Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., June 10, 2007 Sivan 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:10 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 17:28 31/05/2007
Boycotting Israel as moral masturbation
By Bradley Burston


Just for the sake of argument, let's suppose that you're a British academic. You believe strongly that the occupation must end, that the Palestinians should have an independent state, that Israel's military and diplomatic policies are wrongheaded to the point of immorality.

What to do? Simple. Find the one group within Israeli society which has consistently, vigorously and courageously campaigned against the occupation since its inception.

Advertisement

Then attack them.

Single them out for professional ruin. Do your best to get as many of their colleagues around the world to shun them. Yes, just as if you were in seventh grade and had decided to alleviate your own feelings of insecurity, inadequacy, panic and lack of requisite cool by cutting another victim from the middle school herd and lobbying your equally insecure colleagues to abuse the chosen victim.

Choose your victim with care. Select the one group in Israel which has taken substantive physical, professional, legal and personal risks, which has defied the spirit of Israeli nationalism and the letter of Israeli law, in order to seek out Palestinians to search for equitable solutions.

Select the one group which has, from the very beginning, spoken out eloquently for the rights of the Palestinians to self-determination, to freedom from Israeli domination, to freedom from disproportionate and often indiscriminate use of force, to freedom from social injustice.

Then denounce them.

Decide that your moral vision fully empowers you to declare Israeli professors and other university and college faculty to be unworthy of practicing their calling. All of them.

That is, perhaps, the real beauty of the British campaign to declare a quarantine over Israeli academics.

You really must envy the U.K. far-left for its blindness. Its consummate inability to see more than one side, which is to say, its demonstrated refusal to see Jews as fellow human beings, is only exceeded by its exquisite sense of timing.

No matter that in the whole of the 1991 Gulf war, Saddam Hussein managed to hit all of Israel with a total of 39 missiles, and that two weeks ago, Hamas sent 40 rockets into the Sderot area in the space of a single day.

No matter that Sapir College, Israel's largest public college, has for years been a primary target of Qassam crews.

No matter that in boycotting all Israeli academics on the basis of their being Israelis, the measure is patently racist, a grotesque reprise of the history of curbing academic freedom.

No matter that Israeli Arab academics who are staunchly opposed to the occupation are vehement opponents of the boycott as well.

No matter, even, that opposition to the boycott runs strong within the British University and College Union itself. In fact, all the more reason to press on.

For the genuine elitist, the unpopularity of an opinion is the best assurance of its real value.

Perhaps this is why the whole boycott campaign smacks of a uniquely far-left British brand of moral masturbation, a desperate, delusional, sterile, supremely self-contained form of non-activism that risks nothing even as it changes nothing.

There must be some reason why no one in this world does condescension better than the British far-left. There must be some reason why the British far-left manages to satisfy itself with a uniquely public, uniquely self-congratulatory form of ideological self-abuse.

Leftists abroad would do well to respect their Israeli counterparts for defying societal norms to work for the rights of people with whom their nation is at war. Perhaps the Israeli left deserves respect, as well, for having to do this while enduring the racist abuse of leftists abroad.

_____________


Recent blogs:
U.K.-based humanists who don't care for Jews
Hamas' latest conquest, The Walt Disney Co

Talkbacks are for cowardly bigots
Israel's worst blunders since '67 - and the Arabs'

__________________



The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.


Bookmark to del.icio.us
Slamming the court
Friedmann seeks to increase the politicization of choosing an attorney general while increase the government's control over the process
He shoots, he scores
Something in Gaydamak's financial moves in the last month is reminiscent of his soccer adventure.
  1.   You`ve hit the nail, squarely on the head. 13:15  |  Niall 31/05/07
  2.   If true, then they should be for the boycott. 13:24  |  Rutger Omedahl 31/05/07
  3.   The Apartheid must end Bradley 13:35  |  Daniel 31/05/07
  4.   Ending Occupation - Rutger 13:52  |  David 31/05/07
  5.   Facts, please, Daniel 14:08  |  sellier 31/05/07
  6.   Bradley,Bradley,Bradley Opening point is a Home Run 14:18  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  7.   NOBODY`S PERFECT 14:21  |  indrajaya 31/05/07
  8.   totally off the mark 14:29  |  jj burke 31/05/07
  9.   Bradley Burston 14:45  |  Daniel 31/05/07
  10.   JJ Burke - Don`t Whine 14:47  |  John 31/05/07
  11.   jj burke - moral idiot 15:09  |  MarkC 31/05/07
  12.   this boycott is NOT racist or political but MORAL 15:11  |  David 31/05/07
  13.   # 8, JJ BURKE 15:11  |  indrajaya 31/05/07
  14.   Many have written on this "boycott" 15:16  |  Michael Steiner 31/05/07
  15.   jj burke 15:21  |  Inigo Montoya 31/05/07
  16.   jj burke2 15:23  |  Inigo Montoya 31/05/07
  17.   #2: 15:39  |  Michael Steiner 31/05/07
  18.   #10 15:48  |  jj burke 31/05/07
  19.   #9 Daniel from Mersey side 15:55  |  Itsik 31/05/07
  20.   Boycotting Israel by British Academics 16:03  |  Randy 31/05/07
  21.   we should boycott the english language 16:15  |  christoph 31/05/07
  22.   Some Comments on This Article 16:17  |  Howard Katz 31/05/07
  23.   A question for Daniel in the UK 16:27  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  24.   Well David, that of course is a matter of opinion 16:31  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  25.   As the Vilna Gaon Said... 16:41  |  Evan 31/05/07
  26.   3: Yes Daniel, when will you stop it? 16:44  |  David Teich 31/05/07
  27.   Jacob Blues-Very good question 16:54  |  almagor 31/05/07
  28.   Remind them of the Acco prison break 17:18  |  Jake 31/05/07
  29.   At first I was aginst this boycott... 17:33  |  GrossedOut 31/05/07
  30.   Unison in 14 days time will announce their boycott 17:37  |  Chris Linthwaite 31/05/07
  31.   Boycott Arab World`s abuse Womens Rights, Gay Rights 17:40  |  Margaret 31/05/07
  32.   The Left Does Respect those oppossed to occupation 17:47  |  Yaakov Sullivan 31/05/07
  33.   Far-Left Pro-Palestinian israeli Academics Boycotted 17:47  |  Penelope 31/05/07
  34.   Kassam are falling..... 17:48  |  Shalom 31/05/07
  35.   Evidence? 17:48  |  Frederico 31/05/07
  36.   ZIONISM is RACIST MASTURBATION 17:50  |  BOYCOTT ISRAEL-NOW 31/05/07
  37.   Honor Killings of Women in Palestinian Cities 17:51  |  Jen 31/05/07
  38.   "Morally masturbation" isn`t moral at all! 17:52  |  Sink 31/05/07
  39.   Giving Masterbation a Bad Name 17:57  |  FOX 31/05/07
  40.   Masturbation, the "LEFT" and Jews. 17:57  |  curious 31/05/07
  41.   For jj burke - Ditto 17:58  |  Les Moore 31/05/07
  42.   Perhaps British Academics should declare support 17:58  |  H50 31/05/07
  43.   The south African model 17:58  |  Yaron 31/05/07
  44.   #3 - @Daniel, "Apartheid", lmao! 18:02  |  Freedom of press 31/05/07
  45.   #31 Margerat 18:02  |  Chris Linthwaite 31/05/07
  46.   The Arab World is FAR from perfect, but OCCUPATION is AN EVIL 18:05  |  BOYCOTT ISRAEL-NOW 31/05/07
  47.   To my leftist "academic & intellectual brothers..." 18:07  |  bat yam 31/05/07
  48.   I love theses boycotts! Gimme more, more, more! :-) 18:07  |  Israeli right 31/05/07
  49.   Yaron 18:07  |  H50 31/05/07
  50.   They do what they can 18:11  |  Fritz 31/05/07
  51.   Bradley: Deja Vu! 18:12  |  CHGODMK 31/05/07
  52.   Silly bursting Bradley 18:13  |  Tosefta 31/05/07
  53.   Why is Ilan Pappe leaving Israel? 18:22  |  Abier Shamma 31/05/07
  54.   #23 media should bring them to task on China 18:26  |  Felix Drost 31/05/07
  55.   Not to go off topic, but it was what, just over a week ago 18:26  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  56.   They want to stick it to the Jews 18:28  |  Sam 31/05/07
  57.   left is and always anti-Semitic 18:31  |  Tomas 31/05/07
  58.   #49, to H50 18:38  |  Yaron 31/05/07
  59.   knew i would find tosefta in section entitled moral masturbation 18:40  |  yirmiyahu 31/05/07
  60.   For Daniel 18:42  |  Simon 31/05/07
  61.   tosefta is being carried away by his verbosity 18:44  |  yirmiyahu 31/05/07
  62.   Lesson for Israeli leftists 18:45  |  Lou 31/05/07
  63.   Good article, Haaretz 18:50  |  Polybios 31/05/07
  64.   British Moral Masturbation 18:51  |  JW 31/05/07
  65.   The Brits Must Employ MORAL MATURBATION 18:55  |  Eli 31/05/07
  66.   Academic Wanker`s.... 18:59  |  Nils 31/05/07
  67.   Boycotting Israel 19:02  |  Chajah 31/05/07
  68.   Indrajaya? Israel An Evil Regime? 19:03  |  Yosemite 31/05/07
  69.   Talkback Generalisations 19:06  |  Stephen J 31/05/07
  70.   The left is not against Jews 19:09  |  Marilyn 31/05/07
  71.   Slap in the face of Israeli peaceniks 19:14  |  Gene 31/05/07
  72.   You`re pumping up the blood pressure Bradley. 19:17  |  Nick Ferriman 31/05/07
  73.   All Palestinians live under Self-Rule PA/HAMAS 19:19  |  Mohammad 31/05/07
  74.   Great - and excactly to the point. 19:22  |  Elias 31/05/07
  75.   Israeli and Palestinian academics = Helpless human beings 19:23  |  Swiss (Dino) 31/05/07
  76.   Make "Peace" with Qassam rocketers and Terrorists? 19:24  |  Shimon Peres 31/05/07
  77.   70marilyn, "nutters" & "squatters" 19:31  |  curious 31/05/07
  78.   Chris Linthwaite 19:34  |  Jeremy Woolf 31/05/07
  79.   Yaron 19:36  |  H50 31/05/07
  80.   Beautifully justified. 19:41  |  Ali bin Abu ibn Abd 31/05/07
  81.   Academic community that violates its own first principles 19:41  |  Shalom Freedman 31/05/07
  82.   To #70 19:44  |  Seraph 31/05/07
  83.   The British army is occupying Iraq 19:46  |  Colonial 31/05/07