Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., May 27, 2007 Sivan 10, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:22 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A diplomatic solution to Gaza
By Uzi Benziman

There is something revolting about the crocodile tears the Palestinians are shedding. They appeal to the UN Security Council, asking it to intervene against Israel's military actions. Mahmoud Abbas travels to the Gaza Strip and urges the armed groups to restore calm. Hamas spokesmen do not reject proposals for a cease-fire. The impression is that after Hamas began taking blows from the Israel Defense Forces, they remembered to cry "stop."

No country would have put up with an assault on its sovereignty, which is what Hamas is doing with the Qassam barrages against Sderot and its environs. No army would hold back from seeking to maximize its initial successes, as has been evident in the IDF operations in the Gaza Strip. It appears that Hamas has come under pressure from the Israeli attacks, and even when it issues bellicose statements, it seems it is seeking a way to end the current conflagration.

On the face of it, Israel should reject such feelers. It has the right not to come to terms with a situation in which Hamas retains its ability to decide when to resume the missile attacks. But this attitude, however legitimate it may be, is dangerous: A violent confrontation has a dynamic of its own. It could get out of control and Israel may find itself missing an opportunity to put an end to it. The Second Lebanon War illustrates this. As early as the first days of the war the prime minister had a number of opportunities to shift toward diplomacy, but chose otherwise. As the campaign wore on, Ehud Olmert found it increasingly difficult to create a clear "victorious image." Presumably, in retrospect, he is very sorry about that.

Advertisement

A government that knows where it is headed, one that has a clear political vision, would take advantage of the pressure Hamas is under, and would transform it into a platform for dialogue for a comprehensive agreement. Under the present circumstances there is no chance for this: This government is bound by its refusal to recognize Hamas, and too weak to begin negotiations on the future of the West Bank or the Golan Heights. So it is best to make do with little, to limit the current bloodletting as much as possible and reach calm on the Gaza border, even for a limited period. This is so because a continuation of the violent confrontation is destined to result in an escalation whose scope cannot be predicted. It may also become complicated because of a military error, and mostly, because it comes at the expense of the people of Sderot. While the residents of Kiryat Shmona and other communities in the North had bomb shelters last summer (even if these had not been prepared for a long stay), the inhabitants of Sderot are completely exposed to the Qassams.

We should realize that the residents of Sderot are shell-shocked - nothing can hide this. They show textbook behavior of a population under such stress: When people are under existential threat they develop anxieties and fears. This is a natural and legitimate response. To deal with the crisis, the affected population must be made to feel that things are under control. Actively confronting the harsh circumstances is the key to overcoming the trauma. When the response is passive, the feeling of helplessness intensifies and the internal breakdown worsens. A community in a life-threatening situation needs leadership; when this is not working, societal cohesion is undermined.

This is what is happening in Sderot, and to restore the stricken town to its senses, the first thing needed is to set up basic defensive infrastructure. Research carried out about treating the citizens in the North during "Operation Accountability" in 1993 and "Operation Grapes of Wrath" in 1996 has resulted in important insights. In short: evacuating the population for a short period of time is useless. On the contrary, this might be harmful if it exposes the evacuees to the conditions that have contributed to their anxiety. Furthermore, the development of esprit de corps among the community under attack, stressing an ability to withstand a crisis, is an important way to bolster morale.

The residents of Sderot must be offered basic defenses to counter the difficulties and anxieties of the war. A cease-fire is therefore necessary to carry out an urgent operation that would set up secure rooms and reinforced shelters in the suffering town. Unfortunately, it's not only Hamas that needs a break in the current conflagration, but also Israel.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Far from home
British-born Major Benji Hillman who died in Lebanon was mourned by 1,500 marchers.
55,000 a week
Soccer captain Yossi Benayoun has just become Israel's best-paid player ever.
  1.   Israel should create the precedent: ANNEXATION FROM GAZA THE..... 10:18  |  Vittorio 27/05/07
  2.   Hamas Must Be Physically Eliminated. 10:47  |  Terry 27/05/07
  3.   #1 Vittorio. "The world cannot tolerate Hamas with qassams." 11:05  |  Maureen Ann 27/05/07
  4.   #3 Maureen Ann 11:42  |  Peter Mall 27/05/07
  5.   Too late -also for the diplomatic solution 11:51  |  Anne 27/05/07
  6.   A Cease-Fire Only Works When Fire Ceases 12:22  |  Yaela Katz 27/05/07
  7.   Sderot will suffer as long as Gaza does 12:23  |  American 27/05/07
  8.   Either Israel should enter with ground forces or stop 12:44  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 27/05/07
  9.   A ceasefire with Hamas 12:54  |  Ellen Rosser 27/05/07
  10.   Always beware of he who has nothing to lose 13:51  |  Natallie Durson 27/05/07
  11.   Israel cannot and will not undertake a ground invasion of Gaza 14:10  |  lakshmi 27/05/07
  12.   to Natallie 14:18  |  cesare 27/05/07
  13.   Lakshmi-`Only way forward is Arab Initiative` 15:27  |  Sam 27/05/07
  14.   Nice idea 16:27  |  Mark Lincoln 27/05/07
  15.   Uzi Benziman, Israel`s soveignty 18:06  |  Dutch 27/05/07
  16.   #s 3 and 4 Time to recall some history 21:31  |  Elihu 27/05/07
  17.   Earth to Dutch 22:02  |  David G 27/05/07
  18.   Retake Gaza forever! 23:45  |  Chaim 27/05/07
  19.   Israel Paying for Self-Delusion and Stupidity 00:04  |  Tod Zuckerman 28/05/07
  20.   Indolent defeatism 00:15  |  Ya`akov 28/05/07
 Today Online
Qassam damages Sderot home; IAF strikes Hamas post
Responses: 127
British academics challenging Israel's very right to exist
Responses: 161
Ya'alon: Bring down Iran regime, send troops into Gaza
Responses: 44
Gideon Levy: Olmert's policies better than Sharon's destruction
Responses: 51
PM: IDF may continue Gaza operations even if Qassams stop
Responses: 49


More Headlines
00:44 Qassam damages Sderot home; IAF strikes Hamas post in Gaza
22:55 PM: We may continue operating in Gaza even if Qassams stop
01:05 Israeli duo wins Cannes prize for best film by debut directors
20:17 Arab League Chief meets Fatah representatives in Cairo
01:32 Jordan: U.S. Congress has crucial role in peace process
01:58 70 sex offenders deemed 'dangerous' to be released this year
01:15 Secret IDF anthrax vaccine trial on soldiers to be investigated
00:11 2006 report: 46% of factories exceed pollution standards
17:58 Knesset panel: 'Protected areas' fail to safeguard Sderot residents
20:36 Soldier arrested for allegedly raping 14-year-old girl
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved