Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., February 07, 2008 Adar1 1, 5768 | | Israel Time: 18:33 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Rosner's Domain
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Advertising
Books Arts & Leisure Business Real Estate Easy Start Travel Week's End Anglo File
Last update - 10:07 25/05/2007
Surrendering its honor
By Yossi Melman

Any self-respecting country would have summoned the U.S. ambassador to the Foreign Ministry and demanded that he clarify his harsh statement that the fact that Jonathan Pollard, an American citizen sentenced to life for spying for Israel, has not been executed should be seen as an act of clemency.

But Israel is a country that has long ago stopped respecting its own sovereignty, given up its independence of thought and subordinated its will to that of Washington. Israel refuses to respond to Syria's offer of negotiations for fear of incurring the wrath of the American administration. It has submitted to the American dictate and established a special unit within the Defense Ministry to monitor security exports, solely because the United States demanded it. And these are only two examples among many in the last few years that indicate the obsequiousness of Israel's political and security leadership before the Washington nobleman.

In light of this, Jerusalem's stammered response to Ambassador Richard Jones' intolerable remark is not surprising. "The fact that he wasn't executed is the mercy that Jonathan Pollard will receive," said the U.S. envoy to Israel. In other words, Pollard, his family and the Israeli government, which controlled his espionage, should be thankful for the "light" sentence he received.
Advertisement
Jonathan Pollard was a civilian intelligence analyst for the U.S. Navy when he sold his country's secrets for money to his handlers in Israel. He betrayed his country. There is no dispute over that. Twenty-one years ago, he was given the heavy sentence of life imprisonment.

The Israeli government does not just have a moral responsibility for the fate of its agent. It also contributed significantly to the fact that he's rotting in prison. It began with the hasty decision of Elyakim Rubinstein - then the political attache at the Israeli Embassy in Washington and now a Supreme Court justice - to remove Pollard from the embassy grounds, where he was seeking asylum. He could have been brought in, as the Americans held Soviet citizens in their embassy in Moscow when they sought political asylum. One could have argued that according to the Law of Return, he's an Israeli citizen - in addition to which his handlers had already secretly given him an Israeli passport. It could be that Israel would ultimately have been forced to surrender Pollard, but that should have been done in exchange for an assurance that his sentence would be reduced.

Even after Pollard was handed over in such a shameful way and arrested, Israel could still have helped get him a lighter sentence - for instance, by setting it as a condition for Israeli participation in the investigation. Israel unconditionally provided the United States with the thousands of documents it received from him, thereby helping to incriminate him, without receiving anything in exchange. Even later, Israeli leaders and heads of the intelligence community did not really go out of their way to lobby the American government institutions and intelligence agencies for a pardon for Pollard.

The only one who almost achieved this was Benjamin Netanyahu, during his tenure as prime minister. In 1998, during the peace talks held at the Wye Plantation in Maryland, Netanyahu insisted that Pollard be released as part of the deal with the Palestinians. The U.S. president at the time, Bill Clinton, leaned toward agreeing to do so, but the head of the Central Intelligence Agency, George Tenet, brought all his weight to bear against it, threatening to resign, and Clinton backed off.

Pollard is not the only American citizen since 1980 who has been accused of espionage and given an extended sentence, but the others were despicable ones who caused far more damage to the American national interest. For instance, CIA agent Aldrich Aimes' treachery allowed the Soviet Union to discover the identities of agents working for the United States and execute them. But Pollard is the only one to whom the Americans are so hostile.

It could be because Pollard spied for a friendly country, making his act a more stinging affront. Nonetheless, it's difficult to accept or understand the American lust for revenge when it comes to Pollard. There's something irrational about it. Jones' remarks were rude and bereft of diplomatic tact, reflecting this American pathology that aspires to keep Pollard from ever being pardoned. Even though Jones has apologized, he deserves to be denounced. By essentially ignoring his comments, Israel is adding insult to the injury it has already done Pollard.
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Get a job
The Interior Minister tells the ultra-Orthodox to find work and enlist in the IDF.
Trapped in Gaza
An Irish woman and her daughter are stuck in Gaza after Egypt seals the border.
  1.   You are in no position to make demands 11:01  |  Natallie Durson 25/05/07
  2.   Loud Of Old Bollocks that should fool no-one 11:31  |  Johnboy 25/05/07
  3.   #1 natallie and HYPOCRISY RIDE THE RAILS AGAIN 11:40  |  paul harris 25/05/07
  4.   Pollard unmasked American duplicity 12:01  |  Per 25/05/07
  5.   Praise Israel 12:08  |  indrajaya 25/05/07
  6.   FREE JONATHAN POLLARD! 12:37  |  Ohev Tsion 25/05/07
  7.   Yossi, I don`t appreciate your article. 12:50  |  S 25/05/07
  8.   Vanunu... 12:55  |  Hanoman 25/05/07
  9.   What if he is Spy in Israel? 12:59  |  Sharif Hafez 25/05/07
  10.   No Dual Loyalty But Rather Dual Standards 13:08  |  Yisrael Medad 25/05/07
  11.   Has US President the real unrestricted power of clemency? 13:10  |  H.H.M 25/05/07
  12.   It is just simple anti semitism which keep Pollard in prison!!! 13:12  |  arthur 25/05/07
  13.   Traitor? 13:36  |  Dilip Nirody 25/05/07
  14.   You forget he`s an American citizen 14:16  |  Tim 25/05/07
  15.   It`s the Duplicty Yet Again 14:23  |  Yaakov Sullivan 25/05/07
  16.   LOL!!! 14:51  |  T A Sheppard 25/05/07
  17.   Ohev Tsion on Pollard #6 14:57  |  Yaakov Sullivan 25/05/07
  18.   How to restore your self-respect 14:57  |  John Jensen 25/05/07
  19.   Pollard 15:11  |  Realist 25/05/07
  20.   The problem with Pollard 15:15  |  Evelyn 25/05/07
  21.   Kudos to John Jensen 15:39  |  Hanoman 25/05/07
  22.   LOL Evelyn #17 15:46  |  T A Sheppard 25/05/07
  23.   OMG!!! 16:24  |  janmarie 25/05/07
  24.   Evelyn is a living example 16:42  |  Yaakov Sullivan 25/05/07
  25.   the real insult and injury 16:46  |  david 25/05/07
  26.   OMG II 16:47  |  Hanoman 25/05/07
  27.   Sharif Hafez # 9 16:49  |  T A Sheppard 25/05/07
  28.   #10 Yisrael YOU don`t know 16:53  |  T A Sheppard 25/05/07
  29.   long sentences are normal 17:01  |  texdot 25/05/07
  30.   Do you people ever stop and listen to yourselves? 17:03  |  Hubris = disaster 25/05/07
  31.   Any Jewish person who demands Pollard`s release is insane 17:04  |  Steve Holden 25/05/07
  32.   Pollard could`ve received the Death Penalty 17:06  |  Fred Gawen 25/05/07
  33.   Evelyn # 18 17:08  |  Chaval 25/05/07
  34.   Jones/ Pollard --and movie possibilities 17:10  |  D.R. Zukerman 25/05/07
  35.   I suspect... 17:29  |  Avi yerushalmi 25/05/07
  36.   #23 Well-Said!!! 17:29  |  T A Sheppard 25/05/07
  37.   What a load of 17:50  |  bobby 25/05/07
  38.   Am I missing something here? 17:55  |  dervish 25/05/07
  39.   The US ambassador was correct 17:57  |  John 25/05/07
  40.   Free him now!! 18:15  |  adi 25/05/07
  41.   #18 18:27  |  Elias 25/05/07
  42.   Israel. With friends like these 18:29  |  Baz Mann 25/05/07
  43.   A curious conceit 18:36  |  ipse dixit 25/05/07
  44.   Remember Venunu? 18:36  |  Baz Mann 25/05/07
  45.   Pollard is responsible for his treason and his sentence. 20:10  |  Mr. Knowitall 25/05/07
  46.   Problem of Jones is ...why was he sent ? 20:14  |  Chick Corea 25/05/07
  47.   Pollard- look at the facts - US spies for friendly nations 20:19  |  Chick Corea 25/05/07
  48.   @natalie durson, we have enormous influence 20:33  |  vladimir 25/05/07
  49.   Prison Rules: Admit your Crime, Do your Time 20:44  |  Pablo B 25/05/07
  50.   All documents? 20:49  |  Pssd Off American 25/05/07
  51.   Pollard punishment not irrational 21:25  |  Rick 25/05/07
  52.   #6 - Free the traitor - wrong 21:33  |  Rick 25/05/07
  53.   Surrendering its honor, "WHAT HONOR" 22:28  |  Peter 25/05/07
  54.   Extent of harm 22:40  |  W 25/05/07
  55.   Jonathan Pollard 22:59  |  Vince 25/05/07
  56.   Don`t worry, Jew-haters, Pollard will rot in prison 23:00  |  Jake 25/05/07
  57.   And to think . . . 23:08  |  Veritas 25/05/07
  58.   Honor? 23:13  |  P. J. Casey 25/05/07
  59.   #51 Rick; well you laid it out, the good, the bad and the ugly! 23:16  |  ballistic 25/05/07
  60.   #50 Pssd Off American 23:23  |  ballistic 25/05/07
  61.   #51/2 rick BLOWS HIS TOP BUT FORGETS TO LOOK IN THE MIRROR 23:30  |  paul harris 25/05/07
  62.   #56 Say Jake; are you brainwashed or what? 23:44  |  ballistic 25/05/07
  63.   If Israel has an honor, .. 23:48  |  Sharif Hafez 25/05/07
  64.   Interesting that all the anti-Pollard writers here 23:55  |  Chick Corea 25/05/07
  65.   To # 51 , Rick "Punishment not irrational ....! 00:12  |  Henk 26/05/07
  66.   #61 Say Paul, stop whining why don`t you? 00:30  |  ballistic 26/05/07
  67.   Whom one spies for in indeed relevant. 01:04  |  Tom 26/05/07
  68.   Twaddle 01:08  |  Mark Lincoln 26/05/07
  69.   Olmert should go to Bush and demand he denounce Jones 02:34  |  Pablo B 26/05/07
  70.   You left something out 03:43  |  Colin Wright 26/05/07
  71.   Different Perspectives 05:35  |  Rick 26/05/07
  72.   Biting the hand that feeds 05:38  |  Gordon 26/05/07
  73.   #66KNICKER E, STILL SENDS MESSAGES IN CODE 06:11  |  paul harris 26/05/07
  74.   hubris disaster 08:07  |  Connie 26/05/07
  75.   # 11 no no no, h.h.m.; not "between" friends... 08:41  |  eric 26/05/07
  76.   Israel`s sovereignty 10:08  |  Ze`ev ben Shmaryahu 26/05/07
  77.   A Bigger Betrayal 13:32  |  Ronnie Wolman 26/05/07
  78.   SOVEREIGNTY 13:57  |  Peter Dale 26/05/07
  79.   Pollard will rot in prison, deal with it. 14:18  |  Devin 26/05/07
  80.   no surprise 14:35  |  arab 26/05/07
  81.   go after antisemite america 14:42  |  arab 26/05/07
  82.   C WRIGHT..YOU left something out.Margolis`s vitriolic anti Israel 15:03  |  PETER SM 26/05/07
  83.   #78 UP HILL AND DOWN DALE ITS THE WRONG TALE 15:22  |  paul harris 26/05/07
  84.   eric #75 15:26  |  S 26/05/07
  85.   ERIC Between friends.The Jihadists and their spinnmeisters. 16:19  |  PETER SM 26/05/07
  86.   Capital Punishment for Pollard 16:23  |  asa 26/05/07
  87.   Pollard - to Natalie Durson, #1 17:41  |  Gad Giladi 26/05/07
  88.   #73 Hey Paul; never mind slinging the BS! 18:33  |  ballistic 26/05/07
  89.   pollard 18:54  |  goyboy 26/05/07
  90.   #84, sources re Pollard & Russia 19:06  |  Rick 26/05/07
  91.   Melman is confused 19:14  |  tadchase 26/05/07
  92.   #61- I blow my type with hypocrisy 19:22  |  Rick 26/05/07
  93.   Israel should provide example of compassion 20:18  |  Jozef 26/05/07
  94.   American Jews who support Pollard are the reason he is in jail 20:49  |  Eric 26/05/07
  95.   Rick #89 21:03  |  S 26/05/07
  96.   He`s one amongst thousands of sionist spies 21:31  |  Bonheur 26/05/07
  97.   S, #94 21:39  |  Rick 26/05/07
  98.   #90 Rick of Texas 21:43  |  ballistic 26/05/07
  99.   #88 knicker I DONT SQUAT ANYWHERE 22:25  |  paul harris 26/05/07
  100.   POLLARD DIDNOT SPY,he gave authorized info.2 ally 22:35  |  sam 26/05/07
  101.   #92 AND WHO INFORMDS YOU OF THESE FACTS RICK 23:09  |  paul harris 26/05/07
  102.   pollard 23:10  |  tom 26/05/07
  103.   #90 RICK LEARN ABOUT HEARSAY EVIDENCE 23:12  |  paul harris 26/05/07
  104.   #99 Say Paul; I was wondering where you were? 23:24  |  ballistic 26/05/07
  105.   #100 Where is ADL and AIPAC? 23:26  |  ballistic 26/05/07
  106.   Surrending Honor article. 23:31  |  Steve 26/05/07
  107.   RICK No gratitude or loyalty.You obviously avoid any mention 00:02  |  PETER SM 27/05/07
  108.   A roadmap to defeat 00:06  |  Mark Lincoln 27/05/07
  109.   Pollard 00:25  |  Ze`ev Silverman 27/05/07
  110.   bonheur 00:47  |  Connie 27/05/07
  111.   Att Natallie 01:26  |  Sam Weinstein 27/05/07
  112.   #94 Eric 01:29  |  Sam Weinstein 27/05/07
  113.   Hearsay - you`re wrong 02:08  |  Rick 27/05/07
  114.   BALLISTIC Most American Jewish organisations do NOT defend Pollar 02:16  |  PETER SM 27/05/07
  115.   #107 02:16  |  Rick 27/05/07
  116.   Recruiting for the Mossad 02:34  |  Gilad 27/05/07
  117.   #101 - US undemining Israel???? 02:59  |  Rick 27/05/07
  118.   Had Israel acted honestly and handed over Rafi Eitan & Irit Erb, 03:52  |  Yossi Cronenberg 27/05/07
  119.   # 100 is this post relayed from mars, sam? 03:56  |  eric 27/05/07
  120.   #106 I regret goyyim remark 04:18  |  Rick 27/05/07
  121.   # 85 to petersm in melbourne 04:35  |  eric 27/05/07
  122.   # 112 hey sam weinstein in the usa 04:44  |  eric 27/05/07
  123.   Pollard 04:54  |  Johnf 27/05/07
  124.   #103 Paul Harris; say, I guess you are not 05:18  |  ballistic 27/05/07
  125.   #110 Say Connie; gnawing on posters again with 05:22  |  ballistic 27/05/07
  126.   #113 Uh oh, Rick; I posted Paul 05:23  |  ballistic 27/05/07
  127.   message to Fred Gawen 05:25  |  Yussuf ibn Mohamed 27/05/07
  128.   #117 Say Rick; glad you reminded 05:25  |  ballistic 27/05/07
  129.   #114 Peter SM; I responded to a post 05:29  |  ballistic 27/05/07
  130.   #118 is correct. We should quit whining about Pollard and grow up 05:42  |  Dror Levy 27/05/07
  131.   Pollard`s freedom 07:49  |  howiej 27/05/07
  132.   American inteelect or lack thereof 08:08  |  howiej 27/05/07
  133.   Rick #97 09:33  |  S 27/05/07
  134.   #112 Sam 16:38  |  Eric 27/05/07
  135.   Pollard should FRY -- why else did Israel LIE 22:16  |  Dolores 30/05/07
  136.   #12 Arthur 23:12  |  Hindus For Peace? 29/08/07
  137.   #12 Arthur 23:24  |  Hindus For Peace 29/08/07
  138.   Israel could care less about Pollard 00:01  |  Josh 02/02/08
  139.   Pollard Case 18:11  |  Eve Gale 07/02/08
 Today Online
Seven Gazans killed in IDF raid; 7 Qassams hit Negev
Responses: 60
Barak vows harsher IDF response to Qassam fire
Responses: 78
Senator: U.S. to shun UN racism meet over anti-Israel agenda
Responses: 49
Israel Harel: Barak refuses to learn that only an invasion can stop rockets
Responses: 37
Vatican rejects criticism of new prayer for conversion of Jews
Responses: 79


More Headlines
18:23 Israel to begin reducing power supply to Gaza
13:20 Barak vows harsher IDF response if Qassam fire continues
16:26 Egyptian FM: Whoever breaks border will have his legs broken
18:09 Seven Palestinians killed in IDF raid in Gaza; 7 Qassams hit Negev
15:55 Vatican rejects criticism of new prayer for Jewish conversion
12:26 Kadima MK Yitzhaki resigns over Winograd report on Lebanon war
18:19 Israel halts West Bank-destined truck loaded with explosive material
09:02 Senator: U.S. to boycott UN anti-racism meet due to anti-Israel agenda
16:59 Haifa, T.A. domestic airports suspend plans halt weekend civil aviation
17:17 AG rejects leniency claims in jail sentence of ex-MK Omri Sharon
02:25 PM, ministers approve recommendations on streamlined conversion
06:08 Freed African refugees are expected to flock to Tel Aviv
09:38 Education Ministry mulls starting English study as early as 1st grade
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Fattal Hotel Chain
Perfectly located hotels on best resorts of Israel.
ISRAEL BONDS Build Israel
Israel bonds - a multi-purpose way to celebrate Israel's 60th
Dead Sea Salt
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on all online reservations
U.S. CITIZEN PRESIDENTIAL PRIMARY
Last chance to vote in Israel, in-person, Democrats-Abroad Global Primary.
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Underground | Site rules |
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved