"We want to change this. We, the people, can do this, and we want to do it by democratic, legal means," added Hatib.

President of the Israeli Press Council, Justice Dalia Dorner, said the demand for a change in the nature of the Jewish nation may have negatively effect the Jewish majority, but that it was necessary to have democracy.

"Israel was not founded to promote democracy, it was founded to be a Jewish state. However it is Israel's responsibility to be democratic and to grant its Arab citizens total equality," she said. "It is a failure on the part of the state that Arab citizens have not been granted equal rights," Dorner added.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Asian temple
Zepra is an example of concept dining: as much an experience in ambience as in fine dining.
Friedmann's failure
No one should argue that the gov't cannot function due to a fear of criminal probes.
  1.   Very Ironic 17:15  |  ARTH 31/05/07
  2.   citizenship on Israel based and established on Jewish values!!!! 17:51  |  Ben Uziel 31/05/07
  3.   Not to Worry 17:53  |  Lev 31/05/07
  4.   We Should Offer Them Dhimmi Rights 17:58  |  Yishai Kohen 31/05/07
  5.   #4 18:18  |  ARTH 31/05/07
  6.   We must ensure the rights of our 5th column 18:33  |  Steven 31/05/07
  7.   #5 18:34  |  Gili 31/05/07
  8.   Individual Rights, not Group Rights 18:39  |  David B. 31/05/07
  9.   Jewish people=Jewish state!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 19:28  |  Yoni 31/05/07
  10.   Jewish State = Racist State, Israeli State = Democracy 19:44  |  anti-racist 31/05/07
  11.   #8 democracy doesn`t mean only western democracy!!!!! 19:46  |  George 31/05/07
  12.   Jewish "rights" under Islam - "Dhimmi" 19:54  |  Sharon Green 31/05/07
  13.   #10 his answer perfectly describes his Intellect!!!!!!!!! 19:58  |  James 31/05/07
  14.   Ray of Hope 20:06  |  Richard 31/05/07
  15.   only jews can make law in a jewish state!!!! 20:09  |  Ben 31/05/07
  16.   Jews in Arab nation`s history toleraterd UNTOLERABLY!!!!!! 20:15  |  Ben Uziel 31/05/07
  17.   should be done for th eright reasons 20:19  |  Rami 31/05/07
  18.   to #12 although i don`t advocate anyone doing 20:33  |  terry 31/05/07
  19.   It`s very important move 21:05  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 31/05/07
  20.   in other words they will get what they already have in israel as 21:08  |  nh 31/05/07
  21.   what a joke 21:16  |  socalmaverick 31/05/07
  22.   Knesst constitution 21:19  |  Louis 31/05/07
  23.   #6 Steven 21:38  |  Galilee Arab 31/05/07
  24.   Ben Sasson is ignorant and dagerous 21:49  |  Elie 31/05/07
  25.   Blindness from within 22:09  |  observer 31/05/07
  26.   every one of these arab`s is racist non-democratic anti-israel we 22:11  |  ralph 31/05/07
  27.   these arab speakers cannot leave because no democratic arab count 22:11  |  ralph 31/05/07
  28.   plentry of arab countries to go to if they want whoops non democr 22:12  |  ralph 31/05/07
  29.   these rights are more than any arab/muslim country grants its min 22:14  |  ralph 31/05/07
  30.   Why only blame the state 23:06  |  Gary 31/05/07
  31.   Ben for Occupied Jerusalem...you are so wrong! 23:27  |  New Yorker 31/05/07
  32.   A good step forward 23:41  |  Wael Hendawi 31/05/07
  33.   Collective rights for Arabs=anti-Democratic 00:07  |  Scharker Yid 01/06/07
  34.   New yorker...how`s the view from the cheap seats!!! 00:22  |  Ben 01/06/07
  35.   Yet more nonsense from Israel`s radical democrats 02:20  |  Raymond from DC 01/06/07
  36.   another really bad idea 02:35  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 01/06/07
  37.   #7 03:09  |  ARTH 01/06/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Boycotting Israel as moral masturbation
Responses: 178
Amira Hass: Israel waging technological war on Palestinians
Responses: 152
Talia Sasson: Forcing Israeli Arabs to take a loyalty oath
Responses: 112
South Africa's largest trade union seeks to boycott Israel
Responses: 342
U.K. minister slams British boycott of Israeli academic institutions
Responses: 293
Olmert explores, via third party, resuming talks with Syria
Responses: 87
Rosner's Domain
* It's not the war stupid, it's the occupation
* Summer surprises in Syria and Palestine
* WTR: Iraq Study Group popular than ever
* Guest: I will support my daughter whether or not she marries Jewish


More Headlines
03:28 Israel waiting for new list of prisoners from Hamas
03:51 IDF: No Gaza ground operation due to fear of war with Syria
03:32 U.S. envoy to PA slams Israel for refusing to ease PA conditions
03:30 U.K. envoy to Israel: British lecturers' boycott call unlikely to affect bilateral ties
22:34 White House: Bush, Olmert to hold summit on June 19 in Washington
23:07 FM talks with Pakistani minister, Iraqi First Lady at Vienna conference
22:40 U.K. public services union to consider boycott of Israel
19:35 Officials: Israel ready to transfer withheld tax revenues to PA
19:46 State: PM to appoint finance minister after Labor Party primaries
17:42 Shin Bet arrests three Hamas militants who tried to attack IDF troops
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved