Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., May 30, 2007 Sivan 13, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:07 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 10:08 25/05/2007
Mazuz versus Herzl
By Israel Harel

Hanging on the wall was a box: "This is the sky-blue box (and) every penny inserted in it liberates the soil." This box was in homes, classrooms, youth movement branches, and workplaces - in Israel and the Diaspora. Young and old recited a song, actually a prayer, that said thanks to the pennies placed in those boxes, "we will redeem the nation's soil, from the North to the Negev."

The Jewish National Fund owns 2.5 million dunam (625,000 acres) of land in Israel. They were bought - I must tell you today, Attorney General Menachem Mazuz and the justices of the Supreme Court in its capacity as the High Court of Justice - "dunam by dunam, clod by clod" so they would become the "Jewish people's eternal property," in accordance with the principle established by modern Zionism's founder, Theodor Herzl, at the Fifth Zionist Congress in 1901. Now, 106 years later, along comes the attorney general of the Jewish state created by Herzl's vision and declares that this era is over. Mazuz instructed the JNF this week, to allocate lands, without discrimination, to Jews and non-Jews alike. The State Prosecutor's Office conveyed the attorney general's instruction to the High Court in response to appeals various organizations submitted in 2004 on behalf of Arabs to whom the JNF had refused to sell lands. The State Prosecutor's Office also instructed the Israel Lands Administration to cancel tenders where one standard condition is that the purchasers must be Jews, since the JNF owns the land.

In 1961, when the JNF's lands were transferred to the ILA's management, not ownership, nobody could have suspected that one day the Jewish state would proclaim the allocation of Jewish-owned land to Jews a discriminatory act. In a covenant signed by former prime minister Levi Eshkol, on Israel's behalf, and Yaacov Tsur, representative of the World Zionist Movement, the JNF's owner, it was stated that Israel would comply with the "JNF's fundamental principle that the lands would remain in the nation's possession." Furthermore, the covenant specified, the "JNF would continue serving as an institution of the Zionist Organization in the Jewish public in Israel and the exile [Diaspora] ... for the redemption of land."

Advertisement

Earlier, in May 1954, the government authorized - the authorization was given official effect in the government gazette - the JNF memorandum whose central purpose was "to purchase lands ... for the settlement of Jews." Regarding this point, the covenant specifies that the "JNF lands shall be administered in compliance with this memorandum and the JNF's articles of incorporation." These articles were based on Herzl's words: "The Jewish people will be not only the founder (of the JNF) but its constant, eternal owner. This will prevent any use incongruent with the founder's goals."

After Mazuz's decision and judging from precedents in his rulings, it will not be hard to guess what the High Court will decide. This judicial establishment is intent on forcing Israel to gradually part with its definition as a Jewish state and become a state of all its citizens. The instruction to allocate the Jewish people's lands to the very nation competing with it for this country's ownership and sovereignty is part of the general moral degeneration to which we have succumbed in recent years. The memorandums Arab organizations have published over the past few months - the Higher Arab Monitoring Committee's "Future Vision," the Mossawa Center's document, Adalah's proposed constitution and the "Haifa Document," published on Jerusalem Day, have not opened the eyes of our blinded judicial establishments, which are changing, right before our eyes, as our legislators sit idly by, Israel's Jewish character and its Zionist objectives for which blood and money have been expended in huge quantities.

The Zionist movement - hopefully, it will not be declared a racist movement in Israel, too - must abrogate its covenant with the state and manage the JNF on its own. Article 17 allows this. If, in a Jewish state, a Zionist organization cannot earmark land for the exclusive use by Jews, it is hard, very hard, to define the meaning of "a national home for the Jewish people."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Musical Mishna
Composer Andre Hadjou blends contemporary music with religious texts.
Lap dog
If your dog is old and you're worried about his health, hydrotherapy may help.
  1.   It is what it is ..... Racist 10:54  |  Natallie Durson 25/05/07
  2.   TIME FOR CHANGE AT THE TOP 11:08  |  paul harris 25/05/07
  3.   The JNF has two paths it can take 11:18  |  David G 25/05/07
  4.   That last line says it all, doesn`t it? 11:45  |  Johnboy 25/05/07
  5.   #3 MORE NONSENSE ESPOUSED 11:47  |  paul harris 25/05/07
  6.   A state of all its citizens? Preposterous! 12:17  |  Thomas Jackson 25/05/07
  7.   Fascinating Article by Harel 12:23  |  Josh Goldman 25/05/07
  8.   Natallie 12:52  |  Ehud 25/05/07
  9.   JNF Donations and off color comments 13:14  |  L D Ginsburg 25/05/07
  10.   The solution is the Jewish concept of "Ger" 13:27  |  AV 25/05/07
  11.   Israel is a Jewish nation-state 13:30  |  AV 25/05/07
  12.   LEFTIST SECULAR HUMANISTIC MADNESS TO GIVE G-D`S LAND AWAY ?? 13:44  |  Bill. 25/05/07
  13.   Ehud - if I may say so 13:46  |  Josh Goldman 25/05/07
  14.   The Apartheid Case grows stronger 14:18  |  Tim 25/05/07
  15.   AV - a question 14:22  |  Josh Goldman 25/05/07
  16.   Jewish National Homeland 14:47  |  Nicole 25/05/07
  17.   Harel admits why western democracies see Israel as a racist state 14:49  |  Apartheid Watch 25/05/07
  18.   Mazuz versus Herzl 15:16  |  Rivka 25/05/07
  19.   French culture and Jewish culture are not the same 15:22  |  AV 25/05/07
  20.   Israel is a "Western" culture like Japan is a "Western" culture 15:25  |  AV 25/05/07
  21.   BEING ISRAEL HAREL 15:38  |  Stephen Connor 25/05/07
  22.   To Apartheid Watch and Natalie 15:38  |  Raanan Geberer 25/05/07
  23.   #15 read NO 5 AND LEARN SOMETHING 15:39  |  paul harris 25/05/07
  24.   Israel`s solution is the ancient Jewish concept of a "Ger" 15:46  |  AV 25/05/07
  25.   Nicole - On racism 15:55  |  Stephen Connor 25/05/07
  26.   Paul Harris - The Israeli Judiciary 15:57  |  Stephen Connor 25/05/07
  27.   Paul 16:05  |  Stephen Connor 25/05/07
  28.   Paul and Real Property Law 16:09  |  Stephen Connor 25/05/07
  29.   #23 Israel has as many problems because 16:19  |  T A Sheppard 25/05/07
  30.   Mazuz anti- Zionist Atty. General of Jewish state 16:28  |  Shalom Freedman 25/05/07
  31.   Arab Muslims are guilty of apartheid 16:33  |  Hal 25/05/07
  32.   Naivety 17:00  |  Richard 25/05/07
  33.   Reply to Thomas Jackson (Post No. 6) 17:10  |  Johnny Weintraub 25/05/07
  34.   Mazuz 17:31  |  Alex 25/05/07
  35.   #12 Bill 18:06  |  Boycott 25/05/07
  36.   Reply to Richard in Texas (Post No. 31) 18:06  |  Johnny Weintraub 25/05/07
  37.   Josh Goldman, exactly the opposite of what you said is true 18:13  |  Jake 25/05/07
  38.   Justice system 18:13  |  Tareq 25/05/07
  39.   AV, I agree with you 100% about Gerim 18:15  |  Jake 25/05/07
  40.   Harel admits Israel`s Apartheid 18:18  |  Boycott 25/05/07
  41.   Those now accusing Israel of Apartheid are disingenous deceivers 18:38  |  Jake 25/05/07
  42.   "Boycott": Interpretation vs. practise 18:45  |  Jake 25/05/07
  43.   Then OUTLAW Arab sales to Arabs Only! 18:51  |  Me 25/05/07
  44.   God will win 18:55  |  AV 25/05/07
  45.   Read "Not for Arabs" 19:01  |  sean 25/05/07
  46.   Questions for Israel Harel 19:13  |  Morrie Schreibman 25/05/07
  47.   "No Jews or dogs allowed" 19:20  |  Sean 25/05/07
  48.   Bravo! Israel enters the 20th century! 19:32  |  tadchase 25/05/07
  49.   AV - you`ve lost the plot 19:46  |  Josh Goldman 25/05/07
  50.   Thank you, Stephen Connor 19:47  |  Sam 25/05/07
  51.   Hey Harel!! One question please 19:48  |  Danite 25/05/07
  52.   Jake - this is nonsense 19:51  |  Josh Goldman 25/05/07
  53.   Goy`s and arab`s need not apply and stay off the grass 20:35  |  levi 25/05/07
  54.   No lands Impossible 20:40  |  Alberto Cohen 25/05/07
  55.   Honorable IDF service should be sole requirement 20:41  |  Yosef 25/05/07
  56.   you can have a Jewish national homeland... 20:54  |  Pssd Off American 25/05/07
  57.   JEWISH LAND RUSTLERS HIJACKED THE LAND 21:27  |  Muhammud al-Swain 25/05/07
  58.   #48 IF YOU DONT KNOW STOP WRITING TO THIS PAPER !! 21:36  |  paul harris 25/05/07
  59.   Modern day realities 22:08  |  Sam 25/05/07
  60.   Josh Goldman, your comparison says it all 22:31  |  Jake 25/05/07
  61.   original intent 22:33  |  avramele 25/05/07
  62.   Josh Goldman`s stodgy arrogance 22:38  |  Jake 25/05/07
  63.   From one Sam to another Sam 23:09  |  Sam 25/05/07
  64.   land 23:19  |  arik 25/05/07
  65.   reality principle 23:22  |  yonah 25/05/07
  66.   I SUGGEST YOU REMOVE #57 FROM THIS TALKBACK 23:34  |  paul harris 25/05/07
  67.   Back to Sam 23:35  |  Sam 25/05/07
  68.   #12 Bill of New Zealand. Just wondering... 23:48  |  Maureen Ann 25/05/07
  69.   paul harris 01:10  |  Will Turner 26/05/07
  70.   If all jews 01:15  |  Will Turner 26/05/07
  71.   THE EXISTANCE OF ISRAEL MAKES KORAN AND MUHAMMED A LIE ?? 01:37  |  Bill. 26/05/07
  72.   WILL SAUDI ARABIA ALLOW A JEW TO BUY LAND IN MECCA ?? 01:44  |  Bill. 26/05/07
  73.   Jake - a few facts 01:47  |  Josh Goldman 26/05/07
  74.   #72 Bill ..and his preaching 02:52  |  maoriboy 26/05/07
  75.   "racist" 03:25  |  Mark Katzman 26/05/07
  76.   A heart-warming plea -- one point is overlooked. 03:32  |  Colin Wright 26/05/07
  77.   re Paul Haris #66 `I suggest you remove #57..." 03:35  |  Colin Wright 26/05/07
  78.   Israel is not for sale! 04:45  |  Michael 26/05/07
  79.   Critics of Israel need not apply! 04:55  |  Michael 26/05/07
  80.   Bill - YOU ARE A LIE 05:53  |  Human Being 26/05/07
  81.   Israel is geographically a huge, expansionist country. 07:06  |  Abu Moishe 26/05/07
  82.   #79 Excuse me Michael, you are forgetting something. 07:37  |  Maureen Ann 26/05/07
  83.   Reply to Johnny Weintraub (#33) 08:07  |  Thomas Jackson 26/05/07
  84.   Ehud 08:23  |  kiwi girl 26/05/07
  85.   re #79 `Critics...` 08:44  |  Colin Wright 26/05/07
  86.   re #20 `Israel is an ethical culture...` 08:49  |  Colin Wright 26/05/07
  87.   Theodor Herzl and Palestine 10:15  |  maoriboy 26/05/07
  88.   Basic of Judaism 10:24  |  Honi 26/05/07
  89.   Listen to Josh Goldman 12:22  |  A Lebanese 26/05/07
  90.   Ben Jabo where are you? Even now the JNF only owns 2500k2 out 12:39  |  Apartheid 26/05/07
  91.   #56, American with funny name 13:18  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 26/05/07
  92.   change never been a choice, it is rather a must 14:09  |  arab 26/05/07
  93.   * 80 HUMAN BEING . 14:10  |  Bill. 26/05/07
  94.   Waqf land is for muslims only!!! 14:25  |  David 26/05/07
  95.   #87 NO MARI BOY IT STARTED IN BABYLON 3000 YEARS BACK 14:59  |  paul harris 26/05/07
  96.   #87 Maoriboy: Herzl`s poisonous dream 15:06  |  A Lebanese 26/05/07
  97.   Maureen- You are forgetting something: The Holocaust 15:41  |  Michael 26/05/07
  98.   Family property 15:45  |  Pater familias 26/05/07
  99.   #93 MAN FROM LEB NEVER HEARD OF THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE 15:54  |  paul harris 26/05/07
  100.   #94 Michael 15:56  |  Boycott 26/05/07
  101.   #95 paul harris 17:14  |  maoriboy 26/05/07
  102.   #101 TELL ME MAORIBOY WHERE CAN I FIND A CANAANITE ?? 17:30  |  paul harris 26/05/07
  103.   Israel Belongs To The Jews 18:13  |  Not Jewish 26/05/07
  104.   #100 What language is "boycott"? 18:27  |  Michael 26/05/07
  105.   Natallie Durson (#1), not exactly 18:29  |  christoph 26/05/07
  106.   lease management 18:53  |  David Bloch 26/05/07
  107.   response to Maoriboy 19:06  |  world citizen 26/05/07
  108.   Bill - Read the Koran with a scholar, you know nothing of culture 21:38  |  Human Being 26/05/07
  109.   Back to sam 21:40  |  Sam 26/05/07
  110.   Paul Harris 21:43  |  Sam 26/05/07
  111.   Bill - Use reason and don`t be afraid to write "GOD" silly BOO! 21:44  |  Human Being 26/05/07
  112.   Meanwhile they Arrest Infidels in Saudi Arabia 21:48  |  Efox 26/05/07
  113.   Muzuz fights the Lord &his children 22:27  |  sam 26/05/07
  114.   #110 SAM WANTS TO KNOW WHAT ITS ALL ABOUT 22:33  |  paul harris 26/05/07
  115.   MAZUZ CAN GIVE HIS OWN MONEY . . . 23:31  |  Wendy 26/05/07
  116.   Natalie Durson 23:58  |  rafael Goldchain 26/05/07
  117.   Dear Paul (#114), a story for you 00:00  |  christoph 27/05/07
  118.   THomas Jackson 00:04  |  Rafael Goldchain 27/05/07
  119.   Tim 00:08  |  Rafael Goldchain 27/05/07
  120.   *101 MAORI BOY ? 00:24  |  Bill. 27/05/07
  121.   Exclusivity 00:42  |  Faraz 27/05/07
  122.   * 108 HUMAN BEING ? 00:50  |  Bill. 27/05/07
  123.   to Pissed Off American #56 00:59  |  B`Galil 27/05/07
  124.   to Muhammud al-Swain 01:01  |  B`Galil 27/05/07
  125.   *108 HUMAN BEING 2/ 01:10  |  Bill. 27/05/07
  126.   #102 paul harris needs a history lesson 01:20  |  maoriboy 27/05/07
  127.   Thanks, Paul Harris 01:21  |  Sam 27/05/07
  128.   *111 HUMAN BEING ? 01:34  |  Bill. 27/05/07
  129.   #107 world citizen 02:10  |  maoriboy 27/05/07
  130.   Bill 02:30  |  Human Being 27/05/07
  131.   #120 bill a stranger in a strange land 02:40  |  maoriboy 27/05/07
  132.   Bill. 03:12  |  Human Being 27/05/07
  133.   Not Jewish 03:23  |  Real American 27/05/07
  134.   #101 bill a strange in a strange land part 2 03:32  |  maoriboy 27/05/07
  135.   What is the `Final Solution` 04:37  |  David 27/05/07
  136.   Sam from Va 04:53  |  Sam 27/05/07
  137.   *134 MAORI BOY 06:18  |  Bill. 27/05/07
  138.   IF THEY MOST SELL LAND 06:20  |  TOBIA 27/05/07
  139.   DAVID WHO IS RACIST 06:25  |  TOBIA 27/05/07
  140.   *132 HUMAN BEING . 06:42  |  Bill. 27/05/07
  141.   Bill Part 1 08:05  |  Human Being 27/05/07
  142.   Bill Part 2 08:10  |  Human Being 27/05/07
  143.   #126 DELUSIONS FROM NZ AGAIN 08:13  |  paul harris 27/05/07
  144.   #137 bill ..a lot of tribes view themselves as being seperate . 08:21  |  maoriboy 27/05/07
  145.   JNF 08:22  |  howiej 27/05/07
  146.   Sam from Canada 09:01  |  Sam 27/05/07
  147.   Bill - Final Part :) 09:41  |  Human Being 27/05/07
  148.   It`s called New Yor 19:26  |  David Neunuebel 27/05/07
  149.   God`s convenant with Jews 23:06  |  JC 27/05/07
  150.   JNF not Tax Exempt 19:40  |  Veritas 29/05/07
  151.   Israel is the Hand in the Cookie jar 20:04  |  T A Sheppard 30/05/07
 Today Online
British lecturers to vote on calls for academic boycott of Israel
Responses: 226
Meshal: IDF won't deter Hamas attacks on Israel
Responses: 131
Yitzhak Laor: Shin Bet wants democracy for Jews only
Responses: 66
Rosner: Rice is still being eyed as a U.S. presidential candidate
Responses: 35
Rosner's Domain
* New feature: Rosner's What To Read
* Revisiting the possibility of a Rice ticket in 2008
* Guest: Jewish kids today see the idea of interfaith as cool
* Poll: Will the new sanctions on Sudan stop the Darfur massacre?


More Headlines
18:50 Sheetrit, Eitan propose firing 'Israeli Qassam' at Gaza Strip
18:43 Ayalon meets with Peretz over support in Labor leadership race
18:02 Haniyeh: PA gov't wants a truce, the ball is now in Israel's court
19:46 EU parliament chief urges Israel to free Palestinian lawmakers
18:24 Report: U.K. union boss wants members to reject Israel academic boycott
18:26 Report accuses Shin Bet, police of severely torturing Palestinian suspects
16:47 Peres formally announces his candidacy for the presidency
15:50 State Prosecutor slams rights groups for signing Hamas court petition
18:58 Former MK Bishara says Syria requires democratic reform
17:46 Qassam hits Sderot; 2 militants killed in IAF strike in Gaza Strip
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved