Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., May 31, 2007 Sivan 14, 5767 | | Israel Time: 07:02 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 07:45 25/05/2007
Physicist who refused to lecture in U.K.: I'm not calling for boycott
By Charlotte Halle, Haaretz Correspondent

An American physicist and Nobel Prize laureate who withdrew from a speaking engagement at a London university, citing anti-Israel and anti-Semitic sentiment in the U.K., says he is not calling for a boycott of Britain.

"I'm not calling on anyone else not to go to Britain," Prof. Steven Weinberg of the University of Texas, who was awarded the Nobel Prize for physics in 1979, told Haaretz on Thursday night. "I don't want to say I'm cutting ties with the U.K. - I love England. I just feel personally uncomfortable going with the atmosphere there at the moment. It's increasingly hostile to Israel, especially in the intellectual world."

Weinberg told the Imperial College in London, where he had been invited to speak in July in honor of Pakistani physicist Abdus Salam, that his decision was motivated by a move by Britain's National Union of Journalists to boycott Israeli products.

Advertisement

"I just felt this was too disgusting and I didn't want to go there this summer," Weinberg said. "I see in the British press and the BBC signs of a very strong anti-Israel bias - a kind of blind hostility that whatever Israel does, it is always in the wrong - so this is not an isolated action of a small group of anti-Semitic conspirators. This represents a widespread feeling among British journalists."

Weinberg said he sent the letter before learning that 120,000 members of the University and College Union were asked to vote on a proposed boycott of Israeli universities at its annual congress in Bournemouth on Tuesday and before he knew about the call in March by 130 British doctors to boycott the Israeli Medical Association.

Weinberg said he is against boycotts, and specifically boycotts of Israel: "To boycott Israel today would be like boycotting Czechoslovakia in 1938 when Hilter was complaining the Czechs were being unpleasant to the Germans in the Sudetenland."

Weinberg also pulled out of a 2006 conference at Durham University due to a boycott of Israeli academics imposed by the British National Association of Teachers in Further and Higher Education.

The International Advisory Board for Academic Freedom at Bar-Ilan University, which coordinates Israeli efforts against boycotts, said it respects but does not endorse Weinberg's position.

"Although we respect Prof. Weinberg's decision and sympathize with his feelings, we do not believe counter-boycotts are an effective way of dealing with the situation," the board said in a statement.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Taste the city
From French fries to calamari rings to health food, the Taste of the City Festival has it all.
Far from immaterial
Comme il faut embarks on a new approach to fashion this summer, gimmicks intact.
  1.   Weinberg`s Decision 07:15  |  Edward 25/05/07
  2.   WHY NOT PROFESSOR? 07:58  |  indrajaya 25/05/07
  3.   Anti-Semitism in France, England 08:26  |  Fritz 25/05/07
  4.   the coward academician who support occupation 09:30  |  cristina 25/05/07
  5.   INDRAJAYA.Why not call for a boycott of Indonesia.Defend that? 09:58  |  PETER SM 25/05/07
  6.   Weinberg * not comfortable* 10:18  |  Raoul Schur 25/05/07
  7.   #2, indrajaya 10:24  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 25/05/07
  8.   Czechoslovakia in 1938? 10:24  |  Faraz 25/05/07
  9.   Cristina 10:30  |  Raoul Schur 25/05/07
  10.   "cristina" you are so wise 10:31  |  Binyamin 25/05/07
  11.   occupation 10:33  |  gilbert 25/05/07
  12.   If Jewish thinkers all followed his lead the world would stop 10:45  |  don 25/05/07
  13.   Very courageous attitude 10:51  |  Rolandus 25/05/07
  14.   LONG LIVE PROF. STEVEN WEINBERG 10:53  |  RON 25/05/07
  15.   cristina 11:03  |  charles 25/05/07
  16.   Boycott of Israeli products 11:13  |  charles 25/05/07
  17.   # 7, CIPORA JULIANNA KOHN 11:13  |  indrajaya 25/05/07
  18.   # 5, PETER SM 11:15  |  indrajaya 25/05/07
  19.   thank you prof` 11:21  |  m b k 25/05/07
  20.   Well done, Prof Weinberg 11:36  |  notbrittish 25/05/07
  21.   Christina Who are you fooling? 11:36  |  Aby 25/05/07
  22.   Speaking for the many 11:44  |  Joe 25/05/07
  23.   Patients have taken ovr their asylums 11:49  |  Joseph 25/05/07
  24.   English anti-semitism 11:49  |  martin 25/05/07
  25.   @12 Don, exaggerating is an art in itself 11:56  |  Mark B. 25/05/07
  26.   Martin 12:42  |  Millie 25/05/07
  27.   24- Martin 12:56  |  Jozef 25/05/07
  28.   Counter Boycott is effective 13:24  |  Evelyn 25/05/07
  29.   especially to Martin 13:54  |  Ron 25/05/07
  30.   Well done Prof Weinberg 13:59  |  rich 25/05/07
  31.   I am not particularly impressed with this academic 14:01  |  lakshmi 25/05/07
  32.   Surprise: Someone who knows when he`s been spit on 14:01  |  Ilan 25/05/07
  33.   I`ll do my bit 14:08  |  Yonatan 25/05/07
  34.   We dont want to Boycott Britain .. Just to stop the so called 14:10  |  SA 25/05/07
  35.   British anti-semitism 14:11  |  Nik Miller 25/05/07
  36.   #2 14:14  |  Sarah 25/05/07
  37.   Cristina,the tube perps,arent they a native Brit population? 14:17  |  Absolute Sweden 25/05/07
  38.   A handful of `nutters`? 14:22  |  Bemba Colora 25/05/07
  39.   Cristina - and your knowledge is based on what? 14:29  |  SA 25/05/07
  40.   Charles - How about an advert? 14:39  |  SA 25/05/07
  41.   XHY NOT PROFESSOR ? 14:45  |  Goz 25/05/07
  42.   #21 Aby about Cristina 14:46  |  Sarah 25/05/07
  43.   Martin #26: GB=good people, Israel=bad people 14:46  |  Rolandus 25/05/07
  44.   England a hotbed of Anti Semitism 14:49  |  Chris Linthwaite 25/05/07
  45.   #26 Millie - Slight correction - 15th century 15:02  |  Yonatan 25/05/07
  46.   A lot of talks of Brits not using Jewish inventions 15:05  |  Chris Linthwaite 25/05/07
  47.   The Boycott 15:05  |  MR 25/05/07
  48.   #36 Bemba Colora 15:07  |  Yonatan 25/05/07
  49.   to Martin Uk anti-occupation????? 15:09  |  Conor 25/05/07
  50.   #41 Chris Linthwaite 15:11  |  Yonatan 25/05/07
  51.   To Martin #24 15:13  |  Durak 25/05/07
  52.   #41 Chris Linthwaite 15:16  |  Sarah 25/05/07
  53.   Bravo Steven 15:22  |  Jew boy 25/05/07
  54.   lakshmi #29 15:23  |  Sarah 25/05/07
  55.   #24 - Just anti, biased and not helpful 15:24  |  Voice of reason 25/05/07
  56.   Good for Prof. Weinberg! 15:40  |  Gerrit 25/05/07
  57.   British Fools and Deniers, Boycott England 15:47  |  SES 25/05/07
  58.   Binyamin/Cristina .. Facts vs Fool 15:56  |  Eliot 25/05/07
  59.   Fritz (3) seems to want suicide bombers to have any easy job 15:58  |  Steven 25/05/07
  60.   #46 What is anti-semetism? 16:01  |  Chris Linthwaite 25/05/07
  61.   #48 Sarah 16:10  |  Chris Linthwaite 25/05/07
  62.   if you say no = you are antisemite! 16:11  |  Egyptian Soldier 25/05/07
  63.   Dr. Weinberg 16:11  |  david 25/05/07
  64.   UK ACADEMICS KNOW HOW THEIR BREAD IS BUTTERED 16:21  |  Ian 25/05/07
  65.   Indrajaya: Please read some of his works 16:25  |  Michael Korn 25/05/07
  66.   Thank you. 16:31  |  Anniina 25/05/07
  67.   Chris Linthwaite#41 16:37  |  Yariv 25/05/07
  68.   to Chris Linthwaite#43 16:38  |  Ilya 25/05/07
  69.   For Lakshmi, a falsifier of the historical record 16:38  |  Ed 25/05/07
  70.   Steven Weinberg is radical 16:41  |  Palestinian 25/05/07
  71.   Chris #44 Was it Cathartic 16:50  |  FOX 25/05/07
  72.   #58 Chris Linthwaite 16:55  |  Sarah 25/05/07
  73.   Faraz on international law 16:56  |  Laura 25/05/07
  74.   The Jewish people have a lot of reason to be proud...... 16:57  |  Swiss (Dino) 25/05/07
  75.   Bravo Prof. Steven Weinberg !!! 16:57  |  Judith, Haifa 25/05/07
  76.   He`ll probably skip out of the U.S. next. 16:58  |  Ibrahim 25/05/07
  77.   Nothing new in British academe 17:05  |  Rufus 25/05/07
  78.   Binyamin £10 17:07  |  H50 25/05/07
  79.   MIND-BOGGLING 17:09  |  Brant 25/05/07
  80.   Chris Linthwaite on democratic debate 17:13  |  Rufus 25/05/07
  81.   Cristina and Faraz 17:13  |  Hook `Em 25/05/07
  82.   Ooohh Ian .. I think thats a bit strong! 17:20  |  SA 25/05/07
  83.   To # 46, Chris Linthwaite, 17:28  |  Sayani 25/05/07
  84.   ...to Mr Indrajaya...153 Jew Novel prizes are laughing about you. 17:28  |  abraham...mico 25/05/07
  85.   Chris Lithwaite - I am a little confused 17:35  |  SA 25/05/07
  86.   Retarded Israeli academia just doesnt get it... 17:43  |  SLAVO