Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., May 30, 2007 Sivan 13, 5767 | | Israel Time: 14:56 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
It's better to be orphans
By Gideon Levy

Once again we are being hit by a wave of desire for "a strong man." From every direction, from the left and right, voices that miss former prime minister Ariel Sharon are being heard, like voices of longing for a father who has departed. "If Sharon were here the war in Lebanon would have ended differently," and "Sharon would have put an end to the Qassams a long time ago."

Let it be said at once: Being orphaned in Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's shadow is better than the fatherliness of the mythical leader. Hamas should be profoundly grateful to Sharon, thanks to whom it now controls Gaza. Hezbollah, too, would be ungrateful if it did not thank the man who led to its firm footing in Lebanon, and here in Israel Sderot owes that man for the Qassams that are landing on its head. Those who now miss Sharon are longing for the brute force and bullying that led us to the brink. Israel is nostalgic for its most dangerous leader, for the person who caused it more damage than anyone else.

During his six years as prime minister Sharon wiped out the last chance for the existence of a Palestinian partner. Sharon's Israel waged war on the Palestinian Liberation Organization, and instead of a secular movement that believes in compromises we received a fanatical Islamic leadership, just as the first Lebanon war gave rise to Hezbollah. Whom do we have to thank for this? Sharon.

Advertisement

Under Sharon's leadership the Israel Defense Forces destroyed all the institutions of the new and fragile Palestinian regime, from the police headquarters in various places to the welfare offices. As for Yasser Arafat, the only person who was able to forge a historic compromise, we eliminated him as a leader, and no one in Israel asked what would rise on the ruins of the PLO and who would come after Arafat. We have locked up Marwan Barghouti, a promising potential leader, for many years, together with a long list of political activists who talked about peace. We have also denied Arafat's successor, Mahmoud Abbas, the most moderate of the Palestinian leaders, any chance of gaining control, and we are not letting him present even the slightest achievement to his suffering citizenry.

Sharon is responsible for all of this. Under him, Israel spoke only the language of force, and of military and engineering operations, from Defensive Shield to the separation fence. After that, Sharon landed the much-praised disengagement on us. While ignoring in a racist and lordly way the existence of the Palestinian people in the Gaza Strip, which has its needs and desires, and ignoring its leadership, Sharon pulled the IDF and Jewish settlements out of Gaza without any agreement or hope for the future, only to allow Israel to continue to control the West Bank. We destroyed everything and we left the Gaza Strip behind lock and bolt, imprisoned as it had never been before.

And it is no wonder that imprisoned and hungry people, who have no exit, have turned to anarchy and violence. The experiment with humans has succeeded: They have indeed begun to run amok in their huge cage. Hamas came into power - this too was no surprise - and the world imposed a cruel economic boycott on the Palestinian Authority, with Israel's encouragement, even when the unity government arose. The civil war and the Qassams were not long in coming. These are just the appetizer. And what did we expect? And what did Sharon intend when he replaced one occupation with another?

If, heaven forbid, Sharon were now in a position of leadership, the IDF would already have invaded Gaza, just as it invaded Jenin and Nablus and sowed killing and destruction there. The firing of the Qassams might have ceased for a while, just as has happened with the terror attacks from the West Bank. But on the ruins, reinforced by poverty and despair, a new form of violent resistance would have arisen. Sharon, a real man, would also have totally destroyed the last remnants of the Palestinian unity government, and even then no one would have asked what would come in its stead. It isn't that we aren't acting like bullies now as well, kidnapping an education minister in the middle of the night and bombing money changers. But Olmert has refrained from going all the way in Sharon's path. How pleasant it is, relatively and temporarily, to be orphans in his lap.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Musical Mishna
Composer Andre Hadjou blends contemporary music with religious texts.
Lap dog
If your dog is old and you're worried about his health, hydrotherapy may help.
  1.   Gideon Levy is a traitor. What the traitor can advise? 10:10  |  Vittorio 27/05/07
  2.   Insanity 10:29  |  Daniel 27/05/07
  3.   Yes, it seems Israelis are always eager to bash 10:39  |  Dutch 27/05/07
  4.   Gideon Levy: You`re Totally Crazy. 10:40  |  Terry 27/05/07
  5.   this proves clearly, Olmert must be removed, forthwith, no delay! 10:42  |  Pavel 27/05/07
  6.   Do we need internal enemies? 10:49  |  Ebenezer 27/05/07
  7.   The historical fallacy of the Israeli right 10:51  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/05/07
  8.   Hamas is doomed 10:53  |  Steven 27/05/07
  9.   GIDEON LEVY: Israel`s next PM! 11:02  |  Samy 27/05/07
  10.   Haaretz: BEST NEWS SOURCE! 11:07  |  Samy 27/05/07
  11.   Sad.... 11:15  |  jake 27/05/07
  12.   #3 Dutch 11:22  |  Kapule David Mabuta 27/05/07
  13.   # Vittorio, An apologist for the truth.... 11:26  |  Dutch 27/05/07
  14.   @ 6 11:27  |  ralph 27/05/07
  15.   where is gidon levy living? 11:39  |  charles 27/05/07
  16.   if gidgeon became PM, peace would be achieved 13:29  |  VIPER 27/05/07
  17.   Excellent words! 14:01  |  Dutch Dirk 27/05/07
  18.   Estoy contigo Gideon 14:02  |  Gonzalo 27/05/07
  19.   Gideon Levy -seen by the outsiders 14:32  |  Anne 27/05/07
  20.   Gideon`s honesty 15:56  |  howiej 27/05/07
  21.   Gideon,Sharon was changing 16:11  |  Ronnie Wolman 27/05/07
  22.   The real traitors 16:20  |  Guershom 27/05/07
  23.   Arik Sharon 17:40  |  Mickey 27/05/07
  24.   Gideon`s got it 18:32  |  Omran, Fred 27/05/07
  25.   Insidious Expansion .... through Misdirection 19:20  |  Natallie Durson 27/05/07
  26.   Australia would love Gideon 19:59  |  Marilyn 27/05/07
  27.   Kudos to Gideon, though I have one point of disagreement 20:43  |  lakshmi 27/05/07
  28.   ORPHANS... to #22 21:01  |  Gabe 27/05/07
  29.   Chomsky was right: Mr. Levy always assertive 21:03  |  Wolfowitz 27/05/07
  30.   # 1 Of course Gideon Levy is a traitor 21:04  |  Avrom H 27/05/07
  31.   # 4 Levy is crazy 21:06  |  Mansour M 27/05/07
  32.   no 26 Australia would pelt you with salmonella eggs 21:13  |  Marc S 27/05/07
  33.   KISS SHARONS FEET 21:14  |  TOBIA 27/05/07
  34.   Gideon`s dishonesty # 20 21:15  |  Ilan K 27/05/07
  35.   #6 JAKE 21:21  |  TOBIA 27/05/07
  36.   Gideon Lewy for Prime Minister in Gaza 21:25  |  Monica L 27/05/07
  37.   Gideon Levy and the Haaretz 21:41  |  Severino T. Melo 27/05/07
  38.   Yes this TREASON! 21:41  |  Chris 27/05/07
  39.   For all the Gideon Levy "bashers"...... 22:31  |  Swiss (Dino) 27/05/07
  40.   Lakshmi -Thanks 22:40  |  AM 27/05/07
  41.   Kiss Sharon feet, Levy # 33 22:57  |  Amir P 27/05/07
  42.   To the fake `jake` #11: Not in my name! 23:16  |  Jake 27/05/07
  43.   alas gideon, once again you`ve unleashed 23:40  |  eric 27/05/07
  44.   Like "fragile" P.A. media, which constantly incites genocide... 23:52  |  Chaim 27/05/07
  45.   #39, Levy is ambassador of Jewish self hatred 23:58  |  Chaim 27/05/07
  46.   Sharon 00:19  |  Twogunz 28/05/07
  47.   No need 00:22  |  Yakov 28/05/07
  48.   and gideon`s explanation for 00:27  |  rich 28/05/07
  49.   Nonsense 00:42  |  Crack 28/05/07
  50.   Israel Needs A Civil War 00:45  |  Nite Owl 28/05/07
  51.   # 45 Chaim Political ambassador - Goodwill ambassador 00:51  |  Swiss (Dino) 28/05/07
  52.   40AM,thanks for the acknowledgment,it`s all important that the 01:25  |  lakshmi 28/05/07
  53.   Nite Owl - Israel Has Yet to Use Real Force in Gaza 03:07  |  Jane 28/05/07
  54.   Gideon`s" Imprisoned and Hungry People" 04:03  |  Yoram 28/05/07
  55.   Looking from scapegoats 04:09  |  Frank 28/05/07
  56.   Gideon Levy 04:32  |  Dwido 28/05/07
  57.   Eric, the Bard is turning in his grave 04:53  |  Jake 28/05/07
  58.   the problem is 04:59  |  ami 28/05/07
  59.   shocking, you really know how to sell out your country 05:46  |  jake 28/05/07
  60.   gideon levy 05:55  |  majer 28/05/07
  61.   ANOTHER HAARETZ WRITER WHOSE IDEAS ARE LOVED BY iSRAELS ENEMIES 06:06  |  Jorge 28/05/07
  62.   Ah, Bagels&Lakshmi, I agree! 06:51  |  whomever 28/05/07
  63.   Ah, Bagels&Lakshmi, I agree! 06:52  |  whomever 28/05/07
  64.   #35 tobia..stolen land 07:32  |  jake 28/05/07
  65.   SHARON IS A SUPEREGO OF ISRAELIS 07:41  |  indrajaya 28/05/07
  66.   # 59 ohhhh...to jake in montreal 07:58  |  eric 28/05/07
  67.   Indrajaya, a sad waste of gray matter 08:22  |  FOX 28/05/07
  68.   Eric, watching the news #66 09:40  |  FOX 28/05/07
  69.   to FOX #67 - a sad waste of precious lives 17:20  |  zeev 28/05/07
  70.   to Jorge #61 17:23  |  zeev 28/05/07
  71.   to FOX #68 17:30  |  zeev 28/05/07
  72.   62whomever,both Hezbollah and Hamas have publicly distanced 22:22  |  lakshmi 28/05/07
  73.   # 68 oh believe me fox, i have been...pt 1 07:09  |  eric 29/05/07
  74.   # 68 oh believe me fox, i have been...pt2 07:10  |  eric 29/05/07
  75.   Ebenezer #6 14:41  |  JJ 30/05/07
 Today Online
British lecturers to vote on calls for academic boycott of Israel
Responses: 92
Meshal: IDF won't deter Hamas attacks on Israel
Responses: 63
Yitzhak Laor: Shin Bet wants democracy for Jews only
Responses: 18
Rosner: Rice is still being eyed as a U.S. presidential candidate
Responses: 20


More Headlines
14:29 Vice Premier Shimon Peres announces candidacy for presidency
14:47 Report accuses Shin Bet, police of severely torturing Palestinian suspects
14:45 Security cabinet rejects Gaza truce, opts to keep pressure on Hamas
13:07 Qassam hits Sderot; 2 militants killed in IAF strike in Gaza Strip
11:43 Knesset to vote on bill allowing Jerusalem to ban gay pride parade
13:04 Meshal: Hamas to continue attacks on Israel despite IDF strikes
14:30 State Prosecutor slams rights groups for signing Hamas court petition
13:03 British lecturers to vote on boycott of Israeli academic institutions
10:39 Eichmann's fake passport goes on display in Buenos Aires Holocaust Museum
13:01 Barak, Olmert aides deny Peretz deal over Labor leadership race
Previous Editions