Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., July 02, 2007 Tamuz 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 15:13 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Battle for Britain
By Haaretz Editorial

Britain has become in recent years the battlefield in Israel's fight for its existence as a Jewish state.

The number of British organizations calling for the boycott of Israel, their public campaigns, and their constant comparisons between Israel and the apartheid regime of South Africa have made the battle for British public opinion particularly significant.

On Wednesday, representatives of the new British University and College Union (UCU) will be meeting in Bournemouth. On the agenda is another proposal to boycott Israel's academic institutions. These proposals have become as regular and as predictable as Qassam attacks on Sderot. The fact that studies at the Sapir Academic College in Sderot are not taking place because of the constant rocket fire from Gaza, even though the college is not in occupied territory and Gaza is no longer occupied, apparently does not bother British academia. The fact that Hamas, which controls the Palestinian Authority, does not recognize even pre-1967 Israel, and commits acts of terror against civilians, does not matter either. These nuances did not stop one boycott initiator from saying last week that justice in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict is entirely on one side.

Advertisement

In the face of boycott proposals by Britain's National Union of Journalists, by a group of British doctors and a group of architects, and in the wake of the Anglican Church's decision to divest from companies cooperating with Israel, even the Israeli left - which opposes the occupation and has been working against it for years - has no choice but to fight back. Taking off the gloves in this debate involves knowingly foregoing the kudos that British academia lavishes on all who are willing to express anti-Israel stands. The UCU has even had the termerity to proclaim that Israeli lecturers who disown the policies of the Israeli government will not be boycotted. It is British academics who should lose sleep over this McCarthyistic demand. Academic freedom means first of all an open exchange of opinions, without coercion, and not shutting people's mouths. Moreover, the British boycott is directed at Israel's academic institutions that in any case are a bastion of opposition to the occupation.

On the 40th anniversary of the Six-Day War, British academia should look realistically at peace efforts in the Middle East: Over the past decade, Israel has elected governments that have expressed the desire of a majority of Israelis for a bilateral solution of two states for two peoples and a withdrawal from most of the settlements. The withdrawal from Gaza was to have been the first stage. The victory of Hamas, which refuses to recognize Israel, cut off the process.

The anti-Zionist winds blowing in Europe, mainly in academia and in Britain, strengthen the position that the very birth of the Jewish state was a mistake. The European hard left regards the Law of Return as the root of all evil; however, without acknowledging the Jewish character of the State of Israel, there is not even a basis for dialogue. British academia is in fact demanding that Israel democratically cease to exist as a Zionist entity, and that it be swallowed up in the non-democratic region in order to pander to the latest trend.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
'Katsav must confess'
Katsav's lawyer says his client could face a harsher indictment unless he confesses.
Spared the shame
The AG knew that if Katsav were to be jailed, the entire state would suffer.
  1.   Israel Bashers and Jew Hayers initiate boycott. Their names shoul 10:02  |  Vittorio 27/05/07
  2.   Its about time 10:08  |  JustWondering 27/05/07
  3.   major reasons for boycott ... 10:09  |  Leona 27/05/07
  4.   I am afraid the only ones threatening the existence of Israel.... 10:22  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/05/07
  5.   Illustrates Why Israeli Leftists Are Fools. 10:28  |  Terry 27/05/07
  6.   Illustrates Why Israeli Leftists Are Fools. 10:28  |  Terry 27/05/07
  7.   NUJ ignore Sudanese slaughterers 10:35  |  Seymour 27/05/07
  8.   You hear, Israel bashers? 10:41  |  S 27/05/07
  9.   I think, Britain is polarized. Half is anti-Semitic, half is not. 10:43  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 27/05/07
  10.   Haaretz`s Hypocrisy 10:48  |  FOX 27/05/07
  11.   stupid reaction to stupid boycott 10:48  |  joe 27/05/07
  12.   The truth is they don`t care about the facts 10:54  |  Judith, Haifa 27/05/07
  13.   To Leona 10:55  |  CuttheBS 27/05/07
  14.   Jews of UK should migrate 10:57  |  Nechama 27/05/07
  15.   Where are you Borat? 10:59  |  Nechama 27/05/07
  16.   #7 Hey Seymour 11:01  |  jake 27/05/07
  17.   A boycott could be effective 11:05  |  David 27/05/07
  18.   What happened in Rome Shall happen in britian 11:09  |  Ariel 27/05/07
  19.   British Academia scared, jealous, on the run 11:09  |  defender 27/05/07
  20.   Does `Hamas` Control ANYTHING? 11:14  |  Rowan Berkeley 27/05/07
  21.   Who are the boycott supporters? 11:22  |  CuttheBS 27/05/07
  22.   #4 Swiss ( Dino) 11:26  |  Sarah 27/05/07
  23.   Names of "academics" 11:31  |  CuttheBS 27/05/07
  24.   BOYCOTT DIVESTMENT SANCTIONS 11:32  |  Sami 27/05/07
  25.   #16 Jake 11:52  |  Kapule David Mabuta 27/05/07
  26.   Not anti-semitism, just decency 12:10  |  Spider 27/05/07
  27.   leona - part 1 12:11  |  saul a. readner 27/05/07
  28.   Kudos to the editors 12:12  |  Fed Up 27/05/07
  29.   Essential reading for a better understanding of Israel`s legal st 12:17  |  noel 27/05/07
  30.   swiss dino and "israel`s fault" 12:19  |  saul a. readner 27/05/07
  31.   Battle for Britain 12:22  |  Tony 27/05/07
  32.   david 12:23  |  saul a. readner 27/05/07
  33.   rowan berkeley 12:25  |  saul a. readner 27/05/07
  34.   Israel & the academic boycott 12:26  |  Barnes 27/05/07
  35.   anti semitism 12:30  |  tony 27/05/07
  36.   Boycott is the way to peace 12:32  |  A Lebanese 27/05/07
  37.   # 3 No reasons at all - all nonsense 13:02  |  Maureen Haigh 27/05/07
  38.   Does Hamas Control Anything 13:04  |  Barry 27/05/07
  39.   British Leftist Anti-Semitism 13:06  |  j10 27/05/07
  40.   Confused youths 13:08  |  ScotGuy 27/05/07
  41.   leona - part 2 13:23  |  saul a. readner 27/05/07
  42.   Leona 13:23  |  dangor 27/05/07
  43.   The Unions have been hijacked by leftists 13:27  |  British academic 27/05/07
  44.   The Sun Never Sets on..... 13:28  |  FOX 27/05/07
  45.   Name of the "academics` 13:31  |  dangor 27/05/07
  46.   Lebanese #36 13:37  |  Judith, Haifa 27/05/07
  47.   Response to #s- 3,17,20,24,26,34 &36 13:42  |  noel 27/05/07
  48.   26Spider-The 20%vote & run for PM, YET arab states are JUDENREIN 13:49  |  Ben 27/05/07
  49.   For the British backlash you can thank Israeli land-grabbers 13:50  |  Ivar 27/05/07
  50.   #31 Tony 13:52  |  Sarah 27/05/07
  51.   Myths and facts about "Palestine" revisited 13:53  |  Judith, Haifa 27/05/07
  52.   This article is not accurate and neither some posters 14:01  |  lakshmi 27/05/07
  53.   # 22 Sarah 14:02  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/05/07
  54.   Thanks Leona that needed to be said 14:05  |  Shelly 27/05/07
  55.   # 30 saul a. readner 14:12  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/05/07
  56.   This is an encouraging development 14:14  |  Pt 27/05/07
  57.   Sarah, #50, knows not the battle for hearts and minds 14:22  |  Ivar 27/05/07
  58.   To Ben: Racism inside the Green Line 1 14:28  |  Spider 27/05/07
  59.   To Ben: Racism inside the Green Line 2 14:28  |  Spider 27/05/07
  60.   58/59spider-Very unconvincing argument for Boycott 14:45  |  Ben 27/05/07
  61.   Sarah, Dino (Swiss) has a point 14:47  |  Mark B. 27/05/07
  62.   The UN made it Kosher 14:51  |  ATLAS 27/05/07
  63.   The expression of a desre for peace is just talk. Construction of 14:51  |  Apartheid 27/05/07
  64.   Britain`s Academia: My Perspective 1 15:09  |  Omid the Persian 27/05/07
  65.   Too distorted coverage, just as usual 15:11  |  M 27/05/07
  66.   #53 Swiss (Dino) 15:18  |  Sarah 27/05/07
  67.   Elena Bonner, widow of Andrei Sakharov, on boycott 15:18  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 27/05/07
  68.   WAY TO GO BRITISH ACADEMIA, THE TIME IS RUNNING OUT 15:35  |  indrajaya 27/05/07
  69.   Irony 15:41  |  Derek 27/05/07
  70.   Omid the Persian 15:41  |  CuttheBS 27/05/07
  71.   British academic self- incrimination 15:43  |  Shalom Freedman 27/05/07
  72.   Hang on a minute 15:49  |  Chris Linthwaite 27/05/07
  73.   Swiss and defense 15:52  |  Lynn 27/05/07
  74.   Comment to Fox on Haaretz`s hypocrisy 15:55  |  Laura 27/05/07
  75.   Indy 15:55  |  Intellectual 27/05/07
  76.   #64 Omid the Persian 16:00  |  Lynn 27/05/07
  77.   Barnes 16:02  |  Laura 27/05/07
  78.   Israel is and was a big mistake 16:05  |  A Z Shamma 27/05/07
  79.   #72 Weinberg is not boycotting 16:06  |  Lynn 27/05/07
  80.   Ben, the occupation is the major reason for boycott 16:10  |  Spider 27/05/07
  81.   Swiss Dino 16:11  |  Laura 27/05/07
  82.   Swiss Dino again 16:15  |  Laura 27/05/07
  83.   # 75, INTELLECTUAL 16:18  |  indrajaya 27/05/07
  84.   #15 Nechama - How can Borat 16:28  |  Yonatan 27/05/07
  85.   Lynn if they are so stupid 16:29  |  Chris Linthwaite 27/05/07
  86.   again swiss dino 16:30  |  saul a. readner 27/05/07
  87.   To Spider 16:52  |  Ehud