Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., May 06, 2008 Iyyar 1, 5768 | | Israel Time: 12:50 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Holding on tight to the frequencies
By Amira Hass

The air is one escape route from the roadblocks and the separation regime that Israel imposes on the Palestinians. But Israel catches up with them even in the air. Israel does not allocate cellular frequencies to the Palestinians that answer their modern technological, economic, social and personal needs. More precisely, Israel refuses to coordinate with the Palestinians so they can use the cellcom frequencies they should have according to the International Telecommunications Union.

The Communications Ministry claims there is no coordination because we are not speaking to the Hamas government. A convenient excuse, but flawed, because even before the Hamas government arose, Palestinian requests to coordinate additional frequencies went unanswered. The Palestinian cellphone company Jawwal received the frequencies it should have had only in 1999, two years after it was founded. In March this year, Jawwal got a competitor: Al-Wataniya. The Kuwaiti company Wataniya International won the Palestinian Authority tender at the end of 2006. Ownership is to be shared between the international company, the Palestinian Investment Fund (PIF) and the public. A professional British management team was appointed, 500 jobs were promised, but no frequencies were allocated.

The importance of the air is reflected in the following data: Jawwal has about 800,000 subscribers, about 60 percent of the Palestinian cellphone market. Economists estimate that Israeli companies have about a 40-percent share of the market. The approximately 4 million Palestinians have more than 1.3 million cellphones. Some people have two - a Palestinian one and an Israeli one. The Palestinians come in third in the Arab world in the number of people connected to the fast data transmission system ADSL. They are also frequent users of video-conferencing services at their parliament - the Palestinian Legislative Council - at government ministries and at private businesses.
Advertisement
That is how they overcome the severing of Gaza from the West Bank and the roadblocks between Jenin and Ramallah. Families who live a few dozen kilometers apart and who have not seen each other for five years or more have learned how to make do with phones, Skype, and e-mails. No wonder Paltel (the Palestinian telecoms company, of which Jawwal is a subsidiary) is the most profitable Palestinian firm.

Dozens of requests for operating permits for Internet and information technology companies lie on the desk of the deputy Palestinian communications minister, Suleiman Zuhairi, who has been working at the ministry since its establishment in 1994. He cannot approve them because of the lack of frequencies.

The geopolitical reality of the multiplied "borders" between the Palestinian enclaves, on the one hand, and area C (of full Israeli control) and the settlements - which comprise 60 percent of the West Bank - requires maximum coordination between Israel and the PA. As long as Israel does not agree to coordinate the distribution and use of frequencies, it will be impossible to install proper equipment in C areas. That is the reason that even the development of landline infrastructure is limited. No private company will risk installing equipment in C areas lest the Civil Administration's supervisors and the Israel Defense Forces bulldozers pounce on it and destroy it.

Although the Israeli Communications Ministry denies any connection with this matter, the non-allocation of frequencies to Palestinians serves the Israeli companies that compete with Jawwal on terms favorable to them. (They do not pay taxes to the PA, although the cellular phones are being used in the Palestinian territories.)

The non-allocation of frequencies is another front in the economic war Israel is waging against the Palestinians. It means a direct loss of income, of jobs, and the blocking of the desire to develop economic niches, which by making use of the air, could overcome the earthen roadblocks and apartheid roads.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Shimon goes green
Peres says to fight terror Israel should reduce its dependence on oil.
Voices of heroism
IDF releases audio recordings from famed 1976 Entebbe raid.
  1.   We Should Destroy Communication Network. 10:06  |  Terry 31/05/07
  2.   Frequencies 10:17  |  bish 31/05/07
  3.   amira 10:35  |  eva 31/05/07
  4.   It is an economic siege 10:42  |  Jessie Coehn 31/05/07
  5.   Good article. 10:56  |  cfs 31/05/07
  6.   Holding on tight to the frequencies 10:59  |  David Pacifici 31/05/07
  7.   Amira Give me a Call 11:00  |  FOX 31/05/07
  8.   Re: #1 :We Should Destroy Communication Network 11:17  |  Guy From NYC 31/05/07
  9.   Ignore Israeli frequencies 11:18  |  John 31/05/07
  10.   how dare the zionists interfere 11:35  |  Leon Rosgarten 31/05/07
  11.   and so ummmm... 11:55  |  eric 31/05/07
  12.   terry #1 12:04  |  isaac 31/05/07
  13.   to terry 12:05  |  strongbow 31/05/07
  14.   boo hoo 12:20  |  don 31/05/07
  15.   If we expel them then there will be no need to ban frequencies! 12:27  |  Yael 31/05/07
  16.   Arab colonists should be removed from our country 12:33  |  Jo 31/05/07
  17.   Amira`s conspiracy theories 12:42  |  Nik Miller 31/05/07
  18.   Boycott Israel? 12:44  |  Nik Miller 31/05/07
  19.   Who cares about cell phones, the Palestinians are bombing us. 13:09  |  Steven 31/05/07
  20.   Appalling 13:28  |  Marilyn 31/05/07
  21.   Amira school of journalism 13:28  |  Meni 31/05/07
  22.   Holding on tight to the frequencies 13:37  |  Marlene 31/05/07
  23.   Broken Telephone 14:00  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  24.   question HOW DO IDENTIFY AZIONIST IN THE STREET ?? 14:02  |  paul harris 31/05/07
  25.   Go Marlene! Let`s boycott technology! 14:18  |  Shlomi 31/05/07
  26.   BOOHOO-OCCUPIED FAMILIES ONLY GET 80 CHANNELS & 2AIR CONDITIONERS 14:26  |  Buncha Kooks 31/05/07
  27.   A M I R A the angry Jewess 14:31  |  GABE !!!!!! 31/05/07
  28.   oh my amira tell it to the rocket launchers war is war get used t 14:40  |  ralph 31/05/07
  29.   Gabe come on we`ve all got cellphones in canada 14:53  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  30.   Marilyn (second attempt) 14:55  |  Nik Miller 31/05/07
  31.   Holding on tight to the freequencies 14:56  |  Rosa 31/05/07
  32.   Marilyn may I ask your opinion 15:13  |  Mordechai 31/05/07
  33.   to PAUL HARRIS - TELL US WHERE YOU LIVE... 15:18  |  David 31/05/07
  34.   Shlomi the dummy 15:19  |  Mordechai 31/05/07
  35.   Dear Amira 15:24  |  Yussuf 31/05/07
  36.   #30 for Rosa - a good post 15:26  |  David 31/05/07
  37.   David vs Paul Harris 15:30  |  Mordechai 31/05/07
  38.   to Terry #1 15:33  |  Clickfan 31/05/07
  39.   David I am not a right winger... 15:34  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  40.   @10, leon happy to see you back. bravo!!!!! 15:36  |  vladimir 31/05/07
  41.   Amira Hass on frequencies 15:37  |  Nora 31/05/07
  42.   #33 DAVID DEVOID OF COMMON SENSE MAKES A STATEMENT 15:38  |  paul harris 31/05/07
  43.   A bucket of tears 15:38  |  Yakov 31/05/07
  44.   Loss of jobs, income and economic holds 15:41  |  Yaakov Sullivan 31/05/07
  45.   Aparteid State 15:43  |  Clickfan 31/05/07
  46.   David Give him TWO on the chin!!!! 15:45  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  47.   To Terry /Sometimes I tell to my friends abroad... 16:06  |  Lena 31/05/07
  48.   Ronnie Wolman #29 16:07  |  GABE1 31/05/07
  49.   Paul Harris 16:12  |  GABE 1 31/05/07
  50.   Amira`s Hamas Manifesto 16:14  |  Robert 31/05/07
  51.   Hass: serving Hamas from the outside 16:15  |  Rachel 31/05/07
  52.   Haas waging a war on Haaretz readers 16:24  |  Sal 31/05/07
  53.   Robert and others bristle at the truth #50 16:32  |  Yaakov Sullivan 31/05/07
  54.   An example why Israel wants to maintain control 16:33  |  Ibrahim 31/05/07
  55.   to MORDECHAI and RONNIE - we too suffer from terrorism 16:36  |  David 31/05/07
  56.   Haas a hero under a burka-not from this century 16:43  |  A writer 31/05/07
  57.   Ronnie Wolman #29 16:43  |  GABE! 31/05/07
  58.   Analysis? Not really, 16:44  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  59.   The next article of Amira Hass 16:47  |  Jacques Kurdian 31/05/07
  60.   David in London #55 16:50  |  GABE! 31/05/07
  61.   Yes Clickfan, Palestinians are ready to blow up over cell phones 16:53  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  62.   To be expected.... 16:53  |  Natallie Durson 31/05/07
  63.   David: Standing Tall 17:01  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  64.   Yaacov of course, ignores 7 years of war 17:02  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  65.   Sorry Terry, but it appears you`re going to have to wait in line 17:07  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  66.   Gabe: Assault and Batteries not included 17:07  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  67.   No frequencies so sorry 17:30  |  Twogunz 31/05/07
  68.   haas has nothing more important to have a critic 17:34  |  vladimir 31/05/07
  69.   Ronnie on being "miserable" 17:45  |  Ibrahim 31/05/07
  70.   #63 A mautre and thoughtful post 17:52  |  David 31/05/07
  71.   Jacob Blues and his timelines #64 17:53  |  Yaakov Sullivan 31/05/07
  72.   #60 for Gabe - have you tried counselling? 17:55  |  David 31/05/07
  73.   Ibrahim: I ALSO know Nussink 17:56  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  74.   David in London re: Paul Harris 18:00  |  CHGODMK 31/05/07
  75.   What`s Wrong With This Picture? 18:02  |  Jeff Northridge 31/05/07
  76.   But Ibrahim isn`t that the reason Israel left Gaza 18:03  |  A writer 31/05/07
  77.   Ibrahim: Better Lives 18:08  |  CHGODMK 31/05/07
  78.   David: Nationalists and Democrats 18:10  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  79.   To all my friends,the antagonists and of course the censors 18:26  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  80.   David In the UK #72 18:34  |  GABE1 31/05/07
  81.   Palestinians should boycott cellphones 18:38  |  Steven 31/05/07
  82.   Indeed Yaacov, timing is everything 18:43  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  83.   One More thing Here David 18:45  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  84.   David 72, UR describing the Camorra in Naples 18:48  |  A writer 31/05/07
  85.   #74 CHGODMK - I have been to the West Bank 18:49  |  David 31/05/07
  86.   GABE if you are sane I`ll stay mad thanks. 18:54  |  David 31/05/07
  87.   #80 - Gabe you avoided answering my question - please ansswer it. 18:56  |  David 31/05/07
  88.   jeff northridge 18:57  |  strongbow 31/05/07
  89.   #83 Ronnie Your Warning about Gabe 18:58  |  David 31/05/07
  90.   Bombs are exploded with cell-phones! Like horse and carriage! 19:00  |  Alicia 31/05/07
  91.   David in the UK 19:03  |  CHGODMK 31/05/07
  92.   Not sure of your level of sanity David 19:09  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  93.   MRS HASS SENSE AND SENSABILITY 19:23  |  siem 31/05/07
  94.   Israeli actions against Judaism 19:38  |  S.Topen 31/05/07
  95.   David: Gabe and the 4 Amigos 19:38  |  Ronnie Wolman 31/05/07
  96.   It is called resisting the terrorism 19:40  |  TonyL 31/05/07
  97.   David in the UK #87 19:42  |  GABE1 31/05/07
  98.   CHGODMK 19:50  |  Ibrahim 31/05/07
  99.   Steven # 81 To Hell With Phones Already 19:53  |  Jeff Northridge 31/05/07
  100.   An inexcusable excuse 20:10  |  Tosefta 31/05/07
  101.   strongbow # 88 Not From Where I Live 20:21  |  Jeff Northridge 31/05/07
  102.   Jeff Northridge I am just trying to help the Palestinian cause 20:27  |  Steven 31/05/07
  103.   Insidious 20:38  |  Pssd Off American 31/05/07
  104.   94 - Pals have gotten billions in aid. 20:44  |  Bruriah Sarah 31/05/07
  105.   #85 DAVID DELUDES HIMSELF AGAIN 21:06  |  paul harris 31/05/07
  106.   I am fed uuup with this shitty inequality in Israel 21:15  |  Dutch 31/05/07
  107.   Why should Israel help the Palis? 21:18  |  RA 31/05/07
  108.   Amira Hass 21:20  |  Connie 31/05/07
  109.   no such thing as collective punishment 21:26  |  Igor D. 31/05/07
  110.   Amira Hass & her fantaisies 21:27  |  Monica Lewis 31/05/07
  111.   Ibrahim 21:29  |  CHGODMK 31/05/07
  112.   What is a difference 21:40  |  Dr. Ari Nir 31/05/07
  113.   They made their beds 21:40  |  Dr David I. Gross 31/05/07
  114.   Palestinian Cave Men Don`t Need Technology 21:49  |  Efox 31/05/07
  115.   # 104 21:50  |  Goldie 31/05/07
  116.   Cell Phone Frequencies 21:53  |  Garry 31/05/07
  117.   Ibrahim 22:00  |  CHGODMK 31/05/07
  118.   #105 I AM FED UP WITH THE DORIS CADIGAN INANITIES 22:10  |  paul harris 31/05/07
  119.   to # 65-terry #1 is right-from american terry 22:13  |  terry 31/05/07
  120.   jeff northridge 22:13  |  strongbow 31/05/07
  121.   Steven # 102 Because I Hate Phones 22:20  |  Jeff Northridge 31/05/07
  122.   to the 4 Amigos 22:24  |  David 31/05/07
  123.   Apartheid roads? 22:30  |  Phil 31/05/07
  124.   97 GABE - sorry but the PA has no control over anything 22:49  |  David 31/05/07
  125.   More petty harassment 22:51  |  Mark Lincoln 31/05/07
  126.   ALL COMUNICATIONS SHOULD BE CURTAILED 22:57  |  Jorge 31/05/07
  127.   What about the Ouija? ISraeli victims couyld use this 23:21  |  Ignacio 31/05/07
  128.   Pssd Off American # 103 Potential And Actual 23:26  |  Jeff Northridge 31/05/07
  129.   David #113 23:30  |  GABE! 31/05/07
  130.   To # 114 23:40  |  Michael 31/05/07
  131.   Where is the problem? 23:41  |  KUTW 31/05/07
  132.   Israel should also give the pals 23:53  |  KUTW 31/05/07
  133.   Mark Lincoln`s view of harassment 23:57  |  Jacob Blues 31/05/07
  134.   103.Pssd Off American 23:59  |  KUTW 31/05/07
  135.   #11 Eric - Israel feels it`s essential to 00:00  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/07
  136.   David lets sort it out 00:01  |  Ronnie Wolman 01/06/07
  137.   Which peace dove would that be David? 00:01  |  Jacob Blues 01/06/07
  138.   #20 Marilyn, you`re so right, you are APPALLING 00:02  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/07
  139.   123 Gabe1 - did you actually READ my post? 00:03  |  David 01/06/07
  140.   #36 David - tell me just one thing 00:10  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/07
  141.   Pssd of American #103 00:16  |  TonyL 01/06/07
  142.   #105 Daffy Dutch - I too am fed up 00:17  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/07
  143.   #125 Mark Lincoln - It`s not petty 00:19  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/07
  144.   #103 insidious 00:23  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/07
  145.   jeff northridge re #103 00:40  |  strongbow 01/06/07
  146.   Mark Lincoln #125 00:46  |  TonyL 01/06/07
  147.   David in the UK 00:49  |  CHGODMK 01/06/07
  148.   are the palestians going to die if Israel does this? 01:23  |  zionist forever 01/06/07
  149.   #4 Jessie Coehn - tell me 01:24  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/07
  150.   15# Yael 01:49  |  Zebulonguy 01/06/07
  151.   wars 02:17  |  darwin 01/06/07
  152.   Amira Hass - You Are Delusional 02:36  |  Eli 01/06/07
  153.   Many more examples of how Israeli`s profit from occupation 03:07  |  Joe 01/06/07
  154.   amira ...you have the power. 03:29  |  maria 01/06/07
  155.   Talkback Observation 04:16  |  just passing through 01/06/07
  156.   CHGODMK spare me the tired rhetoric 04:27  |  Ibrahim 01/06/07
  157.   David #139 04:36  |  GABE! 01/06/07
  158.   Amiri Hass: Big Joke 05:12  |  Bill 01/06/07
  159.   # 135 that`s not what it said, ben 07:10  |  eric 01/06/07
  160.   Amira Hass is a Traitor. What do you expect from her? 07:18  |  Vittorio 01/06/07
  161.   The pals are rich are they????? 07:41  |  Willy 01/06/07
  162.   You got it backwards: PA waging war on Israel 08:06  |  Reuven 01/06/07
  163.   Well, after reading all the posts, you zionists 08:19  |  tad 01/06/07
  164.   Best Amira 08:29  |  George 01/06/07
  165.   #149 Ben Jabo--and the poor victimized 08:38  |  tad 01/06/07
  166.   `Haaretz ` supplies ammunition to British boycotters 09:11  |  Shalom Freedman 01/06/07
  167.   Palistinians bombed the offices of Jawwal. 10:05  |  Zev 01/06/07
  168.   #166 Shalom Freedman 10:32  |  tad 01/06/07
  169.   Guess what they can?t buy fertilizers too!!! 11:04  |  Gil 01/06/07
  170.   palestians are should think themselves lucky Israel does this 14:20  |  zionst forever 01/06/07
  171.   #165 Tad - try making a tad of sense 17:55  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/07
  172.   166 What Shalom Freedman is really whining about .... 18:08  |  Dutch 01/06/07
  173.   Amira, Israel`s ugly crime of land aggression 21:11  |  Dutch 01/06/07
  174.   Dutch`s Ugly crime of making a pledge 22:25  |  * BEN JABO 01/06/07
  175.   #1, cuting off 04:04  |  yuval 03/06/07
  176.   Wow....why you hate them this much?? 15:08  |  Abu Al Abed 06/06/07
  177.   Go Marlene! Let`s boycott technology! 12:23  |  Cool Dude 06/05/08
 Read & React
Moshe Arens: Is Olmert pushing for peace at any price?
Responses: 15
Daphna Golan: When will we listen to the Palestinians' suffering?
Responses: 27
Soldier killed in Lebanon War 'finally promoted to rank of Jew'
Responses: 12
Erekat: No progress in Monday's talks, key issues still contested
Responses: 40


More Headlines
12:23 Court: Foreign national's testimony needed in new Olmert probe
12:30 Erekat: No progress in Monday's talks, key issues still contested
11:30 IAF airstrike kills Hamas gunman in northern Gaza mortar squad
09:38 Panel: Ultra-Orthodox settlement should be city, despite illegal construction
10:12 Soldier killed in Lebanon War 'finally promoted to rank of Jew'
11:32 1948 Diaries: Former Jordanian POW recalls Gush Etzion defeat
08:06 IDF releases audio recordings from famed 1976 Entebbe rescue
05:34 Boy's death in Lod fire may have been part of domestic dispute
11:23 Egyptian police kill Nigerian trying to cross into Israel
05:03 Israeli backpackers' deaths fan parents' fears
11:12 Italian president defends Turin book fair honoring Israeli writers
09:31 Reform Jews open Israel's first state-funded non-Orthodox synagogue
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Dead Sea Products
Buy Dead Sea mineral skin care and beauty products. Coupon code Haaretz for 10% off.
Together Celebrating Israel's 60th
The Jewish Agency and world Jewry shaping the destiny of Israel and the Jewish people.
Pardes Institute Summer Sessions
http://www.pardes.org.il/
FAREWELL ISRAEL New Film
The Coming War for Islamic Revival - View Movie Trailer
The interest rates haven't changed
But your profits will!
Learn Hebrew online
with Israel's best teachers Sign up for a trial lesson today
Free the Palestinians from:
Corrupt Kleptocracy, Tyrannical Theocracy, Abysmal Anarchy
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
Real Estate in Israel
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved